Developed by Barbara Minto at McKinsey (The Pyramid Principle, 1978 edition).
Opens a document or argument with four moves, an accepted situation, the complication that disturbs it, the question that raises, and the answer, stated up front.
Four opening sentences for a memo asking to delay a launch, and how the reader takes each
At each of the writer's turns, pick the sentence that goes next: situation, complication, question, then answer. The chief operating officer's reaction shows with a verdict, and the line under the panel counts the links that hold. Illustrative.
Writer
The COO
Writer
The COO
Links that hold: 0 of 4Links that hold: 1 of 4Links that hold: 2 of 4Links that hold: 3 of 4Links that hold: 4 of 4
- The reader (The COO). The COO reads the first paragraph of thirty memos a week and decides most of them from it. This one asks her to delay a launch promised for March 1.
- Situation (Writer). Pick the memo's first sentence.
- Our launch planning has been poorly managed from the start. That is not how I see it. Who managed it? A disputed premise: the memo is now an argument about the past.
- We plan to launch the new billing app to all customers on March 1. Yes. Go on. Common ground: nothing to dispute, so she reads on.
- Complication (Writer). Pick the second sentence.
- As you know, testing time has always been tight on this team. That has been true for years. Why a memo now? Stale: it gives no reason for the memo to exist today.
- Last week's load test failed: invoices took 40 seconds at half of March volume. That is new. What does it mean for March 1? What changed: it disturbs the situation and raises the question.
- Question (Writer). Pick the third sentence.
- How can we build a stronger testing culture? Worth discussing, but it is not what I need to decide this week. Off target: the complication forced a different question.
- Do we launch on March 1, or wait? That is exactly the question. The question the complication forces, in plain words.
- Answer (Writer). Pick the fourth sentence.
- There are several options, each with pros and cons, set out below. So what do you recommend? A menu: the decision goes back to her.
- Launch April 5 to monthly-billing customers, ten percent, and to everyone by May 1. Clear. Show me why. An answer to the question, in one sentence she can approve.
- The decision (The COO). The COO approves the phased launch after the first paragraph and asks one question: when is the second load test?
An example
A product manager at a billing software company needed the chief operating officer to approve a delay to a launch everyone had been promised for March 1. Her first draft opened with two paragraphs on the history of the project, a page on the testing process, and the recommendation on page three. A colleague who had worked for the COO said she reads the first paragraph of every memo and decides most of them there.
The rewrite opened with four sentences. The situation: we plan to launch the new billing app to all customers on March 1. The complication: last week's load test failed, with invoices taking forty seconds to generate at half of March's expected volume. The question: do we launch on March 1 or wait? The answer: launch on April 5 to the ten percent of customers on monthly billing, and to everyone by May 1, after two more load tests. The history and test details moved below.
The COO approved the phased launch in the meeting, asking only when the second load test would run.
Why it works
A busy reader decides how much attention a document deserves from its opening, and many decide the matter itself there. An opening that starts with background spends that attention on what the reader already knows, and an answer on page three is often never reached.
The four moves earn the answer a hearing. The situation states something the reader already accepts, so there is nothing to argue with yet. The complication says what has changed, which is the document's reason to exist. The question is the one the change forces, written out so the answer can be checked against it, and the answer comes next, in one sentence. Each link can fail on its own: a disputed situation turns the memo into an argument about the premise, a stale complication makes the reader wonder why now, and an answer to a different question gets a polite nod and no decision.
The thinking behind it
Barbara Minto Barbara Minto, the first woman MBA hired by McKinsey, taught its consultants to write by putting the main point first and grouping the supporting points beneath it, each group mutually exclusive and collectively exhaustive. She published the method herself through Minto International as The Pyramid Principle: Logic in Writing and Thinking, in a revised second edition by 1978. The situation, complication, question, and answer opening is how she brings a reader to the top of the pyramid, the main point, in the first paragraph.
How to run it
- Name the reader and what they accept. Write down what this reader already knows and would not dispute.
- State the situation. One or two sentences the reader would nod at, with no argument in them.
- State the complication. Say what has changed, recently and specifically, that makes the situation a problem.
- Write the question out. Put it as a literal question the complication forces, even if it is cut from the final draft.
- Answer it in one sentence. Give the recommendation directly, as something the reader can approve or reject.
- Check every link. Confirm the complication disturbs the situation, the question follows, and the answer answers it.
- Put everything else below. Move the history, method, and detail into the body, as support for the answer.
Where it goes wrong
The situation argues. Writers slip their conclusion into the opening, such as our launch planning has been poor, and the reader stops to dispute it. Spot it when the first sentence would draw a wait, is that true; replace it with a plain fact the reader accepts.
The complication is old news. Testing has always been tight could have been written a year ago, and the reader wonders why the memo exists. Find what changed this week.
The answer is a menu. Several options, each with pros and cons, hands the decision back to the reader with no recommendation. Pick one, state it, and put the alternatives below with the reasons they lost.
When to use something else
- Pyramid Principle. When the whole document, and not only its opening, needs its points grouped and ordered under the main one.
- Problem-Solution-Result. When the writing is evidence of past work, told as the problem, the action, and the measured result.
- Toulmin Model. When the argument itself needs testing: the claim, its grounds, the warrant, and the rebuttals.
Where it sits in SOLVE eX
Go to the source
- The Pyramid Principle: Logic in Writing and Thinking, Minto International, revised second edition; the first edition is undated in library catalogs, 1978