Nominal Group Technique

Thinking Tools4.2 Expansive Idea FormationAlso known as NGT

Developed by André L. Delbecq and Andrew H. Van de Ven (A Group Process Model for Problem Identification and Program Planning, 1971), with David H. Gustafson (Group Techniques for Program Planning, 1975).

Runs a meeting through silent idea writing, round-robin sharing, clarifying discussion, and private ranking, producing a prioritized list that every member had an equal hand in.

Four moves in a churn meeting, each one open or nominal

Seven people must rank ideas for cutting customer churn, and one of them is the sales vice president. At each of the facilitator's turns, pick the move: the ordinary open meeting, or the nominal group step. The group's response shows, and the count tallies the steps that kept every voice equal. Illustrative.

Facilitator

The group

Facilitator

The group

Select a stage to read it, or play the sequence.Getting ideas. The question on the wall: what would most cut cancellations in the first ninety days? Pick how the facilitator gets ideas.Pick a move to see the reply.The sales vice president speaks for ten minutes about pricing. The next four ideas are all about pricing.The first voice anchors the rest.Seven people write 31 ideas. The support lead writes four about the first week of onboarding.Silent writing: every head works before any voice is heard.The ideas. Ideas nobody would have said aloud in front of the vice president are now on paper.Sharing. Pick how the ideas reach the wall.Pick a move to see the reply.The vice president reads six. By the time it reaches the support lead, time is short and she reads one.Rank decides whose ideas get heard.Four rounds. Every person's ideas are on the wall, 24 once duplicates are set side by side.Round-robin: equal turns, nothing lost.The list. Each idea is written in its author's words, numbered, and not yet judged.Discussion. Pick what the facilitator allows before the vote.Pick a move to see the reply.The vice president calls the onboarding ideas small ball. Two people stop talking for the rest of the meeting.Open debate: status settles it before the vote.Twelve minutes. Three pairs turn out to be the same idea and are merged.Everyone votes on the same understanding of each idea.Clarified. Nobody has said which ideas they favor.Choosing. Pick how the group chooses.Pick a move to see the reply.Hands go up a beat after the vice president's. The price cut wins.A public vote: people follow the room.Seven ballots, face down. The facilitator adds the points on the wall.A private ranking: each vote counts once, unseen.The ranking. Combined points: a welcome call in week one, 24; fixing failed-payment emails, 19; an alert when an account goes idle, 15; a discount on annual plans, 11. An open meeting would have put the discount first.

Steps that kept every voice equal: 0 of 4Steps that kept every voice equal: 1 of 4Steps that kept every voice equal: 2 of 4Steps that kept every voice equal: 3 of 4Steps that kept every voice equal: 4 of 4

  1. Getting ideas (Facilitator). The question on the wall: what would most cut cancellations in the first ninety days? Pick how the facilitator gets ideas.
    • Let's hear ideas. Who wants to start? The sales vice president speaks for ten minutes about pricing. The next four ideas are all about pricing. The first voice anchors the rest.
    • Eight minutes: write your own ideas, one per card, without talking. Seven people write 31 ideas. The support lead writes four about the first week of onboarding. Silent writing: every head works before any voice is heard.
  2. The ideas (The group). Ideas nobody would have said aloud in front of the vice president are now on paper.
  3. Sharing (Facilitator). Pick how the ideas reach the wall.
    • Read out your best ones, starting with the most senior. The vice president reads six. By the time it reaches the support lead, time is short and she reads one. Rank decides whose ideas get heard.
    • Around the table, one idea each per turn, until every card is up. Four rounds. Every person's ideas are on the wall, 24 once duplicates are set side by side. Round-robin: equal turns, nothing lost.
  4. The list (The group). Each idea is written in its author's words, numbered, and not yet judged.
  5. Discussion (Facilitator). Pick what the facilitator allows before the vote.
    • Let's debate which ones are strongest. The vice president calls the onboarding ideas small ball. Two people stop talking for the rest of the meeting. Open debate: status settles it before the vote.
    • Questions to clarify only: what an idea means, not whether it is good. Twelve minutes. Three pairs turn out to be the same idea and are merged. Everyone votes on the same understanding of each idea.
  6. Clarified (The group). Nobody has said which ideas they favor.
  7. Choosing (Facilitator). Pick how the group chooses.
    • Show of hands for each idea. Hands go up a beat after the vice president's. The price cut wins. A public vote: people follow the room.
    • Each person ranks a top five privately: five points for first, one for fifth. Seven ballots, face down. The facilitator adds the points on the wall. A private ranking: each vote counts once, unseen.
  8. The ranking (The group). Combined points: a welcome call in week one, 24; fixing failed-payment emails, 19; an alert when an account goes idle, 15; a discount on annual plans, 11. An open meeting would have put the discount first.

