Thinking Tools4.4 Refining Ideas Into Practical SolutionsAlso known as TRIZ Separation Principles
Developed by Genrich Altshuller (Creativity as an Exact Science, 1979) and set out by Darrell Mann (Hands-On Systematic Innovation, 2002).
Resolves a requirement that something be two opposite things at once by separating the demands in time, in space, in scale, or by condition.
Eight facts about one office floor, each showing where open and quiet come apart
The floor must be open and it must be quiet. Each tag is a fact about how the floor is used: select one, then the box for how the two demands come apart in it, and the box names the design it points to. The first is placed as an example. TRIZ lists the four separations (in time, in space, between whole and parts, on condition); the two axes are only this page's way of laying them out. Illustrative.
Items (select one, then a box)
Not placedPlacedSplit the hoursSplit the floorSplit whole from partsSwitch on a signal
Not placedPlacedSplit the hoursSplit the floorSplit whole from partsSwitch on a signal
Not placedPlacedSplit the hoursSplit the floorSplit whole from partsSwitch on a signal
Not placedPlacedSplit the hoursSplit the floorSplit whole from partsSwitch on a signal
Not placedPlacedSplit the hoursSplit the floorSplit whole from partsSwitch on a signal
Not placedPlacedSplit the hoursSplit the floorSplit whole from partsSwitch on a signal
Not placedPlacedSplit the hoursSplit the floorSplit whole from partsSwitch on a signal
Not placedPlacedSplit the hoursSplit the floorSplit whole from partsSwitch on a signal
Told apart by
Event or levelClock or map
Switch on a signal
Split whole from parts
Split the hours
Split the floor
WhenWhere
The two demands differ in
Huddles cluster by noon. A week of calendars: pairing and huddles mostly fall between nine and twelve.Not placed yet.Huddles cluster by noon. A week of calendars: pairing and huddles mostly fall between nine and twelve.Split the hours: The two demands peak at different times, so each gets its own hours: open in the morning, quiet in the afternoon.Open mornings, quiet hours from one to five: each demand gets the time it actually uses.Huddles cluster by noon. A week of calendars: pairing and huddles mostly fall between nine and twelve.Split the floor: Different people or places carry the two demands, so each gets its own area of the floor.Huddles cluster by noon. A week of calendars: pairing and huddles mostly fall between nine and twelve.Split whole from parts: The whole and its parts need different things, so the floor takes one property and each desk or conversation the other.Huddles cluster by noon. A week of calendars: pairing and huddles mostly fall between nine and twelve.Switch on a signal: The need appears only when something happens, so a signal or a rule switches the property on and off.Focus peaks after lunch. Engineers say their longest stretches of focus start after one o'clock.Not placed yet.Focus peaks after lunch. Engineers say their longest stretches of focus start after one o'clock.Split the hours: The two demands peak at different times, so each gets its own hours: open in the morning, quiet in the afternoon.The same split, seen from the other side: the afternoon block is protected for deep work.Focus peaks after lunch. Engineers say their longest stretches of focus start after one o'clock.Split the floor: Different people or places carry the two demands, so each gets its own area of the floor.Focus peaks after lunch. Engineers say their longest stretches of focus start after one o'clock.Split whole from parts: The whole and its parts need different things, so the floor takes one property and each desk or conversation the other.Focus peaks after lunch. Engineers say their longest stretches of focus start after one o'clock.Switch on a signal: The need appears only when something happens, so a signal or a rule switches the property on and off.Back-end needs silence. Only the back-end team works in long unbroken blocks; sales spends the day talking.Not placed yet.Back-end needs silence. Only the back-end team works in long unbroken blocks; sales spends the day talking.Split the hours: The two demands peak at different times, so each gets its own hours: open in the morning, quiet in the afternoon.Back-end needs silence. Only the back-end team works in long unbroken blocks; sales spends the day talking.Split the floor: Different people or places carry the two demands, so each gets its own area of the floor.Different people carry the two demands, so the back-end team sits at the far end past the kitchen.Back-end needs silence. Only the back-end team works in long unbroken blocks; sales spends the day talking.Split whole from parts: The whole and its parts need different things, so the floor takes one property and each desk or conversation the other.Back-end needs silence. Only the back-end team works in long unbroken blocks; sales spends the day talking.Switch on a signal: The need appears only when something happens, so a signal or a rule switches the property on and off.Sales calls carry far. Phone calls are the loudest sound on the floor, and almost all come from one team.Not placed yet.Sales calls carry far. Phone calls are the loudest sound on the floor, and almost all come from one team.Split the hours: The two demands peak at different times, so each gets its own hours: open in the morning, quiet in the afternoon.Sales calls carry far. Phone calls are the loudest sound on the floor, and almost all come from one team.Split the floor: Different people or places carry the two demands, so each gets its own area of the floor.The loudest source goes farthest from the