Thinking Tools3.3 Mapping the System Around the ProblemAlso known as Stakeholder Matrix, Mendelow's Matrix
Developed by Aubrey L. Mendelow (Environmental Scanning: The Impact of the Stakeholder Concept, 1981) and popularized by Gerry Johnson and Kevan Scholes (Exploring Corporate Strategy, fifth edition, 1999) and Colin Eden and Fran Ackermann (Making Strategy, 1998).
Plots stakeholders by their power over an initiative and their interest in it, then gives each quadrant an approach: manage closely, keep satisfied, keep informed, or monitor.
Nine stakeholders in a hospital's switch to a new records system, sorted by power and interest
The chief medical officer is placed as an example. Select each other stakeholder to read the facts about them, then the box their power and interest put them in; the box says how to engage them. Show the sort to compare yours with the program lead's. Illustrative.
Items (select one, then a box)
Not placedPlacedManage closelyKeep satisfiedKeep informedMonitor
Not placedPlacedManage closelyKeep satisfiedKeep informedMonitor
Not placedPlacedManage closelyKeep satisfiedKeep informedMonitor
Not placedPlacedManage closelyKeep satisfiedKeep informedMonitor
Not placedPlacedManage closelyKeep satisfiedKeep informedMonitor
Not placedPlacedManage closelyKeep satisfiedKeep informedMonitor
Not placedPlacedManage closelyKeep satisfiedKeep informedMonitor
Not placedPlacedManage closelyKeep satisfiedKeep informedMonitor
Not placedPlacedManage closelyKeep satisfiedKeep informedMonitor
Power over the switch
High powerLow power
Keep satisfied
Manage closely
Monitor
Keep informed
Low interestHigh interest
Interest in the switch
Manage closely: High power, high interest: bring them into the decisions, meet often, and settle their objections before go-live.Keep satisfied: High power, low interest: keep every ask short, report only what touches their concerns, and watch for anything that would wake them up.Keep informed: Low power, high interest: brief them on a schedule and act on what they report; they carry the change on the wards.Monitor: Low power, low interest: a notice at the right moment, and a check now and then that neither rating has moved.Select a stakeholder, then the box it belongs in.Chief medical officer. Chairs the steering group, signs off every change to clinical workflows, and reads the project report every Monday.Not placed yet.Chief medical officer. Chairs the steering group, signs off every change to clinical workflows, and reads the project report every Monday.Manage closely: High power, high interest: bring them into the decisions, meet often, and settle their objections before go-live.She can stop go-live and wants to shape it, so she approves each order set in a weekly working session.Chief medical officer. Chairs the steering group, signs off every change to clinical workflows, and reads the project report every Monday.Keep satisfied: High power, low interest: keep every ask short, report only what touches their concerns, and watch for anything that would wake them up.Chief medical officer. Chairs the steering group, signs off every change to clinical workflows, and reads the project report every Monday.Keep informed: Low power, high interest: brief them on a schedule and act on what they report; they carry the change on the wards.Chief medical officer. Chairs the steering group, signs off every change to clinical workflows, and reads the project report every Monday.Monitor: Low power, low interest: a notice at the right moment, and a check now and then that neither rating has moved.Director of nursing. Runs 1,100 nurses, controls the training rota, and lost a week of charting in the last upgrade.Not placed yet.Director of nursing. Runs 1,100 nurses, controls the training rota, and lost a week of charting in the last upgrade.Manage closely: High power, high interest: bring them into the decisions, meet often, and settle their objections before go-live.She holds the training hours the switch needs and cares how it lands, so she co-owns the training plan.Director of nursing. Runs 1,100 nurses, controls the training rota, and lost a week of charting in the last upgrade.Keep satisfied: High power, low interest: keep every ask short, report only what touches their concerns, and watch for anything that would wake them up.Director of nursing. Runs 1,100 nurses, controls the training rota, and lost a week of charting in the last upgrade.Keep informed: Low power, high interest: brief them on a schedule and act on what they report; they carry the change on the wards.Director of nursing. Runs 1,100 nurses, controls the training rota, and lost a week of charting in the last upgrade.Monitor: Low power, low interest: a notice at the right moment, and a check now and then that neither rating has moved.IT director. Owns the cutover weekend, the vendor contract, and the rollback decision.Not placed yet.IT director. Owns the cutover weekend, the vendor contract, and the rollback decision.Manage closely: High power, high interest: