Thinking Tools6.3 Implementing the Action PlanAlso known as ZPD
Developed by Lev Vygotsky (Thought and Language, 1934), with the scaffolding of David Wood, Jerome Bruner, and Gail Ross (The Role of Tutoring in Problem Solving, 1976).
Locates the band between what a learner can do alone and what they can do with skilled help, where support teaches the most.
A new analyst's tasks in month two, sorted into three bands
The middle band holds the tasks the analyst can do with a more experienced person's help but not yet alone: the zone where coaching teaches the most. The first task is placed as an example; place the rest from the notes on how each went. Illustrative.
Items (select one, then a box)
Not placedPlacedCan do aloneThe zoneOut of reach
Not placedPlacedCan do aloneThe zoneOut of reach
Not placedPlacedCan do aloneThe zoneOut of reach
Not placedPlacedCan do aloneThe zoneOut of reach
Not placedPlacedCan do aloneThe zoneOut of reach
Not placedPlacedCan do aloneThe zoneOut of reach
Not placedPlacedCan do aloneThe zoneOut of reach
Not placedPlacedCan do aloneThe zoneOut of reach
Month two
Tasks
Can do alone
The zone
Out of reach
AloneWith helpNot yet, even with help
What the analyst can do
Build the variance model. Built the first one with the manager walking through the structure; stuck on where the price and volume effects split.Not placed yet.Build the variance model. Built the first one with the manager walking through the structure; stuck on where the price and volume effects split.Can do alone: Mastered. Hand it over fully; coaching here teaches nothing new, and checking it costs both people time.Build the variance model. Built the first one with the manager walking through the structure; stuck on where the price and volume effects split.The zone: Done with help, not yet alone. Coach here: a worked example, a hint at the stuck point, a review, and less of each every time.Done with help, not alone: coach here. Next time, a hint at the split and nothing else.Build the variance model. Built the first one with the manager walking through the structure; stuck on where the price and volume effects split.Out of reach: Not yet possible even with help. Hold it back until the tasks beneath it are done alone; for now, let the analyst watch it done.Pull monthly sales data. Has done it four times without a question or an error.Not placed yet.Pull monthly sales data. Has done it four times without a question or an error.Can do alone: Mastered. Hand it over fully; coaching here teaches nothing new, and checking it costs both people time.Mastered. Stop checking it.Pull monthly sales data. Has done it four times without a question or an error.The zone: Done with help, not yet alone. Coach here: a worked example, a hint at the stuck point, a review, and less of each every time.Pull monthly sales data. Has done it four times without a question or an error.Out of reach: Not yet possible even with help. Hold it back until the tasks beneath it are done alone; for now, let the analyst watch it done.Format the board pack. Follows the template exactly and catches the manager's typos.Not placed yet.Format the board pack. Follows the template exactly and catches the manager's typos.Can do alone: Mastered. Hand it over fully; coaching here teaches nothing new, and checking it costs both people time.Done alone. Hand it over.Format the board pack. Follows the template exactly and catches the manager's typos.The zone: Done with help, not yet alone. Coach here: a worked example, a hint at the stuck point, a review, and less of each every time.Format the board pack. Follows the template exactly and catches the manager's typos.Out of reach: Not yet possible even with help. Hold it back until the tasks beneath it are done alone; for now, let the analyst watch it done.Write the commentary. Drafts say what changed but not why; with two questions from the manager, the second draft is good.Not placed yet.Write the commentary. Drafts say what changed but not why; with two questions from the manager, the second draft is good.Can do alone: Mastered. Hand it over fully; coaching here teaches nothing new, and checking it costs both people time.Write the commentary. Drafts say what changed but not why; with two questions from the manager, the second draft is good.The zone: Done with help, not yet alone. Coach here: a worked example, a hint at the stuck point, a review, and less of each every time.Two questions get it there: the help