quietest work: sales by the door, with the phone booths.Sales calls carry far. Phone calls are the loudest sound on the floor, and almost all come from one team.Split whole from parts: The whole and its parts need different things, so the floor takes one property and each desk or conversation the other.Sales calls carry far. Phone calls are the loudest sound on the floor, and almost all come from one team.Switch on a signal: The need appears only when something happens, so a signal or a rule switches the property on and off.Visitors see open floor. Leaders want the floor to look open to visitors and new hires; each person wants a quiet desk.Not placed yet.Visitors see open floor. Leaders want the floor to look open to visitors and new hires; each person wants a quiet desk.Split the hours: The two demands peak at different times, so each gets its own hours: open in the morning, quiet in the afternoon.Visitors see open floor. Leaders want the floor to look open to visitors and new hires; each person wants a quiet desk.Split the floor: Different people or places carry the two demands, so each gets its own area of the floor.Visitors see open floor. Leaders want the floor to look open to visitors and new hires; each person wants a quiet desk.Split whole from parts: The whole and its parts need different things, so the floor takes one property and each desk or conversation the other.The whole stays open to the eye while each part is closed to sound: high-backed acoustic booths on an open floor.Visitors see open floor. Leaders want the floor to look open to visitors and new hires; each person wants a quiet desk.Switch on a signal: The need appears only when something happens, so a signal or a rule switches the property on and off.Forty soft voices add up. Any one conversation is quiet; the noise comes from the sum across the floor.Not placed yet.Forty soft voices add up. Any one conversation is quiet; the noise comes from the sum across the floor.Split the hours: The two demands peak at different times, so each gets its own hours: open in the morning, quiet in the afternoon.Forty soft voices add up. Any one conversation is quiet; the noise comes from the sum across the floor.Split the floor: Different people or places carry the two demands, so each gets its own area of the floor.Forty soft voices add up. Any one conversation is quiet; the noise comes from the sum across the floor.Split whole from parts: The whole and its parts need different things, so the floor takes one property and each desk or conversation the other.The parts are fine and the whole is not, so treat the whole: an absorbing ceiling and carpet, and every conversation stays as it is.Forty soft voices add up. Any one conversation is quiet; the noise comes from the sum across the floor.Switch on a signal: The need appears only when something happens, so a signal or a rule switches the property on and off.Interruptions mid-task. A question costs little between tasks and a lot in the middle of one.Not placed yet.Interruptions mid-task. A question costs little between tasks and a lot in the middle of one.Split the hours: The two demands peak at different times, so each gets its own hours: open in the morning, quiet in the afternoon.Interruptions mid-task. A question costs little between tasks and a lot in the middle of one.Split the floor: Different people or places carry the two demands, so each gets its own area of the floor.Interruptions mid-task. A question costs little between tasks and a lot in the middle of one.Split whole from parts: The whole and its parts need different things, so the floor takes one property and each desk or conversation the other.Interruptions mid-task. A question costs little between tasks and a lot in the middle of one.Switch on a signal: The need appears only when something happens, so a signal or a rule switches the property on and off.Quiet is needed in one state, so a signal switches the norm: lamp on means send a chat message before walking over.Incidents need quiet now. When a production incident starts, the on-call engineers need silence at once, at any hour.Not placed yet.Incidents need quiet now. When a production incident starts, the on-call engineers need silence at once, at any hour.Split the hours: The two demands peak at different times, so each gets its own hours: open in the morning, quiet in the afternoon.Incidents need quiet now. When a production incident starts, the on-call engineers need silence at once, at any hour.Split the floor: Different people or places carry the two demands, so each gets its own area of the floor.Incidents need quiet now. When a production incident starts, the on-call engineers need silence at once, at any hour.Split whole from parts: The whole and its parts need different things, so the floor takes one property and each desk or conversation the other.Incidents need quiet now. When a production incident starts, the on-call engineers need silence at once, at any hour.Switch on a signal: The need appears only when something happens, so a signal or a rule switches the property on and off.The need switches on with an event, so the rule does too: an incident flag turns the nearest room into a quiet incident room.
Your sort matched 0 of 8.Your sort matched 1 of 8.Your sort matched 2 of 8.Your sort matched 3 of 8.Your sort matched 4 of 8.Your sort matched 5 of 8.Your sort matched 6 of 8.Your sort matched 7 of 8.Your sort matched 8 of 8.
Split the hours
The two demands peak at different times, so each gets its own hours: open in the morning, quiet in the afternoon.
Split the floor
Different people or places carry the two demands, so each gets its own area of the floor.