bring them into the decisions, meet often, and settle their objections before go-live.He decides whether the cutover goes ahead on the night, so he sits in the weekly session and runs the go or no-go call.IT director. Owns the cutover weekend, the vendor contract, and the rollback decision.Keep satisfied: High power, low interest: keep every ask short, report only what touches their concerns, and watch for anything that would wake them up.IT director. Owns the cutover weekend, the vendor contract, and the rollback decision.Keep informed: Low power, high interest: brief them on a schedule and act on what they report; they carry the change on the wards.IT director. Owns the cutover weekend, the vendor contract, and the rollback decision.Monitor: Low power, low interest: a notice at the right moment, and a check now and then that neither rating has moved.Finance committee. Approved the $14 million budget last year, meets quarterly, and has not asked about the project since.Not placed yet.Finance committee. Approved the $14 million budget last year, meets quarterly, and has not asked about the project since.Manage closely: High power, high interest: bring them into the decisions, meet often, and settle their objections before go-live.Finance committee. Approved the $14 million budget last year, meets quarterly, and has not asked about the project since.Keep satisfied: High power, low interest: keep every ask short, report only what touches their concerns, and watch for anything that would wake them up.It can freeze spending but only looks when costs move, so it gets a one-page cost note before each meeting.Finance committee. Approved the $14 million budget last year, meets quarterly, and has not asked about the project since.Keep informed: Low power, high interest: brief them on a schedule and act on what they report; they carry the change on the wards.Finance committee. Approved the $14 million budget last year, meets quarterly, and has not asked about the project since.Monitor: Low power, low interest: a notice at the right moment, and a check now and then that neither rating has moved.State regulator. Must be told of any records outage longer than four hours; has no other role in the project.Not placed yet.State regulator. Must be told of any records outage longer than four hours; has no other role in the project.Manage closely: High power, high interest: bring them into the decisions, meet often, and settle their objections before go-live.State regulator. Must be told of any records outage longer than four hours; has no other role in the project.Keep satisfied: High power, low interest: keep every ask short, report only what touches their concerns, and watch for anything that would wake them up.One long outage would bring an inquiry, so it gets a named contact and the outage plan a month ahead.State regulator. Must be told of any records outage longer than four hours; has no other role in the project.Keep informed: Low power, high interest: brief them on a schedule and act on what they report; they carry the change on the wards.State regulator. Must be told of any records outage longer than four hours; has no other role in the project.Monitor: Low power, low interest: a notice at the right moment, and a check now and then that neither rating has moved.Ward nurses. Will chart in the new system every shift and have no vote on how it is set up.Not placed yet.Ward nurses. Will chart in the new system every shift and have no vote on how it is set up.Manage closely: High power, high interest: bring them into the decisions, meet often, and settle their objections before go-live.Ward nurses. Will chart in the new system every shift and have no vote on how it is set up.Keep satisfied: High power, low interest: keep every ask short, report only what touches their concerns, and watch for anything that would wake them up.Ward nurses. Will chart in the new system every shift and have no vote on how it is set up.Keep informed: Low power, high interest: brief them on a schedule and act on what they report; they carry the change on the wards.They feel every flaw first, so they get a briefing every two weeks and a direct line for problems.Ward nurses. Will chart in the new system every shift and have no vote on how it is set up.Monitor: Low power, low interest: a notice at the right moment, and a check now and then that neither rating has moved.Records clerks. Will move forty years of scanned files and worry the new system will shrink their jobs.Not placed yet.Records clerks. Will move forty years of scanned files and worry the new system will shrink their jobs.Manage closely: High power, high interest: bring them into the decisions, meet often, and settle their objections before go-live.Records clerks. Will move forty years of scanned files and worry the new system will shrink their jobs.Keep satisfied: High power, low interest: keep every ask short, report only what touches their concerns, and watch for anything that would wake them up.Records clerks. Will