Thinking Tools4.2 Expansive Idea FormationAlso known as Product-Market Growth Matrix, Ansoff Growth Matrix
Originated by H. Igor Ansoff (Strategies for Diversification, 1957).
Sorts growth options into four boxes by whether the product and the market are existing or new, each box carrying a different level of risk.
Eight growth ideas for a regional dairy, sorted by how much is new
Place each idea by whether it sells an existing product or a new one, to existing customers or new ones. The box says the risk and the capability the move demands; the further up and right, the more the dairy has to learn at once. The first idea is placed as an example. Illustrative.
Items (select one, then a box)
Not placedPlacedSell more of the sameNew customersNew productsDiversify
Not placedPlacedSell more of the sameNew customersNew productsDiversify
Not placedPlacedSell more of the sameNew customersNew productsDiversify
Not placedPlacedSell more of the sameNew customersNew productsDiversify
Not placedPlacedSell more of the sameNew customersNew productsDiversify
Not placedPlacedSell more of the sameNew customersNew productsDiversify
Not placedPlacedSell more of the sameNew customersNew productsDiversify
Not placedPlacedSell more of the sameNew customersNew productsDiversify
Product
New productsExisting products
New products
Diversify
Sell more of the same
New customers
Existing customersNew customers
Market
More shelf space. Negotiate a second shelf facing for milk at the three grocery chains already stocking it.Not placed yet.More shelf space. Negotiate a second shelf facing for milk at the three grocery chains already stocking it.Sell more of the same: Market penetration: the lowest risk. It needs sales, pricing, and shelf skill the dairy already has, and its limit is how much more the current market will take.Same milk, same stores: the safest move, and the smallest.More shelf space. Negotiate a second shelf facing for milk at the three grocery chains already stocking it.New customers: Market development: a known product, an unknown buyer. It needs distribution, and knowledge of a market the dairy has never served.More shelf space. Negotiate a second shelf facing for milk at the three grocery chains already stocking it.New products: Product development: a known buyer, an unknown product. It needs recipes, equipment, and the skill to launch, sold through channels the dairy already has.More shelf space. Negotiate a second shelf facing for milk at the three grocery chains already stocking it.Diversify: Diversification: two unknowns at once, the highest risk. Usually it needs capability bought or borrowed, so test it small.School milk contract. Win the two districts nearby whose schools already buy from small dairies.Not placed yet.School milk contract. Win the two districts nearby whose schools already buy from small dairies.Sell more of the same: Market penetration: the lowest risk. It needs sales, pricing, and shelf skill the dairy already has, and its limit is how much more the current market will take.Existing product, a kind of buyer the dairy already serves.School milk contract. Win the two districts nearby whose schools already buy from small dairies.New customers: Market development: a known product, an unknown buyer. It needs distribution, and knowledge of a market the dairy has never served.School milk contract. Win the two districts nearby whose schools already buy from small dairies.New products: Product development: a known buyer, an unknown product. It needs recipes, equipment, and the skill to launch, sold through channels the dairy already has.School milk contract. Win the two districts nearby whose schools already buy from small dairies.Diversify: Diversification: two unknowns at once, the highest risk. Usually it needs capability bought or borrowed, so test it small.Lactose-free milk. A lactose-free line for the same grocery shoppers.Not placed yet.Lactose-free milk. A lactose-free line for the same grocery shoppers.Sell more of the same: Market penetration: the lowest risk. It needs sales, pricing, and shelf skill the dairy already has, and its limit is how much more the current market will take.Lactose-free milk. A lactose-free line for the same grocery shoppers.New customers: Market development: a known product, an unknown buyer. It needs distribution, and knowledge of a market the dairy has never served.Lactose-free milk. A lactose-free line for the same grocery shoppers.New products: Product development: a known buyer, an unknown product. It needs recipes, equipment, and the skill to launch, sold through channels the dairy already has.New product, same shoppers: needs a new process, not a new market.Lactose-free milk. A lactose-free line for the same grocery shoppers.Diversify: Diversification: two unknowns at once, the highest risk. Usually it needs capability bought or borrowed, so test it small.Greek yogurt. A strained yogurt sold beside the current milk.Not placed yet.Greek yogurt. A strained yogurt sold beside the current milk.Sell more of the same: Market penetration: the lowest risk. It needs sales, pricing, and shelf skill the dairy already has, and its limit is how much more the current market will take.Greek