From Chicago improvisational theater (the Compass Players, Second City, and ImprovOlympic), set out by Keith Johnstone (Impro, 1979) and by Charna Halpern, Del Close, and Kim Howard Johnson (Truth in Comedy, 1994).
A collaboration rule: accept each offer and add to it, holding back the reflex to block, judge, or redirect, so ideas build on one another.
An offsite idea built one offer at a time, then judged separately
At each of the lead's turns, answer the teammate's offer: accept it and add to it, or block it with yes, but. The reply shows whether the idea keeps growing, and the bar counts what has been built. The last turn opens the critique round. Illustrative.
Operations lead
Teammate
Operations lead
Teammate
What has been built0of 4
- The first offer (Teammate). Planning the annual team offsite: "What if we held it at the warehouse instead of a hotel?"
- First answer (Operations lead). Pick the lead's answer.
- Yes, but the warehouse has no meeting rooms. True. Okay, a hotel, then. A block: the idea dies at its weakest point, before anyone sees its best one.
- Yes, and each team could run a station on the floor. Yes, and the night crew could teach the day teams their stations. Accepted and added to: the teammate builds again.
- A build (Teammate). The idea now has a purpose the hotel never offered: the two shifts learning each other's work.
- Second answer (Operations lead). Pick the lead's answer.
- That sounds like a liability problem. Fair. Forget the floor, then. A block: a real concern, raised at the wrong time, ends the chain.
- Yes, and lunch goes to whichever team wins a pick-rate race. Yes, and we film it all for new hires. Accepted and added to: another offer comes back.
- Another build (Teammate). An offer that could outlast the day itself.
- Third answer (Operations lead). Pick the lead's answer.
- Yes, and the film becomes the onboarding video we never got around to making. Yes! That alone pays for the day. Accepted and added to: the chain reaches something worth having.
- Let's not get carried away. Budget is tight this year. Right. Sorry. A block: the teammate apologizes for having ideas.
- The chain (Teammate). Four linked ideas: the warehouse, stations taught across shifts, a pick-rate race, and a film for onboarding.
- Critique round (Operations lead). The building is done. Pick the lead's next line.
- Great, let's book all of it. Even the race on a live floor? No critique: the weak parts go through with the strong ones.
- Now, separately: which of these survive a safety and budget check? Stations and the film, yes. The race needs a closed area, so it's out. Critique, after the building: it keeps the best and drops the risky part.
- What survives (Teammate). The offsite runs at the warehouse with cross-shift stations, filmed for onboarding. The race is dropped.
An example
The operations team at a regional distributor had held its annual offsite in the same hotel ballroom for five years, and planning meetings for it took ten minutes because every new idea drew a reason it would not work. This year the lead set one rule for the first half hour: every reply starts with "yes, and", and no one judges anything until the half hour is up.
A teammate suggested holding it at the warehouse. Someone added that each team could run a station on the floor; another, that the night crew could teach the day crew their stations. A pick-rate race for lunch followed, then filming the day for new hires, then the idea that the film could become the onboarding video they had never made.
In the critique round that came after, the race went (it needed a closed floor), and the stations and the film stayed. The offsite ran at the warehouse, and the film is now the first thing new hires watch.
Why it works
A new idea is at its weakest when first spoken: half formed, with its flaws in plain view and its value not yet visible. A block at that moment kills it before anyone sees what it could become, and people learn to stop offering. Yes, and separates building from judging. Each person accepts what was offered and adds to it, so ideas get developed past the point where their best version shows.
The rule works because it changes what people listen for. Someone obliged to add to an offer has to look for its usable part, not its flaw. The building also compounds: the onboarding film in the example came five additions down a chain that a single reasonable objection would have ended at the first. The critique round keeps the method honest. Ideas are judged after they have been built, and the weak ones are still dropped.
The thinking behind it
Keith Johnstone Keith Johnstone, an English theater teacher, set out the principle in Impro: Improvisation and the Theatre (1979): accept an offer instead of blocking it. In his account a scene grows when each player takes what the other offers and builds on it, and a block, refusing the offer, stops it. The same book teaches status work, and he also created Theatresports.
Charna Halpern Charna Halpern co-founded the ImprovOlympic theater in Chicago with Del Close and, with him, adapted and taught the Harold, the long-form improvisation Close developed. Truth in Comedy: The Manual of Improvisation (1994), written with Close and Kim Howard Johnson, is the manual of that approach, and it sets out the practice of accepting a scene partner's offer and building on it, the habit the yes, and rule carries from the stage to the meeting room.
How to run it
- Set the rule and the clock. Agree that for a fixed time every reply builds on the last offer, and that critique comes afterward.
- Give the opening prompt. State the question in one line, such as where and how to hold this year's offsite.
- Make the first offer. Someone offers an idea, good or not, and says it out loud.
- Accept and add. The next person starts with "yes, and" and adds one new thing to the idea just offered.
- Catch the blocks. When a reply starts with "yes, but" or "that won't work", the facilitator stops it and asks for an addition instead.
- Write the chain down. Record every link, since the best idea is often several links in.
- Critique separately. After the clock runs out, judge the chain for cost, risk, and fit, and keep the parts that survive.
Where it goes wrong
The critique round never happens. A team that falls in love with its chain books everything, including the part that needs a closed floor. Put the critique round on the agenda before the building starts, with its own time.
Yes, but sneaks back in. "Yes, and we'd need to check whether that's even allowed" is a block with a polite opening. The facilitator should hear the function of a reply, not its first two words.
The rule is applied to decisions. Yes, and is for generating options; used in a meeting that has to choose, it suppresses the objections the choice needs. Switch modes explicitly, and tell people when judging is welcome again.
When to use something else
- Brainwriting 6-3-5. When a few loud voices dominate spoken sessions and the group needs many ideas fast, written in silence.
- SCAMPER. When there is an existing product or process to vary and the group needs prompts, not a blank page.
- Six Thinking Hats. When the group has to judge an idea from several sides in turn, critique included.
Where it sits in SOLVE eX
Go to the source
- Impro: Improvisation and the Theatre, Faber and Faber, 1979
- Truth in Comedy: The Manual of Improvisation, Meriwether, 1994