Difficult Conversations

Thinking Tools6.3 Implementing the Action Plan

Developed by Douglas Stone, Bruce Patton, and Sheila Heen of the Harvard Negotiation Project (Difficult Conversations, 1999).

Treats a hard conversation as three at once (what happened, what each side feels, and what it means for each identity) and shifts the aim from persuading to learning.

Eight things said after a missed handoff, sorted into the three conversations

A client sat alone on a kickoff call that nobody joined. The account manager and the implementation lead each said or thought what is listed here. One line is placed as an example. Select each other line and pick its box by conversation and by side: the panel shows how each one sounds once blame becomes each person's contribution. Illustrative.

Items (select one, then a box)
  • Not placedPlacedHer storyHer feelingsHer identityHis storyHis feelingsHis identity
  • Not placedPlacedHer storyHer feelingsHer identityHis storyHis feelingsHis identity
  • Not placedPlacedHer storyHer feelingsHer identityHis storyHis feelingsHis identity
  • Not placedPlacedHer storyHer feelingsHer identityHis storyHis feelingsHis identity
  • Not placedPlacedHer storyHer feelingsHer identityHis storyHis feelingsHis identity
  • Not placedPlacedHer storyHer feelingsHer identityHis storyHis feelingsHis identity
  • Not placedPlacedHer storyHer feelingsHer identityHis storyHis feelingsHis identity
  • Not placedPlacedHer storyHer feelingsHer identityHis storyHis feelingsHis identity

Whose side

Account managerImplementer
Her story
Her feelings
Her identity
His story
His feelings
His identity
What happenedFeelingsIdentity