yogurt. A strained yogurt sold beside the current milk.New customers: Market development: a known product, an unknown buyer. It needs distribution, and knowledge of a market the dairy has never served.Greek yogurt. A strained yogurt sold beside the current milk.New products: Product development: a known buyer, an unknown product. It needs recipes, equipment, and the skill to launch, sold through channels the dairy already has.New product to existing buyers; it needs straining equipment and a launch.Greek yogurt. A strained yogurt sold beside the current milk.Diversify: Diversification: two unknowns at once, the highest risk. Usually it needs capability bought or borrowed, so test it small.Cheese to Asian buyers. Export the aged cheddar the dairy already makes.Not placed yet.Cheese to Asian buyers. Export the aged cheddar the dairy already makes.Sell more of the same: Market penetration: the lowest risk. It needs sales, pricing, and shelf skill the dairy already has, and its limit is how much more the current market will take.Cheese to Asian buyers. Export the aged cheddar the dairy already makes.New customers: Market development: a known product, an unknown buyer. It needs distribution, and knowledge of a market the dairy has never served.A product it knows, to buyers it does not: export rules, distributors, and taste.Cheese to Asian buyers. Export the aged cheddar the dairy already makes.New products: Product development: a known buyer, an unknown product. It needs recipes, equipment, and the skill to launch, sold through channels the dairy already has.Cheese to Asian buyers. Export the aged cheddar the dairy already makes.Diversify: Diversification: two unknowns at once, the highest risk. Usually it needs capability bought or borrowed, so test it small.Milk for coffee chains. Sell barista milk in bulk to regional coffee chains.Not placed yet.Milk for coffee chains. Sell barista milk in bulk to regional coffee chains.Sell more of the same: Market penetration: the lowest risk. It needs sales, pricing, and shelf skill the dairy already has, and its limit is how much more the current market will take.Milk for coffee chains. Sell barista milk in bulk to regional coffee chains.New customers: Market development: a known product, an unknown buyer. It needs distribution, and knowledge of a market the dairy has never served.Existing milk, a new kind of buyer with its own contracts and delivery needs.Milk for coffee chains. Sell barista milk in bulk to regional coffee chains.New products: Product development: a known buyer, an unknown product. It needs recipes, equipment, and the skill to launch, sold through channels the dairy already has.Milk for coffee chains. Sell barista milk in bulk to regional coffee chains.Diversify: Diversification: two unknowns at once, the highest risk. Usually it needs capability bought or borrowed, so test it small.Open a cafe chain. Run five cafes under the dairy's name.Not placed yet.Open a cafe chain. Run five cafes under the dairy's name.Sell more of the same: Market penetration: the lowest risk. It needs sales, pricing, and shelf skill the dairy already has, and its limit is how much more the current market will take.Open a cafe chain. Run five cafes under the dairy's name.New customers: Market development: a known product, an unknown buyer. It needs distribution, and knowledge of a market the dairy has never served.Open a cafe chain. Run five cafes under the dairy's name.New products: Product development: a known buyer, an unknown product. It needs recipes, equipment, and the skill to launch, sold through channels the dairy already has.Open a cafe chain. Run five cafes under the dairy's name.Diversify: Diversification: two unknowns at once, the highest risk. Usually it needs capability bought or borrowed, so test it small.New product and new customers: retail, staffing, and leases, none of which it knows.Pet treats from whey. Turn cheese-making whey into dog treats for pet stores.Not placed yet.Pet treats from whey. Turn cheese-making whey into dog treats for pet stores.Sell more of the same: Market penetration: the lowest risk. It needs sales, pricing, and shelf skill the dairy already has, and its limit is how much more the current market will take.Pet treats from whey. Turn cheese-making whey into dog treats for pet stores.New customers: Market development: a known product, an unknown buyer. It needs distribution, and knowledge of a market the dairy has never served.Pet treats from whey. Turn cheese-making whey into dog treats for pet stores.New products: Product development: a known buyer, an unknown product. It needs recipes, equipment, and the skill to launch, sold through channels the dairy already has.Pet treats from whey. Turn cheese-making whey into dog treats for pet stores.Diversify: Diversification: two unknowns at once, the highest risk. Usually it needs capability bought or borrowed, so test it small.A new product into a new channel. Worth a small test, not a plant.
Your sort matched 0 of 8.Your sort matched 1 of 8.Your sort matched 2 of 8.Your sort matched 3 of 8.Your sort matched 4 of 8.Your sort matched 5 of 8.Your sort matched 6 of 8.Your sort matched 7 of 8.Your sort matched 8 of 8.
