Developed by Bernd Rohrbach (Kreativ nach Regeln: Methode 635, 1969).
Has six people each write three ideas in five minutes, then pass their sheets on to build on one another's ideas, producing a large pool in about thirty minutes.
One sheet's eighteen ideas after six rounds, drawn by what each one built on
One of the six sheets from a hotel group's session on direct bookings. Each round the sheet moved one seat, and the next person read what was above and added three ideas, most of them building on one already there. Select a box to see what it added; tick up to three of the furthest-built ideas to take to the review. Six sheets like this one made 108 ideas in thirty minutes. Illustrative.
0 of 3 marked1 of 3 marked2 of 3 marked3 of 3 marked
An example
A regional hotel group was paying travel sites a large commission on most of its bookings, and two open brainstorms on the problem had produced the same three ideas, all from the revenue manager. The general manager of the largest property tried a silent format with six people: the revenue manager, two front-desk leads, a marketer, a housekeeping supervisor, and a night auditor.
Each got a sheet headed with the question (how might more guests book with us directly?) and three columns. They wrote three ideas in five minutes, passed the sheet to the left, read what was above, and added three more. Most of the later ideas built on earlier ones: a members-only rate became one-tap signup at check-in, then members skipping the desk, then the phone as a room key. A rebooking code handed over at checkout moved onto the key sleeve and grew into a referral code.
After thirty minutes there were 108 ideas on six sheets. The group clustered them, and two of the furthest-built chains went into a pilot.
Why it works
Spoken brainstorms have two problems. Only one person can talk at a time, so most of the session is listening, and the loudest or most senior voices set the direction early. Writing in silence removes both: six people produce at once, and nobody knows whose idea is whose while it is being built on.
The passing is what makes it more than six people writing lists. Each round, a person reads ideas they would never have had and is asked to add to them, so the sheet climbs past the obvious first answers. The fixed numbers do work too. Three ideas in five minutes is little enough that nobody freezes and enough that people go past their safest thought, and the arithmetic (six people, three ideas, six rounds) guarantees a large pool in half an hour.
The thinking behind it
Bernd Rohrbach Bernd Rohrbach, a marketing consultant, devised Method 635 and published it in Kreativ nach Regeln: Methode 635, eine neue Technik zum Lösen von Problemen (1969), in the German journal Absatzwirtschaft. The title means creative by rules, and the rules are in the name: six people each write three ideas on a sheet, then pass the sheets on every five minutes, building on what the others wrote, until each sheet has been around the whole group.
How to run it
- Write the question at the top. Phrase one problem as a question, the same on all six sheets, and draw three columns under it.
- Seat six people. Mix roles and seniority, since the format keeps the senior voices from dominating.
- Write three ideas in five minutes. Each person fills one row in silence, one idea per column.
- Pass the sheet. Everyone hands their sheet to the next person at the bell.
- Read, then build. Read every idea above before writing, and add three that extend, combine, or fix them, or start fresh.
- Repeat until the sheets are full. Six rounds fill six rows, which takes thirty minutes and gives 108 ideas.
- Cluster and pick. Group the ideas, then pick the strongest few, often the ones built on across several rounds.
Where it goes wrong
People write without reading. Someone who uses the five minutes to list their own ideas, ignoring the sheet, turns the method into six separate lists. Remind the group before each pass that the rows above are the input.
The question is too broad. "How can we grow?" gives eighteen unrelated ideas per sheet and nothing builds. Narrow it to one problem a single sheet can work on.
The pool is never sorted. A pile of 108 ideas left in a folder is a session with no result. Book the clustering and selection right after the rounds, while people remember what the half-sentences meant.
When to use something else
- Yes, And. When the group is small, spoken, and comfortable together, and ideas need to build out loud.
- Nominal Group Technique. When the group must also rank the ideas and leave with a decision, not only a pool.
- SCAMPER. When the job is to vary an existing product or process, and prompts will do more than a blank sheet.
Where it sits in SOLVE eX
Go to the source
- Kreativ nach Regeln: Methode 635, eine neue Technik zum Lösen von Problemen, Absatzwirtschaft 12, no. 19, 1969