move forty years of scanned files and worry the new system will shrink their jobs.Keep informed: Low power, high interest: brief them on a schedule and act on what they report; they carry the change on the wards.Their worry is loud but their say is small; an honest briefing on staffing settles more than a meeting with the board would.Records clerks. Will move forty years of scanned files and worry the new system will shrink their jobs.Monitor: Low power, low interest: a notice at the right moment, and a check now and then that neither rating has moved.Patient council. Meets monthly, wants the patient portal working on day one, and advises the board without deciding anything.Not placed yet.Patient council. Meets monthly, wants the patient portal working on day one, and advises the board without deciding anything.Manage closely: High power, high interest: bring them into the decisions, meet often, and settle their objections before go-live.Patient council. Meets monthly, wants the patient portal working on day one, and advises the board without deciding anything.Keep satisfied: High power, low interest: keep every ask short, report only what touches their concerns, and watch for anything that would wake them up.Patient council. Meets monthly, wants the patient portal working on day one, and advises the board without deciding anything.Keep informed: Low power, high interest: brief them on a schedule and act on what they report; they carry the change on the wards.Its members will talk about the portal in public, so they see it a month early and their questions go into the launch notes.Patient council. Meets monthly, wants the patient portal working on day one, and advises the board without deciding anything.Monitor: Low power, low interest: a notice at the right moment, and a check now and then that neither rating has moved.Facilities team. Needs to know which rooms the trainers will book; nothing else changes for them.Not placed yet.Facilities team. Needs to know which rooms the trainers will book; nothing else changes for them.Manage closely: High power, high interest: bring them into the decisions, meet often, and settle their objections before go-live.Facilities team. Needs to know which rooms the trainers will book; nothing else changes for them.Keep satisfied: High power, low interest: keep every ask short, report only what touches their concerns, and watch for anything that would wake them up.Facilities team. Needs to know which rooms the trainers will book; nothing else changes for them.Keep informed: Low power, high interest: brief them on a schedule and act on what they report; they carry the change on the wards.Facilities team. Needs to know which rooms the trainers will book; nothing else changes for them.Monitor: Low power, low interest: a notice at the right moment, and a check now and then that neither rating has moved.A room schedule in January covers it, with a check in February that nothing new has come up.
Your sort matched 0 of 9.Your sort matched 1 of 9.Your sort matched 2 of 9.Your sort matched 3 of 9.Your sort matched 4 of 9.Your sort matched 5 of 9.Your sort matched 6 of 9.Your sort matched 7 of 9.Your sort matched 8 of 9.Your sort matched 9 of 9.
Manage closely
High power, high interest: bring them into the decisions, meet often, and settle their objections before go-live.
Keep satisfied
High power, low interest: keep every ask short, report only what touches their concerns, and watch for anything that would wake them up.
Keep informed
Low power, high interest: brief them on a schedule and act on what they report; they carry the change on the wards.
Monitor
Low power, low interest: a notice at the right moment, and a check now and then that neither rating has moved.
The sort
Chief medical officer: Manage closely. She can stop go-live and wants to shape it, so she approves each order set in a weekly working session.
Director of nursing: Manage closely. She holds the training hours the switch needs and cares how it lands, so she co-owns the training plan.
IT director: Manage closely. He decides whether the cutover goes ahead on the night, so he sits in the weekly session and runs the go or no-go call.
Finance committee: Keep satisfied. It can freeze spending but only looks when costs move, so it gets a one-page cost note before each meeting.
State regulator: Keep satisfied. One long outage would bring an inquiry, so it gets a named contact and the outage plan a month ahead.
Ward nurses: Keep informed. They feel every flaw first, so they get a briefing every two weeks and a direct line for problems.
Records clerks: Keep informed. Their worry is loud but their say is small; an honest briefing on staffing settles more than a meeting with the board would.
Patient council: Keep informed. Its members will talk about the portal in public, so they see it a month early and their questions go into the launch notes.
Facilities team: Monitor. A room schedule in January covers it, with a check in February that nothing new has come up.
