Aristotelian Rhetoric

Thinking Tools6.3 Implementing the Action PlanAlso known as Ethos, pathos, and logos, Stasis theory

From Aristotle (Rhetoric, 4th century BCE), with the stasis theory of Hermagoras of Temnos (2nd century BCE) and the five canons of Cicero and the Rhetorica ad Herennium (1st century BCE).

Checks a persuasive message on three appeals (credibility, feeling, and argument), names which kind of speech the audience needs, and settles the earlier point of dispute first.

Four objections from a skeptical board, and the appeal each one calls for

A request for $4.2M to replace the plants' scheduling system. At each of the presenter's turns, pick the answer: one settles the earlier dispute or supplies the appeal the objection is really about (credibility, feeling, or argument), and the other misses it. The bar tracks the board's support. Illustrative.

Operations head

Board

Operations head

Board

Select a stage to read it, or play the sequence.Is it even scheduling? A director opens: last year's late orders were blamed on the freight carrier. The board has not yet agreed what happened, so any talk of a new system starts in the wrong place.Answer the fact. The dispute is still about the facts. Pick the answer.Pick a move to see the reply.That assumes scheduling is what is broken. I am not convinced it is.Argues what to do before the board agrees what happened: the payback lands on no one.So most of it is ours. All right, that changes the question.Settles the fact first: now the board can argue about what to do.Can we trust this team? The audit chair raises the last systems project from operations, which ran a year late. The objection is about the speaker, so more numbers will not answer it.Answer the doubt. The question is whether to trust the person asking. Pick the answer.Pick a move to see the reply.It was the same department, and it is the same request.A deflection: it costs credibility, the appeal the objection was about.Phased, with a gate. That I can support.Credibility: owns the past, shows what was learned, and puts a check in the board's hands.Why half? The finance chair asks where the assumption comes from. This is a question about the argument itself: claim, evidence, and the step between them.Answer the numbers. The objection tests the reasoning. Pick the answer.Pick a move to see the reply.Vendors always say that. What did we see?A claim borrowed from the seller: the argument still has no evidence of its own.Our own data, and a cautious reading of it. Fine.Argument: the board's own evidence, and a margin it can see.Why this year? A director accepts the case and still asks why it cannot wait a year. The board agrees with the argument but does not yet feel the cost of waiting.Answer the stakes. The board has the logic and lacks a reason to act now. Pick the answer.Pick a move to see the reply.Nine percent of an estimate. We can live with that.More argument where the board needed a reason to care: the decision drifts.Two hundred jobs at the north plant ride on that account. Fund the first plant.Feeling: a concrete stake the board can picture, resting on the argument already made.The vote. With the facts settled, the speaker trusted, the numbers shown, and the stakes felt, the board funds the first plant and makes the next three depend on its date.

Answers that met the objection: 0 of 4Answers that met the objection: 1 of 4Answers that met the objection: 2 of 4Answers that met the objection: 3 of 4Answers that met the objection: 4 of 4

Support0of 4

  1. Is it even scheduling? (Board). A director opens: last year's late orders were blamed on the freight carrier. The board has not yet agreed what happened, so any talk of a new system starts in the wrong place.
  2. Answer the fact (Operations head). The dispute is still about the facts. Pick the answer.
    • The new system pays for itself in 26 months. That assumes scheduling is what is broken. I am not convinced it is. Argues what to do before the board agrees what happened: the payback lands on no one.
    • Of last year's 212 late orders, 151 left our dock late, before a truck touched them. So most of it is ours. All right, that changes the question. Settles the fact first: now the board can argue about what to do.
  3. Can we trust this team? (Board). The audit chair raises the last systems project from operations, which ran a year late. The objection is about the speaker, so more numbers will not answer it.
  4. Answer the doubt (Operations head). The question is whether to trust the person asking. Pick the answer.
    • That was a different vendor and a different team. It was the same department, and it is the same request. A deflection: it costs credibility, the appeal the objection was about.
    • That rollout was mine: four plants at once. This plan starts with one, and gates the rest. Phased, with a gate. That I can support. Credibility: owns the past, shows what was learned, and puts a check in the board's hands.
  5. Why half? (Board). The finance chair asks where the assumption comes from. This is a question about the argument itself: claim, evidence, and the step between them.
  6. Answer the numbers (Operations head). The objection tests the reasoning. Pick the answer.
    • The vendor's other customers cut late orders dramatically. Vendors always say that. What did we see? A claim borrowed from the seller: the argument still has no evidence of its own.
    • Our pilot cell went from 18 late orders a month to 7 in eight weeks. We assumed half. Our own data, and a cautious reading of it. Fine. Argument: the board's own evidence, and a margin it can see.
  7. Why this year? (Board). A director accepts the case and still asks why it cannot wait a year. The board agrees with the argument but does not yet feel the cost of waiting.
  8. Answer the stakes (Operations head). The board has the logic and lacks a reason to act now. Pick the answer.
    • Waiting a year lowers the return by about 9 percent. Nine percent of an estimate. We can live with that. More argument where the board needed a reason to care: the decision drifts.
    • Our largest customer wrote Monday: one more late quarter and we are on probation. Two hundred jobs at the north plant ride on that account. Fund the first plant. Feeling: a concrete stake the board can picture, resting on the argument already made.
  9. The vote (Board). With the facts settled, the speaker trusted, the numbers shown, and the stakes felt, the board funds the first plant and makes the next three depend on its date.

