Thinking Tools6.3 Implementing the Action PlanAlso known as Kairos Timing Discernment, Kairos and chronos
From classical Greek rhetoric, where the sophists taught kairos as the opportune moment, revived by John E. Smith (1969) and James L. Kinneavy (1986).
Separates the calendar signal (the schedule says act) from the moment signal (conditions, the counterparty, and the actor are ready) and forces a deliberate choice when they disagree.
Eight timing calls sorted by what the calendar says and whether the moment is ready
Each call gets two separate readings: the date the schedule gives, and whether conditions, the other party, and the leader are ready. The first is placed as an example; place the rest, and the two boxes where the signals disagree say which cost to weigh. Illustrative.
Items (select one, then a box)
Not placedPlacedActWaitWeigh the deadlineWeigh the opening
Not placedPlacedActWaitWeigh the deadlineWeigh the opening
Not placedPlacedActWaitWeigh the deadlineWeigh the opening
Not placedPlacedActWaitWeigh the deadlineWeigh the opening
Not placedPlacedActWaitWeigh the deadlineWeigh the opening
Not placedPlacedActWaitWeigh the deadlineWeigh the opening
Not placedPlacedActWaitWeigh the deadlineWeigh the opening
Not placedPlacedActWaitWeigh the deadlineWeigh the opening
Whether the moment is ready
ReadyNot ready
Weigh the opening
Act
Wait
Weigh the deadline
Not yetAct now
What the calendar says
Announce the reorg. The plan says Monday. The largest renewal closes in nine days, and one team's head is on leave.Not placed yet.Announce the reorg. The plan says Monday. The largest renewal closes in nine days, and one team's head is on leave.Act: Both signals say go. Act, and move on.Announce the reorg. The plan says Monday. The largest renewal closes in nine days, and one team's head is on leave.Wait: Neither signal calls for it. Leave it, and set a date to look again.Announce the reorg. The plan says Monday. The largest renewal closes in nine days, and one team's head is on leave.Weigh the deadline: The calendar pushes and the moment resists. Ask what moving the date really costs; a date you set yourself usually costs less to move than acting into a bad moment.The date was set in a planning meeting; the renewal and the absent leader are real. Move it a week and tell the board why.Announce the reorg. The plan says Monday. The largest renewal closes in nine days, and one team's head is on leave.Weigh the opening: The moment has arrived before the schedule. Ask whether it will still be open when the date comes; if not, act now and say why.Hire rival's engineer. No opening is budgeted until next year. She was passed over for promotion last week.Not placed yet.Hire rival's engineer. No opening is budgeted until next year. She was passed over for promotion last week.Act: Both signals say go. Act, and move on.Hire rival's engineer. No opening is budgeted until next year. She was passed over for promotion last week.Wait: Neither signal calls for it. Leave it, and set a date to look again.Hire rival's engineer. No opening is budgeted until next year. She was passed over for promotion last week.Weigh the deadline: The calendar pushes and the moment resists. Ask what moving the date really costs; a date you set yourself usually costs less to move than acting into a bad moment.Hire rival's engineer. No opening is budgeted until next year. She was passed over for promotion last week.Weigh the opening: The moment has arrived before the schedule. Ask whether it will still be open when the date comes; if not, act now and say why.She is open to a call now and may not be in six months. Make the offer and find the budget.Renew the office lease. The lease ends this month. The landlord has offered the same terms.Not placed yet.Renew the office lease. The lease ends this month. The landlord has offered the same terms.Act: Both signals say go. Act, and move on.A fixed date and a willing landlord: sign it.Renew the office lease. The lease ends this month. The landlord has offered the same terms.Wait: Neither signal calls for it. Leave it, and set a date to look again.Renew the office lease. The lease ends this month. The landlord has offered the same terms.Weigh the deadline: The calendar pushes and the moment resists. Ask what moving the date really costs; a date you set yourself usually costs less to move than acting into a bad moment.Renew the office lease. The lease ends this month. The landlord has offered the same terms.Weigh the opening: The moment has arrived before the schedule. Ask whether it will still be open when the date comes; if not, act now and say why.Merge the tool budgets. No date is set. The two team leads are still arguing over last quarter's overrun.Not placed yet.Merge the tool budgets. No date is set. The two team leads are still arguing over last quarter's overrun.Act: Both signals say go. Act, and move on.Merge the tool budgets. No date is set. The two team leads are still arguing over last quarter's overrun.Wait: Neither signal calls for it. Leave it, and set a date to look again.No deadline and no goodwill. Park it until the overrun is settled.Merge the tool budgets. No date is set. The two team leads are still arguing over last quarter's overrun.Weigh the deadline: The calendar pushes and the moment resists. Ask what moving the date really costs; a date you set yourself usually costs