Developed by Bob Eberle (SCAMPER: Games for Imagination Development, 1971) from the idea-spurring checklist of Alex F. Osborn (Applied Imagination, 1953).
Runs an existing product, process, or idea through seven prompts (substitute, combine, adapt, modify, put to other uses, eliminate, and reverse) to produce many variants.
Seven prompts run on a hardware store's tool rental counter
Each prompt is applied to the same rental counter and produces its own variants, written without judging; twenty-one of the session's forty-four are shown here. Tick the ones worth testing and copy the shortlist. Illustrative.
1 variant picked0 variants picked
CopiedCould not copyS: Substitute
What part, person, material, or step could something else replace?
- Removes the most common complaint at the counter.
C: Combine
What could be joined to it: another product, a service, a skill?
A: Adapt
What works somewhere else that could be borrowed?
M: Modify
What could be made bigger, smaller, longer, or shorter?
P: Put to other uses
Who else could use it, or what else could it do?
E: Eliminate
What step, part, or cost could be dropped entirely?
R: Reverse
What could run backward, or swap who does what?
An example
A family-owned hardware store's tool rental counter had flat revenue for three years, and its brainstorming meetings kept producing the same two ideas: more tools and a lower price. The store manager ran the seven prompts on the counter with four staff in a ninety-minute session, one prompt at a time, with a rule that nobody judged an idea until all seven were done.
Substitute gave a hold on the customer's card in place of the cash deposit. Adapt borrowed a library's hold queue, so a customer could reserve the tile saw for Saturday. Put to other uses found that the fleet sat idle midweek, when contractors' crews would rent it. Reverse produced the odd one, customers renting their own tools to neighbors through the store. By the end they had forty-four variants. They grouped them, scored the groups on cost and likely demand, and picked three to test: weekday rates for crews, Saturday reservations, and the card hold. Midweek rentals doubled within the quarter.
Why it works
Free brainstorming runs out fast because people circle the ideas they already have. Each prompt is a different operation on the same thing (swap a part, join it to something, borrow from elsewhere, change its size, find it a new user, remove a piece, run it backward), so each one sends the search in a direction the group had not tried. Applying the prompts to something that already exists helps too: transforming a familiar object is easier than inventing from nothing, and every variant arrives already connected to something the business runs. Keeping judgment out until all seven are done matters as much as the prompts. Ideas that look silly in the moment, such as customers renting out their own tools, often hold the piece of a good idea that the later sorting finds.
The thinking behind it
Bob Eberle Bob Eberle, an American educator, arranged Alex Osborn's idea-spurring questions into the mnemonic SCAMPER, one letter for each operation, in SCAMPER: Games for Imagination Development (1971). He wrote it as games for developing children's imagination. The seven letters make the questions easy to remember and to run in order, and the checklist is now used widely, well beyond the classroom, to generate variations on a product or idea that already exists.
Alex F. Osborn Alex F. Osborn, a co-founder of the advertising agency BBDO, named brainstorming and gave it four rules: go for quantity, withhold criticism, welcome wild ideas, and combine and improve ideas. Applied Imagination (1953) carried his checklist of idea-spurring questions, the source of SCAMPER's prompts. Studies reviewed by Diehl and Stroebe in 1987 found that interacting groups produce fewer ideas than the same number of people working alone, a reason to have people write variants on their own before the group shares them.
How to run it
- Pick one existing thing. Choose a specific product, service, or process, such as the rental counter; a whole business is too broad.
- Run the prompts in order. Spend ten minutes on each of the seven, and write every variant down without comment.
- Push past the obvious. Aim for five or more variants per prompt; the useful ones often come after the first three.
- Write alone, then share. Have each person list variants silently for a few minutes before the group pools them.
- Hold judgment until the end. Only when all seven prompts are done, group similar variants together.
- Score the groups. Rate each group on cost, likely impact, and how quickly it could be tried.
- Pick three to test. Choose three to five variants and set a small, dated test for each.
Where it goes wrong
The first failure is judging as you go. A comment like "we tried that" in the room ends a line of thought, so ideas shrink to the safe ones; if the list per prompt is short and sensible, criticism got in early, and the fix is a written round with no talking. The second is skipping prompts that feel awkward. Reverse and Eliminate are the ones most often dropped and the ones most likely to produce something new, so run all seven. The third is a subject too broad. Running the prompts on the whole company produces slogans; narrow it to one product or one step of a process.
When to use something else
- TRIZ. When the problem is a technical contradiction, where improving one property makes another worse.
- Brainwriting 6-3-5. When the group talks over each other and needs ideas written in silent rounds that build on each other.
- Morphological Analysis. When the design splits into parameters and the aim is to combine options for each into whole alternatives.
Where it sits in SOLVE eX
Go to the source
- SCAMPER: Games for Imagination Development, 1971
- Applied Imagination, 1953