Tactical Empathy

Thinking Tools6.3 Implementing the Action PlanAlso known as Labeling and Mirroring

Developed by Chris Voss from FBI hostage negotiation (Never Split the Difference, 2016).

Lowers a counterpart's defenses by naming their emotions, mirroring their last words, and asking open how and what questions, then uses the opening to surface their interests.

Four replies to an angry supplier, and what each one does to his guard

At each of the buyer's turns, pick a reply: a label, a mirror, or an open question against a counterargument. The supplier's answer shows, and the bar under it tracks how open he is. Illustrative.

Buyer

Supplier

Buyer

Supplier

Select a stage to read it, or play the sequence.The opening blast. The owner of the box plant opens the call: three late payments this year, and now a request for a price cut. Maybe they are done.First reply. He has just said: "Three late payments, and now you want a cut? Maybe we're done." Pick the buyer's reply.Pick a move to see the reply.Technically. Great. Go find another supplier.A counterargument: it tells him he is wrong, and his guard goes up.Taken for granted is exactly it. Seven years, and we get paid last.A label: it names the feeling, and he confirms it instead of fighting it.He vents. Once a label lands, people say more. Let him finish: the details he adds are what the deal will turn on.Second reply. He has said they get paid last. Pick the buyer's reply.Pick a move to see the reply.Last. My bank calls me before your payables team does. I carried your stock all spring.A mirror: two words back, and he explains what sits under the anger.So we're just everyone. Noted.An excuse: it shrinks his grievance and puts him back on guard.The real issue. His first problem is cash: slow payment is straining his credit line, and the bank is the one calling.Third reply. The buyer still needs a better price. Pick the reply.Pick a move to see the reply.Then we really are done here.A demand made before he feels heard: the talk stalls.Pay me in thirty days and I can live with a thinner margin.A calibrated question: a what or how question that asks him to solve it with her.His interest. An interest has surfaced: cash in thirty days matters more to him than the price. That is something the buyer can trade.Fourth reply. There is a deal in reach. Pick how to move toward it.Pick a move to see the reply.No, that's not a bad idea. Send it over.A question built for a no: he can refuse safely, so agreeing feels like his own call.I didn't say 8 percent. Don't put words in my mouth.A push for yes: he feels cornered and pulls back.Terms on paper. He has gone from threatening to leave to reviewing terms. The labels, mirrors, and questions cost the buyer no concession.

How open he is0of 4

  1. The opening blast (Supplier). The owner of the box plant opens the call: three late payments this year, and now a request for a price cut. Maybe they are done.
  2. First reply (Buyer). He has just said: "Three late payments, and now you want a cut? Maybe we're done." Pick the buyer's reply.
    • Our terms are net 60, so technically we were never late. Technically. Great. Go find another supplier. A counterargument: it tells him he is wrong, and his guard goes up.
    • It sounds like you feel we've been taking you for granted. Taken for granted is exactly it. Seven years, and we get paid last. A label: it names the feeling, and he confirms it instead of fighting it.
  3. He vents (Supplier). Once a label lands, people say more. Let him finish: the details he adds are what the deal will turn on.
  4. Second reply (Buyer). He has said they get paid last. Pick the buyer's reply.
    • Paid last? Last. My bank calls me before your payables team does. I carried your stock all spring. A mirror: two words back, and he explains what sits under the anger.
    • Everyone is paying slowly right now. It's the market. So we're just everyone. Noted. An excuse: it shrinks his grievance and puts him back on guard.
  5. The real issue (Supplier). His first problem is cash: slow payment is straining his credit line, and the bank is the one calling.
  6. Third reply (Buyer). The buyer still needs a better price. Pick the reply.
    • We still need 8 percent off to stay competitive. Then we really are done here. A demand made before he feels heard: the talk stalls.
    • What would it take for this account to work for you again? Pay me in thirty days and I can live with a thinner margin. A calibrated question: a what or how question that asks him to solve it with her.
  7. His interest (Supplier). An interest has surfaced: cash in thirty days matters more to him than the price. That is something the buyer can trade.
  8. Fourth reply (Buyer). There is a deal in reach. Pick how to move toward it.
    • Would it be a bad idea to put net 30 and a smaller cut in writing this week? No, that's not a bad idea. Send it over. A question built for a no: he can refuse safely, so agreeing feels like his own call.
    • Great, so we're agreed: 8 percent off and net 30? I didn't say 8 percent. Don't put words in my mouth. A push for yes: he feels cornered and pulls back.
  9. Terms on paper (Supplier). He has gone from threatening to leave to reviewing terms. The labels, mirrors, and questions cost the buyer no concession.

