Three Horizons

Thinking Tools3.4 Facts About the FutureAlso known as Three Horizons Framework

Developed by Bill Sharpe (Three Horizons: The Patterning of Hope, 2013), Anthony Hodgson (Deepening Futures with System Structure, with Sharpe, 2007), and Andrew Curry (Seeing in Multiple Horizons, with Hodgson, 2008), adapting McKinsey's three horizons of growth.

Maps three patterns running at once (the dominant system in decline, the emerging one that could replace it, and the contested transition between them) to decide where to invest.

Three horizons at an electric utility, and which one carries the business

Three patterns run at once: the first horizon (big plants, one-way supply) declines, the third (local solar and storage) rises, and the second (the transition) swells and fades between them. Move today along the years to read each period, then shift the growth budget from defending the first horizon toward the second and third: the business curve gives up some of today's result and follows the new system later. Illustrative.

0 years
10%
The business now, index (first horizon now = 90)
86
The business in fifteen years, index
20

Our businessH1: big plants, one-way supplyH2: the transitionH3: local solar and storage

0255075100Now3 years6 years9 years12 years15 years0255075100Now3 years6 years9 years12years15years

Which horizon carries the businessNow: The first horizon pays nearly all the bills. The second is a handful of pilots, and the third lives in pockets at the edges: a co-op's microgrid, a startup trading solar power.3 years: The first horizon still dominates but has stopped growing. Second-horizon moves are spreading, and each one is choosing a side: prop up the old model or build toward the new.6 years: The crossover years. The first horizon is shrinking fast and the second is at its peak; whatever the second horizon built now decides which system it hands the business to.9 years: The third horizon is now as large as the first. A business that only defended the old system is living off a shrinking base.12 years: The third horizon is the main system. The second fades as its bridges are either absorbed into the new or abandoned.15 years: The first horizon is a remnant. The business is whatever share of the third horizon it built a place in.

An example

A regional electric utility's strategy team had a capital plan with forty initiatives and a board asking which of them prepared the company for a grid of rooftop solar and home batteries.

The team drew the three horizons on a wall. The first was today's system: large plants, one-way supply, revenue from selling more power. The third was the system already visible at the edges: a housing co-op running its own panels and batteries, a startup letting neighbors trade solar power. The hard sorting was in the middle. Smart meters had been sold to the board as the future; the plan used them only to cut meter-reading staff, which made the old model cheaper and left their real value, flexible demand, unused. A new fixed fee on solar homes existed to protect the old revenue. The team moved the meter budget to time-of-use pricing, doubled the home battery pilot, and gave the co-op a grid connection to learn from, which took the share of the growth budget spent beyond the first horizon from a tenth to nearly half.

Why it works

Change runs as three patterns at once: a dominant system losing its fit, an emerging one growing at the edges, and a transition between them where both compete for the same money and attention. Strategy that looks at one horizon at a time misreads the other two. Looking only at the first defends the old system past its time; looking only at the third produces visions with no route to them.

The sharpest insight is about the second horizon. Every innovation in the transition ends up serving one system or the other, and the old system is good at absorbing new ideas and using them to prolong itself. Asking of each new move which system it will strengthen separates the ones worth carrying through from the ones captured by the old, which often look identical in a capital plan.

The thinking behind it

Bill Sharpe Bill Sharpe, a futures practitioner, is one of the framework's developers, with Anthony Hodgson, Graham Leicester, and others. His book Three Horizons: The Patterning of Hope (2013) sets out the full practice: the declining dominant system, the emerging future, and the turbulent transition between them, mapped as three patterns that are present at the same time, so that each move in the present can be read against all three of them.

Anthony Hodgson Anthony Hodgson, a founder member of the International Futures Forum with a doctorate in systems science, spent four decades facilitating leadership teams. He created the framework in 2006 by adapting McKinsey's three horizons of growth, setting the dominant system that is losing its fit beside the desired future and the transition between them. He wrote on it with Sharpe in Deepening Futures with System Structure (2007), a chapter of Scenarios for Success, and later with Andrew Curry.

Andrew Curry Andrew Curry, a futures practitioner, set out the framework with Anthony Hodgson in a 2008 paper for the Journal of Futures Studies on seeing in multiple horizons and connecting that view to strategy. The paper reads change as a dominant system declining, an emerging one rising, and a contested zone of transition between them, and argues that holding all three in view at once is what lets futures work inform an organization's strategy.

How to run it

  1. Describe the first horizon. Today's dominant system, how it makes its money, and the signs it is losing its fit.
  2. Describe the third horizon. The system that could replace it, starting from pockets already running somewhere today.
  3. List the moves in between. Every initiative, pilot, and innovation in the current plan that is new to the business.
  4. Ask which system each move strengthens. A move that makes the old model cheaper or protects its revenue is captured; one that builds capability for the new is a bridge.
  5. Decide what to defend. The parts of today's system that must keep working through the transition, funded to run, not to grow.
  6. Decide what to carry through. The bridging moves, protected from being judged only on today's margins.
  7. Decide what to seed. Small bets on third-horizon pockets, chosen to learn from more than to earn.

Where it goes wrong

Horizon two becomes a label for everything new. Every pilot gets called transformational, and the captured moves hide among the bridges. Ask of each one what it would do to the old revenue model if it worked; a move that protects it is not a bridge.

The first horizon gets treated as the enemy. Teams defund the system that pays the bills before the new one can, and the transition fails for lack of money. The first horizon is defended for a reason; plan its decline, do not wish for it.

The third horizon stays a vision. A slide describes the future with no pockets of it in the present. Find where it is already running, at a customer, a rival, or another region, and start there.

When to use something else

  • Scenario Planning. When the future is genuinely uncertain and the plan must hold up in several different ones.
  • Technology S-Curve. When the question is how far one technology has left to run before a successor overtakes it.
  • Wardley Map. When the job is seeing how each component of a business is evolving and where to build, buy, or rent.

Where it sits in SOLVE eX

Go to the source

  • Three Horizons: The Patterning of Hope, Triarchy Press, 2013
  • Deepening Futures with System Structure, chapter 5 of Scenarios for Success: Turning Insights into Action, Wiley; with Bill Sharpe, 2007
  • Seeing in Multiple Horizons: Connecting Futures to Strategy, Journal of Futures Studies 13(1), with Anthony Hodgson, 2008

Back to the catalog