Split whole from parts
The whole and its parts need different things, so the floor takes one property and each desk or conversation the other.
Switch on a signal
The need appears only when something happens, so a signal or a rule switches the property on and off.
The sort
Huddles cluster by noon: Split the hours. Open mornings, quiet hours from one to five: each demand gets the time it actually uses.
Focus peaks after lunch: Split the hours. The same split, seen from the other side: the afternoon block is protected for deep work.
Back-end needs silence: Split the floor. Different people carry the two demands, so the back-end team sits at the far end past the kitchen.
Sales calls carry far: Split the floor. The loudest source goes farthest from the quietest work: sales by the door, with the phone booths.
Visitors see open floor: Split whole from parts. The whole stays open to the eye while each part is closed to sound: high-backed acoustic booths on an open floor.
Forty soft voices add up: Split whole from parts. The parts are fine and the whole is not, so treat the whole: an absorbing ceiling and carpet, and every conversation stays as it is.
Interruptions mid-task: Switch on a signal. Quiet is needed in one state, so a signal switches the norm: lamp on means send a chat message before walking over.
Incidents need quiet now: Switch on a signal. The need switches on with an event, so the rule does too: an incident flag turns the nearest room into a quiet incident room.
An example
A software company of 120 people was moving to a single new floor, and the planning meeting had split in two. Product and sales wanted an open floor, because their work runs on overheard questions and quick huddles. The engineers wanted quiet, because an interrupted hour of debugging is a lost hour. Every proposal so far was a compromise: half-height partitions that blocked sight lines and stopped no noise.
The facilities lead wrote the problem as one sentence: the floor must be open and it must be quiet. Then she asked where the two demands actually came apart. A week of calendar data showed that huddles and pairing clustered before lunch. Only the back-end team needed long silence; sales lived on the phone. And interruptions hurt only when someone was in the middle of something.
The design followed from those three facts: quiet hours from one to five, the back-end team at the far end past the kitchen, and a small desk lamp that meant: send a chat message before walking over. The floor stayed open.
Why it works
Most design arguments treat a contradiction as a trade-off and look for the least bad middle, which leaves both sides half served. The separation principles start from a different reading: when something must be A and not A, the two demands are almost never made in the same place, at the same moment, at the same level, and under the same conditions. Find the dimension along which they come apart and each side can be given all of what it needs where and when it needs it.
The four questions make that search systematic. Asking when each demand holds, where it holds, whether it holds for the whole or for the parts, and what conditions switch it on turns a stuck argument into four specific inquiries, each answered with facts about how the system is actually used.
The thinking behind it
Genrich Altshuller Genrich Altshuller, an engineer and inventor, built TRIZ, the theory of inventive problem solving, from the study of thousands of patents, and set it out in Creativity as an Exact Science (1979). TRIZ holds that technical systems evolve by knowable patterns and that inventive problems turn on contradictions. A small set of methods resolves them: the 40 inventive principles, the separation of the conflicting requirements, and ARIZ, his step-by-step algorithm.
Darrell Mann Darrell Mann, an engineer and TRIZ practitioner associated with Systematic Innovation, updated Altshuller's theory for working designers in Hands-On Systematic Innovation (2002). The handbook brings together function analysis, trimming, the ideal final result, and the separation principles, and it is written as a practitioner's manual: each method is laid out as steps a team can follow on a real problem.
How to run it
Write the contradiction in one line. Name the one thing that must take two opposite values: the floor must be open and quiet.
Say why each side needs its value. Open for overheard questions and huddles; quiet for long stretches of focus.
Ask when each demand holds. If the two peak at different hours or stages, give each its own time.
Ask where each demand holds. If different people or areas carry different needs, give each its own space.
Ask whether the whole and the parts differ. The floor can be open while each desk is closed, or the reverse.
Ask what condition switches it. If the need turns on an event or a state, let a signal or a mechanism flip the property.
Combine and test the separations. Pick the one or two that the facts support best and trial them before building.
Where it goes wrong
The contradiction is stated as a trade-off between two different things, cost against speed, and the team spends the session looking for a separation that does not exist. Restate it as one property that must take two values; if that cannot be done, a trade-off method fits better.
The separations are answered from opinion. Someone asserts that collaboration happens all day, and the time separation is dropped. Check each question against data, such as calendars, floor counts, or logs.
The team picks the cleverest separation and ignores whether people will use it. A desk signal nobody respects separates nothing. Trial the design for a few weeks and measure whether both demands are met.
When to use something else
TRIZ Inventive Principles. When the problem is a trade-off between two features, where improving one makes the other worse.
Ideal Final Result. When the team needs to picture the outcome with no cost or harm before choosing how to get there.
Constraint Satisfaction. When many requirements must hold at once and the task is finding a design that meets them all.