is working. Ask fewer each month.Write the commentary. Drafts say what changed but not why; with two questions from the manager, the second draft is good.Out of reach: Not yet possible even with help. Hold it back until the tasks beneath it are done alone; for now, let the analyst watch it done.Reconcile to the ledger. Finds the differences when shown which accounts to check first.Not placed yet.Reconcile to the ledger. Finds the differences when shown which accounts to check first.Can do alone: Mastered. Hand it over fully; coaching here teaches nothing new, and checking it costs both people time.Reconcile to the ledger. Finds the differences when shown which accounts to check first.The zone: Done with help, not yet alone. Coach here: a worked example, a hint at the stuck point, a review, and less of each every time.Almost alone. Next time, ask the analyst to choose the accounts and explain why.Reconcile to the ledger. Finds the differences when shown which accounts to check first.Out of reach: Not yet possible even with help. Hold it back until the tasks beneath it are done alone; for now, let the analyst watch it done.Present to the CFO. Has not yet explained a variance aloud to anyone outside the team.Not placed yet.Present to the CFO. Has not yet explained a variance aloud to anyone outside the team.Can do alone: Mastered. Hand it over fully; coaching here teaches nothing new, and checking it costs both people time.Present to the CFO. Has not yet explained a variance aloud to anyone outside the team.The zone: Done with help, not yet alone. Coach here: a worked example, a hint at the stuck point, a review, and less of each every time.Present to the CFO. Has not yet explained a variance aloud to anyone outside the team.Out of reach: Not yet possible even with help. Hold it back until the tasks beneath it are done alone; for now, let the analyst watch it done.Too far for now. Have the analyst present to the team first, and sit in on a CFO review.Build three-year plan. Has not yet built a one-year forecast.Not placed yet.Build three-year plan. Has not yet built a one-year forecast.Can do alone: Mastered. Hand it over fully; coaching here teaches nothing new, and checking it costs both people time.Build three-year plan. Has not yet built a one-year forecast.The zone: Done with help, not yet alone. Coach here: a worked example, a hint at the stuck point, a review, and less of each every time.Build three-year plan. Has not yet built a one-year forecast.Out of reach: Not yet possible even with help. Hold it back until the tasks beneath it are done alone; for now, let the analyst watch it done.Out of reach until the one-year forecast is in the middle band.Explain a price effect. Gets it right when the manager draws the price and volume split on paper first.Not placed yet.Explain a price effect. Gets it right when the manager draws the price and volume split on paper first.Can do alone: Mastered. Hand it over fully; coaching here teaches nothing new, and checking it costs both people time.Explain a price effect. Gets it right when the manager draws the price and volume split on paper first.The zone: Done with help, not yet alone. Coach here: a worked example, a hint at the stuck point, a review, and less of each every time.The drawing is the scaffold. Next time, ask the analyst to draw it.Explain a price effect. Gets it right when the manager draws the price and volume split on paper first.Out of reach: Not yet possible even with help. Hold it back until the tasks beneath it are done alone; for now, let the analyst watch it done.
Your sort matched 0 of 8.Your sort matched 1 of 8.Your sort matched 2 of 8.Your sort matched 3 of 8.Your sort matched 4 of 8.Your sort matched 5 of 8.Your sort matched 6 of 8.Your sort matched 7 of 8.Your sort matched 8 of 8.
Can do alone
Mastered. Hand it over fully; coaching here teaches nothing new, and checking it costs both people time.
The zone
Done with help, not yet alone. Coach here: a worked example, a hint at the stuck point, a review, and less of each every time.
Out of reach
Not yet possible even with help. Hold it back until the tasks beneath it are done alone; for now, let the analyst watch it done.
The sort
Build the variance model: The zone. Done with help, not alone: coach here. Next time, a hint at the split and nothing else.
Pull monthly sales data: Can do alone. Mastered. Stop checking it.
Format the board pack: Can do alone. Done alone. Hand it over.
