Ideal Final Result

Thinking Tools4.2 Expansive Idea FormationAlso known as IFR

From TRIZ, developed by Genrich Altshuller (Creativity as an Exact Science, 1979), and restated by Darrell Mann (Hands-On Systematic Innovation, 2002).

Pictures the function delivered with no system at all, then works back toward that ideal to find designs that use existing resources or remove the need entirely.

Seven ideas for clean van floors, sorted by how close each comes to the ideal

The ideal: every van's cargo floor is clean each morning, and nobody washes it. The night crew is placed as an example, at the far end. Select each other idea and pick how close it comes: adding a system, using what is already there, a van that cleans itself, or no mess to clean. Illustrative.

Items (select one, then a box)
  • Not placedPlacedNew systemReuseSelf-actingNo need
  • Not placedPlacedNew systemReuseSelf-actingNo need
  • Not placedPlacedNew systemReuseSelf-actingNo need
  • Not placedPlacedNew systemReuseSelf-actingNo need
  • Not placedPlacedNew systemReuseSelf-actingNo need
  • Not placedPlacedNew systemReuseSelf-actingNo need
  • Not placedPlacedNew systemReuseSelf-actingNo need

Ideas

Van floors
New system
Reuse
Self-acting
No need
Adds a systemUses what is thereDoes it itselfNeed removed