Which conversation it belongs to

Sent it all Friday. Account manager: "I sent the notes and the invite on Friday, same as always."Not placed yet.Sent it all Friday. Account manager: "I sent the notes and the invite on Friday, same as always."Her story: What happened, from her side: her facts, her guess at his intent, and where she puts the blame. Swap blame for contribution: what did she do that helped cause it?Her contribution: she sent them to the shared inbox, which he stopped checking in March, and did not confirm they arrived.Sent it all Friday. Account manager: "I sent the notes and the invite on Friday, same as always."Her feelings: Her feelings, often dressed up as judgments about him. Said plainly, they become part of the conversation.Sent it all Friday. Account manager: "I sent the notes and the invite on Friday, same as always."Her identity: What the miss seems to say about who she is. Named, it can be separated from one bad Monday.Sent it all Friday. Account manager: "I sent the notes and the invite on Friday, same as always."His story: What happened, from his side: his facts, his guess at her intent, and where he puts the blame. Swap blame for contribution.Sent it all Friday. Account manager: "I sent the notes and the invite on Friday, same as always."His feelings: His feelings, often dressed up as judgments about her. Said plainly, they stop driving the argument from underneath.Sent it all Friday. Account manager: "I sent the notes and the invite on Friday, same as always."His identity: What the miss seems to say about who he is. Named, it stops making every fact feel like an attack.Nothing reached me. Implementation lead: "Nothing reached me, so there was no kickoff on my calendar."Not placed yet.Nothing reached me. Implementation lead: "Nothing reached me, so there was no kickoff on my calendar."Her story: What happened, from her side: her facts, her guess at his intent, and where she puts the blame. Swap blame for contribution: what did she do that helped cause it?Nothing reached me. Implementation lead: "Nothing reached me, so there was no kickoff on my calendar."Her feelings: Her feelings, often dressed up as judgments about him. Said plainly, they become part of the conversation.Nothing reached me. Implementation lead: "Nothing reached me, so there was no kickoff on my calendar."Her identity: What the miss seems to say about who she is. Named, it can be separated from one bad Monday.Nothing reached me. Implementation lead: "Nothing reached me, so there was no kickoff on my calendar."His story: What happened, from his side: his facts, his guess at her intent, and where he puts the blame. Swap blame for contribution.His contribution: he knew a handoff was due that week and did not ask where it was.Nothing reached me. Implementation lead: "Nothing reached me, so there was no kickoff on my calendar."His feelings: His feelings, often dressed up as judgments about her. Said plainly, they stop driving the argument from underneath.Nothing reached me. Implementation lead: "Nothing reached me, so there was no kickoff on my calendar."His identity: What the miss seems to say about who he is. Named, it stops making every fact feel like an attack.She set me up. Implementation lead: "She wanted this to land on me."Not placed yet.She set me up. Implementation lead: "She wanted this to land on me."Her story: What happened, from her side: her facts, her guess at his intent, and where she puts the blame. Swap blame for contribution: what did she do that helped cause it?She set me up. Implementation lead: "She wanted this to land on me."Her feelings: Her feelings, often dressed up as judgments about him. Said plainly, they become part of the conversation.She set me up. Implementation lead: "She wanted this to land on me."Her identity: What the miss seems to say about who she is. Named, it can be separated from one bad Monday.She set me up. Implementation lead: "She wanted this to land on me."His story: What happened, from his side: his facts, his guess at her intent, and where he puts the blame. Swap blame for contribution.A guess at her intent, which belongs to the story of what happened. Her intent is hers to say; his was the impact on him.She set me up. Implementation lead: "She wanted this to land on me."His feelings: His feelings, often dressed up as judgments about her. Said plainly, they stop driving the argument from underneath.She set me up. Implementation lead: "She wanted this to land on me."His identity: What the miss seems to say about who he is. Named, it stops making every fact feel like an attack.He doesn't care. Account manager: "He doesn't care about my clients."Not placed yet.He doesn't care. Account manager: "He doesn't care about my clients."Her story: What happened, from her side: her facts, her guess at his intent, and where she puts the blame. Swap blame for contribution: what did she do that helped cause it?He doesn't care. Account manager: "He doesn't care about my clients."Her feelings: Her feelings, often dressed up as judgments about him. Said plainly, they become part of the conversation.A judgment carrying a feeling. Said plainly: "I was scared when the client called me furious."He doesn't care. Account manager: "He doesn't care about my clients."Her identity: What the miss seems to say about who she is. Named, it can be separated from one bad Monday.He doesn't care. Account manager: "He doesn't care about my clients."His story: What happened, from his side: his facts, his guess at her intent, and where he puts the blame. Swap blame for contribution.He doesn't care. Account manager: "He doesn't care about my clients."His feelings: His feelings, often dressed up as judgments about her. Said plainly, they stop driving the argument from underneath.He doesn't care. Account manager: "He doesn't care about my clients."His identity: What the miss seems to say about who he is. Named, it stops making every fact feel like an attack.Furious at director. Implementation lead: "Hearing about it from my director first made me furious."Not placed yet.Furious at director. Implementation lead: "Hearing about it from my director first made me furious."Her story: What happened, from her side: her facts, her guess at his intent, and where she puts the blame. Swap blame for contribution: what did she do that helped cause it?Furious at director. Implementation lead: "Hearing about it from my director first made me furious."Her feelings: Her feelings, often dressed up as judgments about him. Said plainly, they become part of the conversation.Furious at director. Implementation lead: "Hearing about it from my director first made me furious."Her identity: What the miss seems to say about who she is. Named, it can be separated from one bad Monday.Furious at director. Implementation lead: "Hearing about it from my director first made me furious."His story: What happened, from his side: his facts, his guess at her intent, and where he puts the blame. Swap blame for contribution.Furious at director. Implementation lead: "Hearing about it from my director first made me furious."His feelings: His feelings, often dressed up as judgments about her. Said plainly, they stop driving the argument from underneath.A feeling, named as one. It is part of what happened to him and needs saying.Furious at director. Implementation lead: "Hearing about it from my director first made me furious."His identity: What the miss seems to say about who he is. Named, it stops making every fact feel like an attack.I lose the account. Account manager: "If this client leaves, I'm the one who lost it."Not placed yet.I lose the account. Account manager: "If this client leaves, I'm the one who lost it."Her story: What happened, from her side: her facts, her guess at his intent, and where she puts the blame. Swap blame for contribution: what did she do that helped cause it?I lose the account. Account manager: "If this client leaves, I'm the one who lost it."Her feelings: Her feelings, often dressed up as judgments about him. Said plainly, they become part of the conversation.I lose the account. Account manager: "If this client leaves, I'm the one who lost it."Her identity: What the miss seems to say about who she is. Named, it can be separated from one bad Monday.What she fears it says about her. One miss does not make her the person who loses accounts.I lose the account. Account manager: "If this client leaves, I'm the one who lost it."His story: What happened, from his side: his facts, his guess at her intent, and where he puts the blame. Swap blame for contribution.I lose the account. Account manager: "If this client leaves, I'm the one who lost it."His feelings: His feelings, often dressed up as judgments about her. Said plainly, they stop driving the argument from underneath.I lose the account. Account manager: "If this client leaves, I'm the one who lost it."His identity: What the miss seems to say about who he is. Named, it stops making every fact feel like an attack.I'm the careful one. Implementation lead: "I'm the careful one on this team. People rely on me."Not placed yet.I'm the careful one. Implementation lead: "I'm the careful one on this team. People rely on me."Her story: What happened, from her side: her facts, her guess at his intent, and where she puts the blame. Swap blame for contribution: what did she do that helped cause it?I'm the careful one. Implementation lead: "I'm the careful one on this team. People rely on me."Her feelings: Her feelings, often dressed up as judgments about him. Said plainly, they become part of the conversation.I'm the careful one. Implementation lead: "I'm the careful one on this team. People rely on me."Her identity: What the miss seems to say about who she is. Named, it can be separated from one bad Monday.I'm the careful one. Implementation lead: "I'm the careful one on this team. People rely on me."His story: What happened, from his side: his facts, his guess at her intent, and where he puts the blame. Swap blame for contribution.I'm the careful one. Implementation lead: "I'm the careful one on this team. People rely on me."His feelings: His feelings, often dressed up as judgments about her. Said plainly, they stop driving the argument from underneath.I'm the careful one. Implementation lead: "I'm the careful one on this team. People rely on me."His identity: What the miss seems to say about who he is. Named, it stops making every fact feel like an attack.What he fears the miss says about him, which is why he hears every question as an accusation.Client waited alone. Account manager: "The client sat on that call for forty minutes and nobody came."Not placed yet.Client waited alone. Account manager: "The client sat on that call for forty minutes and nobody came."Her story: What happened, from her side: her facts, her guess at his intent, and where she puts the blame. Swap blame for contribution: what did she do that helped cause it?A fact both can agree on. Start the joint story from facts like this one.Client waited alone. Account manager: "The client sat on that call for forty minutes and nobody came."Her feelings: Her feelings, often dressed up as judgments about him. Said plainly, they become part of the conversation.Client waited alone. Account manager: "The client sat on that call for forty minutes and nobody came."Her identity: What the miss seems to say about who she is. Named, it can be separated from one bad Monday.Client waited alone. Account manager: "The client sat on that call for forty minutes and nobody came."His story: What happened, from his side: his facts, his guess at her intent, and where he puts the blame. Swap blame for contribution.Client waited alone. Account manager: "The client sat on that call for forty minutes and nobody came."His feelings: His feelings, often dressed up as judgments about her. Said plainly, they stop driving the argument from underneath.Client waited alone. Account manager: "The client sat on that call for forty minutes and nobody came."His identity: What the miss seems to say about who he is. Named, it stops making every fact feel like an attack.

