Attribute Listing

Thinking Tools4.2 Expansive Idea Formation

Originated by Robert P. Crawford (The Techniques of Creative Thinking, 1954).

Lists every attribute of a product, service, or process, then varies each attribute in turn to generate new versions in an orderly sweep.

An office chair broken into four attributes, each with values to swap in

Each row is one attribute of the maker's current chair; the first value in each row is today's. Change one row at a time and read the variant it produces; change two and the figure notes the combinations that work together or clash. One change is already made: four glides in place of casters. Illustrative.

Seat material

Height adjustment

Base

How it is sold

  • Today's chair. Change one attribute to see the variant it produces.Variant: a foam seat, warmer and cheaper to make, for cold offices and call centers.Variant: a felt seat that absorbs sound, for open-plan floors that are too loud.Variant: no gas cylinder, the part that fails most, in small, medium, and large.Variant: a chair that fits whoever sits in it, for shared desks with no setup.Variant: a chair that stays put, for meeting rooms and hard floors.Variant: a chair that moves without rolling, for people who fidget through long calls.Variant: chairs as a monthly fee, with repairs included, for fast-growing firms.Variant: old chairs taken back, rebuilt, and resold at 60 percent of the new price.Works together: no cylinder to fail means cheaper repairs on every leased chair.Clash: felt does not clean well between owners, so a trade-in needs a removable cover.Works together: a meeting-room chair anyone can sit in without touching a lever.
  • Today's chair. Change one attribute to see the variant it produces.Variant: a foam seat, warmer and cheaper to make, for cold offices and call centers.Variant: a felt seat that absorbs sound, for open-plan floors that are too loud.Variant: no gas cylinder, the part that fails most, in small, medium, and large.Variant: a chair that fits whoever sits in it, for shared desks with no setup.Variant: a chair that stays put, for meeting rooms and hard floors.Variant: a chair that moves without rolling, for people who fidget through long calls.Variant: chairs as a monthly fee, with repairs included, for fast-growing firms.Variant: old chairs taken back, rebuilt, and resold at 60 percent of the new price.Works together: no cylinder to fail means cheaper repairs on every leased chair.Clash: felt does not clean well between owners, so a trade-in needs a removable cover.Works together: a meeting-room chair anyone can sit in without touching a lever.
  • Today's chair. Change one attribute to see the variant it produces.Variant: a foam seat, warmer and cheaper to make, for cold offices and call centers.Variant: a felt seat that absorbs sound, for open-plan floors that are too loud.Variant: no gas cylinder, the part that fails most, in small, medium, and large.Variant: a chair that fits whoever sits in it, for shared desks with no setup.Variant: a chair that stays put, for meeting rooms and hard floors.Variant: a chair that moves without rolling, for people who fidget through long calls.Variant: chairs as a monthly fee, with repairs included, for fast-growing firms.Variant: old chairs taken back, rebuilt, and resold at 60 percent of the new price.Works together: no cylinder to fail means cheaper repairs on every leased chair.Clash: felt does not clean well between owners, so a trade-in needs a removable cover.Works together: a meeting-room chair anyone can sit in without touching a lever.
  • Today's chair. Change one attribute to see the variant it produces.Variant: a foam seat, warmer and cheaper to make, for cold offices and call centers.Variant: a felt seat that absorbs sound, for open-plan floors that are too loud.Variant: no gas cylinder, the part that fails most, in small, medium, and large.Variant: a chair that fits whoever sits in it, for shared desks with no setup.Variant: a chair that stays put, for meeting rooms and hard floors.Variant: a chair that moves without rolling, for people who fidget through long calls.Variant: chairs as a monthly fee, with repairs included, for fast-growing firms.Variant: old chairs taken back, rebuilt, and resold at 60 percent of the new price.Works together: no cylinder to fail means cheaper repairs on every leased chair.Clash: felt does not clean well between owners, so a trade-in needs a removable cover.Works together: a meeting-room chair anyone can sit in without touching a lever.
  • Today's chair. Change one attribute to see the variant it produces.Variant: a foam seat, warmer and cheaper to make, for cold offices and call centers.Variant: a felt seat that absorbs sound, for open-plan floors that are too loud.Variant: no gas cylinder, the part that fails most, in small, medium, and large.Variant: a chair that fits whoever sits in it, for shared desks with no setup.Variant: a chair that stays put, for meeting rooms and hard floors.Variant: a chair that moves without rolling, for people who fidget through long calls.Variant: chairs as a monthly fee, with repairs included, for fast-growing firms.Variant: old chairs taken back, rebuilt, and resold at 60 percent of the new price.Works together: no cylinder to fail means cheaper repairs on every leased chair.Clash: felt does not clean well between owners, so a trade-in needs a removable cover.Works together: a meeting-room chair anyone can sit in without touching a lever.
  • Today's chair. Change one attribute to see the variant it produces.Variant: a foam seat, warmer and cheaper to make, for cold offices and call centers.Variant: a felt seat that absorbs sound, for open-plan floors that are too loud.Variant: no gas cylinder, the part that fails most, in small, medium, and large.Variant: a chair that fits whoever sits in it, for shared desks with no setup.Variant: a chair that stays put, for meeting rooms and hard floors.Variant: a chair that moves without rolling, for people who fidget through long calls.Variant: chairs as a monthly fee, with repairs included, for fast-growing firms.Variant: old chairs taken back, rebuilt, and resold at 60 percent of the new price.Works together: no cylinder to fail means cheaper repairs on every leased chair.Clash: felt does not clean well between owners, so a trade-in needs a removable cover.Works together: a meeting-room chair anyone can sit in without touching a lever.
  • Variant: a foam seat, warmer and cheaper to make, for cold offices and call centers. (seat: Molded foam)
  • Variant: a felt seat that absorbs sound, for open-plan floors that are too loud. (seat: Wool felt)
  • Variant: no gas cylinder, the part that fails most, in small, medium, and large. (adjust: Three fixed sizes)
  • Variant: a chair that fits whoever sits in it, for shared desks with no setup. (adjust: Sets itself by weight)
  • Variant: a chair that stays put, for meeting rooms and hard floors. (base: Four glides)
  • Variant: a chair that moves without rolling, for people who fidget through long calls. (base: Rocker)
  • Variant: chairs as a monthly fee, with repairs included, for fast-growing firms. (sold: Leased per seat)
  • Variant: old chairs taken back, rebuilt, and resold at 60 percent of the new price. (sold: Refurbished trade-in)
  • Works together: no cylinder to fail means cheaper repairs on every leased chair. (adjust: Three fixed sizes, sold: Leased per seat)
  • Clash: felt does not clean well between owners, so a trade-in needs a removable cover. (seat: Wool felt, sold: Refurbished trade-in)
  • Works together: a meeting-room chair anyone can sit in without touching a lever. (adjust: Sets itself by weight, base: Four glides)

