Thinking Tools4.4 Refining Ideas Into Practical SolutionsAlso known as KJ Method
Originated by Jiro Kawakita (the KJ method, Hasso-ho, 1967).
Groups a large pile of notes, ideas, or observations by similarity from the bottom up, naming the themes only after the clusters settle.
Nine interview notes grouped by what they share, named only once the groups settle
Each tag is one note from customer interviews about a small-business accounting app. One note already starts each group. Place the rest beside the notes they belong with, by the problem underneath, not by shared words; then show the sort to see the groups named. Illustrative.
Items (select one, then a box)
Not placedPlacedBilling surprisesGetting started is slowData will not leave
Not placedPlacedBilling surprisesGetting started is slowData will not leave
Not placedPlacedBilling surprisesGetting started is slowData will not leave
Not placedPlacedBilling surprisesGetting started is slowData will not leave
Not placedPlacedBilling surprisesGetting started is slowData will not leave
Not placedPlacedBilling surprisesGetting started is slowData will not leave
Not placedPlacedBilling surprisesGetting started is slowData will not leave
Not placedPlacedBilling surprisesGetting started is slowData will not leave
Not placedPlacedBilling surprisesGetting started is slowData will not leave
Notes
Interview notes
Billing surprises
Getting started is slow
Data will not leave
First groupSecond groupThird group
Groups on the wall
Charged twice. I was charged twice in March and found out from my bank.Not placed yet.Charged twice. I was charged twice in March and found out from my bank.Placed. The groups are named when the sort is shown.Charged twice. I was charged twice in March and found out from my bank.Billing surprises: Customers did not expect what they were charged, or when. A pricing page and renewal notices, not a billing system rebuild.The first note of its group: a charge the customer did not expect.Charged twice. I was charged twice in March and found out from my bank.Getting started is slow: Customers stall before they ever use the product. The first week matters more than any feature.Charged twice. I was charged twice in March and found out from my bank.Data will not leave: Customers cannot hand their numbers to the people who need them. Exports are a reason to stay, not a nice-to-have.Bank link took a week. Connecting my bank account took a week of back and forth.Not placed yet.Bank link took a week. Connecting my bank account took a week of back and forth.Placed. The groups are named when the sort is shown.Bank link took a week. Connecting my bank account took a week of back and forth.Billing surprises: Customers did not expect what they were charged, or when. A pricing page and renewal notices, not a billing system rebuild.Bank link took a week. Connecting my bank account took a week of back and forth.Getting started is slow: Customers stall before they ever use the product. The first week matters more than any feature.The first note of its group: time lost before any real use.Bank link took a week. Connecting my bank account took a week of back and forth.Data will not leave: Customers cannot hand their numbers to the people who need them. Exports are a reason to stay, not a nice-to-have.No CSV for accountant. My accountant wants a spreadsheet file and I cannot find one.Not placed yet.No CSV for accountant. My accountant wants a spreadsheet file and I cannot find one.Placed. The groups are named when the sort is shown.No CSV for accountant. My accountant wants a spreadsheet file and I cannot find one.Billing surprises: Customers did not expect what they were charged, or when. A pricing page and renewal notices, not a billing system rebuild.No CSV for accountant. My accountant wants a spreadsheet file and I cannot find one.Getting started is slow: Customers stall before they ever use the product. The first week matters more than any feature.No CSV for accountant. My accountant wants a spreadsheet file and I cannot find one.Data will not leave: Customers cannot hand their numbers to the people who need them. Exports are a reason to stay, not a nice-to-have.The first note of its group: numbers stuck inside the app.Surprise renewal. I did not know the plan renewed for a whole year.Not placed yet.Surprise renewal. I did not know the plan renewed for a whole year.Placed. The groups are named when the sort is shown.Surprise renewal. I did not know the plan renewed for a whole year.Billing surprises: Customers did not expect what they were charged, or when. A pricing page and renewal notices, not a billing system rebuild.Another charge nobody expected: billing surprises.Surprise renewal. I did not know the plan renewed for a whole year.Getting started is slow: Customers stall before they ever use the product. The first week matters more