Your sort matched 0 of 8.Your sort matched 1 of 8.Your sort matched 2 of 8.Your sort matched 3 of 8.Your sort matched 4 of 8.Your sort matched 5 of 8.Your sort matched 6 of 8.Your sort matched 7 of 8.Your sort matched 8 of 8.

Her story
What happened, from her side: her facts, her guess at his intent, and where she puts the blame. Swap blame for contribution: what did she do that helped cause it?
Her feelings
Her feelings, often dressed up as judgments about him. Said plainly, they become part of the conversation.
Her identity
What the miss seems to say about who she is. Named, it can be separated from one bad Monday.
His story
What happened, from his side: his facts, his guess at her intent, and where he puts the blame. Swap blame for contribution.
His feelings
His feelings, often dressed up as judgments about her. Said plainly, they stop driving the argument from underneath.
His identity
What the miss seems to say about who he is. Named, it stops making every fact feel like an attack.

The sort

  • Sent it all Friday: Her story. Her contribution: she sent them to the shared inbox, which he stopped checking in March, and did not confirm they arrived.
  • Nothing reached me: His story. His contribution: he knew a handoff was due that week and did not ask where it was.
  • She set me up: His story. A guess at her intent, which belongs to the story of what happened. Her intent is hers to say; his was the impact on him.
  • He doesn't care: Her feelings. A judgment carrying a feeling. Said plainly: "I was scared when the client called me furious."
  • Furious at director: His feelings. A feeling, named as one. It is part of what happened to him and needs saying.
  • I lose the account: Her identity. What she fears it says about her. One miss does not make her the person who loses accounts.
  • I'm the careful one: His identity. What he fears the miss says about him, which is why he hears every question as an accusation.
  • Client waited alone: Her story. A fact both can agree on. Start the joint story from facts like this one.

