Calibrated Questions

Thinking Tools6.3 Implementing the Action Plan

Developed by Chris Voss (Never Split the Difference, with Tahl Raz, 2016).

Replaces yes-or-no and why questions with open how and what questions, which set the other side working on the problem with less defensiveness.

Four questions to a buyer who has cut the budget, asked closed and asked open

At each of the seller's turns, pick the question: a yes-or-no or why version, or the same question rebuilt to start with how or what. The director's answer shows, and the bar tracks how far she is working on the problem with him. Illustrative.

Seller

HR director

Seller

HR director

Select a stage to read it, or play the sequence.The cut. The proposal was $90,000 for a program for forty managers. The director calls back: "We have $55,000. Take it or leave it."First question. The seller needs to know what the $55,000 rests on. Pick the question.Pick a move to see the reply.Yes.Closed: a one-word answer, and now she has said final out loud.Last year's training spend for the main plant, more or less.Open: the number has an origin, and the origin is one plant.One plant's budget. A budget set from last year's spend at one site is a habit, not a ceiling.Second question. The seller cannot deliver the full program for $55,000. Pick how to tell her.Pick a move to see the reply.It probably can't. The second plant has a training line nobody has touched.A how: it puts the gap in front of her, and she finds the room herself.Because that's what we have. I don't set the budgets.A why: she defends herself instead of the problem.A second budget. The answer came from her, so she will defend it inside her company.Third question. The second plant's money has an owner. Pick the question.Pick a move to see the reply.I can ask. They'll probably say no.Closed: it asks her to promise something she cannot.That coaching won't pull supervisors off the floor in the busy season.Open: it names the real objection, and the objection can be designed around.The real objection. The block is timing, not money. Moving the coaching to the slow quarter answers it.Fourth question. The seller has a proposal in reach. Pick the question that moves it forward.Pick a move to see the reply.I take it to both plant managers on Thursday. Send me a version with the coaching in the slow quarter.Open: it maps the path to yes and who stands on it.Not today. I'd have to check.Closed: a yes is a commitment she cannot make alone, so no is safer.Two budgets. The program closes at $78,000, paid from two plants' budgets, with the coaching in the slow quarter.

Working on the problem0of 4

  1. The cut (HR director). The proposal was $90,000 for a program for forty managers. The director calls back: "We have $55,000. Take it or leave it."
  2. First question (Seller). The seller needs to know what the $55,000 rests on. Pick the question.
    • Is $55,000 your final number? Yes. Closed: a one-word answer, and now she has said final out loud.
    • What is the $55,000 built around? Last year's training spend for the main plant, more or less. Open: the number has an origin, and the origin is one plant.
  3. One plant's budget (HR director). A budget set from last year's spend at one site is a habit, not a ceiling.
  4. Second question (Seller). The seller cannot deliver the full program for $55,000. Pick how to tell her.
    • How is a program for forty managers supposed to fit in one plant's budget? It probably can't. The second plant has a training line nobody has touched. A how: it puts the gap in front of her, and she finds the room herself.
    • Why is the budget so low for a program this size? Because that's what we have. I don't set the budgets. A why: she defends herself instead of the problem.
  5. A second budget (HR director). The answer came from her, so she will defend it inside her company.
  6. Third question (Seller). The second plant's money has an owner. Pick the question.
    • Can you get the second plant to pay for half? I can ask. They'll probably say no. Closed: it asks her to promise something she cannot.
    • What would the plant managers need to see to put that money in? That coaching won't pull supervisors off the floor in the busy season. Open: it names the real objection, and the objection can be designed around.
  7. The real objection (HR director). The block is timing, not money. Moving the coaching to the slow quarter answers it.
  8. Fourth question (Seller). The seller has a proposal in reach. Pick the question that moves it forward.
    • What happens on your side between now and a signature? I take it to both plant managers on Thursday. Send me a version with the coaching in the slow quarter. Open: it maps the path to yes and who stands on it.
    • So can we agree on $78,000 today? Not today. I'd have to check. Closed: a yes is a commitment she cannot make alone, so no is safer.
  9. Two budgets (HR director). The program closes at $78,000, paid from two plants' budgets, with the coaching in the slow quarter.

An example

A training firm had proposed a $90,000 leadership program to a manufacturer's HR director. She called back with a number: $55,000, take it or leave it. The partner's first draft of a reply asked whether that was final and why the budget was so low.

He threw the draft out and called with open questions instead. What is the $55,000 built around? It was last year's training spend for the main plant. How is a program for forty managers supposed to fit inside one plant's budget? The director allowed that it couldn't, and that the second plant had its own line that nobody had touched. What would the plant managers need to see to put that money in? Proof that the coaching sessions would not pull supervisors off the floor during the busy season.

The program closed at $78,000 across both plants, with the coaching moved to the slow quarter and paid from two budgets.

Why it works

A closed question hands the other side a choice between yes and no, and under pressure no is the safe answer. A why question asks them to defend themselves, which makes them do exactly that. Neither moves the problem.

A how or what question cannot be answered with a word. To answer it the other side has to think about the problem from your position, and the act of describing a solution starts them owning it. "How am I supposed to do that?" is a refusal that does not sound like one: it puts the gap on the table and asks them to close it. Each answer also gives away information, such as what the number is built on, who else decides, and what they fear, that a yes or no never would.

The thinking behind it

Chris Voss Chris Voss, a former FBI hostage negotiator, sets out calibrated questions in Never Split the Difference (2016), written with the journalist Tahl Raz. They belong to the method he calls tactical empathy, beside labeling the other side's emotions and running an accusation audit of their likely objections: open questions that start with how or what, which hand the other side the problem and set them working on it. The book rests on his field experience, not controlled studies.

How to run it

  1. Strip out the closed questions. Find every question in your plan that can be answered yes or no, and every one that starts with why.
  2. Rebuild each with how or what. "Is that final?" becomes "what is that number built around?", and "can you do more?" becomes "how can we make this work?"
  3. Aim at their constraint. Ask about what limits them, such as the budget's origin, the approver, or the deadline, since the answer is where room appears.
  4. Keep a refusal question ready. "How am I supposed to do that?" says no to an impossible demand while keeping them in the problem.
  5. Ask, then stop talking. Let them think through the answer without offering one, because the solution counts for more when they find it.
  6. Ask how it gets done. Close with "what happens next on your side?", which finds the people who can still block the deal.

Where it goes wrong

The questions turn into a technique the other side can see. Three "how am I supposed to do that" lines in a row sound like stonewalling, and a counterpart who feels handled stops answering honestly. Vary the wording, and mean the question.

The tone can also undo the grammar. "What makes you think that's fair?" is a how-or-what question that lands as an attack. Ask from curiosity, and if a question would sound sarcastic out loud, rewrite it.

The last failure is never landing. Open questions gather information, but at some point someone has to put a number on the table. When the answers have shown you where the room is, make a specific proposal built on what you heard.

When to use something else

  • Tactical Empathy. When the other side is still angry or guarded and needs to feel heard before any question will land.
  • Interest-Based Bargaining. When both sides are ready to lay out their interests openly and build options together.
  • Socratic Method. When the aim is to test a belief's footing, not to win room in a deal.

Where it sits in SOLVE eX

Go to the source

  • Never Split the Difference: Negotiating As If Your Life Depended On It, HarperBusiness, chapter 7, 2016

Back to the catalog