An example

A subscription software company was losing a fifth of new customers in their first ninety days. The chief operating officer wanted a ranked list of fixes from the seven people closest to it, and she knew how the last such meeting had gone: the sales vice president spoke first, argued for a price cut, and the room agreed.

This time a facilitator ran it as a nominal group. Everyone wrote ideas alone for eight minutes, one per card: 31 cards. Then each person read out one idea per turn, around the table, until every card was on the wall. The support lead's four cards, all about the first week of onboarding, went up alongside the vice president's. Discussion was for clarifying only, and three pairs of cards turned out to be the same idea. Last, each person ranked a top five privately.

The combined points put a welcome call in the first week at the top, with 24 points, and fixing failed-payment emails second. The price cut came fourth. The company ran the welcome call first.

Why it works

An open meeting merges two jobs that interfere: generating ideas and judging them. The first idea spoken anchors the rest, the most senior or the most confident voice sets the frame, and people who disagree either stay quiet or change their minds to match the room. The result looks like consensus and is mostly the view of whoever spoke first.

The technique separates the jobs and protects each. Writing alone means every person's thinking is done before anyone else's can steer it. Turn-taking gets every idea onto the wall in its author's words. Clarifying without judging means people vote on the same understanding. Ranking in private means each vote counts once, unseen. The group still meets and talks, but no one voice can carry the result.

The thinking behind it

André L. Delbecq André L. Delbecq, an organization scholar who later became dean of the Leavey School of Business at Santa Clara University, first developed the nominal group technique with Andrew Van de Ven in A Group Process Model for Problem Identification and Program Planning (1971), in the Journal of Applied Behavioral Science: silent idea generation, round-robin recording, discussion, and independent voting. Each step is there to keep any one voice from setting the result.

Andrew H. Van de Ven Andrew H. Van de Ven, an organization scholar at the University of Minnesota, was Delbecq's coauthor on the 1971 paper and on Group Techniques for Program Planning: A Guide to Nominal Group and Delphi Processes (1975). The guide set out the nominal group, with its silent writing, round-robin listing, discussion, and private vote, side by side with the Delphi method.

David H. Gustafson David H. Gustafson, a decision researcher, was the third author, with Delbecq and Van de Ven, of the 1975 guide to the nominal group and Delphi processes. In a 1973 experiment he compared the estimates made by four kinds of judges: individuals working alone, interacting groups, Delphi groups, and nominal groups, a direct test of whether the way a group works changes what it concludes.

How to run it

  1. Frame one question. Write it on the wall in one sentence, such as what would most cut cancellations in the first ninety days.
  2. Have everyone write alone. Give five to ten minutes of silence, with each idea on its own card.
  3. Go around the table. Take one idea per person per turn, written up in the author's words, until every card is on the wall.
  4. Clarify without judging. Allow questions about what an idea means, merge true duplicates, and stop anyone from arguing for or against.
  5. Rank in private. Have each person pick a top five and give points, five for first down to one, on a ballot no one else sees.
  6. Combine and show the result. Add the points on the wall, and discuss the top few only once the ranking is visible.

Where it goes wrong

Clarifying turns into arguing. One person's question becomes a pitch against an idea, and the room follows status again. The facilitator stops it and asks only what the author meant.

The ranking happens in the open. A quick show of hands, or dots placed on the wall while others watch, brings back the pressure to follow the room. Use ballots, collected face down.

The group is too big or too small. With fifteen people the round-robin takes an hour and attention fades; with three it adds little over a conversation. Keep it to five to nine, and split a larger group into tables that rank separately.

When to use something else

Where it sits in SOLVE eX

Go to the source

  • A Group Process Model for Problem Identification and Program Planning, Journal of Applied Behavioral Science 7(4), 1971
  • Group Techniques for Program Planning: A Guide to Nominal Group and Delphi Processes, Scott, Foresman, 1975

Back to the catalog