Originated by Juanita Brown and David Isaacs (The World Café, 2005).
Breaks a large group into small tables that rotate through a sequence of questions, with a host at each table carrying ideas between rounds.
Sixty people, twelve tables, three rounds on why nurses leave
At each of the facilitator's turns pick a move; the room's response shows, with whether the move keeps the format working. The hosts who stay put while everyone else moves are what carry ideas from table to table. Illustrative.
Facilitator
The room
Facilitator
The room
Moves that keep the format working: 0 of 4Moves that keep the format working: 1 of 4Moves that keep the format working: 2 of 4Moves that keep the format working: 3 of 4Moves that keep the format working: 4 of 4
- The questions (Facilitator). Sixty managers and nurses from a hospital group are in one room for the afternoon. Pick the facilitator's questions.
- Three that build: what keeps nurses here, what pushes them out, what would we try first? Each round starts from what the last one found. Fits: open questions, each one building on the answers to the one before.
- One question: do we support the new retention plan, yes or no? Tables split into camps within five minutes. A vote: it leaves nothing for later rounds to build on.
- Round one (The room). Twelve tables of five, with paper covering each table and markers out. Twenty minutes on the first question; people write and draw as they talk.
- The move (Facilitator). Round one is over. Pick how the room moves.
- Everyone moves to a new table, except one host per table who stays. Every table now holds people who heard five different conversations. Fits: the mix is what spreads ideas, and the host keeps each table's thread.
- Each table moves together to the next table. The same five people pick up where they left off. No mixing: the groups never hear each other.
- Nobody moves; go straight to the second question. The talk deepens at each table and never crosses the room. A set of separate meetings: the format depends on the movement.
- Round two (The room). Ideas from round one turn up at tables that never discussed them. Two tables, independently, raise the night-shift schedule.
- The host's job (Facilitator). New people have just sat down at a host's table. Pick what the host does.
- Give a two-minute summary, then ask newcomers what it connects to from their last table. Within ten minutes the table links schedules to the exit interviews. Fits: a short handover, and the newcomers do the linking.
- Read out every note on the paper from round one. Fifteen minutes later the newcomers have said nothing. Too long: the host's round crowds out the new people.
- Round three (The room). By the third question, people at different tables use the same phrases for the same problems. The patterns now belong to the room as a whole.
- The harvest (Facilitator). Three rounds are done. Pick how the room closes.
- Each table names the one idea that kept coming back; the room clusters them on a wall. Four clusters appear, and people volunteer to own two of them. Fits: the whole room sees its own patterns.
- The chief nursing officer sums up what she heard. The summary is thoughtful, and it is one person's. One view: it replaces the room's patterns with a single reading.
- What the room made (The room). Night-shift schedules, the first ninety days, charge-nurse workload, and pay transparency. Volunteers took the first two to a working group the next week.
An example
A hospital group was losing a fifth of its new nurses within a year, and its leaders had heard the same five people explain why at every meeting. For the annual leadership afternoon, the organizer set up a café instead: sixty managers and nurses at twelve tables of five, paper over every table, and three questions in order. What keeps nurses here? What pushes them out? What would we try first?
After each twenty-minute round, everyone moved to a new table except one host per table, who briefed the newcomers in two minutes and asked what connected to their last conversation. By the second round, two tables that had never met were both talking about the night-shift schedule. At the close, each table named the idea that kept coming back, and the room clustered them on a wall into four themes. Two of the themes had volunteer owners before people left, and a working group on night shifts met the following week.
Why it works
In a plenary of sixty, a handful of people do the talking and the rest listen or check their phones. Small tables give everyone airtime, and the paper on the table keeps a record that does not depend on any one person's memory.
The rotation is what turns twelve separate conversations into one. Each move mixes people who have heard different discussions, and the host who stays carries the table's thread forward without letting it harden. Ideas that keep surfacing at tables that never spoke to each other are strong signals about what the whole group thinks. Questions that build on each other let each round start from what the last one found, and the closing harvest shows the room its own patterns.
The thinking behind it
Juanita Brown Juanita Brown, a dialogue practitioner, and David Isaacs, an organizational consultant, originated the World Café together. The format began at a 1995 gathering at their home in Mill Valley, California: small tables hold rounds of conversation on questions that matter, people move between tables to cross-pollinate ideas, and the whole room then harvests what emerged. They set it out, with the World Café Community, in The World Café: Shaping Our Futures Through Conversations That Matter (Berrett-Koehler, 2005).
How to run it
- Write three or four questions that build. Make each open and tied to the group's real situation, and order them so each starts from the last.
- Set the tables. Seat four or five people per table, with paper on the table and markers for everyone.
- Run the first round. Give about twenty minutes to the first question, and ask people to write and draw on the paper as they talk.
- Move everyone but the hosts. One person stays at each table; everyone else goes to a table with people they have not yet sat with.
- Have each host brief the newcomers. Two minutes on the key ideas from the last round, then the next question.
- Harvest in the whole room. Ask each table for the idea that kept coming back, and cluster them where everyone can see.
- Give the themes owners. Ask for volunteers before people leave, and set the date of the first follow-up.
Where it goes wrong
The questions have answers. A yes-or-no question, or one the leaders have already decided, gives the tables nothing to build on, and people notice. Test each question by asking whether the people in the room could change the outcome.
The hosts take over. A host who replays the whole last round turns newcomers into an audience. Keep the briefing short and ask the new arrivals to add.
The harvest goes nowhere. A wall of sticky notes photographed and filed teaches people that talking changes nothing. Decide before the café what will happen to its themes, and say so at the start.
When to use something else
- Nominal Group Technique. When a smaller group needs to generate ideas and rank them, with every voice counted equally.
- Brainwriting 6-3-5. When the group needs many ideas fast, in writing, before any discussion.
- Affinity Diagram. When the ideas already exist and the job is to sort a large pile of them into themes.
Where it sits in SOLVE eX
Go to the source
- The World Café: Shaping Our Futures Through Conversations That Matter, Berrett-Koehler, 2005