Sell more of the same
Market penetration: the lowest risk. It needs sales, pricing, and shelf skill the dairy already has, and its limit is how much more the current market will take.
New customers
Market development: a known product, an unknown buyer. It needs distribution, and knowledge of a market the dairy has never served.
New products
Product development: a known buyer, an unknown product. It needs recipes, equipment, and the skill to launch, sold through channels the dairy already has.
Diversify
Diversification: two unknowns at once, the highest risk. Usually it needs capability bought or borrowed, so test it small.
The sort
More shelf space: Sell more of the same. Same milk, same stores: the safest move, and the smallest.
School milk contract: Sell more of the same. Existing product, a kind of buyer the dairy already serves.
Lactose-free milk: New products. New product, same shoppers: needs a new process, not a new market.
Greek yogurt: New products. New product to existing buyers; it needs straining equipment and a launch.
Cheese to Asian buyers: New customers. A product it knows, to buyers it does not: export rules, distributors, and taste.
Milk for coffee chains: New customers. Existing milk, a new kind of buyer with its own contracts and delivery needs.
Open a cafe chain: Diversify. New product and new customers: retail, staffing, and leases, none of which it knows.
Pet treats from whey: Diversify. A new product into a new channel. Worth a small test, not a plant.
An example
A family-owned regional dairy had flat sales for three years, and its planning offsite produced a whiteboard of growth ideas: more shelf space at the grocers, a school milk contract, lactose-free milk, Greek yogurt, exporting its aged cheddar, bulk milk for coffee chains, a chain of cafes, and dog treats made from cheese whey.
The finance director sorted the list into four boxes before anyone voted. Two ideas sold more of the same milk to the same kind of buyer. Two were new products for the shoppers it already had. Two took existing products to buyers it had never served. Two, the cafes and the pet treats, were new on both counts, and those had been the most popular ideas in the room. Seen in the grid, the cafes meant learning retail, staffing, and leases while also learning a new customer. The board chose shelf space and the school contract for this year, lactose-free milk for next, a small export trial with a distributor, and dropped the cafes.
Why it works
Every growth idea carries two separate risks: making something the company has not made before, and selling to buyers it does not know. A list of ideas mixes them, and excitement tends to favor the ideas with the most novelty. The grid pulls the two risks apart, so a board can see at a glance which ideas extend what the firm already does well and which stack two unknowns at once.
The position also tells the company what each move will demand. Selling more of the same draws on skills it has; a new market needs distribution and local knowledge; a new product needs development and launch skill; diversification usually needs capability it has to buy. Sequencing moves from the lower-left box outward lets the firm learn one new thing at a time.
The thinking behind it
H. Igor Ansoff H. Igor Ansoff, an applied mathematician who became a planning executive at Lockheed and later a professor, is often called the father of strategic management. In Strategies for Diversification (1957, Harvard Business Review) he set out four paths to growth by crossing existing and new products with existing and new markets: market penetration, market development, product development, and diversification. The grid is now called the Ansoff matrix, and its top-right box, a new product for a new market, is the one that asks the firm to learn the most at once.
How to run it
Place the current business. Write what the firm sells today, and to whom, in the lower-left box: existing products in existing markets.
List the growth ideas. Collect every option on the table, each described as a product sold to a buyer.
Put each idea in its box. Ask two questions separately: is the product new to us, and is the buyer new to us?
Note what each box demands. Beside each idea, write the capability it needs that the firm does not yet have.
Match the risk to the appetite. Keep the ideas whose combined risk the owners, the board, and the balance sheet can carry.
Sequence the moves. Start nearest the lower left, and let each move build the capability the next one needs.
Where it goes wrong
New is judged from the inside. A product that is new to the firm but common in the market is still new to the firm, and the grid should say so. Ask what the company has done before, not what the industry has.
Adjacent moves are filed as diversification, or the reverse. Selling the same cheese to a new country is a new market, not a new business, while a cafe chain is a new business with a familiar name on it. Describe each move as a product sold to a buyer before placing it.
The grid ranks risk and stops. A low-risk idea can still be a poor one if the current market is saturated. Pair the grid with the size and the return of each idea.
When to use something else
BCG Growth-Share Matrix. When the question is which existing units should fund which, not which new moves to make.
Blue Ocean Strategy Canvas. When the aim is a new kind of offer that changes how buyers compare the choices on the market.
Three Horizons. When the growth ideas need balancing across time, from today's core to tomorrow's bets.