Popularized by Clayton M. Christensen (The Innovator's Solution, 2003; Competing Against Luck, 2016) and developed as outcome-driven innovation by Anthony W. Ulwick (2002), after Theodore Levitt's quarter-inch hole (The Marketing Mode, 1969).
Treats customers as hiring a product to make progress in a particular situation, with functional, emotional, and social jobs, so competitors and innovations are defined by the job.
Three things a restaurant owner hires to make payroll in a slow month
The bank's credit line is the cheapest, yet the owner's own card and paying suppliers late both do the job better: the job has a speed, a feeling, and an audience, and the weights say how much each matters. Change a score or a weight and watch which one gets hired. Illustrative.
Functional: cash in hand by Friday
WeightThe bank's lineOwner's cardPaying lateFunctional: cheap for a few weeks
WeightThe bank's lineOwner's cardPaying lateEmotional: no forms when already stressed
WeightThe bank's lineOwner's cardPaying lateSocial: staff and suppliers never find out
WeightThe bank's lineOwner's cardPaying lateWeighted total
The bank's line159OutOwner's card212OutPaying late194OutGets hired for this jobNo option passes every must: rescope or find another.The bank's lineOwner's cardPaying late
In order, for this job
- 212The bank's lineOwner's cardPaying late
- 194The bank's lineOwner's cardPaying late
- 159The bank's lineOwner's cardPaying late
An example
A regional bank's small-business team could not understand why restaurant owners rarely drew on its credit lines, which were cheaper than any other bank's. They stopped comparing rates and interviewed twenty owners who had run short of cash in the past year, asking each to walk through the week it happened. The job was the same every time: make Friday payroll in a slow month. It had a feeling attached, getting through without forms and phone calls at the worst moment, and an audience, since no owner wanted the staff or the produce supplier to know.
What the owners hired for that job was their own credit card first and paying suppliers late second, with cash advance apps close behind. The bank's line came last: five days to approve and a stack of paperwork. The team stopped selling the rate. It opened a small line with every new business account and let owners draw on it from a phone in under a minute.
Why it works
A product category is the seller's idea; customers do not shop that way. They are trying to make progress in a particular situation, and they pull in whatever gets them there, including things no one in the industry counts as a rival. Asking about the moment of purchase, instead of the buyer's profile, exposes that situation and the full set of options weighed in it. The emotional and social sides of the job matter because they decide between options that all do the practical task: every option above produces cash, and they differ in how it feels and who notices. Seen through the job, the bank's real competitor was a credit card, and the fix was speed. Price had never been the problem.
The thinking behind it
Clayton M. Christensen Clayton M. Christensen, a Harvard Business School professor known for disruptive innovation, developed the jobs view with coauthors in The Innovator's Solution (2003, with Michael E. Raynor) and Competing Against Luck (2016, with Taddy Hall, Karen Dillon, and David S. Duncan). Its claim is that customers hire a product to make progress in a particular circumstance, so the circumstance explains the purchase better than any trait of the customer.
Anthony W. Ulwick Anthony W. Ulwick, founder of the Strategyn consultancy, set out the measured form in Turn Customer Input into Innovation (Harvard Business Review, 2002) and What Customers Want (2005). His outcome-driven innovation treats the results customers want from a job as needs that can be measured, then ranks them by importance and by how well they are met today, so the unmet ones show where to build.
Theodore Levitt Theodore Levitt, a Harvard Business School professor and editor of the Harvard Business Review, carried the famous line about the quarter-inch drill in The Marketing Mode (1969): what the buyer is after is the quarter-inch hole. He credited it to Leo McGivena, and Percy H. Whiting had printed it in 1947. It remains the shortest statement of the job view. The product is a means, and the customer is paying for the result.
How to run it
- Pick recent switchers. Find people who bought your product or an alternative in the last few months, while the moment is fresh.
- Walk through the moment. Ask what was happening the day they decided, what they had tried before, and what nearly stopped them.
- Write the functional job. State the progress they wanted in one line, in their words, with the situation attached.
- Add the feeling and the audience. Note how they wanted to feel and who they did or did not want to notice.
- List everything hired for the job. Include workarounds, delays, and doing nothing, along with products in your category.
- Score each option on the job. Rate every option on each part of the job and see where yours loses.
- Change the product where it loses. Fix the part of the job where a rival wins, and describe your offer in the job's terms.
Where it goes wrong
The first failure is stopping at the functional job. Every option does the practical task, so a list of functional jobs never explains why one gets chosen; probe the feeling and the audience until the options separate. The second is interviewing about preferences. People asked what they want describe an ideal; people asked about last Tuesday describe what they did, so keep every question tied to a dated purchase. The third is job inflation, naming every feature as its own job until the list is useless. A job is progress in the customer's life or work, a level above any feature, and a team that cannot say it in one line has not found it yet.
When to use something else
- Customer Discovery. When there is no product yet and the first question is whether the problem is real and painful.
- Empathy Map. When the team needs a shared picture of one customer's thoughts and feelings before any interviews are planned.
- Blue Ocean Strategy Canvas. When the job is known and the question is which factors to raise, cut, or create against the rivals.
Where it sits in SOLVE eX
Go to the source
- The Innovator's Solution, 2003
- Turn Customer Input into Innovation, Harvard Business Review, 2002
- The Marketing Mode: Pathways to Corporate Growth, 1969
- Competing Against Luck: The Story of Innovation and Customer Choice, HarperBusiness, with Taddy Hall, Karen Dillon, and David S. Duncan, 2016