Developed by W. Chan Kim and Renée Mauborgne (Value Innovation, 1997; Charting Your Company's Future, 2002; Blue Ocean Strategy, 2005).
Plots the factors an industry competes on and each rival's level on them, then uses eliminate, reduce, raise, and create to draw a value curve unlike any rival's.
Redraw a budget hotel's value curve away from its rivals
Eight factors budget hotels compete on, each scored from 0 (none) to 10 (the most). The two rivals' curves have the same shape. The chain's own curve opens redrawn with the four actions: food and the lobby eliminated, room size and desk hours reduced, beds and Wi-Fi raised, and a phone key created, which no hotel offers. Move the sliders back to the economy chains' levels (4, 3, 3, 4, 6, 3, 3, 0) to see the copy it started as, and watch the running cost climb. Illustrative.
The chain, redrawnMidscale chainsEconomy chains
An example
A regional chain of forty economy hotels near office parks was losing on price to two national brands with nearly the same offer. The strategy team drew the canvas on one wall: eight factors guests weighed, from price to the restaurant to front desk hours, with each rival's level on each. The rivals' curves ran parallel, and the chain's own curve sat right on top of the economy brand's.
They worked through the four actions. The restaurant and the lobby lounge went, since their guests ate at the office park and checked in after nine at night. Room size and front desk hours came down. Beds, soundproofing, and Wi-Fi went up past midscale levels. And they added something no rival offered: a phone key with check-in in under a minute. The new curve broke from both rivals on six of the eight factors, and the running cost per room fell by about 40 percent, enough to price below the economy brand. Business travelers who used neither brand asked about the beds and the phone key first.
Why it works
A value curve makes an industry's assumptions visible. When every rival's line has the same shape, they are all competing on the same factors at different levels, and the only lever left is price. Drawing the curves side by side shows that sameness at a glance, which a list of features never does.
The four actions then force a trade ordinary planning avoids. Eliminating and reducing take cost out; raising and creating add value; doing all four at once lets a company offer one group of buyers more of what they care about while spending less than its rivals. Because the factors come from what buyers weigh, a feature the industry takes for granted, such as the hotel restaurant, gets questioned instead of polished.
The thinking behind it
W. Chan Kim W. Chan Kim, a professor of strategy at INSEAD, introduced value innovation with Renée Mauborgne in Value Innovation: The Strategic Logic of High Growth (1997), published in the Harvard Business Review. The value curve came with it: a line drawn across the factors an industry competes on, showing what a company offers buyers on each. Over the following decade the two built the idea into the argument that firms grow by creating uncontested market space, where the usual rivals have no offer to compare.
Renée Mauborgne Renée Mauborgne, also a professor of strategy at INSEAD, developed every stage of the method with Kim. In Charting Your Company's Future (2002) they set a company's value curve beside its rivals' on one chart, the strategy canvas, so a management team could see whether its offer differed from anyone else's. Blue Ocean Strategy: How to Create Uncontested Market Space and Make the Competition Irrelevant (2005) gathered the canvas, the four actions, and the cases behind them into a book.
How to run it
- Define the category and the buyer. Name the category as buyers see it, such as overnight stays near office parks, and the buyer whose choice should change.
- List the factors of competition. Write eight to fifteen things rivals spend on and buyers weigh, price included, in the buyers' own words.
- Plot the rivals' curves. Score each main rival on each factor from low to high and draw the lines; matching shapes mean a crowded market.
- Apply the four actions. For every factor, ask what to eliminate, what to reduce well below the norm, what to raise well above it, and what no one offers that should be created.
- Draw the new curve and test it. A strong curve diverges from the rivals, has a clear focus, and can be summed up in one line a buyer would repeat.
- Check it with noncustomers. Show it to people who buy from no one in the category today, since they reveal which factors keep them away.
Where it goes wrong
The usual failure is a curve that is only higher. A team raises every factor, calls the result a blue ocean, and has drawn a costlier copy of the leader; spot it when nothing was eliminated or reduced. Require at least two cuts before any factor may go up.
The second is a factor list written from the inside. Engineers list features, finance lists costs, and the curve misses what buyers actually trade off. Draw the factors from buyer interviews, with noncustomers among them.
The third is stopping at the picture. A divergent curve still has to be priced, delivered at the target cost, and sold, and a canvas with no plan behind it changes nothing. Give each action an owner and a cost estimate before the workshop ends.
When to use something else
- Porter's Five Forces. When the question is how attractive the current industry is and who holds the power in it, before deciding whether to leave it.
- Jobs to Be Done. When the factors themselves are uncertain and the team first needs to learn what progress buyers are trying to make.
- Ansoff Matrix. When the choice is among current markets, new markets, and new products across a portfolio.
Where it sits in SOLVE eX
Go to the source
- Value Innovation: The Strategic Logic of High Growth, Harvard Business Review, 1997
- Charting Your Company's Future, Harvard Business Review, 2002
- Blue Ocean Strategy: How to Create Uncontested Market Space and Make the Competition Irrelevant, 2005