Originated by Richard Dawkins (The Selfish Gene, 1976) and developed by Daniel C. Dennett (Darwin's Dangerous Idea, 1995), Susan Blackmore (The Meme Machine, 1999), and Limor Shifman (Memes in Digital Culture, 2014).
Treats ideas, phrases, and practices as units that copy themselves from person to person, and asks why some spread and last while others fade.
Three versions of a company value, rated on how well each copies, spreads, and lasts
Each version of the value is rated 1 to 5 on fidelity (people repeat it without garbling it), fecundity (people repeat it often), and longevity (it is still in use six months on). Fitness is the product, so one weak property drags the whole score down. The short question copies and spreads well and fades by spring; tying it to a meeting where it gets asked lifts the weak property. Rate them yourself. Illustrative.
Original: We put the customer at the center of everything we do
FidelityFecundityLongevityFitness8Rewrite: Would a customer pay for this?
FidelityFecundityLongevityFitness60Rewrite, asked aloud at every roadmap sign-off
FidelityFecundityLongevityFitness100Fittest version100
VerdictScore every row to see the verdict.Will fadeEven the best version is weak on at least two properties: rewrite it.Spreads, may not lastThe best version copies well but has a weak property; strengthen that one next.Likely to spread and lastThe best version is strong on all three: launch it and check in six months.
Fittest first
- 100Rewrite, asked aloud at every roadmap sign-off
- 60Rewrite: Would a customer pay for this?
- 8Original: We put the customer at the center of everything we do
An example
A 600-person software company launched a new set of values with posters, a town hall, and a laminated card. Six months later the head of internal communications asked twenty employees to recite the customer value. Three got close; most offered a version of the old mission statement. The line was We put the customer at the center of everything we do, and nobody had said it in a meeting since the launch.
She treated the value as an idea that had to copy itself and rated it on three properties: whether people repeated it intact, how often they repeated it, and whether it would still be in use months later. It scored low on all three. The team rewrote it as a question short enough to survive retelling: Would a customer pay for this? Product leads began asking it in reviews within weeks. Expecting it to fade like the last one, she asked the head of product to make it the first question at every roadmap sign-off. A year on, new hires were quoting it in their first month.
Why it works
The ideas that spread are the ones that copy well, which are often different from the best ones. A phrase that is long or abstract gets paraphrased into something else, a phrase nobody has a reason to say goes unsaid, and a phrase with no recurring occasion fades once the launch is over. Merit does not save it.
Rating an idea on fidelity, fecundity, and longevity turns a vague complaint, that the value did not stick, into a diagnosis. Because the three multiply, the weakest property limits the whole, so the fix goes where the score is lowest: shorten what garbles, give people a reason to repeat what goes unsaid, and attach what fades to a ritual or a habit that recurs on its own.
The thinking behind it
Richard Dawkins Richard Dawkins, an evolutionary biologist, coined the word meme in The Selfish Gene (1976) for a unit of cultural transmission, the cultural counterpart of the gene. He compared replicators on three properties: longevity, fecundity, and copying fidelity. Memetics has not become an established science, and critics question whether ideas replicate with the stability and discreteness the gene analogy needs; as a way of asking why one message spreads and another fades, the three properties remain useful.
Daniel C. Dennett Daniel Dennett, a philosopher, argued in Darwin's Dangerous Idea: Evolution and the Meanings of Life (1995) that natural selection is a general algorithm: wherever there is variation, selection, and heredity, adaptation follows, in culture as well as in biology. On that basis he extended Dawkins's idea of the meme, treating the spread of ideas as one more case of the same process, which is what lets a manager ask of a message the questions a biologist asks of a gene.
Susan Blackmore Susan Blackmore, a British psychologist, worked the idea into a fuller theory in The Meme Machine (1999), in which imitation, the copying of behavior from one person to another, is the process memes ride on and a force that shaped the human mind. Her account remains contested: critics argue that memes cannot be specified as units and that the field has produced little direct evidence for memetic mechanisms.
How to run it
- Name the unit. Pick one phrase, story, or practice, stated exactly as it should be repeated.
- Find who carries it and what it competes with. List the people who would pass it on and the older phrases or habits already in their heads.
- Rate the three properties. Score fidelity, fecundity, and longevity from 1 to 5, from what people actually say, never from the launch plan.
- Multiply and find the weakest. The lowest of the three limits the whole, so it is the one to work on first.
- Strengthen that property. Shorten or sharpen for fidelity, give people a reason to say it for fecundity, and tie it to a recurring occasion for longevity.
- Check again in a few months. Ask a sample of people to repeat it and note where and how often it shows up unprompted.
Where it goes wrong
The first failure is rating the idea by its merit. A thoughtful statement can still be impossible to repeat. Rate how it travels, from what people actually say, and keep the argument about whether it is right for another meeting.
The second is chasing fecundity alone. Repetition bought with posters and prizes stops when the campaign does, and garbled copies spread a different idea. If the version people repeat differs from the original, fix fidelity first.
The third is treating the model as a science. The gene analogy is loose, and memes cannot be counted like genes. Use the three properties as a diagnostic checklist, and test any rewrite with the people who are meant to carry it.
When to use something else
- Tipping Points. When the question is how adoption crosses from a few early carriers to the majority, whatever the version.
- Conceptual Metaphor Analysis. When the message fails because its underlying metaphor frames the issue badly for the audience.
- StoryBrand. When the task is building one clear story around the customer before any phrase is tested.
Where it sits in SOLVE eX
Go to the source
- The Selfish Gene, Oxford University Press, 1976
- Darwin's Dangerous Idea, Simon and Schuster, 1995
- The Meme Machine, Oxford University Press, 1999
- Memes in Digital Culture, MIT Press, 2014