Developed by David H. Maister, Charles H. Green, and Robert M. Galford (The Trusted Advisor, 2000).
Scores trustworthiness as credibility plus reliability plus intimacy, divided by self-orientation, which shows which factor is holding a relationship back.
Self-orientation divides everything else, so it sinks trust whatever the other three are
A consultant rates one client relationship as the client would see it, from 1 to 10 on each factor. The score is credibility plus reliability plus intimacy, divided by self-orientation. Move the ratings and compare the two what-ifs: two more points of intimacy help a little, two fewer points of self-orientation help far more, and only one of them lifts the point past the advisor the client already trusts. Illustrative.
This relationshipTrusted more than the incumbent: the client is likely to bring you the next hard problem.Trusted less than the incumbent: the hard problems still go to the other advisor.
An example
A consultant had worked with a hospital group's COO for a year. The work was good and always on time, yet the COO still took her hardest problems to an older advisor she had known for a decade, and the consultant could not see why.
His practice lead suggested rating the relationship the way the COO would. Credibility was high, an 8: she trusted his analysis. Reliability was a 7. Intimacy was a 3: their meetings stayed on the agenda, and she never told him what worried her. Self-orientation was a 6, which stung, but he recognized it: he steered every conversation toward the next phase of work. The score came to 3.0, against about 4.4 for the incumbent. Raising intimacy by two points would lift it a little; cutting self-orientation by two would lift it past the incumbent. He stopped pitching follow-on work in their meetings, asked about her board, and three months later she called him first about a merger.
Why it works
Competence is necessary for trust and is rarely what limits it. A client who already believes an advisor and finds them dependable can still hold back, and the trust equation shows why: the three things the advisor offers are added, and the one thing the advisor wants is divided into them. Self-orientation, the sense that the advisor is focused on their own interest, shrinks the whole sum.
That structure tells the advisor where to work. Adding a point of credibility to a score already at 8 changes little; removing a point of self-orientation changes everything above it. The equation also separates factors that are often blurred. Credibility is about what is said, reliability about what is done over time, and intimacy about whether the client feels safe saying what really worries them. Rating each one on its own makes the weak one visible.
The thinking behind it
David H. Maister David H. Maister, a former Harvard Business School professor who wrote on managing professional service firms, published The Trusted Advisor (2000) with Charles H. Green and Robert M. Galford. The book gave the trust equation: credibility, reliability, and intimacy, divided by self-orientation. It is a practitioner's book, written for advisors in professional firms, and the equation is usually credited to Green.
Charles H. Green Charles H. Green, founder of Trusted Advisor Associates, coauthored The Trusted Advisor (2000), where the trust equation first appeared. He is usually credited with the equation itself. It is a practitioner's model, not a measured scale, so the numbers in it are judgments, best made from the client's point of view and compared over time for the same relationship, never across people.
Robert M. Galford Robert M. Galford, a management consultant, was the third coauthor of The Trusted Advisor (2000), the professional services book that introduced the trust equation. Like his coauthors, he presents it as a practitioner's model for diagnosing a working relationship, which is how this page uses it: to find the factor that is holding a relationship back and to plan a change aimed at it.
How to run it
- Pick one relationship. A single client, sponsor, or partner; averages across relationships hide the one that needs work.
- Rate credibility as they see it. Would they repeat what the advisor told them to their own boss without checking?
- Rate reliability. Count the small promises kept: calls returned, drafts on the day, follow-ups sent.
- Rate intimacy. Ask whether they have told the advisor something that worries them which is not on the agenda.
- Rate self-orientation honestly. Notice how often the conversations turn to the advisor's next piece of work or own credit.
- Find the factor holding the score back. Compare what two points better on each factor would do; self-orientation usually wins.
- Plan one change and rerate later. Try a specific behavior for a quarter, then score the relationship again.
Where it goes wrong
The common failure is rating from the advisor's own view. Advisors tend to score their credibility and reliability high and their self-orientation low, and the result explains nothing. Rate as the client would, or ask a colleague who has seen the relationship.
A second failure is treating the score as a measurement. It is a structured judgment, and comparing scores across people or firms means little. Use it to compare one relationship with itself over time. The third is working on the easy factor. Advisors add more analysis because credibility is comfortable ground, while the low intimacy or high self-orientation goes untouched. Start with the factor that limits the score, even when it is the uncomfortable one.
When to use something else
- Johari Window. When the gap is between how someone sees themselves and how others see them, beyond one working relationship.
- Tactical Empathy. When the immediate need is a single hard conversation where the other side must feel heard.
- Influence Sociogram. When the question is who the client listens to across the organization, and where the advisor sits in that web.
Where it sits in SOLVE eX
Go to the source
- The Trusted Advisor, Free Press, 2000