Influence Sociogram

Thinking Tools3.3 Mapping the System Around the ProblemAlso known as Sociogram, Influence Network Map

Developed by Jacob L. Moreno (Who Shall Survive?, 1934) and carried into organizations by David Krackhardt and Jeffrey R. Hanson (Informal Networks: The Company Behind the Chart, 1993) and by Rob Cross and Andrew Parker (The Hidden Power of Social Networks, 2004).

Draws people as points and influence as arrows, then reads the picture for the hubs, brokers, and outliers who actually move opinion on a given question.

Who shapes whose view on a distributor's move to tiered pricing

Each line joins two people who shape each other's view of the pricing change. Size people by their ties to find the hub, or by how often they sit between others to find the broker; select a person to read their place, and take the pricing analyst out to see sales lose its only route to the decider. Illustrative.

How many ties the person has. Highest: Raj, top sales repBea, sales operationsIris, finance directorOmar, key accountsLena, sales managerTheo, pricing analystDana, commercial chiefMo, service desk leadGus, chief of staffHow often the person sits on the shortest route between two others. Highest: Raj, top sales repBea, sales operationsIris, finance directorOmar, key accountsLena, sales managerTheo, pricing analystDana, commercial chiefMo, service desk leadGus, chief of staff

Select a person to read their place in the map.Raj, top sales rep. The best-paid rep and the loudest voice against tiers. His view reaches the decider only through Theo, by way of Lena or Bea. Degree 3 · Betweenness 0.00Bea, sales operations. Builds the quotes, is trusted by the reps, and has a second, weaker line to Theo. Degree 4 · Betweenness 0.14Iris, finance director. Dana's closest adviser on margins. She hears the sales view only through Theo. Degree 2 · Betweenness 0.00Omar, key accounts. Well inside the sales cluster; he moves when Lena and Raj move. Degree 3 · Betweenness 0.00Lena, sales manager. The hub: every rep tests a pricing idea on her first, so winning her over carries the whole sales cluster. Degree 5 · Betweenness 0.39Theo, pricing analyst. The broker: the one person both the sales cluster and Dana's circle talk to. The shortest credible route from sales to the decider runs Lena, Theo, Dana. Degree 4 · Betweenness 0.54Dana, commercial chief. Decides on the pricing change. She listens to Iris, Gus, and Theo, and to no one in sales directly. Degree 3 · Betweenness 0.25Mo, service desk lead. The isolate: one tie, to Lena. He takes every customer complaint about price, and nobody asks him what they say. Degree 1 · Betweenness 0.00Gus, chief of staff. Sets Dana's agenda and hears everything through her; he has no tie to sales at all. Degree 1 · Betweenness 0.00

PersonDegreeBetweenness
Raj, top sales rep30.00
Bea, sales operations40.14
Iris, finance director20.00
Omar, key accounts30.00
Lena, sales manager50.39
Theo, pricing analyst40.54
Dana, commercial chief30.25
Mo, service desk lead10.00
Gus, chief of staff10.00

An example

The head of product marketing at an industrial parts distributor wanted to replace a single list price with three tiers. The commercial chief would decide, and the sales team was against it. Her first plan was a deck for the sales kickoff. Before building it she spent an evening drawing who talked to whom about pricing, nine people in all, from what she had seen in meetings and heard in the hallway.

The drawing changed the plan. Every rep tested pricing ideas on the sales manager, so the manager was the hub. The commercial chief heard nothing from sales directly: her view came from the finance director, her chief of staff, and a junior pricing analyst, the only person both camps talked to. The service desk lead, who took every price complaint, was tied to almost no one. She skipped the kickoff deck, worked the pricing analyst and the sales manager through the numbers over two weeks, and brought the service desk's complaint log to the decision meeting. The tiers passed with a carve-out for the largest accounts.

Why it works

Opinion on a decision travels along a few personal channels, and those channels rarely match the reporting lines. Drawing them makes three positions visible that the org chart hides. Hubs have many ties, so a view that wins them spreads without further effort. Brokers sit between groups that otherwise do not talk, so everything that crosses passes through them, and they often hold little rank. Isolates hold information nobody asks for.

Once the map exists, the question of how to persuade becomes a question of routing: which few people, in what order, carry a case to the decider with the fewest hops. That is cheaper than persuading everyone, and it shows where a single person leaving or turning against the case would cut the route.

The thinking behind it

Jacob L. Moreno Jacob L. Moreno, a psychiatrist who founded psychodrama and sociometry, introduced the sociogram in Who Shall Survive? (1934). He drew the members of a group as points and the attractions and rejections among them as lines, so that the shape of the group's relationships could be read at a glance. The influence sociogram keeps his device and narrows the lines to one question: whose view shapes whose.

David Krackhardt David Krackhardt and Jeffrey R. Hanson's Informal Networks: The Company Behind the Chart (Harvard Business Review, 1993) showed managers how to map the advice, trust, and communication networks that do much of an organization's work outside the formal chart. Their habit of drawing advice, trust, and communication as separate maps is why a sociogram is drawn for one question at a time. Krackhardt also wrote the KrackPlot software for drawing such maps.

Rob Cross Rob Cross and Andrew Parker's The Hidden Power of Social Networks (2004) drew on more than sixty informal networks to show managers how to map the relationships through which work actually gets done, and how to find the people at a network's center and at its edges. Those are the positions this map reads for: the hubs and brokers at the center, the isolates at the edge.

How to run it

  1. Fix one question. Influence on pricing differs from influence on hiring, so name the decision the map is for.
  2. List everyone involved, whatever their title. Include the decider, the people the decider hears, and the people whose work the change touches.
  3. Draw a line wherever one person shapes another's view. Use what you have seen and heard, and mark the lines you are guessing at.
  4. Find the hubs, brokers, and isolates. Count ties for hubs, look for the one person joining two groups for brokers, and note who is barely connected.
  5. Trace the shortest credible route to the decider. Pick the two or three people who carry a case there in the fewest steps, and decide the order to see them.
  6. Test the route by removing a person. If one departure or defection cuts the route, find a second path before you need it.
  7. Keep the map private and redraw it each quarter. It names people's standing plainly; store it as you would a salary list.

Where it goes wrong

A sociogram drawn from the org chart misses the point of drawing one. It shows up as a map whose lines match the reporting lines exactly. Rebuild it from observed conversations, or ask three people separately whose opinion each person seeks on the question.

A second failure is a stale map. Influence shifts with leadership changes and big events, and a year-old drawing sends effort to people who no longer carry weight. The third is leaking it. A map that names a broker or an isolate can embarrass people if it circulates, and the damage lands on its author. Keep it with one person or a very small group.

When to use something else

  • Network Centrality Analysis. When the network is large enough that the positions must be measured from collected tie data.
  • Power-Interest Grid. When the question is how much attention each stakeholder needs, more than who sways whom.
  • Coalition Mapping. When the work is counting who stands for and against the proposal and building a group large enough to win.

Where it sits in SOLVE eX

Go to the source

  • Who Shall Survive?, 1934
  • Informal Networks: The Company Behind the Chart, Harvard Business Review, 1993
  • The Hidden Power of Social Networks, 2004

Back to the catalog