Lateral Thinking

Thinking Tools4.2 Expansive Idea FormationAlso known as Po

Developed by Edward de Bono (The Use of Lateral Thinking, 1967).

Uses set provocations (a random word, a deliberate impossibility, a negated assumption, a dropped concept, or a reversed goal) to shift thinking off its usual track.

Five provocations on a lake hotel's empty midweek rooms

The facilitator offers a provocation; at each of the team's turns, pick a response. Judging the provocation ends it; moving from it, by taking a principle and carrying it back to the problem, produces an option. The score counts options moved. Illustrative.

Facilitator

Team

Facilitator

Team

Select a stage to read it, or play the sequence.A random word. The hotel is full on weekends and 35 percent full Tuesday to Thursday. The facilitator opens a dictionary at random and reads the word: library.Move from the word. The hotel is a third full midweek, and the random word is library. The team can judge the word or move from it.Pick a move to see the reply.The word is dropped and the room goes quiet.Judgment: the provocation is killed before it moves anything.Someone notes that remote workers in town have nowhere quiet to take calls.Movement: a principle from the word becomes an option.An impossibility. The facilitator states something that cannot be true, on purpose: the hotel has no rooms. What would it sell?Move from it. The team can dismiss the statement or ask what follows from it.Pick a move to see the reply.The chef says he has wanted to teach for years.Movement: the impossible case exposes assets that go unsold midweek.The facilitator moves on with nothing written down.Judgment: correct, and it produces nothing.A negated assumption. Everyone assumes rooms are sold by the night. The facilitator turns it around: rooms are sold by the month.Move from the reversal. The team can argue with the reversal or follow it.Pick a move to see the reply.The point stands, and so does the empty midweek.Judgment: the assumption survives untested.The sales manager knows two firms whose reps drive through every week.Movement: the reversal turns into a bundle someone could buy.A dropped concept. The facilitator removes a concept the problem depends on: there are no weekends, only days.Move without it. The team can call it silly or ask who lives without weekends.Pick a move to see the reply.The front desk says shift nurses already ask for midweek rates.Movement: without the weekend, other people's free days appear.Agreed, and the idea goes no further.Judgment: true and beside the point.A reversed goal. The facilitator flips the goal: instead of filling the hotel midweek, make it emptier.Move from the flip. The team can reject the goal or look for who would pay for emptiness.Pick a move to see the reply.The session ends on the same problem it started with.Judgment: the flip is refused instead of used.The events manager has a list of retreat organizers.Movement: emptiness becomes the thing being sold.

Options moved out of provocations: 0 of 5Options moved out of provocations: 1 of 5Options moved out of provocations: 2 of 5Options moved out of provocations: 3 of 5Options moved out of provocations: 4 of 5Options moved out of provocations: 5 of 5

  1. A random word (Facilitator). The hotel is full on weekends and 35 percent full Tuesday to Thursday. The facilitator opens a dictionary at random and reads the word: library.
  2. Move from the word (Team). The hotel is a third full midweek, and the random word is library. The team can judge the word or move from it.
    • Libraries have nothing to do with hotels. Next. The word is dropped and the room goes quiet. Judgment: the provocation is killed before it moves anything.
    • Libraries are quiet and lend space by the hour: rent rooms as day offices midweek. Someone notes that remote workers in town have nowhere quiet to take calls. Movement: a principle from the word becomes an option.
  3. An impossibility (Facilitator). The facilitator states something that cannot be true, on purpose: the hotel has no rooms. What would it sell?
  4. Move from it (Team). The team can dismiss the statement or ask what follows from it.
    • The kitchen and the dock: sell cooking classes and lakeside offsites, rooms optional. The chef says he has wanted to teach for years. Movement: the impossible case exposes assets that go unsold midweek.
    • A hotel without rooms is not a hotel. That is not useful. The facilitator moves on with nothing written down. Judgment: correct, and it produces nothing.
  5. A negated assumption (Facilitator). Everyone assumes rooms are sold by the night. The facilitator turns it around: rooms are sold by the month.
  6. Move from the reversal (Team). The team can argue with the reversal or follow it.
    • Nobody books a hotel by the month. The point stands, and so does the empty midweek. Judgment: the assumption survives untested.
    • Sell a regional sales team twelve midweek nights over a quarter, at one flat price. The sales manager knows two firms whose reps drive through every week. Movement: the reversal turns into a bundle someone could buy.
  7. A dropped concept (Facilitator). The facilitator removes a concept the problem depends on: there are no weekends, only days.
  8. Move without it (Team). The team can call it silly or ask who lives without weekends.
    • Sell a "weekend" that starts on Tuesday to retirees and shift workers. The front desk says shift nurses already ask for midweek rates. Movement: without the weekend, other people's free days appear.
    • Weekends exist. We cannot change the calendar. Agreed, and the idea goes no further. Judgment: true and beside the point.
  9. A reversed goal (Facilitator). The facilitator flips the goal: instead of filling the hotel midweek, make it emptier.
  10. Move from the flip (Team). The team can reject the goal or look for who would pay for emptiness.
    • That is the opposite of what we want. The session ends on the same problem it started with. Judgment: the flip is refused instead of used.
    • Sell privacy: a whole wing to one small group, nobody else there, at a premium. The events manager has a list of retreat organizers. Movement: emptiness becomes the thing being sold.

