Originated by William J. J. Gordon (Synectics, 1961) and developed by George M. Prince (The Practice of Creativity, 1969).
Group problem solving that uses four kinds of analogy (direct, personal, symbolic, and fantasy) to step outside the problem, then forces the analogies back into proposals.
Four analogies for a rental chain's missing tools, each forced back into a proposal
The facilitator asks for a restatement, then one kind of analogy at a time. At each of the group's turns, pick how it answers: snap back to the standard fix, or carry the analogy's own mechanism into a proposal. Illustrative.
Facilitator
Group
Facilitator
Group
Analogies carried into proposals: 0 of 5Analogies carried into proposals: 1 of 5Analogies carried into proposals: 2 of 5Analogies carried into proposals: 3 of 5Analogies carried into proposals: 4 of 5Analogies carried into proposals: 5 of 5
- The problem as given (Facilitator). A fourteen-store tool rental chain loses about four percent of its tools a year to customers who keep them. Bigger deposits, calls, and a collections agency have all been tried.
- Restate it (Group). Pick the group's restatement of the problem.
- How do we stop customers keeping our tools? The ideas that follow are all penalties: fees, deposits, blacklists. The problem's own terms: they lead back to what was already tried.
- How do we make bringing the tool back the easiest thing to do? The room starts talking about the customer's week after the job is done. A goal with room in it: the search moves to why tools stay put.
- Direct analogy (Facilitator). Homing pigeons fly back to the loft, and keepers say they return because home is where the food is.
- Force the pigeon back (Group). Homing pigeons return because home is where the food is. Pick the proposal the group draws from it.
- Raise the deposit so customers have more to lose. Finance points out that this is the deposit increase from last year. Snapped back: the analogy added nothing.
- Give them something to come back for: the deposit becomes credit on the next rental. Marketing likes it at once: a return is now a reason to rent again. The pigeon's mechanism, carried over: home is where the next job is.
- Personal analogy (Facilitator). A store clerk speaks as the drill: the job was done on Saturday, it is Wednesday, and nobody has touched me since.
- Force the drill back (Group). The drill says: the job was done Saturday, and nobody has touched me since. Pick the proposal the group draws from it.
- Charge a late fee from day three. Stores report late fees already cause most of the complaints. Snapped back: a penalty, and no new insight about the forgotten drill.
- Text the customer the day the job is likely done, with a one-tap free pickup. The clerk says most keepers are not thieves; they just forget. Carried over: the drill is forgotten, so reach the customer at the moment it is.
- Symbolic analogy (Facilitator). The group compresses the problem into a phrase that contradicts itself: a generous deposit.
- Force the phrase back (Group). The phrase is a generous deposit. Pick what the group does with it.
- Deposits are never generous. Next one. The phrase goes unexamined. Dismissed: the contradiction was the point.
- A deposit that pays the customer back more when the tool returns on time. It joins the pigeon's credit idea: on time, the deposit grows by ten percent as credit. Carried over: the phrase sharpened the first proposal.
- Fantasy analogy (Facilitator). The wildest answer anyone can give: the tool gets up and walks back to the store when the job is done.
- Force the fantasy back (Group). The tool walks back to the store by itself when the job is done. Pick the proposal the group draws from it.
- Put GPS trackers on every tool. The trackers find tools in garages; customers still have to bring them back. Snapped back: the standard fix, surveillance, with nothing of the fantasy in it.
- Book the pickup when the tool is rented, so it goes home without the customer. Logistics notes the delivery vans run past most addresses twice a week. Carried over: the tool cannot walk, but the van can come for it.
- Two for the pilot (Facilitator). The chain pilots the likely-done text with free pickup and the deposit that becomes credit. At the pilot stores, losses fall by half.
An example
A tool rental chain with fourteen stores was losing about four percent of its fleet a year to tools that never came back. Larger deposits, reminder calls, and a collections agency had each cost more goodwill than they recovered. The operations director booked a half-day session.
The facilitator restated the problem from keep customers from keeping tools to make bringing the tool back the easiest thing to do, then asked for four kinds of analogy. A direct one: homing pigeons fly back because home is where the food is. A personal one: a clerk spoke as the drill, forgotten in a garage after the job. A symbolic one: a generous deposit. A fantasy one: the tool walks home by itself.
Forced back onto the problem, each became a proposal. Two went to a pilot: a text on the day the job was likely finished offering free pickup, and a deposit that turned into credit on the next rental when the tool came back on time. Losses at the pilot stores fell by half.
Why it works
A well-worked problem keeps producing the same answers because people search in its own terms: rental, deposit, late fee. Analogy pulls the search somewhere else. A pigeon or a tool with legs has nothing to do with rental policy, which is why the ideas they suggest are new to the room.
The four kinds of analogy reach different distances. A direct one borrows a working mechanism from another field. A personal one puts the group inside the problem, where it notices what the object or the customer is going through. A symbolic one compresses the tension into a phrase that holds both sides, and a fantasy one drops every constraint at once.
The analogies are raw material. The value comes in the forcing back, when the group asks what the pigeon's reason for returning would be in a rental business, and answers with something a store could pilot next month.
The thinking behind it
William J. J. Gordon William J. J. Gordon, an inventor and psychologist, developed synectics with George Prince in the 1950s in the invention design group at Arthur D. Little, and described it in Synectics: The Development of Creative Capacity (1961). The method uses analogy in two directions: it brings an unfamiliar problem within reach by likening it to something known, and it makes a worn, familiar problem look odd again by likening it to something far away.
George M. Prince George M. Prince, a creativity consultant, codeveloped synectics with Gordon at Arthur D. Little and set out its meeting practices in a manual for group problem solving, The Practice of Creativity (1969). Among them is the itemized response, which answers a new idea first with what is good about it and then with its concerns, each phrased as a problem to solve, so a half-formed proposal is developed instead of shot down.
How to run it
- State the problem as given. Write it the way the owner describes it, with what has already been tried.
- Restate it as a goal. Rephrase it as a how-to, such as make bringing the tool back the easiest thing to do.
- Ask for a direct analogy. How does nature or another field solve something like this?
- Ask for a personal analogy. Have people speak as the object or the customer and say what it is like.
- Ask for a symbolic analogy. Compress the problem into a two-word phrase that holds a contradiction.
- Ask for a fantasy solution. Describe the wildest answer, with no limits on cost or physics.
- Force each analogy back. Ask what its mechanism would look like in this business, and write a proposal.
- Develop before judging. Answer each proposal with its strengths first, then its concerns phrased as problems to solve.
Where it goes wrong
The forcing back snaps to the standard answer. The pigeon leads to a bigger deposit and the fantasy leads to GPS trackers, and the session repeats the standard fixes. Spot it when a proposal could have been written before the analogy; ask what the analogy's own mechanism would be here.
The group stays inside the problem's vocabulary. Analogies drawn from rental or retail are too close to suggest anything new. Push for sources far from the business, such as animals, games, and children's stories.
New proposals are judged too early. Someone points out the flaw in the pickup text, and the idea dies before it is shaped. Use the itemized response: strengths first, then each concern as a problem the group can solve.
When to use something else
- Structure-Mapping Analogy. When one source domain should be mapped onto the problem relation by relation, with the breaks examined.
- SCAMPER. When an existing product or process needs modifying and a checklist of changes is enough to generate options.
- Lateral Thinking. When the group needs provocations and random entry points to break a fixed pattern of thought.
Where it sits in SOLVE eX
Go to the source
- Synectics: The Development of Creative Capacity, 1961
- The Practice of Creativity: A Manual for Dynamic Group Problem-Solving, 1969