Status Work

Thinking Tools6.3 Implementing the Action PlanAlso known as Status Games

Developed by Keith Johnstone (Impro: Improvisation and the Theatre, 1979).

Improvisation exercises in which people play high and low status on purpose, showing how every gesture and pause shifts power in an exchange.

Eight moves from one request to a senior colleague, sorted by the status each one plays

A project manager asks a vice president to move a launch date. Every gesture and phrase raises or lowers her status in the exchange, through her body and voice or through her words. One move is placed as an example. Select each other move, then the box it belongs in, and show the sort to compare. Illustrative.

Items (select one, then a box)
  • Not placedPlacedLow, in the bodyHigh, in the bodyLow, in the wordsHigh, in the words
  • Not placedPlacedLow, in the bodyHigh, in the bodyLow, in the wordsHigh, in the words
  • Not placedPlacedLow, in the bodyHigh, in the bodyLow, in the wordsHigh, in the words
  • Not placedPlacedLow, in the bodyHigh, in the bodyLow, in the wordsHigh, in the words
  • Not placedPlacedLow, in the bodyHigh, in the bodyLow, in the wordsHigh, in the words
  • Not placedPlacedLow, in the bodyHigh, in the bodyLow, in the wordsHigh, in the words
  • Not placedPlacedLow, in the bodyHigh, in the bodyLow, in the wordsHigh, in the words
  • Not placedPlacedLow, in the bodyHigh, in the bodyLow, in the wordsHigh, in the words

Where it shows

WordsBody and voice
Low, in the words
High, in the words
Low, in the body
High, in the body
Lowers itRaises it

