Named biomimetics by Otto H. Schmitt (Some Interesting and Useful Biomimetic Transforms, 1969) and developed as biomimicry by Janine M. Benyus (Biomimicry: Innovation Inspired by Nature, 1997).
Restates a design problem as a function, finds living things that already perform it, and translates their mechanism into a design.
Dusty rooftop solar panels, taken from function to species to principle to design
At each of the team's turns, pick the move: the one that keeps the problem a function and carries over the principle, or the common slip (naming a solution, copying the shape, skipping the test). The biologist's reply shows what each move turns up. Illustrative.
Design team
Biologist
Design team
Biologist
Good moves: 0 of 4Good moves: 1 of 4Good moves: 2 of 4Good moves: 3 of 4Good moves: 4 of 4
- The challenge (Design team). A distributor's rooftop panels lose output to dust, and crews wash them every month. Pick how the team states the problem.
- How do we build a cheaper robot to wash the panels? Nothing in nature washes itself with a robot. What do you need the robot for? A solution, not a function: it rules out every answer except a better robot.
- How does nature keep a surface clean outdoors without washing it? Plenty of things do that. Leaves, wings, some beetles. A function: it opens the search to anything alive that does the job.
- Candidates (Biologist). The biologist lists living things that keep a surface clean. The team has to pick one whose conditions match the panels'.
- Pick the model (Design team). Pick the species to study.
- A cat: it keeps its coat spotless. By licking it for hours. That's active cleaning, which is what you're paying crews for. Wrong conditions: it cleans with effort, and the panels can do nothing.
- The lotus leaf: it stays clean in muddy water, in sun and rain. Good choice. Outdoors, passive, wet and dry. Close to a roof. Matched conditions: a surface that stays clean by doing nothing.
- The mechanism (Biologist). The leaf is covered in microscopic bumps coated in wax. Water cannot spread on it, so it beads up and rolls off, picking up dirt as it goes.
- The principle (Design team). Pick what the team carries over.
- So we make the panels leaf-shaped and curved. The shape does nothing. A flat leaf with the same surface stays just as clean. Copied form: the look of the species, without its mechanism.
- So a rough, water-repelling texture lets rain carry the dirt off. That's it. The texture is the whole trick. A principle: what works, stated without the biology, ready to build.
- It travels (Biologist). A principle stated this way can be built in a material the leaf never used, such as a film on glass.
- Design and test (Design team). Pick the next step.
- Coat the whole roof this month. And if the film cuts the panels' output, you'll find out on every panel at once. No test: the idea is treated as proven before it has been tried.
- Coat twenty panels, leave twenty bare, and compare output after a rainy month. Then you'll know whether it works on your roof, in your dust. A test: the translation is checked against the real conditions.
- The result (Biologist). The coated panels lost about half as much output to dust, and washing moved from monthly to quarterly.
An example
A food distributor had covered its warehouse roofs with solar panels, and in the dry months dust cut their output by a sixth. Crews washed them monthly, at a cost that ate much of the gain. The facilities team's first brief asked for quotes on washing robots.
An engineer rewrote the question as a function: how does nature keep a surface clean outdoors without washing it? A biologist they consulted listed candidates, and the team picked the lotus leaf, which stays clean in muddy ponds with no effort at all, in conditions close to a roof's. Its surface is covered in microscopic waxy bumps that keep water from spreading, so drops bead up, roll off, and take dirt with them. The team stated the principle without the biology (a rough, water-repelling texture lets rain do the cleaning) and found a coating film built on it.
They coated twenty panels and left twenty bare. After a rainy month the coated panels had lost about half as much output, and washing went to quarterly.
Why it works
Teams usually search for answers in their own field, among solutions that already look like the problem. Restating the problem as a function, what has to happen, not what device would do it, removes that limit. A function can be searched for across all of biology, where living things have been working on the same problems far longer than any engineering discipline.
The value lies in the middle steps. Matching the species' conditions to the design's (passive, outdoors, wet and dry) keeps the search from settling on a striking example that will not transfer. Abstracting the principle from the mechanism, the texture and not the leaf, is what makes the idea buildable in a different material at a different scale. Copying a species' shape is the common failure; translating how it works is the method.
The thinking behind it
Janine M. Benyus Janine M. Benyus, a science writer, coined the term biomimicry for design that deliberately borrows nature's solutions, in Biomimicry: Innovation Inspired by Nature (1997), and later cofounded the Biomimicry Institute. Her book is a popular synthesis, not a research study, and it set an agenda for a field that looks at how living things solve a problem first, and designs an answer only after that, wherever the problem comes from.
Otto H. Schmitt Otto H. Schmitt, a biophysicist and engineer who helped found biomedical engineering and invented the Schmitt trigger, coined the word biomimetics for transferring ideas from biology into technology. His paper Some Interesting and Useful Biomimetic Transforms (1969), given at the Third International Biophysics Congress in Cambridge, Massachusetts, used the word in its title, nearly thirty years before Benyus named biomimicry.
How to run it
- State the challenge as a function. Write what has to happen, such as staying clean without washing, with no device named.
- Set the conditions. Note where it has to work: temperature, wet or dry, passive or powered, and scale.
- Search biology for the function. Ask which living things perform it, with a biologist or a biology database.
- Pick a model that matches. Choose a species whose conditions resemble the design's, not the most striking one.
- Work out the mechanism. Find how it does the job, down to the structure or process responsible.
- Abstract the principle. Restate the mechanism with no biology in it, so it could be built in any material.
- Design, then test small. Build the principle into a prototype and compare it with the current way on real conditions.
Where it goes wrong
The team copies the shape. A building shaped like a termite mound or a car shaped like a fish borrows the look and misses the mechanism. If the principle cannot be stated without naming the species, it has not been abstracted yet.
The model is picked for its story. A famous example from a different environment (a desert beetle for a humid problem) rarely transfers. Check the conditions before the mechanism.
Nature is taken as proof. A species shows a principle can work in its setting, not that it will work in the design's setting, at the design's cost. Treat the biology as a source of hypotheses and test the design like any other.
When to use something else
- TRIZ. When the problem is a technical contradiction and the answer is likely in patterns from other inventions, not from biology.
- Structure-Mapping Analogy. When the team wants to borrow from any distant field, and needs a method for mapping relations from one domain to another.
- First Principles Thinking. When the problem is cost or habit, and the answer lies in rebuilding from basic constraints.
Where it sits in SOLVE eX
Go to the source
- Biomimicry: Innovation Inspired by Nature, 1997
- Some Interesting and Useful Biomimetic Transforms, Third International Biophysics Congress, Cambridge, Massachusetts, 1969