than any feature.Surprise renewal. I did not know the plan renewed for a whole year.Data will not leave: Customers cannot hand their numbers to the people who need them. Exports are a reason to stay, not a nice-to-have.Wrong name on invoice. The invoice shows a company name I have never heard of.Not placed yet.Wrong name on invoice. The invoice shows a company name I have never heard of.Placed. The groups are named when the sort is shown.Wrong name on invoice. The invoice shows a company name I have never heard of.Billing surprises: Customers did not expect what they were charged, or when. A pricing page and renewal notices, not a billing system rebuild.A charge that looked like fraud: still a surprise on the bill.Wrong name on invoice. The invoice shows a company name I have never heard of.Getting started is slow: Customers stall before they ever use the product. The first week matters more than any feature.Wrong name on invoice. The invoice shows a company name I have never heard of.Data will not leave: Customers cannot hand their numbers to the people who need them. Exports are a reason to stay, not a nice-to-have.Old invoices fail. My old invoices would not import, so I typed them in.Not placed yet.Old invoices fail. My old invoices would not import, so I typed them in.Placed. The groups are named when the sort is shown.Old invoices fail. My old invoices would not import, so I typed them in.Billing surprises: Customers did not expect what they were charged, or when. A pricing page and renewal notices, not a billing system rebuild.Old invoices fail. My old invoices would not import, so I typed them in.Getting started is slow: Customers stall before they ever use the product. The first week matters more than any feature.It mentions invoices, but the problem is getting started. Group by the problem, not the word.Old invoices fail. My old invoices would not import, so I typed them in.Data will not leave: Customers cannot hand their numbers to the people who need them. Exports are a reason to stay, not a nice-to-have.Gave up on setup. I gave up halfway through setup and called support.Not placed yet.Gave up on setup. I gave up halfway through setup and called support.Placed. The groups are named when the sort is shown.Gave up on setup. I gave up halfway through setup and called support.Billing surprises: Customers did not expect what they were charged, or when. A pricing page and renewal notices, not a billing system rebuild.Gave up on setup. I gave up halfway through setup and called support.Getting started is slow: Customers stall before they ever use the product. The first week matters more than any feature.Stalled before first use: the second group.Gave up on setup. I gave up halfway through setup and called support.Data will not leave: Customers cannot hand their numbers to the people who need them. Exports are a reason to stay, not a nice-to-have.Pasting into Excel. I copy each report into Excel by hand every month.Not placed yet.Pasting into Excel. I copy each report into Excel by hand every month.Placed. The groups are named when the sort is shown.Pasting into Excel. I copy each report into Excel by hand every month.Billing surprises: Customers did not expect what they were charged, or when. A pricing page and renewal notices, not a billing system rebuild.Pasting into Excel. I copy each report into Excel by hand every month.Getting started is slow: Customers stall before they ever use the product. The first week matters more than any feature.Pasting into Excel. I copy each report into Excel by hand every month.Data will not leave: Customers cannot hand their numbers to the people who need them. Exports are a reason to stay, not a nice-to-have.The data does not leave the app on its own: the third group.No year-end export. There is no year-end export for my tax filing.Not placed yet.No year-end export. There is no year-end export for my tax filing.Placed. The groups are named when the sort is shown.No year-end export. There is no year-end export for my tax filing.Billing surprises: Customers did not expect what they were charged, or when. A pricing page and renewal notices, not a billing system rebuild.No year-end export. There is no year-end export for my tax filing.Getting started is slow: Customers stall before they ever use the product. The first week matters more than any feature.No year-end export. There is no year-end export for my tax filing.Data will not leave: Customers cannot hand their numbers to the people who need them. Exports are a reason to stay, not a nice-to-have.Numbers needed elsewhere, again: the third group.
Your sort matched 0 of 9.Your sort matched 1 of 9.Your sort matched 2 of 9.Your sort matched 3 of 9.Your sort matched 4 of 9.Your sort matched 5 of 9.Your sort matched 6 of 9.Your sort matched 7 of 9.Your sort matched 8 of 9.Your sort matched 9 of 9.
