Developed by Bruce Henderson at the Boston Consulting Group (The Product Portfolio, 1970).
Plots each business unit by market growth and relative share into stars, cash cows, question marks, and dogs, showing which units should fund which.
Six business units of a household goods group, sorted by market growth and share
Relative share is the unit's share divided by its largest rival's; it runs from high on the left to low on the right, as in the original chart. Place each unit; the box gives its funding instruction, and the unit notes say where its cash goes. The first unit is placed as an example. Illustrative.
- Not placedPlacedStarQuestion markCash cowDog
- Not placedPlacedStarQuestion markCash cowDog
- Not placedPlacedStarQuestion markCash cowDog
- Not placedPlacedStarQuestion markCash cowDog
- Not placedPlacedStarQuestion markCash cowDog
- Not placedPlacedStarQuestion markCash cowDog
Market growth a year
Relative market share
Your sort matched 0 of 6.Your sort matched 1 of 6.Your sort matched 2 of 6.Your sort matched 3 of 6.Your sort matched 4 of 6.Your sort matched 5 of 6.Your sort matched 6 of 6.
- Star
- A leader in a fast market. Fund it to hold its lead; it uses most of the cash it earns, and becomes a cash cow as the market slows.
- Question mark
- A follower in a fast market. It needs cash to gain share. Decide: back it to become a star, or sell it.
- Cash cow
- A leader in a slow market. Spend only to stay efficient, and send its spare cash to the stars and the chosen question marks.
- Dog
- A follower in a slow market. Little cash in or out. Run it for cash, sell it, or close it.
The sort
- Laundry detergent: Cash cow. The group's main source of cash: it pays for the plant-based cleaner and the refill pilot.
- Plant-based cleaner: Star. A leader in a growing market: keep funding capacity and marketing, mostly from detergent's cash.
- Dish soap: Cash cow. Steady cash with little need for investment.
- Refill stations: Question mark. Fast market, small share: a decision. The board backs it for two years with a share target.
- Pet stain remover: Question mark. Another question mark. With cash for one, the group sells this unit to a pet-care company.
- Candles: Dog. Little growth and no lead: run it for cash and look for a buyer.
An example
A household goods group with six business units was arguing over next year's capital budget, and each unit head had a case for more. The strategy director plotted them on one chart before the budget meeting.
Laundry detergent and dish soap led their markets, but those markets grew one or two percent a year: cash cows, earning far more than they needed. The plant-based cleaner led a market growing 18 percent a year, a star that would need every dollar it made and more. Two units trailed leaders in fast markets: refill stations at a fifth of the leader's share and a pet stain remover at half. Candles trailed in a flat market. The chart turned six claims into one flow of cash. Detergent and dish soap would fund the cleaner and one question mark, not two. The board backed refill stations for two years with a share target, sold the pet stain remover, and ran candles for cash while it found a buyer.
Why it works
A portfolio of businesses is more than a list of projects. Some units generate cash they cannot use well; others could grow fast and need more than they earn. Looked at one at a time, each unit argues for itself, and the budget is shared out by habit or by who argues best.
The growth-share matrix makes the portfolio visible as a system. Market growth stands for how much cash a unit needs to keep up; relative share stands for how much it earns, since a leader usually has the lower cost. Crossing the two shows where cash comes from and where it should go, and it forces the hard call on question marks: not every fast-growing follower can be funded, so pick and back some, and sell the rest.
The thinking behind it
Bruce Henderson Bruce Henderson founded the Boston Consulting Group in 1963. His essay The Product Portfolio (1970, BCG Perspectives) laid out the reasoning behind the growth-share matrix: a company should hold a balance of businesses, those with high share in slow markets generating the cash that those in fast markets need, and the chart sorts its businesses by market growth and relative market share to show the balance. The matrix itself was developed by BCG staff between 1968 and 1970.
How to run it
- Define each unit's market. Name the market each unit competes in narrowly enough that its rivals are real rivals.
- Measure growth and relative share. Use the market's annual growth and the unit's share divided by its largest rival's, so 1.0 or more means it leads.
- Place each unit. Mark the dividing lines, such as 10 percent growth and a relative share of 1.0, and sort the units into the four boxes.
- Trace the cash. Draw where each cash cow's surplus goes, and how much each star and question mark needs.
- Decide on the question marks. Back the ones with a real chance to lead, with a share target and a date, and sell or close the rest.
- Treat the result as a starting point. Check each instruction against the unit's links to the others before acting.
- Replot every year. Markets slow and shares move, so the boxes change and the funding should change with them.
Where it goes wrong
The market is defined to flatter the unit. Drawn narrowly enough, any unit leads its market, and every unit becomes a star. Agree on market definitions before anyone sees the chart.
The labels become verdicts on people. A unit called a dog loses its best staff before any decision is made. Use the chart for funding discussions, and keep the names out of company-wide communication.
Links between units are ignored. A dog may supply parts that make a star profitable, or keep a key customer buying the rest. Before selling a unit, ask what else would leave with it.
When to use something else
- Ansoff Matrix. When the question is which new growth moves to make, not how to fund the units already owned.
- Capital Allocation. When the decision is how to spend the cash across reinvestment, acquisitions, debt, and returns to owners.
- Three Horizons. When the portfolio needs balancing across time, from today's core to future options.
Where it sits in SOLVE eX
Go to the source
- The Product Portfolio, BCG Perspectives, Boston Consulting Group, 1970