less to move than acting into a bad moment.Merge the tool budgets. No date is set. The two team leads are still arguing over last quarter's overrun.Weigh the opening: The moment has arrived before the schedule. Ask whether it will still be open when the date comes; if not, act now and say why.Raise list prices Jan 1. The pricing calendar says January. The main competitor cut its prices last week.Not placed yet.Raise list prices Jan 1. The pricing calendar says January. The main competitor cut its prices last week.Act: Both signals say go. Act, and move on.Raise list prices Jan 1. The pricing calendar says January. The main competitor cut its prices last week.Wait: Neither signal calls for it. Leave it, and set a date to look again.Raise list prices Jan 1. The pricing calendar says January. The main competitor cut its prices last week.Weigh the deadline: The calendar pushes and the moment resists. Ask what moving the date really costs; a date you set yourself usually costs less to move than acting into a bad moment.A date the team chose, against a market that just moved. Weigh a quarter's delay against a lost deal or two.Raise list prices Jan 1. The pricing calendar says January. The main competitor cut its prices last week.Weigh the opening: The moment has arrived before the schedule. Ask whether it will still be open when the date comes; if not, act now and say why.Name the missed handoffs. The quarterly review is six weeks away. The peer raised the problem himself this morning.Not placed yet.Name the missed handoffs. The quarterly review is six weeks away. The peer raised the problem himself this morning.Act: Both signals say go. Act, and move on.Name the missed handoffs. The quarterly review is six weeks away. The peer raised the problem himself this morning.Wait: Neither signal calls for it. Leave it, and set a date to look again.Name the missed handoffs. The quarterly review is six weeks away. The peer raised the problem himself this morning.Weigh the deadline: The calendar pushes and the moment resists. Ask what moving the date really costs; a date you set yourself usually costs less to move than acting into a bad moment.Name the missed handoffs. The quarterly review is six weeks away. The peer raised the problem himself this morning.Weigh the opening: The moment has arrived before the schedule. Ask whether it will still be open when the date comes; if not, act now and say why.He opened the door today. Have the talk this week; in six weeks it is a grievance.File compliance report. The regulator's deadline is Friday. The numbers are closed.Not placed yet.File compliance report. The regulator's deadline is Friday. The numbers are closed.Act: Both signals say go. Act, and move on.Someone outside enforces the date, and the work is ready. File it.File compliance report. The regulator's deadline is Friday. The numbers are closed.Wait: Neither signal calls for it. Leave it, and set a date to look again.File compliance report. The regulator's deadline is Friday. The numbers are closed.Weigh the deadline: The calendar pushes and the moment resists. Ask what moving the date really costs; a date you set yourself usually costs less to move than acting into a bad moment.File compliance report. The regulator's deadline is Friday. The numbers are closed.Weigh the opening: The moment has arrived before the schedule. Ask whether it will still be open when the date comes; if not, act now and say why.Give the hard review. The annual review is next month. The manager is dealing with a family emergency this week.Not placed yet.Give the hard review. The annual review is next month. The manager is dealing with a family emergency this week.Act: Both signals say go. Act, and move on.Give the hard review. The annual review is next month. The manager is dealing with a family emergency this week.Wait: Neither signal calls for it. Leave it, and set a date to look again.Nothing forces it, and he cannot hear it now. Hold to the review date.Give the hard review. The annual review is next month. The manager is dealing with a family emergency this week.Weigh the deadline: The calendar pushes and the moment resists. Ask what moving the date really costs; a date you set yourself usually costs less to move than acting into a bad moment.Give the hard review. The annual review is next month. The manager is dealing with a family emergency this week.Weigh the opening: The moment has arrived before the schedule. Ask whether it will still be open when the date comes; if not, act now and say why.
Your sort matched 0 of 8.Your sort matched 1 of 8.Your sort matched 2 of 8.Your sort matched 3 of 8.Your sort matched 4 of 8.Your sort matched 5 of 8.Your sort matched 6 of 8.Your sort matched 7 of 8.Your sort matched 8 of 8.
Act
Both signals say go. Act, and move on.
Wait
Neither signal calls for it. Leave it, and set a date to look again.
Weigh the deadline
The calendar pushes and the moment resists. Ask what moving the date really costs; a date you set yourself usually costs less to move than acting into a bad moment.
Weigh the opening
The moment has arrived before the schedule. Ask whether it will still be open when the date comes; if not, act now and say why.
The sort
Announce the reorg: Weigh the deadline. The date was set in a planning meeting; the renewal and the absent leader are real. Move it a week and tell the board why.
