Problem-Solution-Result

Thinking Tools6.4 Conducting Follow-Up and Taking FeedbackAlso known as PSR, STAR, PAR

From management consulting case writing, a shape with no single author; its STAR variant comes from the Targeted Selection interviewing system of William C. Byham (1975).

Tells a piece of work in three beats, the problem faced, the action taken, and the measured result, so the activity reads as evidence of impact.

Rebuild a consulting case study in three beats: the problem, the firm's part, the result

It opens on the case as first drafted, and the lines under the rows say how a skeptical reader takes each beat. Pick one option per row: the firm built the slotting model, and the client's team ran the move. Illustrative.

Problem

The firm's part

Result

  • Nothing flagged in this combination.An unsized problem: the reader cannot tell whether any result is large or small.Vague: high compared with what, and by how much?Distance, no ownership: the reader cannot tell what the firm did.An over-claim: the client's team ran the move, and the reference call will say so.Adjectives only: the reader cannot weigh it, so it counts for nothing.Scope with no outcome: it says the work spread and leaves out what it changed.Strong, but with no starting point: the before and after would let the reader see the scale.A credible case: a sized problem, the firm's real part, and a result with its before and after in the same units.
  • Nothing flagged in this combination.An unsized problem: the reader cannot tell whether any result is large or small.Vague: high compared with what, and by how much?Distance, no ownership: the reader cannot tell what the firm did.An over-claim: the client's team ran the move, and the reference call will say so.Adjectives only: the reader cannot weigh it, so it counts for nothing.Scope with no outcome: it says the work spread and leaves out what it changed.Strong, but with no starting point: the before and after would let the reader see the scale.A credible case: a sized problem, the firm's real part, and a result with its before and after in the same units.
  • Nothing flagged in this combination.An unsized problem: the reader cannot tell whether any result is large or small.Vague: high compared with what, and by how much?Distance, no ownership: the reader cannot tell what the firm did.An over-claim: the client's team ran the move, and the reference call will say so.Adjectives only: the reader cannot weigh it, so it counts for nothing.Scope with no outcome: it says the work spread and leaves out what it changed.Strong, but with no starting point: the before and after would let the reader see the scale.A credible case: a sized problem, the firm's real part, and a result with its before and after in the same units.
  • An unsized problem: the reader cannot tell whether any result is large or small. (prob: Logistics was a mess)
  • Vague: high compared with what, and by how much? (prob: Shipping costs were high)
  • Distance, no ownership: the reader cannot tell what the firm did. (part: Supported the project)
  • An over-claim: the client's team ran the move, and the reference call will say so. (part: Ran the whole program)
  • Adjectives only: the reader cannot weigh it, so it counts for nothing. (res: Big efficiency gains)
  • Scope with no outcome: it says the work spread and leaves out what it changed. (res: Adopted at 14 sites)
  • Strong, but with no starting point: the before and after would let the reader see the scale. (res: Saved $640K a year)
  • A credible case: a sized problem, the firm's real part, and a result with its before and after in the same units. (prob: Rush air: $1.1M a year, part: Built the slotting model, res: Rush air $1.1M to $460K)

An example

A small operations consulting firm was answering a request for proposal from a distributor, and the partner reading the draft found that its three case studies all read the same way: we supported a major logistics transformation, delivering significant efficiency gains. Nothing in them could be checked, and nothing set the firm apart.

She rewrote the strongest one in three beats, starting with the result. The client's rush air freight had fallen from $1.1 million a year to $460,000 within nine months, across all fourteen warehouses, by the client's own figures. The problem was then sized to match: late orders were being rescued by air because fast-moving items sat at the back of the warehouses. The action was stated as the firm's actual part. The firm built the slotting model that decided where each item should sit; the client's operations team ran the move. She kept that last sentence, though it claimed less, because the client's reference would be called.

The proposal's evaluators scored that case highest, and one wrote in the margin: specific, and believable.

Why it works

Readers judging past work want to know what changed, and most write-ups tell them what was done. Activity is easy to describe and impossible to weigh, so the reader discounts it. Starting from the result forces the writer to find out what actually changed, and a result with a before and an after lets the reader judge its size without trusting the writer's adjectives.

The other two beats exist to make the result believable. A problem sized in the same units shows the result is in proportion: a $640,000 saving against $1.1 million of rush freight reads as plausible, where the same saving against an unsized mess reads as a claim. An action stated as the writer's real part, no larger, survives the reference call. Credibility in this form is cumulative: a reader who can check one number trusts the rest.

The thinking behind it

William C. Byham William C. Byham, an industrial and organizational psychologist, cofounded Development Dimensions International in 1970. DDI's Targeted Selection, from 1975, put behavioral interviewing, asking candidates what they actually did in past situations, into a packaged hiring system. The STAR answer format, situation, task, action, and result, is widely credited to Targeted Selection, though that credit rests on DDI's own account, which says only that the firm brought the method to market in the 1970s. The wider three-beat shape comes from consulting case writing and has no single author.

How to run it

  1. Find the result first. Write what changed, with a number, a before and after, and a time frame, before anything else.
  2. Size the problem to match. State the problem in the same units, so the reader can see the result is in proportion.
  3. Say what was done, specifically. Name the intervention, such as a slotting model, and leave out the general activity.
  4. Claim your real part. Say what you did and what others did; assume the reference will be called.
  5. Draft in order. Write problem, action, result, and check that each beat leads to the next.
  6. Compress to the format. Keep the same three beats in a one-line bullet or a page-long case.
  7. Read it as a skeptic. Ask which number a doubtful reader would check first, and make sure it holds.

Where it goes wrong

The result is adjectives. Significant gains and major improvements cannot be weighed, so they count for nothing. Spot it when the result has no number or named outcome; go back to the client's data, or say plainly that the figures are confidential.

The problem and the result are out of proportion. A modest problem with a huge result reads as exaggeration, and a huge problem with a modest result reads as failure. State both in the same units and let the ratio speak.

The credit is inflated. We transformed their network, when the client's team did most of the work, is the line a reference call undoes. Name your part exactly; a smaller honest claim is worth more than a large one that fails a check.

When to use something else

  • SCQA. When the writing must open an argument for a decision and lead the reader to a recommendation.
  • StoryBrand. When the story should cast the customer as the hero and the firm as the guide, for marketing.
  • Pyramid Principle. When a long document needs its main point first and its support grouped beneath it.

Where it sits in SOLVE eX

Go to the source

  • Targeted Selection behavioral interviewing system, the source of the STAR format, Development Dimensions International, 1975

Back to the catalog