How close to the ideal

Night wash crew. Three people power-wash all sixty vans each night, forty minutes a van.Not placed yet.Night wash crew. Three people power-wash all sixty vans each night, forty minutes a van.New system: The function gets done by something new: people, machines, or supplies that cost money every night.Today's answer: a whole system added to deliver the function, at $310,000 a year.Night wash crew. Three people power-wash all sixty vans each night, forty minutes a van.Reuse: The function gets done by resources already on site, such as equipment, time, or a trip already made.Night wash crew. Three people power-wash all sixty vans each night, forty minutes a van.Self-acting: The van performs the function as part of its normal work, with no extra step.Night wash crew. Three people power-wash all sixty vans each night, forty minutes a van.No need: The ideal: the mess never happens, so the function is no longer needed at all.Automatic wash bay. Buy a drive-through wash bay for the depot.Not placed yet.Automatic wash bay. Buy a drive-through wash bay for the depot.New system: The function gets done by something new: people, machines, or supplies that cost money every night.A better machine, still a new system with its own cost and upkeep.Automatic wash bay. Buy a drive-through wash bay for the depot.Reuse: The function gets done by resources already on site, such as equipment, time, or a trip already made.Automatic wash bay. Buy a drive-through wash bay for the depot.Self-acting: The van performs the function as part of its normal work, with no extra step.Automatic wash bay. Buy a drive-through wash bay for the depot.No need: The ideal: the mess never happens, so the function is no longer needed at all.Throwaway liners. Lay a plastic liner on each floor and bin it at night.Not placed yet.Throwaway liners. Lay a plastic liner on each floor and bin it at night.New system: The function gets done by something new: people, machines, or supplies that cost money every night.Cheaper labor, but a new supply bought and thrown away every day.Throwaway liners. Lay a plastic liner on each floor and bin it at night.Reuse: The function gets done by resources already on site, such as equipment, time, or a trip already made.Throwaway liners. Lay a plastic liner on each floor and bin it at night.Self-acting: The van performs the function as part of its normal work, with no extra step.Throwaway liners. Lay a plastic liner on each floor and bin it at night.No need: The ideal: the mess never happens, so the function is no longer needed at all.Liner in crate washer. A rigid floor liner, lifted out and run through the crate washer the depot already runs each night.Not placed yet.Liner in crate washer. A rigid floor liner, lifted out and run through the crate washer the depot already runs each night.New system: The function gets done by something new: people, machines, or supplies that cost money every night.Liner in crate washer. A rigid floor liner, lifted out and run through the crate washer the depot already runs each night.Reuse: The function gets done by resources already on site, such as equipment, time, or a trip already made.Uses a machine already paid for and running anyway.Liner in crate washer. A rigid floor liner, lifted out and run through the crate washer the depot already runs each night.Self-acting: The van performs the function as part of its normal work, with no extra step.Liner in crate washer. A rigid floor liner, lifted out and run through the crate washer the depot already runs each night.No need: The ideal: the mess never happens, so the function is no longer needed at all.Wipe at last stop. Drivers wipe the floor while they wait at the last drop, where they idle ten minutes for a signature.Not placed yet.Wipe at last stop. Drivers wipe the floor while they wait at the last drop, where they idle ten minutes for a signature.New system: The function gets done by something new: people, machines, or supplies that cost money every night.Wipe at last stop. Drivers wipe the floor while they wait at the last drop, where they idle ten minutes for a signature.Reuse: The function gets done by resources already on site, such as equipment, time, or a trip already made.Uses time already spent. Closer, though it still depends on someone doing it.Wipe at last stop. Drivers wipe the floor while they wait at the last drop, where they idle ten minutes for a signature.Self-acting: The van performs the function as part of its normal work, with no extra step.Wipe at last stop. Drivers wipe the floor while they wait at the last drop, where they idle ten minutes for a signature.No need: The ideal: the mess never happens, so the function is no longer needed at all.Self-draining floor. A sloped, coated floor with a drain at the doors, so spills run out as the van brakes and turns.Not placed yet.Self-draining floor. A sloped, coated floor with a drain at the doors, so spills run out as the van brakes and turns.New system: The function gets done by something new: people, machines, or supplies that cost money every night.Self-draining floor. A sloped, coated floor with a drain at the doors, so spills run out as the van brakes and turns.Reuse: The function gets done by resources already on site, such as equipment, time, or a trip already made.Self-draining floor. A sloped, coated floor with a drain at the doors, so spills run out as the van brakes and turns.Self-acting: The van performs the function as part of its normal work, with no extra step.The van's own motion does the cleaning, with no added step.Self-draining floor. A sloped, coated floor with a drain at the doors, so spills run out as the van brakes and turns.No need: The ideal: the mess never happens, so the function is no longer needed at all.Lidded crates. Sealed crates for wet produce and meat, which cause nine spills in ten.Not placed yet.Lidded crates. Sealed crates for wet produce and meat, which cause nine spills in ten.New system: The function gets done by something new: people, machines, or supplies that cost money every night.Lidded crates. Sealed crates for wet produce and meat, which cause nine spills in ten.Reuse: The function gets done by resources already on site, such as equipment, time, or a trip already made.Lidded crates. Sealed crates for wet produce and meat, which cause nine spills in ten.Self-acting: The van performs the function as part of its normal work, with no extra step.Lidded crates. Sealed crates for wet produce and meat, which cause nine spills in ten.No need: The ideal: the mess never happens, so the function is no longer needed at all.The ideal for most of the mess: nothing spills, so nothing needs cleaning.

Your sort matched 0 of 7.Your sort matched 1 of 7.Your sort matched 2 of 7.Your sort matched 3 of 7.Your sort matched 4 of 7.Your sort matched 5 of 7.Your sort matched 6 of 7.Your sort matched 7 of 7.

New system
The function gets done by something new: people, machines, or supplies that cost money every night.
Reuse
The function gets done by resources already on site, such as equipment, time, or a trip already made.
Self-acting
The van performs the function as part of its normal work, with no extra step.
No need
The ideal: the mess never happens, so the function is no longer needed at all.

The sort

  • Night wash crew: New system. Today's answer: a whole system added to deliver the function, at $310,000 a year.
  • Automatic wash bay: New system. A better machine, still a new system with its own cost and upkeep.
  • Throwaway liners: New system. Cheaper labor, but a new supply bought and thrown away every day.
  • Liner in crate washer: Reuse. Uses a machine already paid for and running anyway.
  • Wipe at last stop: Reuse. Uses time already spent. Closer, though it still depends on someone doing it.
  • Self-draining floor: Self-acting. The van's own motion does the cleaning, with no added step.
  • Lidded crates: No need. The ideal for most of the mess: nothing spills, so nothing needs cleaning.