An example

The head of operations at a mid-sized parts maker had a $4.2 million request for new scheduling software and a board that had said no once. Her first draft was forty slides of payback math. A week out, she ran it past the three appeals and found the draft lopsided: strong on argument, silent on why the board should trust her team after a late rollout in 2021, and silent on what waiting would cost anyone.

She also asked where the board actually disagreed. The answer was a step earlier than her deck: several directors still believed the late orders were the freight carrier's fault. She rebuilt the talk in that order. It opened with the plant's own records on where late orders started, then her account of the 2021 overrun and the phased plan that answered it, then the pilot cell's numbers, then the customer letter that put a date on the risk. The board funded the first plant and tied the other three to its go-live date.

Why it works

An audience weighs three things at once: whether to believe the speaker, whether the matter is worth caring about, and whether the case holds together. A message that is strong on one cannot make up for a missing second, because each answers a different doubt. Experts tend to pour everything into argument, and an argument from someone the room does not trust is heard as salesmanship.

The stasis questions add an order. A dispute sits at one point: whether something happened, what kind of thing it is, how serious it is, or who should decide. Arguing seriousness to a room still unsure of the facts wastes every slide. Finding where the disagreement sits, and starting there, means each appeal lands on a question the audience is actually asking.

The thinking behind it

Aristotle In the Rhetoric, written in the fourth century BCE, Aristotle set out the three means of persuasion that a speaker controls: the character the speech shows, the emotions it stirs in the audience, and the argument itself. Each answers a different doubt in the listener, which is why a case strong on one can still fail on another. In the Nicomachean Ethics he listed the circumstances of an act (who, what, where, when, why, and how) to judge whether it was voluntary, a list later teachers of rhetoric carried into the questions that locate a dispute.

Hermagoras of Temnos Hermagoras of Temnos, a Greek teacher of rhetoric in the second century BCE, systematized stasis theory: the questions that locate the point at issue in a case. Did it happen? What was it? How serious was it? Should this court hear it at all? He paired them with the seven circumstances of an act: who, what, when, where, why, in what way, and by what means. His handbooks are lost; the system survives through Cicero, Quintilian, and later Latin handbooks.

How to run it

  1. Name the audience and the change sought. Write who must be moved and what they should believe or do at the end, in one sentence.
  2. Decide which kind of talk it is. Settling blame for the past, deciding the future, and honoring the present each need a different opening.
  3. Find the point at issue. Ask a skeptic where the disagreement sits (fact, definition, seriousness, or who decides) and start at the earliest one still open.
  4. Rate the three appeals. Score credibility, feeling, and argument from one to five for this audience, honestly, before writing another slide.
  5. Strengthen the weakest. Add the track record, the concrete stake, or the evidence that the lowest score is missing, in that appeal's own terms.
  6. Rehearse against the likely objections. For each objection, name the appeal it is really about and prepare the answer in that appeal.
  7. Review which appeal failed. After delivery, trace the hardest pushback to the appeal or the stasis point it came from.

Where it goes wrong

The common failure is answering every objection with more argument. A director who asks whether the team can be trusted wants an answer about people, and another chart misses it. When replies keep citing data to questions about people, the weak appeal is credibility, and the fix is to own the record.

Feeling is also easy to overdo. An emotional story laid over a thin case reads as manipulation once someone checks the numbers, and the speaker's credibility pays for it. The story should come after the argument and rest on it.

The third slip is skipping a stasis. If the questions in the room keep circling back to whether the problem is real, the talk started too late in the dispute. Go back, settle the facts, and only then argue the plan.

When to use something else

  • Toulmin Model. When the weak point is the argument itself and each claim, its evidence, and the step that links them need testing one by one.
  • Pyramid Principle. When the content is settled and the task is ordering a written recommendation so the answer comes first.
  • Cialdini's Principles of Influence. When the audience owes the proposal nothing and the question is which honest levers of agreement the situation offers.

Where it sits in SOLVE eX

Go to the source

  • Rhetoric, 4th century BCE
  • Stasis theory, 2nd century BCE
  • De Inventione; Rhetorica ad Herennium, 1st century BCE

Back to the catalog