What the move does to her status

Opens with sorry. "Sorry, quick one, if you have a sec?"Not placed yet.Opens with sorry. "Sorry, quick one, if you have a sec?"Low, in the body: Small, busy, self-soothing movements. They invite the other person to take charge: useful to put someone at ease, costly in a firm ask.Opens with sorry. "Sorry, quick one, if you have a sec?"High, in the body: Stillness and unhurried pauses. They claim the space without a word; overdone, they read as cold.Opens with sorry. "Sorry, quick one, if you have a sec?"Low, in the words: Apologies, hedges, and permission-seeking. They make the request easy to refuse.An apology before the ask tells him the ask is small and his time is bigger. He relaxes into the senior role and the request starts at a discount.Opens with sorry. "Sorry, quick one, if you have a sec?"High, in the words: Plain statements, said once. They make the request hard to wave away; with no warmth, they invite a contest.Touches her face. She touches her face and hair while she makes the ask.Not placed yet.Touches her face. She touches her face and hair while she makes the ask.Low, in the body: Small, busy, self-soothing movements. They invite the other person to take charge: useful to put someone at ease, costly in a firm ask.A self-soothing gesture reads as nerves, and he answers it by taking control of the conversation.Touches her face. She touches her face and hair while she makes the ask.High, in the body: Stillness and unhurried pauses. They claim the space without a word; overdone, they read as cold.Touches her face. She touches her face and hair while she makes the ask.Low, in the words: Apologies, hedges, and permission-seeking. They make the request easy to refuse.Touches her face. She touches her face and hair while she makes the ask.High, in the words: Plain statements, said once. They make the request hard to wave away; with no warmth, they invite a contest.Keeps her head still. Her head stays still while she speaks.Not placed yet.Keeps her head still. Her head stays still while she speaks.Low, in the body: Small, busy, self-soothing movements. They invite the other person to take charge: useful to put someone at ease, costly in a firm ask.Keeps her head still. Her head stays still while she speaks.High, in the body: Stillness and unhurried pauses. They claim the space without a word; overdone, they read as cold.Stillness while talking signals she expects to be listened to. He stops checking his phone.Keeps her head still. Her head stays still while she speaks.Low, in the words: Apologies, hedges, and permission-seeking. They make the request easy to refuse.Keeps her head still. Her head stays still while she speaks.High, in the words: Plain statements, said once. They make the request hard to wave away; with no warmth, they invite a contest.Says the date, stops. "I need the launch on the 28th." Then nothing more.Not placed yet.Says the date, stops. "I need the launch on the 28th." Then nothing more.Low, in the body: Small, busy, self-soothing movements. They invite the other person to take charge: useful to put someone at ease, costly in a firm ask.Says the date, stops. "I need the launch on the 28th." Then nothing more.High, in the body: Stillness and unhurried pauses. They claim the space without a word; overdone, they read as cold.Says the date, stops. "I need the launch on the 28th." Then nothing more.Low, in the words: Apologies, hedges, and permission-seeking. They make the request easy to refuse.Says the date, stops. "I need the launch on the 28th." Then nothing more.High, in the words: Plain statements, said once. They make the request hard to wave away; with no warmth, they invite a contest.A plain statement with no padding claims the topic. He has to answer it.Ends on if that's okay. "...so the 28th, if that's okay with you?"Not placed yet.Ends on if that's okay. "...so the 28th, if that's okay with you?"Low, in the body: Small, busy, self-soothing movements. They invite the other person to take charge: useful to put someone at ease, costly in a firm ask.Ends on if that's okay. "...so the 28th, if that's okay with you?"High, in the body: Stillness and unhurried pauses. They claim the space without a word; overdone, they read as cold.Ends on if that's okay. "...so the 28th, if that's okay with you?"Low, in the words: Apologies, hedges, and permission-seeking. They make the request easy to refuse.A question tag hands him the decision and invites the no.Ends on if that's okay. "...so the 28th, if that's okay with you?"High, in the words: Plain statements, said once. They make the request hard to wave away; with no warmth, they invite a contest.Lets the silence sit. After the ask, she waits and does not fill the pause.Not placed yet.Lets the silence sit. After the ask, she waits and does not fill the pause.Low, in the body: Small, busy, self-soothing movements. They invite the other person to take charge: useful to put someone at ease, costly in a firm ask.Lets the silence sit. After the ask, she waits and does not fill the pause.High, in the body: Stillness and unhurried pauses. They claim the space without a word; overdone, they read as cold.Holding a silence raises her: the next move is his, and he feels it.Lets the silence sit. After the ask, she waits and does not fill the pause.Low, in the words: Apologies, hedges, and permission-seeking. They make the request easy to refuse.Lets the silence sit. After the ask, she waits and does not fill the pause.High, in the words: Plain statements, said once. They make the request hard to wave away; with no warmth, they invite a contest.Laughs after her point. She laughs lightly after saying the date.Not placed yet.Laughs after her point. She laughs lightly after saying the date.Low, in the body: Small, busy, self-soothing movements. They invite the other person to take charge: useful to put someone at ease, costly in a firm ask.The laugh takes the edge off the request, and with it the weight.Laughs after her point. She laughs lightly after saying the date.High, in the body: Stillness and unhurried pauses. They claim the space without a word; overdone, they read as cold.Laughs after her point. She laughs lightly after saying the date.Low, in the words: Apologies, hedges, and permission-seeking. They make the request easy to refuse.Laughs after her point. She laughs lightly after saying the date.High, in the words: Plain statements, said once. They make the request hard to wave away; with no warmth, they invite a contest.Gives the reason once. "Two vendors slipped. The 28th is the earliest clean date."Not placed yet.Gives the reason once. "Two vendors slipped. The 28th is the earliest clean date."Low, in the body: Small, busy, self-soothing movements. They invite the other person to take charge: useful to put someone at ease, costly in a firm ask.Gives the reason once. "Two vendors slipped. The 28th is the earliest clean date."High, in the body: Stillness and unhurried pauses. They claim the space without a word; overdone, they read as cold.Gives the reason once. "Two vendors slipped. The 28th is the earliest clean date."Low, in the words: Apologies, hedges, and permission-seeking. They make the request easy to refuse.Gives the reason once. "Two vendors slipped. The 28th is the earliest clean date."High, in the words: Plain statements, said once. They make the request hard to wave away; with no warmth, they invite a contest.One reason, stated and not repeated, raises her. Repeating it would sound like pleading.

Your sort matched 0 of 8.Your sort matched 1 of 8.Your sort matched 2 of 8.Your sort matched 3 of 8.Your sort matched 4 of 8.Your sort matched 5 of 8.Your sort matched 6 of 8.Your sort matched 7 of 8.Your sort matched 8 of 8.

Low, in the body
Small, busy, self-soothing movements. They invite the other person to take charge: useful to put someone at ease, costly in a firm ask.
High, in the body
Stillness and unhurried pauses. They claim the space without a word; overdone, they read as cold.
Low, in the words
Apologies, hedges, and permission-seeking. They make the request easy to refuse.
High, in the words
Plain statements, said once. They make the request hard to wave away; with no warmth, they invite a contest.

