Founded by Genrich Altshuller and Rafael Shapiro (On the Psychology of Inventive Creativity, 1956) and developed by Altshuller (The Innovation Algorithm, 1969).
Recasts an engineering problem as a contradiction between two parameters and points to the inventive principles that resolved the same contradiction in patents across industries.
A van floor that must get stronger without getting heavier, run through the contradiction matrix
Name the contradiction in the matrix's standard terms: what must improve, and what gets worse when it does. The right pair returns four principles; pick each one to see the design it suggests for the floor, including one that leads nowhere. Illustrative.
What must get better
What gets worse when it does
Principle to try
- Pick what must improve and what gets worse to see what the matrix returns.Cell 14 by 1 (strength against the weight of a moving object) lists principles 1, 8, 15, and 40. Composite materials: a honeycomb-core floor, stiffer than the steel sheet at well under its weight. This is the one the team built and tested.Cell 14 by 1 (strength against the weight of a moving object) lists principles 1, 8, 15, and 40. Segmentation: a floor of bolt-in sections with ribs underneath, so the sheet can be thinner and a damaged section is swapped in an hour.Cell 14 by 1 (strength against the weight of a moving object) lists principles 1, 8, 15, and 40. Anti-weight: offset the weight with a lifting force. Nothing lifts a delivery van, so this one leads nowhere here. The matrix suggests; the engineer judges.Cell 14 by 1 (strength against the weight of a moving object) lists principles 1, 8, 15, and 40. Dynamics: a liner that gives under a dropped pallet and springs back, so the structure beneath it can stay light.Speed is a different problem. The floors crack under forklifts, so the property that must improve is strength.A fair second question, since a cracked floor is slow to fix, but the stated problem is that it cracks at all. Start with strength.Nothing in the problem makes the van harder to drive. What a stronger floor costs is weight, and every pound of it comes off the payload.A thicker floor takes no longer to build or load. The price of strength here is weight.
- Cell 14 by 1 (strength against the weight of a moving object) lists principles 1, 8, 15, and 40. Composite materials: a honeycomb-core floor, stiffer than the steel sheet at well under its weight. This is the one the team built and tested. (improve: Strength, worsen: Weight of moving object, principle: 40 Composite materials)
- Cell 14 by 1 (strength against the weight of a moving object) lists principles 1, 8, 15, and 40. Segmentation: a floor of bolt-in sections with ribs underneath, so the sheet can be thinner and a damaged section is swapped in an hour. (improve: Strength, worsen: Weight of moving object, principle: 1 Segmentation)
- Cell 14 by 1 (strength against the weight of a moving object) lists principles 1, 8, 15, and 40. Anti-weight: offset the weight with a lifting force. Nothing lifts a delivery van, so this one leads nowhere here. The matrix suggests; the engineer judges. (improve: Strength, worsen: Weight of moving object, principle: 8 Anti-weight)
- Cell 14 by 1 (strength against the weight of a moving object) lists principles 1, 8, 15, and 40. Dynamics: a liner that gives under a dropped pallet and springs back, so the structure beneath it can stay light. (improve: Strength, worsen: Weight of moving object, principle: 15 Dynamics)
- Speed is a different problem. The floors crack under forklifts, so the property that must improve is strength. (improve: Speed)
- A fair second question, since a cracked floor is slow to fix, but the stated problem is that it cracks at all. Start with strength. (improve: Ease of repair)
- Nothing in the problem makes the van harder to drive. What a stronger floor costs is weight, and every pound of it comes off the payload. (improve: Strength, worsen: Ease of operation)
- A thicker floor takes no longer to build or load. The price of strength here is weight. (improve: Strength, worsen: Loss of time)
An example
A company that fits out delivery vans had a warranty problem: cargo floors cracked when forklifts dropped pallets onto them. The obvious fix, a thicker steel floor, added about 90 pounds, and every pound came off the payload the van was rated for, which was the number the fleet buyers compared.
The engineering lead wrote the problem down as a contradiction: make the floor stronger without making the van heavier. In the standard terms of the method, that is improving strength while worsening the weight of a moving object. The contradiction matrix lists four principles for that pair: segmentation, anti-weight, dynamics, and composite materials. The team spent an afternoon on each. Anti-weight went nowhere, segmentation produced a bolt-in section design for repairs, and composite materials led to a honeycomb-core floor. The prototype passed the drop test at 40 pounds lighter than the old steel floor.
Why it works
Most engineers treat a trade-off as a dial: a little more strength for a little more weight, until the compromise is tolerable. The method treats the trade-off as the problem itself. Stating it as a contradiction between two named properties makes it general, and a general contradiction has been solved before, in other industries, by people who never saw this product.
The contradiction matrix packs that history into a lookup. Its rows and columns are the standard parameters, and each cell lists the few inventive principles that most often resolved that pair in the patents studied. The engineer still has to turn an abstract principle into a design, and some suggestions fail, but the search starts from moves with a record of breaking this kind of deadlock instead of from a blank page.
The thinking behind it
Genrich Altshuller Genrich Altshuller, an engineer and inventor, built the theory of inventive problem solving from the study of thousands of patents. It holds that technical systems evolve in knowable patterns and that inventive problems turn on contradictions, which a small set of principles can resolve: the 40 inventive principles, fixed in 1971, together with separation of the conflicting requirements and ARIZ, his step-by-step algorithm. He set the method out in Algorithm of Invention (1969), translated into English as The Innovation Algorithm, and in Creativity as an Exact Science (1979).
Rafael Shapiro Rafael Shapiro was Altshuller's school friend and coauthor. The two were imprisoned in 1950 after writing to Stalin and released after 1953. In 1956 they published On the Psychology of Inventive Creativity in the journal Voprosy Psikhologii, the paper that first set out in print the method of inventive problem solving that later took the name TRIZ. Shapiro's name belongs beside Altshuller's at the method's start.
How to run it
- State the contradiction. Write it as one sentence: improve this property without worsening that one.
- Translate both sides into standard parameters. Find the closest of the method's standard parameters for each, such as strength or the weight of a moving object.
- Look up the matrix cell. Read the principles listed where the improving row meets the worsening column.
- Work each principle in your own domain. Spend a fixed block of time per principle, asking what it would look like in this product.
- Keep the dead ends on the list. Write down why a principle fails here; the reason often points to the next idea.
- Develop several candidates and test them. Prototype the two or three strongest and compare them on both parameters, not only the one you set out to improve.
Where it goes wrong
The contradiction is stated too loosely. "Make it better and cheaper" maps to no cell. Keep rewriting until each side is one measurable property; if the team argues over which parameter fits, try both lookups.
The principles are read as answers. A principle is a direction, and a literal reading can sound absurd (anti-weight on a van). Ask what the principle does in general and look for that effect in your product.
The matrix becomes the whole method. Some problems are a physical contradiction, where one part must be both thick and thin, and the matrix handles them poorly. Use separation in time, space, or condition for those.
When to use something else
- Separation Principles. When one part must have two opposite properties at once, such as rigid and flexible, and no lookup fits.
- TRIZ Inventive Principles. When the team only needs fresh idea prompts and no contradiction has been named yet.
- Ideal Final Result. When the first job is to picture the result with no cost or harm, before working out what stands in the way.
Where it sits in SOLVE eX
Go to the source
- On the Psychology of Inventive Creativity, Voprosy Psikhologii, 1956
- The Innovation Algorithm, English translation 1999, 1969