Write the commentary: The zone. Two questions get it there: the help is working. Ask fewer each month.
Reconcile to the ledger: The zone. Almost alone. Next time, ask the analyst to choose the accounts and explain why.
Present to the CFO: Out of reach. Too far for now. Have the analyst present to the team first, and sit in on a CFO review.
Build three-year plan: Out of reach. Out of reach until the one-year forecast is in the middle band.
Explain a price effect: The zone. The drawing is the scaffold. Next time, ask the analyst to draw it.
An example
A finance manager hired a graduate analyst and, by month two, had a problem in both directions. She was still checking the data pulls the analyst had done without error four times, and she had just watched him freeze in his first meeting with the chief financial officer.
She listed every task in his job and sorted each by what he could do alone, what he could do with her help, and what was out of reach even with help. The data pulls and the board-pack formatting went in the first band, and she stopped checking them. The variance model, the written commentary, and the ledger reconciliation went in the middle: he could do each with a hint or two. Presenting to the chief financial officer went in the third. She spent her coaching time on the middle band, cutting the hints each month, and had him present to the team first. By month five the variance model had moved to the first band, and the CFO meeting had moved to the middle.
Why it works
Teaching works at a particular distance from what a person can already do. A task the learner can do alone teaches nothing new, so coaching it is wasted time on both sides. A task too far beyond them teaches nothing either: help cannot bridge a gap that wide, and the learner copies without understanding. Between those sits a band of tasks the learner can do with a more capable person's help but not yet alone, and that is where help turns into skill.
The band moves. Each task learned with help becomes one done alone, which brings the next harder tasks within reach. The support itself is meant to be withdrawn: a hint that is still needed after the fifth time is no longer teaching. Sorting the work into the three bands tells a manager where to spend coaching time, and what to stop doing.
The thinking behind it
Lev Vygotsky Lev Vygotsky, a Soviet psychologist, founded the cultural historical approach to development. His zone of proximal development is the distance between a learner's independent performance and the level the same learner reaches with guidance from someone more capable. The idea appears in Thinking and Speech (1934; in English as Thought and Language, 1962) and in the translated writings collected as Mind in Society (1978).
David Wood David Wood, a developmental psychologist, studied how adults tutor young children with Jerome S. Bruner and Gail Ross in The Role of Tutoring in Problem Solving (Journal of Child Psychology and Psychiatry, 1976). The study brought the term scaffolding into the study of tutoring, for the support a tutor gives and then withdraws as the learner gains control of the task. Scaffolding is what a manager does inside the zone: support given in steps and taken away as the learner masters each one.
How to run it
List the tasks in the role. Every recurring piece of work, from the routine to the senior.
Watch each task done unaided. Judge by what the person does, not by what they say they can do.
Try the harder tasks with help. Give a hint or a worked example and note whether that is enough to get them there.
Sort the tasks into three bands. Alone, with help, and out of reach even with help.
Hand over the first band. Stop checking and stop coaching what is already mastered.
Coach inside the middle band. Use the smallest help that works (a question, a hint, a sketch) and less of it each time.
Re-sort every month. Move tasks across as they are mastered, and bring the next ones into reach.
Where it goes wrong
The support never comes off. A manager who keeps giving the same hint is doing the task through the learner, and the task never moves to the first band. Note what help was given each time and give less the next.
The stretch is too far. A new hire is handed the CFO presentation as a growth opportunity and fails in public, which teaches caution, not skill. If a task needs more than a few hints to get done, it belongs in the third band for now.
The bands get set by title or tenure. A senior hire is assumed to need no help with anything, or a junior one with everything. Sort by watching the work.
When to use something else
Cognitive Apprenticeship. When the skill is mostly thinking that cannot be watched, and the expert has to make the reasoning visible.
Deliberate Practice. When the person already does the task alone and the goal is to get much better at it through practice.
Bloom's Taxonomy. When the job is designing what a course or program should teach, from recall up to creating.