The sort

  • Opens with sorry: Low, in the words. An apology before the ask tells him the ask is small and his time is bigger. He relaxes into the senior role and the request starts at a discount.
  • Touches her face: Low, in the body. A self-soothing gesture reads as nerves, and he answers it by taking control of the conversation.
  • Keeps her head still: High, in the body. Stillness while talking signals she expects to be listened to. He stops checking his phone.
  • Says the date, stops: High, in the words. A plain statement with no padding claims the topic. He has to answer it.
  • Ends on if that's okay: Low, in the words. A question tag hands him the decision and invites the no.
  • Lets the silence sit: High, in the body. Holding a silence raises her: the next move is his, and he feels it.
  • Laughs after her point: Low, in the body. The laugh takes the edge off the request, and with it the weight.
  • Gives the reason once: High, in the words. One reason, stated and not repeated, raises her. Repeating it would sound like pleading.

An example

A project manager at a medical device company kept losing small negotiations with one vice president. She was senior enough and usually right, and still her requests ended with her agreeing to his version. A leadership workshop ran status exercises: walk the room playing high, then low; play a scene where both players fight to be lower. Watching a recording of a practice conversation, she saw her own pattern. She opened every ask with an apology, touched her face while she talked, laughed after stating a date, and filled every silence.

The next time she needed a launch moved, she practiced the opposite. She kept her head still, said the date and one reason (two vendors had slipped), and then waited without filling the pause. He asked two questions and agreed to the 28th.

She also noticed the reverse in her own team meetings, where she played so high that nobody raised problems. There, she started asking her questions sitting down, after everyone else had spoken.

Why it works

Status in this sense is something people do, apart from their rank, moment to moment, with posture, eye movement, pauses, and phrasing, and every exchange is a sequence of small raises and lowerings. Most people have a habitual setting they are unaware of, and they use it whether or not it serves the situation.

The exercises make the habit visible by having people play each extreme on purpose. Once a person can feel the difference between holding a pause and filling it, status becomes a choice. Playing high everywhere is no goal. A low move puts a nervous customer at ease or invites a junior to speak; a high move makes a firm request hard to wave away. The skill is reading which one the moment needs, and noticing when no choice is being made at all.

The thinking behind it

Keith Johnstone Keith Johnstone, an English theater teacher and director who later worked in Calgary, set out status work in Impro: Improvisation and the Theatre (1979), a book that shaped modern improvisation. In his account every interaction plays out as small raises and lowerings of status, and he taught actors to play those shifts on purpose. The same book teaches accepting an offer instead of blocking it, and he also created Theatresports. Its use in management training is an adaptation of a theater method.

How to run it

  1. Walk the room high, then low. Have people move around a room playing high status, then low, and say what they felt change.
  2. Play scenes at matched status. Pair people to play a short scene where both play high, then both play low.
  3. Play the see-saw. Run a scene where one player rises as the other falls, so the trade becomes visible.
  4. Record a real exchange. Film a practice version of a real conversation and list each move that raised or lowered the speaker.
  5. Find the habit. Name each person's default setting and the two or three moves that carry it.
  6. Practice the switch. Choose the status the next real conversation needs, and rehearse the two or three moves that play it.

Where it goes wrong

People learn that high is good. Played everywhere, high status makes a manager unapproachable and turns every request into a contest. A manager whose team has stopped bringing problems can play lower in the meetings where those problems need to be heard.

The moves become a costume. Stillness and pauses copied without attention look rehearsed, and the other person reads the performance. Practice until the move is comfortable, and use it only where it fits.

The exercises stay in the workshop. A group that enjoys the games and never looks at a recording of their own real conversations has had a good afternoon and learned little. Tie each session to an exchange people will actually have that week.

When to use something else

  • Yes, And. When the problem is ideas getting blocked in a group, not power in a two-person exchange.
  • DEAR MAN. When the issue is the content and order of a request, and the delivery is already steady.
  • Trust Equation. When the question is whether a client or colleague trusts the person at all, built over many meetings, more than how one exchange plays.

Where it sits in SOLVE eX

Go to the source

  • Impro: Improvisation and the Theatre, 1979

Back to the catalog