An example

An office chair maker had launched three models in four years, each its best seller in a new mesh color. Sales were flat, and the product team's ideas for next year were more of the same: a new arm, a new finish. The head of design called a half-day session to list what the current chair was made of first.

They listed fourteen attributes, from seat material to warranty and how the chair was sold, with two or three alternative values each. Then they changed one attribute at a time and described the chair each change produced. Most variants were dull. A few were not: four glides in place of casters made a chair for meeting rooms, a seat that set its own height by weight made one for shared desks, and leasing per seat with repairs included made a new line of business. The team paired leasing with a chair in three fixed sizes, since the gas cylinder was the part that failed most, and priced a pilot with three fast-growing clients.

Why it works

Brainstorming about a familiar product tends to circle the attributes everyone already notices, usually color and styling. The others, such as how the product is sold, what it rests on, or what breaks first, stay invisible because nobody thinks of them as choices. Writing every attribute down makes each one a choice.

The sweep then works because it is orderly. Changing one attribute at a time means every variant is a single, understandable difference from the current product, easy to judge and easy to cost. Because the list covers every attribute, the search reaches corners a free-form session never visits, and the strong variants can be combined later. The best ideas often come from the attributes that seemed too boring to list.

The thinking behind it

Robert Platt Crawford Robert Platt Crawford, a journalism professor at the University of Nebraska, taught creative thinking there and is credited with attribute listing. In The Techniques of Creative Thinking (1954) he set out the method: list the attributes of an object or problem, then change each one in turn to generate new ideas. The appeal is its order: instead of waiting for inspiration, the person working the list moves through the object's qualities one by one, so the search covers ground a free session skips. One author database lists an earlier book under a similar title dated 1950; the 1954 edition was published by Hawthorn Books.

How to run it

  1. Pick the thing to redesign. Name one product, service, or process, such as the current best-selling chair.
  2. List its attributes. Aim for ten to twenty, including the unglamorous ones: materials, mechanisms, price, how it is sold, delivered, repaired, and disposed of.
  3. Write alternative values for each. Give two or three per attribute, including at least one that seems odd.
  4. Change one attribute at a time. Describe the product each single change produces and who it would suit.
  5. Mark the promising variants. Keep the ones that open a new use, customer, or cost advantage.
  6. Combine the best changes. Test pairs of kept changes for ones that reinforce each other and ones that clash.
  7. Cost and test the strongest. Price the top two or three and put them in front of customers before building.

Where it goes wrong

The common failure is a short list of obvious attributes. A team that lists color, size, and price produces color, size, and price variants. If the list has fewer than ten entries, or none about how the product is sold, serviced, or used, push for more before generating anything.

The second is changing everything at once. Variants that alter five attributes are hard to judge and harder to explain, and the team cannot tell which change made the idea good. Change one, judge it, and combine later.

The third is stopping at the list of variants. Most will be weak, and that is expected. Without a step that marks the few strong ones and tests them with customers, the session produces a long document and no product.

When to use something else

  • Morphological Analysis. When the aim is to explore whole combinations of values across every attribute at once, and to screen out the ones that cannot work.
  • SCAMPER. When a quick set of prompts, such as substitute, combine, and adapt, is enough to shake loose ideas without a full list.
  • TRIZ Inventive Principles. When improving one property of the product makes another worse, and the conflict itself needs resolving.

Where it sits in SOLVE eX

Go to the source

  • The Techniques of Creative Thinking, 1954

Back to the catalog