Hire rival's engineer: Weigh the opening. She is open to a call now and may not be in six months. Make the offer and find the budget.
Renew the office lease: Act. A fixed date and a willing landlord: sign it.
Merge the tool budgets: Wait. No deadline and no goodwill. Park it until the overrun is settled.
Raise list prices Jan 1: Weigh the deadline. A date the team chose, against a market that just moved. Weigh a quarter's delay against a lost deal or two.
Name the missed handoffs: Weigh the opening. He opened the door today. Have the talk this week; in six weeks it is a grievance.
File compliance report: Act. Someone outside enforces the date, and the work is ready. File it.
Give the hard review: Wait. Nothing forces it, and he cannot hear it now. Hold to the review date.
An example
A division head had board approval to fold two regional sales teams into one, and the plan said announce it Monday. On Friday she wrote the two signals down separately. The calendar said go: the board had set the date and the plan had the week marked. The moment said wait: the largest customer's renewal was due in nine days and its account lead sat in one of the teams being merged, and the head of the other team was on leave until Thursday and would hear the news secondhand.
She asked what each signal would cost to ignore. Moving the date cost a week of quiet and a two-line note to the board. Announcing on Monday put the renewal at risk and made a rival of the leader she needed to run the combined team. She moved the announcement to the Tuesday after the renewal closed, told the board why, and logged the call so she could check it later.
Why it works
Most timing calls arrive fused: one feeling of now or not yet, with the deadline's pressure already mixed in. Splitting it into two readings, what the schedule says and whether the conditions, the other party, and the actor are ready, shows where they disagree, and the disagreement is the decision. When the two agree there is nothing to deliberate.
The split also puts a price on each side. A deadline someone outside sets and enforces usually wins; a date picked in a planning meeting rarely deserves to. A ready moment that will close (a person open to an offer, a customer just burned by a rival) is worth breaking the schedule for; one that will still be there next month is not. Logging which signal won, and checking later, turns a gut sense of timing into one that can be trained.
The thinking behind it
John E. Smith John E. Smith, a philosopher at Yale, set out the distinction in a 1969 essay in The Monist on chronos and kairos. Chronos is measured time, the quantity a clock or a calendar counts. Kairos is qualitative: the right or opportune time for a particular action, a moment defined by what is happening, not by where it falls in a sequence. The essay treats them as two different kinds of time, one counted and one judged by the occasion, so that the second cannot be read off the first.
James L. Kinneavy James L. Kinneavy, a scholar of rhetoric at the University of Texas, argued in Kairos: A Neglected Concept in Classical Rhetoric (in Rhetoric and Praxis, edited by Jean Dietz Moss, 1986) that the idea had been central to Greek rhetoric and then dropped from modern study. For the sophists who taught it, kairos meant both the opportune moment and the fitness of what is said to the situation and the audience. His essay is credited with returning the concept to modern rhetorical study, and he carried it further in Greek Rhetorical Origins of Christian Faith (1987).
How to run it
Name the action. One move with a verb and an object: announce the merger, make the offer, raise the price.
Read the calendar on its own. Write the date it says and who set it, and mark whether someone outside enforces it, it was agreed with others, or you chose it.
Read the moment on its own. Ask three things separately: are the conditions in place, is the other party ready to hear it, and are you in a state to do it well.
Compare the two readings. If both say act or both say wait, follow them and stop; the work is only where they disagree.
Price each override. Write what breaking the date costs and what acting into the wrong moment costs, in money, trust, or options lost.
Decide and log the signal you followed. One line: the action, the signal followed, the reason, and the date you will look back.
Read the log every quarter. See which signal turned out right; the pattern shows whether you lean too hard on dates or on feel.
Where it goes wrong
Every delay gets called judgment. Waiting for the right moment becomes a polite name for avoiding a hard conversation, and the moment never comes. When the same decision has been ruled not ready three times, the problem is the decision, not the timing; set a date that only a named event can move.
The calendar is treated as fixed when it is not. Teams defend dates they set themselves as if a regulator had set them. Ask who would notice if the date moved and what they would do; often the answer is one email.
The two readings are taken together. Someone who wants to act reads the moment as ready. Write the calendar reading first, then have a person who does not own the decision read the moment.
When to use something else
OODA Loop. When timing is a contest with a rival, and acting faster than the other side matters more than finding the ripe moment.
One-Way and Two-Way Doors. When the real question is how reversible the move is, which decides how much its timing deserves.
Disciplined Hold. When the moment is wrong because the support the action needs is missing, and waiting means rebuilding it on purpose.