An example

A lake hotel ran full on weekends and about a third full from Tuesday to Thursday. Every planning meeting produced the same list: discount the midweek rate, advertise to conferences, add a spa package. All three had been tried.

The general manager brought in a facilitator who ran the meeting on provocations. A random word, library, led to renting rooms by the day as quiet offices for remote workers in town. A deliberate impossibility, the hotel has no rooms, made the team list what else it could sell midweek: the kitchen for cooking classes, the dock for lakeside offsites. Reversing the assumption that rooms are sold by the night produced a quarterly bundle of midweek nights for a regional sales team. Removing the idea of a weekend turned up retirees and shift nurses, whose free days fall midweek. Flipping the goal, make the hotel emptier, led to selling a private wing to small retreat groups. The team tested the day offices and the sales bundle first, and midweek occupancy rose from 35 to 52 percent over two quarters.

Why it works

Experienced teams think along tracks laid by their own experience. Each new problem gets routed to the answers that worked before, which is efficient most of the time and a trap when those answers have run out. Ordinary brainstorming stays on the tracks, because every idea is still judged by whether it makes sense.

A provocation is a statement chosen because it does not make sense: a random word, an impossibility, an assumption turned upside down. It knocks thinking off the usual track. The second half of the method is what makes it work: instead of judging the provocation, the team moves from it. They ask what principle it suggests, what it would require, what it would remind a customer of, and carry that back to the real problem. The value is in the movement, and judgment comes later.

The thinking behind it

Edward de Bono Edward de Bono, a Maltese physician and writer, coined the term lateral thinking and set out the method in The Use of Lateral Thinking (1967). He went on to build structured-thinking tools for schools and business: the CoRT lessons (1973), among them PMI, for plus, minus, interesting; Six Thinking Hats (1985); and Serious Creativity (1992). His tools are widely used, and he was more concerned with their usefulness than with tests of their effect.

How to run it

  1. State the problem and the usual answers. Write the focus in one line, then list the answers the team always reaches for, so everyone can see the track.
  2. Pick a provocation. Use a random word, a deliberate impossibility, a negated assumption, a dropped concept, or a reversed goal.
  3. Say it plainly and suspend judgment. Announce that the statement is meant to be wrong and that nobody may argue with it for ten minutes.
  4. Move from it. Ask what principle it suggests, what would follow if it were true, and what it is like, then carry each answer back to the problem.
  5. Write every option down. Record each idea the movement produces, however rough, before moving to the next provocation.
  6. Run several provocations. Use three to five different kinds in one session, since each knocks thinking off a different track.
  7. Judge afterward. Only when the session ends, sort the options by what could be tested in the next month.

Where it goes wrong

The most common failure is judging the provocation. Someone says a hotel without rooms is not a hotel, everyone agrees, and the provocation dies. The facilitator's job is to stop that sentence and ask what follows instead.

The second is a provocation that is not provocative enough. A mild variation on the usual answer, such as a smaller discount, keeps the team on the track. If no one laughs or objects, push it further.

The third is a session with no harvest. A room full of wild ideas and no follow-up teaches the team that the method is a game. End every session by picking one or two options to test, with an owner and a date.

When to use something else

  • Six Thinking Hats. When the team needs to separate kinds of thinking, such as facts, risks, and feelings, more than to jolt off a track.
  • SCAMPER. When the job is to vary an existing product through a fixed list of changes, one at a time.
  • Creative Constraints. When limiting the brief, by budget, time, or format, is a better way to rule out the usual answer.

Where it sits in SOLVE eX

Go to the source

  • The Use of Lateral Thinking, 1967
  • Lateral Thinking: Creativity Step by Step, 1970
  • Po: Beyond Yes and No, 1972

Back to the catalog