From Aristotle (Posterior Analytics, 4th century BCE) and René Descartes (Discourse on the Method, 1637), popularized for business through Elon Musk's cost reasoning at SpaceX (Wired interview, 2012).
Strips a problem down to the constraints that physics, economics, or logic truly impose, then designs a solution from those constraints alone.
What each line of a $2.0M robot quote really rests on
Each tag is one line of the quote. Select a line, then what it rests on: physics, the law, the company's measured need, or a habit carried over from other sites. The mezzanine is placed as an example. Show the tool's answer to compare, then price the design rebuilt from the lines that survive in the next figure. Illustrative.
- Not placedPlacedPhysicsLaw or codeMeasured needHabit
- Not placedPlacedPhysicsLaw or codeMeasured needHabit
- Not placedPlacedPhysicsLaw or codeMeasured needHabit
- Not placedPlacedPhysicsLaw or codeMeasured needHabit
- Not placedPlacedPhysicsLaw or codeMeasured needHabit
- Not placedPlacedPhysicsLaw or codeMeasured needHabit
- Not placedPlacedPhysicsLaw or codeMeasured needHabit
- Not placedPlacedPhysicsLaw or codeMeasured needHabit
The quote
What the line rests on
Your sort matched 0 of 8.Your sort matched 1 of 8.Your sort matched 2 of 8.Your sort matched 3 of 8.Your sort matched 4 of 8.Your sort matched 5 of 8.Your sort matched 6 of 8.Your sort matched 7 of 8.Your sort matched 8 of 8.
- Physics
- Required by how things work. Keep it and design to it.
- Law or code
- Required by regulation or the insurer. Keep it.
- Measured need
- Required by the company's own measured demand. Keep it, sized to the data.
- Habit
- Carried over from other sites or a standard spec. Drop it, or keep it on purpose at a known price.
The sort
- 600 picks an hour, $600k: Measured need. The order history says so: last December ran at 580 picks an hour for three weeks.
- 50 kg lifts, $380k: Habit. The heaviest full tote in the building weighs 18 kg, and the base system's standard lift carries it.
- Mezzanine, $340k: Habit. The vendor's reference sites had low ceilings. This building has 11 meters clear, so the grid can stand on its floor.
- Grippers for all, $260k: Habit. Bulky items are 2% of order lines. Two people picking them by hand cost a fraction of the grippers.
- Real-time link, $120k: Measured need. Orders are released every two minutes for same-day shipping; a nightly file would miss the cutoff.
- Climate room, $120k: Habit. The vendor's standard for food and pharmacy sites. This warehouse holds hardware, inside the robots' rated temperatures.
- Charging bays, $90k: Physics. The robots run on batteries, and batteries need charging; the number of bays follows from the run time.
- Sprinkler gap, $90k: Law or code. The fire code sets it and the insurer inspects it.
Rebuild the $2.0M quote from the lines kept
Each slider is one line of the quote, slid to its full price to keep it or to zero to cut it. Keep what physics, the law, or the company's measured demand requires and cut the habits: the rebuilt design is the total of what is kept, and the bars show which lines it holds. The mezzanine is cut as an example. Illustrative.
Kept in the design
An example
A hardware distributor received a $2.0 million quote for an automated storage and picking system, built from the vendor's three reference sites. The board was ready to approve it.
The operations director took the quote line by line and wrote beside each line the assumption it rested on. Then she asked whether physics, the law, or the company's own measured demand required it, or whether it had come along from other sites. Four lines held: the December peak of 600 picks an hour, which the order history showed; the fire code's sprinkler clearance; the real-time link that same-day shipping needed; and charging bays for battery robots. The rest did not. The lifts were rated for 50 kilogram totes when the heaviest full tote weighed 18. The mezzanine existed because the reference sites had low ceilings. The oversized grippers served 2 percent of order lines, and the climate room was a food and pharmacy standard.
The design rebuilt from the four lines cost $900,000, plus two people at a hand-pick station for bulky items. The vendor requoted at $1.05 million.
Why it works
Most costs are set by analogy: what this kind of system costs, what the last site needed. Analogy is quick and usually close, but it carries every assumption of the original, including ones that never applied here, and nobody remembers choosing them. Asking of each assumption what imposes it separates two kinds of requirement. A constraint comes from physics, regulation, or measured demand, and it holds whoever designs the system. A habit comes from a reference site, a standard spec, or past practice, and it can be dropped.
The method pays most where a field copies its own designs, as vendors do when they quote from reference sites. It also works because the constraints are usually few and checkable: a tote can be weighed and a peak hour pulled from the records.
The thinking behind it
Aristotle Aristotle held in the Posterior Analytics (4th century BCE) that a demonstration must start from first principles: starting points that cannot themselves be demonstrated and are known by induction from perception. Everything else is derived from them. The business use of the phrase keeps his structure. Find the few things that are true however anyone is used to working, such as the weight of the heaviest tote or the fire code, and reason forward from those alone.
René Descartes René Descartes set out four rules of method in his Discourse on the Method (1637): accept as true only what is clearly and distinctly known, divide each difficulty into as many parts as needed, order thoughts from the simplest objects to the most complex, and make enumerations so complete that nothing is left out. The tool runs those rules on a cost. Break the quote into its parts, keep only what is known to be required, and rebuild from the simplest pieces up.
How to run it
- Write down the current answer and its cost. The existing quote or design, line by line, is the starting point.
- Name the assumption behind each line. Ask why each part is there; the answer is usually a requirement nobody wrote down.
- Sort each into constraint or habit. Physics, regulation, and measured demand are constraints; reference sites, standard specs, and past practice are habits.
- Check the constraints against data. Weigh the tote, pull the peak hour, read the code; many supposed constraints turn out to be guesses.
- Design from the constraints alone. Find the simplest thing that meets them, without looking at how others did it.
- Price the new design beside the old. Include anything the new design adds, such as people for the bulky items.
- Keep the habits worth paying for. Some habits carry a lesson someone learned the hard way; keep those on purpose, at a known price.
Where it goes wrong
A real constraint gets called a habit. The exercise rewards cutting, so a fire code or a seasonal peak gets waved away. Spot it when a call of habit has no measured fact behind it, and check every call against data before the design changes.
Everything gets rebuilt. First principles applied to every small part of a design burns weeks on lines where the standard answer is fine. Use it on the few lines that carry most of the cost.
A habit's reason gets lost. A standard spec may encode a failure someone already paid for. Before cutting a line, ask the vendor why it is there.
When to use something else
- Assumption Audit. When the plan should stay as it is and the job is to list its assumptions and test the riskiest.
- TRIZ. When the real constraints conflict with each other and the design needs a way around the contradiction.
- Ideal Final Result. When it helps to start from the ideal outcome and work back toward what is possible.
Where it sits in SOLVE eX
Go to the source
- Posterior Analytics, 4th century BCE
- Discourse on the Method, 1637
- Elon Musk's Mission to Mars, Wired, interview by Chris Anderson, October 2012, 2012