Pyramid Principle

Thinking Tools6.3 Implementing the Action PlanAlso known as Minto Pyramid, Minto Pyramid Principle

Developed by Barbara Minto (The Pyramid Principle, 1978 edition).

Structures a memo, deck, or recommendation with the conclusion first, then grouped supporting points, each group summarizing the ideas beneath it in logical order.

A recommendation built as a pyramid, with two points that do not belong where they sit

The answer sits at the top, three grouped reasons under it, the evidence under each. Every box should sum up the boxes beneath it, and each group should hold one kind of idea. Select a box to read its test, and mark the two pieces of evidence that fail it. Illustrative.

0 of 2 marked1 of 2 marked2 of 2 marked

Select a box to read its test, then mark the two pieces of evidence that fail it.Open clinics in Denver and Austin next spring. The conclusion, first: what the reader must take away even if they read nothing else. It is a summary of the three reasons below it.Demand is already there. A reason. Test: do both pieces of evidence under it show demand? They should.4,000 people on the two waitlists. Evidence of demand. Fits.Local clinics book three weeks out. Evidence of demand. Fits.We can staff both clinics. A reason. Test: is everything under it about staffing?Twelve therapists ready to transfer. Evidence about staffing. Fits.Our Q3 margin fell 2 points. Does not belong: a margin figure says nothing about staffing, and it cuts against the conclusion. Give it a place of its own, such as a risks section.Each clinic pays back within two years. A reason. Test: is everything under it evidence about payback, of the same kind?Leases 15% below our plan. Evidence about payback. Fits.We should hire a regional manager. Does not belong: a recommendation sitting among facts. It is a next step, and it belongs in the plan that follows the case.

An example

A physical therapy chain's strategy lead had eleven pages on expansion and forty minutes with the board. Her draft told the story in the order she had worked it out: the market study, the competitor visits, the staffing survey, the lease search, and on page ten, the recommendation.

She rebuilt it as a pyramid. The first line became the answer: open clinics in Denver and Austin next spring. Under it went three reasons, each a sentence a director could repeat: demand is already there, we can staff both, and each pays back within two years. Then she tested every group. The staffing group held a line about the third quarter's margin, which said nothing about staffing and worked against the case, so it moved to a short risks section. The payback group held a recommendation to hire a regional manager among its facts, and that moved to the plan. The board approved Denver in the first fifteen minutes and spent the rest of the time on Austin's lease.

Why it works

Readers process ideas from the top down: they want the point, then the reasons, then the proof, and they stop when they are satisfied. Writing in the order of discovery makes them carry every fact in memory until the conclusion finally tells them what the facts were for. Putting the answer first gives each later sentence a place to land.

The pyramid's rules make the logic checkable. If every box summarizes the boxes beneath it, the reasons really do add up to the conclusion. If each group holds one kind of idea and nothing overlaps or is missing, the reader can trust that no point is out of place or left out. A stray fact in a group is easy to see in the pyramid and nearly invisible in prose.

The thinking behind it

Barbara Minto Barbara Minto, the first woman MBA hired by McKinsey, taught the firm's consultants to write by putting the main point first and grouping the supporting points beneath it, each group mutually exclusive and collectively exhaustive, the rule now known as MECE. She published the method herself through Minto International as The Pyramid Principle, subtitled Logic in Writing and Thinking, in a revised second edition by 1978.

How to run it

  1. Write the one conclusion. State in a single sentence what the reader must take away, as an answer to the question they have.
  2. Group the reasons beneath it. Find the two to five points that together support the conclusion, each stated as a full sentence.
  3. Check that each box sums up its group. Read each box with the boxes under it and ask whether it is their summary.
  4. Keep one kind of idea per group. Separate facts from recommendations, and move anything that does not fit.
  5. Order each group logically. Arrange the points by time, by structure, or by importance, and say which.
  6. Add evidence only where it is needed. Break a reason into proof when the reader would ask how you know.
  7. Write it top down. Draft the document in the pyramid's order: answer, reasons, then evidence.

Where it goes wrong

The top box is a topic. "Expansion options" is a heading, and the reader still does not know what you think. Rewrite it until it could be wrong.

The groups are a list. Six reasons of different kinds under one heading look thorough and summarize nothing. If you cannot write a sentence that covers the group, regroup it.

Bad news gets buried. A fact that cuts against the conclusion is tucked into a group where it does not belong, or dropped. Give it a place of its own, such as risks, and answer it.

When to use something else

  • SCQA. When the opening needs a short story of situation, complication, and question before the answer.
  • Issue Tree. When the answer is not known yet and the question must be broken down to find it.
  • Problem-Solution-Result. When the piece is a short case account of what was done and what came of it.

Where it sits in SOLVE eX

Go to the source

Back to the catalog