An example

A new client of a software company joined its kickoff call on a Monday morning and waited forty minutes for someone to show up. The account manager blamed the implementation lead, who had never put the call on his calendar. He blamed her for a handoff that never reached him. By Tuesday they were not speaking, and the client had called her twice.

Before talking to him, she wrote down what each of them had said and thought, and sorted it into three piles: what happened, the feelings, and what it meant to each of them. The facts pile was shorter than she expected. She had sent the notes to a shared inbox he had stopped checking in March, and never confirmed they arrived; he had known a handoff was due that week and never asked. She opened the conversation with her part, and asked for his. They agreed that handoffs would be confirmed by direct message, and called the client together that afternoon.

Why it works

A hard conversation feels like one argument about the facts. Underneath it run two more: how each person feels, and what the episode seems to say about who each person is. People argue the facts because feelings and identity feel too risky to name, and the argument never resolves, because the facts were never what was driving it.

Sorting the conversation into its three layers changes each one. In the facts layer, blame becomes contribution: what did each person do that helped produce this? Intent is split from impact, since each person knows only their own. Feelings are said as feelings instead of leaking out as judgments. Identity fears are named, so they stop turning every question into an attack. The aim shifts from persuading the other person to learning what happened from both sides.

The thinking behind it

Douglas Stone Douglas Stone, a lecturer associated with the Harvard Negotiation Project, wrote Difficult Conversations (1999) with Bruce Patton and Sheila Heen. The book's central claim is the one this page uses: every hard conversation is really three conversations, one about what happened, one about feelings, and one about identity. The figure's sorting, line by line into those three, applies that claim to a single bad Monday.

Bruce Patton Bruce Patton, a member of the Harvard Negotiation Project, co-wrote Difficult Conversations with Douglas Stone and Sheila Heen. It is a practitioner's book, written for the person who has to have the conversation more than for the scholar who studies it. Its method splits each hard conversation into three: what happened, the feelings, and what the episode says about each person's identity, so that each part can be prepared on its own.

Sheila Heen Sheila Heen, a professor of practice at Harvard Law School and a member of the Harvard Negotiation Project, is the third author of Difficult Conversations (1999). The guide is built on the project's negotiation work, and it breaks each hard conversation into the same three layers: what happened, the feelings involved, and what the episode says about each person's identity.

How to run it

  1. Write down what each side said and thinks. Capture the lines in their own words, including the ones nobody has said aloud yet.
  2. Sort them into three conversations. Put each line under what happened, feelings, or identity, and note whose side it comes from.
  3. Turn blame into contribution. For each person, list what they did or did not do that helped produce the outcome, starting with your own.
  4. Separate intent from impact. State the impact on you as fact and treat the other person's intent as unknown until they say it.
  5. Name the feelings plainly. Rewrite each judgment about the other person as the feeling under it.
  6. Find the identity stake. Ask what the episode seems to say about who you are and who they are, and say it to yourself first.
  7. Open with the third story. Begin with a description of the disagreement a neutral observer would accept, then ask for their side.

Where it goes wrong

The first failure is sorting only the other person's lines. The exercise turns into a case file against them. Start with the sorter's own contribution, and if none turns up, look again.

The second is staying in the facts layer because it feels safer. The conversation sounds calm and goes nowhere, because the anger and the fear are still steering it. If the same point keeps coming back, a feeling or an identity stake sits behind it.

The third is using the language of the method as a script. Saying "I hear that you feel" while still arguing for the verdict reads as a technique. The point is to learn something neither side knew about what happened.

When to use something else

  • Crucial Conversations. When the stakes are high, opinions differ, and the risk is that one side goes silent or hostile mid-conversation.
  • Nonviolent Communication. When the job is one clear request, built from an observation, a feeling, and a need.
  • Blameless Postmortem. When the miss came from a process, and a team needs to review the timeline together without assigning fault.

Where it sits in SOLVE eX

Go to the source

  • Difficult Conversations: How to Discuss What Matters Most, Harvard Negotiation Project, 1999

Back to the catalog