Billing surprises
Customers did not expect what they were charged, or when. A pricing page and renewal notices, not a billing system rebuild.
Getting started is slow
Customers stall before they ever use the product. The first week matters more than any feature.
Data will not leave
Customers cannot hand their numbers to the people who need them. Exports are a reason to stay, not a nice-to-have.
The sort
Charged twice: Billing surprises. The first note of its group: a charge the customer did not expect.
Bank link took a week: Getting started is slow. The first note of its group: time lost before any real use.
No CSV for accountant: Data will not leave. The first note of its group: numbers stuck inside the app.
Surprise renewal: Billing surprises. Another charge nobody expected: billing surprises.
Wrong name on invoice: Billing surprises. A charge that looked like fraud: still a surprise on the bill.
Old invoices fail: Getting started is slow. It mentions invoices, but the problem is getting started. Group by the problem, not the word.
Gave up on setup: Getting started is slow. Stalled before first use: the second group.
Pasting into Excel: Data will not leave. The data does not leave the app on its own: the third group.
No year-end export: Data will not leave. Numbers needed elsewhere, again: the third group.
An example
A small-business accounting app had run forty customer interviews in a month, and the research lead had 230 sticky notes, one quote or observation each. The product team wanted a list of features to build.
She put the notes on a wall and had five people sort them in silence for forty minutes, moving any note that seemed out of place, until notes stopped moving. Only then did the group name the clusters. One held charges customers had not expected: a double charge, a renewal nobody knew about, an invoice under an unfamiliar company name. Another held stalls before first use, including a note about invoices that would not import, which had first been stuck with the billing notes because of the word invoice. A third held numbers customers could not get out: no spreadsheet for the accountant, reports pasted by hand. The team's feature list had been led by dashboards, which appeared in six notes. The roadmap was rewritten around the first week of use, renewal notices, and exports.
Why it works
When people read a pile of notes, they sort them into the categories they walked in with, and the notes that do not fit are lost. Grouping from the bottom up, note by note, lets the categories come from the material. Naming the groups only after they settle keeps a label from pulling in notes that merely share a word.
Silence matters as much. Talking while sorting lets the most senior or most confident person set the groups, and the rest argue for their own. Sorting without speaking, with anyone free to move any note, lets many small judgments add up to a structure no single person proposed. Disagreement shows up as a note that keeps moving, which is itself a finding.
The thinking behind it
Jiro Kawakita Jiro Kawakita, a geographer and ethnographer, devised the KJ method, named from his initials, to organize the field notes of his own research, and set it out in Hassoho (1967). Each observation goes on its own card; the cards are grouped by affinity from the bottom up, and only then labeled and related to one another. The method is built for data too varied for any ready-made category, which is why the groups are named last. In English it is usually called the affinity diagram.
How to run it
Write one item per note. Keep each note to one quote or observation, in the customer's or observer's words.
Spread them out. Put every note on a wall or table at once, in no order, where everyone can reach them.
Sort in silence. Each person moves notes next to the ones they belong with, and anyone may move any note.
Keep going until notes stop moving. Notes that bounce between groups get a copy in each, or a place of their own.
Name each group last. Write a label that says what the notes share, as a statement such as customers cannot get their data out.
Relate the groups. Draw how the groups connect or cause one another, and mark the biggest.
Carry the structure forward. Turn each named group into a problem statement for the roadmap or the next round of research.
Where it goes wrong
The groups are named first. A facilitator puts up headings such as pricing and onboarding, and the session becomes filing. Notes that fit no heading go to other and disappear. Keep the wall blank until the groups settle.
The sort follows words. Notes that mention invoices land together whatever the problem behind them. Ask of each pair what the customer was trying to do, not what they said.
The labels are topics. A group named billing says where the notes came from, not what they say. Write each label as a sentence a customer could have said, so the group carries its finding into the room where decisions are made.
When to use something else
Mind Mapping. When one person is getting ideas out of their own head and needs to branch from a center, not group a pile.
Jobs to Be Done. When the interviews need to be read for the progress customers are trying to make, not grouped by theme.
Theoretical Saturation. When the question is whether enough interviews have been done for new notes to stop adding groups.