An example

A grocery delivery company power-washed the cargo floors of its sixty vans every night: three people, forty minutes a van, about $310,000 a year. The operations lead was asked to cut the cost, and the first proposals were all better versions of the same thing: an automatic wash bay, a cheaper night crew, throwaway plastic liners.

She started over from the result instead. The ideal: every floor is clean each morning, and nobody washes it. Then she worked back from there. What is already on site that could do the job? The depot ran a crate washer every night, and a rigid floor liner would fit through it. Could the van clean itself? A sloped, coated floor would drain as the van moved. Could the mess not happen at all? Nine spills in ten came from wet produce and meat, so the company bought sealed crates for those lines. Sealed crates and liners through the crate washer cut washing from nightly to weekly, and the cost by four-fifths.

Why it works

Improvement usually starts from the current system and asks how to make it better, which produces a better version of the current system. Starting from the ideal reverses the direction. If the function could be delivered with no system at all, what would that look like? The ideal is rarely reachable, but it points the search away from the existing design and toward the resources and changes that would get closest to it.

The steps back from the ideal are a ladder of ever simpler answers. First, can the job be done by something already present: equipment, time, or a trip already made? Then, can the object do it for itself as part of its own work? Last, can the need be removed altogether? Each rung up the ladder removes cost instead of moving it.

The thinking behind it

Genrich Altshuller Genrich Altshuller, an engineer and inventor, created TRIZ, the theory of inventive problem solving, from the study of thousands of patents. TRIZ holds that technical systems evolve by knowable patterns and that inventive problems turn on contradictions, which can be resolved by a small set of principles. Creativity as an Exact Science (1979; in English, 1984) sets out the theory; the ideal final result is one of its tools for pointing a search before any design is drawn.

Darrell Mann Darrell Mann, an engineer and TRIZ practitioner associated with Systematic Innovation, restated the method for working designers in Hands-On Systematic Innovation (2002). The handbook updates Altshuller's theory with function analysis, trimming, the ideal final result, and the separation principles, and treats each as a practical step a designer can take on a live problem. It is a practitioner's manual, and its restatement of the ideal final result is the one this page follows.

How to run it

  1. State the function, not the system. Write what must be true, such as clean floors each morning, without naming how it happens today.
  2. Write the ideal final result. Describe the function delivered with no system, no cost, and no harm: the floor is clean and nobody cleans it.
  3. Name what blocks the ideal. List what makes the ideal impossible today, such as spills and the lack of a drain.
  4. Search the resources already present. List equipment, time, materials, and trips already on site that could do the job.
  5. Ask whether the object can do it itself. Look for a design where the thing performs the function as part of its normal work.
  6. Ask whether the need can disappear. Find the source of the problem and test whether removing it removes the function entirely.
  7. Pick the closest answer you can build. Choose the idea nearest the ideal that is feasible now, and keep the others for the next round.

Where it goes wrong

The first failure is writing the ideal around today's system. "The wash takes ten minutes" is a better system, not an ideal. If the ideal names a machine or a crew, rewrite it as the function alone.

The second is dismissing the ideal because it is impossible. It is meant to be impossible; its job is to point the search. Judge the ideas it leads to, not the ideal itself.

The third is stopping at the first rung. Using what is already there feels like a win, and it is, but the larger savings usually sit higher up, in removing the need. Ask the last question even when the earlier answers look good enough.

When to use something else

  • TRIZ Trimming. When the system exists and the question is which of its parts can go.
  • Separation Principles. When the path to the ideal is blocked by a requirement that seems to conflict with itself.
  • Backcasting. When the end state is an organization's future and the plan works back from it.

Where it sits in SOLVE eX

Go to the source

  • Creativity as an Exact Science, Russian original 1979; English edition Gordon and Breach, 1984, 1979
  • Hands-On Systematic Innovation, CREAX Press, 2002

Back to the catalog