An example

A buyer at a regional hardware distributor called the owner of a family box plant to open the annual price talk. The owner cut her off in the first minute: three late payments this year, and now a request for a cut, so maybe they were done. Her first instinct was to point out that the contract allowed sixty days.

She said instead that it sounded like he felt the distributor had been taking him for granted. He said that was exactly it, and that after seven years his plant got paid last. She repeated "paid last?" and he told her the rest: his bank was calling about his credit line, and he had carried the distributor's stock through the spring. She asked what it would take for the account to work for him again. Payment in thirty days, he said, and he could live with a thinner margin. They signed a renewal with net 30 terms and a 5 percent cut, and the distributor's finance team moved the plant to the front of its payment run.

Why it works

Someone who feels attacked argues with whatever is said to them, so facts offered to an angry counterpart get treated as more attack. A label names the feeling without agreeing or disagreeing with it, and the natural reply is to confirm or correct it, which means talking about the real grievance. A mirror does the same with fewer words: hearing their own phrase back, people expand on it.

Calibrated questions finish the move. A what or how question has no yes or no answer and cannot be refused as a demand, so the counterpart has to describe what would work, and in describing it they reveal the interest behind the position. The buyer learned that cash timing was worth margin to the supplier, a trade that no argument about the contract would have surfaced.

The thinking behind it

Chris Voss Chris Voss, a former FBI hostage negotiator, set out tactical empathy in Never Split the Difference (2016), written with the journalist Tahl Raz. The book builds a method of negotiation on tactical empathy, drawn from his years in hostage negotiation: labeling the other side's emotions, running an accusation audit of the objections they are likely to raise, and asking calibrated how and what questions that hand them the problem to solve. It rests on his field experience, and the techniques are a practitioner's account without controlled studies behind them.

How to run it

  1. Listen for the emotion first. Before answering any claim, decide what the counterpart is feeling: slighted, anxious, cornered, or tired.
  2. Label it out loud. Say "it sounds like" or "it seems like" and name the feeling, then stop talking and let them answer.
  3. Mirror the key words. Repeat the last one to three words that carried weight, as a question, and wait.
  4. Ask calibrated questions. Use how and what questions, such as "what would it take for this to work for you?", and skip why, which sounds like an accusation.
  5. Invite a safe no. Frame a proposal so that no is the easy answer, which lets the counterpart feel in control of agreeing.
  6. Trade on the interest that surfaces. Once a need appears, such as cash timing or certainty, offer something against it and ask for what the deal needs in return.

Where it goes wrong

Labels used as a script backfire. A counterpart who hears "it sounds like you're frustrated" three times in five minutes knows a technique is being run on them, and trust drops faster than if nothing had been said. Use a label when a feeling is plainly in the room, and vary the words.

Empathy also gets mistaken for agreement. Naming his frustration commits the buyer to nothing, and she still needs a price; a negotiator who starts conceding to keep the warmth has given ground for free. Keep the label and the concession apart.

The last failure is skipping to interests too soon. If the counterpart is still venting, a clever question lands as a dodge. Wait until the heat has dropped, which usually shows as longer, calmer answers.

When to use something else

  • Accusation Audit. When the objections are predictable before the call and naming them first, all at once, will take the sting out of them.
  • Interest-Based Bargaining. When both sides are calm and willing to lay out interests openly, so the work is building options together.
  • Nonviolent Communication. When the conflict is between colleagues, with no deal to win, and each needs to state plainly what they need and what they are asking for.

Where it sits in SOLVE eX

Go to the source

  • Never Split the Difference, with Tahl Raz, 2016

Back to the catalog