An example
A 400-bed regional hospital was moving to a new electronic health record over one weekend in March. Three months out, the program lead noticed she was spending most of her week with the medical records clerks, who were worried and said so loudly, and almost none with the board finance committee, which had approved the $14 million budget and gone quiet. She listed every group with a stake, nineteen in all, and rated each one's power over the switch and interest in it as high or low.
The grid rearranged her calendar. The chief medical officer, the director of nursing, and the IT director went into a weekly working session. The finance committee got a one-page cost note before each quarterly meeting, and the state regulator a named contact and the outage plan. The clerks and ward nurses got a briefing every two weeks and a line for problems. Go-live slipped one week for a training gap the nursing director caught, and the board heard it from the program lead first.
Why it works
Attention is the scarce input in any change, and it drifts toward whoever makes the most noise. The grid replaces that drift with two questions that can be answered for each stakeholder on their own: can they change the outcome, and do they care about it? Crossing the answers gives four kinds of relationship, and each kind earns a different share of time.
The box that pays for the exercise is usually high power with low interest. Those people look safe because they are silent, and one trigger (a cost overrun, an outage, a news story) can switch their interest on overnight. The grid makes that risk visible before it fires. It also gives the loud, low-power groups a real job: kept informed, they carry the change where the work is done and send early warnings upward.
The thinking behind it
Aubrey L. Mendelow Aubrey L. Mendelow's conference paper, Environmental Scanning: The Impact of the Stakeholder Concept (1981), is the usual source of the grid. He sorted an organization's stakeholders by their power over it and their interest in its decisions, and used the sort to decide how closely each one should be managed. The paper is often cited with the date 1991, which is a miscitation; the 1981 paper is the original.
Colin Eden Colin Eden, a management scientist at the University of Strathclyde known for cognitive mapping and problem structuring methods, wrote Making Strategy: The Journey of Strategic Management (1998) with Fran Ackermann. The book treats political feasibility and stakeholder management as part of the work of strategy itself, and it is often cited as a source of the power and interest grid. Its view of feasibility as part of strategy is why a quiet committee with a veto deserves a standing place in the plan.
Kevan Scholes Kevan Scholes and Gerry Johnson set the grid out in later editions of Exploring Corporate Strategy (fifth edition, 1999; first edition 1984) and credit it to Mendelow. Through that widely used textbook the grid reached a wide readership of planners and business students. Scholes and Johnson popularized the grid; they did not originate it, and their text says where it came from.
How to run it
Name the change being mapped. Power and interest differ by question, so write the specific change at the top: this go-live, this budget, this reorganization.
List everyone with a stake. Include groups that cannot vote but can delay, and outsiders such as regulators, unions, and large customers.
Rate power over this outcome. Ask what each one could stop, slow, or force if they chose to, whatever their title says.
Rate interest in this outcome. Ask how far the change touches their work, budget, or standing, and how much attention they are paying now.
Place each one and read the box. Start with high and low; a finer scale adds argument without changing the action.
Write one action for each stakeholder in the top boxes. Give the action an owner, a channel, and a frequency, so the plan shows up in calendars.
Redraw at each milestone. Interest moves fast when something goes wrong, and a quiet committee can change boxes in a week.
Where it goes wrong
The common failure is treating the high-power, low-interest box as safe to ignore. It shows up as a stakeholder who was never briefed asking hard questions at a board meeting. The recovery is a short, direct catch-up with that person and a standing update from then on.
A second failure is rating power by title. The head of a department may hold less sway over this change than the scheduler who controls the training rota. Ask what each person could actually stop, and rerate anyone who could stop nothing. The third is drawing the grid once: stakeholders move between boxes as the work reaches them, and a map from the kickoff misdirects effort by the midpoint.
When to use something else
Influence Sociogram. When the question is who sways whom, and the route to the decider runs through people the grid scores as low power.
Coalition Mapping. When stakeholders will line up for and against a proposal and the work is assembling enough support to carry it.
Ethical Matrix. When the question is what each group is owed by the decision, with fairness weighed alongside influence.