Originated by Robert B. Cialdini (Influence, 1984).
Seven principles (reciprocity, commitment, social proof, liking, authority, scarcity, and unity) used as a checklist to plan honest persuasion and to recognize pressure tactics.
Eight lines from a software vendor's renewal pitch, sorted into honest influence and pressure
Each line leans on one principle of influence, named when the line is selected. A principle is honest when it is true of the situation and pressure when it is invented or inflated. The first line is placed as an example. Select each other line, then the side it belongs on, and show the sort to compare. Illustrative.
- Not placedPlacedHonest influencePressure
- Not placedPlacedHonest influencePressure
- Not placedPlacedHonest influencePressure
- Not placedPlacedHonest influencePressure
- Not placedPlacedHonest influencePressure
- Not placedPlacedHonest influencePressure
- Not placedPlacedHonest influencePressure
- Not placedPlacedHonest influencePressure
The pitch
The claim behind the line
Your sort matched 0 of 8.Your sort matched 1 of 8.Your sort matched 2 of 8.Your sort matched 3 of 8.Your sort matched 4 of 8.Your sort matched 5 of 8.Your sort matched 6 of 8.Your sort matched 7 of 8.Your sort matched 8 of 8.
- Honest influence
- The principle rests on a fact the buyer can check. Weigh it: a real deadline, a real favor, or real peers are good reasons to act.
- Pressure
- The principle is borrowed without the fact behind it. Name it, ask for the evidence, and decide on the merits alone.
The sort
- Prices change on July 1: Honest influence. The new price list is published and applies to every customer, so the deadline is real. Deciding before it is a fair reason to move.
- Only 3 seats at the rate: Pressure. Software seats do not run out. The limit is invented to cut the buyer's time to think.
- Free migration last year: Honest influence. The vendor really did the migration at no charge last year. Some goodwill is earned; it still does not settle the price.
- Gift basket before call: Pressure. An unasked-for gift timed to the negotiation is there to create a sense of debt. Thank them and leave it out of the decision.
- 40 similar firms renewed: Honest influence. The vendor offers the list and three references to call. Peers who chose it with the same needs are evidence worth checking.
- Everyone is going annual: Pressure. No names, no numbers, and no way to check. It invites the buyer to follow a crowd that may not exist.
- Your words: saved hours: Honest influence. The quote is from the buyer's own review last quarter, so it is fair to hold them to it, if it is still true.
- Our CTO says: upgrade: Pressure. The seller's own executive speaks with authority about the product and knows little of the buyer's needs. Ask what evidence the advice rests on.
An example
The head of IT at an insurance broker had a renewal proposal for its claims software: three years at 18 percent more, in a deck that felt urgent. Before the call she went through it line by line and named the principle each line leaned on.
Some were real. The vendor's price list really did change on July 1, for every customer. The free data migration it had done the year before was a genuine favor. Its list of forty similar firms that had renewed came with three references she could call, and the deck quoted her own words from the last review about hours saved. Others were borrowed. Only three seats were left at this rate, for software that does not run out. Everyone is moving to annual terms came with no names. A gift basket arrived the morning of the call. Two references she called held up, and she went into the call with the pressure lines listed. She renewed before July 1 at 9 percent more and set the other lines aside without arguing about them.
Why it works
People agree to things for a small number of reasons that usually serve them well: returning favors, staying consistent with what they said, following peers, liking people, deferring to experts, and acting before something runs out. Because these shortcuts usually work, they fire quickly, and a pitch can trigger them without the facts that would justify them.
The checklist separates the trigger from the fact. For each principle the question is whether it is true of this situation: is the deadline real, are these peers real and like us, is this authority expert on our problem. Where it is true, the principle is a good reason to act and an honest one to use. Where it is borrowed, naming it is usually enough to take its force away, and the decision goes back to the merits.
The thinking behind it
Robert B. Cialdini Robert Cialdini, a social psychologist, studied compliance in laboratory and field experiments and by training undercover as a salesperson, a fundraiser, and a telemarketer. In Influence: How and Why People Agree to Things (1984) he grouped what he found into six principles: reciprocity, commitment and consistency, social proof, liking, authority, and scarcity. In 2016 he proposed a seventh, unity, the pull of a shared identity. Later editions carry the subtitle The Psychology of Persuasion. His undercover work gave him the view from the persuader's side of the table, which is why the principles serve as well for spotting pressure as for planning a case.
How to run it
- List whose agreement is needed. Name the people, what they must agree to, and what they owe the proposal, which is often nothing.
- Go through the seven principles. Take reciprocity, commitment, social proof, liking, authority, scarcity, and unity one at a time.
- Note what is true of the situation. For each, write the fact that supports it, such as a real deadline or a peer who will take a call.
- Use only what is true. Build the case on the principles the facts support, and drop any that would need inventing or inflating.
- Make each one checkable. Offer references, published dates, and sources, so the other side can verify the claim.
- On the receiving end, name the principle. Label each line of a pitch with the principle it leans on, and ask for the fact behind it.
- Decide on the merits. Set aside the lines with no fact behind them and judge the offer on what remains.
Where it goes wrong
The common failure is using the list as a menu of tricks. A team that adds a deadline because scarcity works, without a real reason for the date, is applying pressure, and buyers who check find out. If a principle needs a fact that does not exist, leave it out.
The second is dismissing every principle as manipulation. A real deadline or a real favor is a fair reason to act, and refusing to weigh it costs the buyer. Ask whether the fact is there before discounting the line.
The third is spotting the obvious ones only. Scarcity and authority are easy to see; liking and unity work through rapport and shared identity, and rarely announce themselves. When a decision feels warmer than the numbers justify, check those two.
When to use something else
- Aristotelian Rhetoric. When the task is building a persuasive case for a skeptical audience on credibility, feeling, and argument together.
- BATNA and ZOPA. When the pitch is a negotiation and the question is what the alternatives are worth and where a deal can land.
- Cognitive Bias Checklist. When the worry is the decision-maker's own mental shortcuts, whoever is pitching.
Where it sits in SOLVE eX
Go to the source
- Influence: How and Why People Agree to Things, William Morrow, 1984