Thinking Tools5.1 Defining the Evaluation CriteriaAlso known as Stakeholder Ethics Matrix
Originated by Ben Mepham (the ethical matrix, 1996), on the stakeholder theory of R. Edward Freeman (Strategic Management: A Stakeholder Approach, 1984).
Lays out stakeholders as rows and ethical concerns (rights, interests, harms, fairness, and voice) as columns, so every effect of a decision is written down.
Nine effects of tracking delivery vans, each placed in the stakeholder's row and the principle it touches
The plan puts a tracking app and dashcams in every delivery van. Each row is a group the plan touches; each column a principle. The first effect is placed as an example; place the rest, and each cell says whether its effect is a real concern and what remedy the plan needs. Illustrative.
Items (select one, then a box)
Not placedPlacedWellbeingAutonomyFairnessWellbeingAutonomyFairnessWellbeingAutonomyFairness
Not placedPlacedWellbeingAutonomyFairnessWellbeingAutonomyFairnessWellbeingAutonomyFairness
Not placedPlacedWellbeingAutonomyFairnessWellbeingAutonomyFairnessWellbeingAutonomyFairness
Not placedPlacedWellbeingAutonomyFairnessWellbeingAutonomyFairnessWellbeingAutonomyFairness
Not placedPlacedWellbeingAutonomyFairnessWellbeingAutonomyFairnessWellbeingAutonomyFairness
Not placedPlacedWellbeingAutonomyFairnessWellbeingAutonomyFairnessWellbeingAutonomyFairness
Not placedPlacedWellbeingAutonomyFairnessWellbeingAutonomyFairnessWellbeingAutonomyFairness
Not placedPlacedWellbeingAutonomyFairnessWellbeingAutonomyFairnessWellbeingAutonomyFairness
Not placedPlacedWellbeingAutonomyFairnessWellbeingAutonomyFairnessWellbeingAutonomyFairness
Who is affected
DriversCustomersNeighbors
Wellbeing
Autonomy
Fairness
Wellbeing
Autonomy
Fairness
Wellbeing
Autonomy
Fairness
WellbeingAutonomyFairness
Principle
Tracked after shift ends. The app keeps reporting location while the van is parked at the driver's home overnight.Not placed yet.Tracked after shift ends. The app keeps reporting location while the van is parked at the driver's home overnight.Wellbeing: Drivers' wellbeing: their safety, health, stress, and pay.Tracked after shift ends. The app keeps reporting location while the van is parked at the driver's home overnight.Autonomy: Drivers' autonomy: their control over their own time, data, and judgment on the road.A real concern: the company learns where drivers go off the clock. Remedy: tracking stops at clock-out, and each driver can see their own data.Tracked after shift ends. The app keeps reporting location while the van is parked at the driver's home overnight.Fairness: Fairness to drivers: whether each is judged and paid on equal terms.Tracked after shift ends. The app keeps reporting location while the van is parked at the driver's home overnight.Wellbeing: Customers' wellbeing: whether they get what they ordered, safely and on time.Tracked after shift ends. The app keeps reporting location while the van is parked at the driver's home overnight.Autonomy: Customers' autonomy: their control over what is known about them and their homes.Tracked after shift ends. The app keeps reporting location while the van is parked at the driver's home overnight.Fairness: Fairness to customers: whether every customer gets the same service for the same price.Tracked after shift ends. The app keeps reporting location while the van is parked at the driver's home overnight.Wellbeing: Neighbors' wellbeing: safety and quiet on the streets the vans use.Tracked after shift ends. The app keeps reporting location while the van is parked at the driver's home overnight.Autonomy: Neighbors' autonomy: their choice about being recorded by a company they never dealt with.Tracked after shift ends. The app keeps reporting location while the van is parked at the driver's home overnight.Fairness: Fairness to neighbors: whether the costs of the routes fall evenly across the city.Harsh-braking alerts. The app flags hard braking and speeding to the driver and the depot.Not placed yet.Harsh-braking alerts. The app flags hard braking and speeding to the driver and the depot.Wellbeing: Drivers' wellbeing: their safety, health, stress, and pay.Mostly a benefit: fewer crashes. Watch the stress of constant scoring, and coach on the alerts instead of ranking by them.Harsh-braking alerts. The app flags hard braking and speeding to the driver and the depot.Autonomy: Drivers' autonomy: their control over their own time, data, and judgment on the road.Harsh-braking alerts. The app flags hard braking and speeding to the driver and the depot.Fairness: Fairness to drivers: whether each is judged and paid on equal terms.Harsh-braking alerts. The app flags hard braking and speeding to the driver and the depot.Wellbeing: Customers' wellbeing: whether they get what they ordered, safely and on time.Harsh-braking alerts. The app flags hard braking and speeding to the driver and the depot.Autonomy: Customers' autonomy: their control over what is known about them and their homes.Harsh-braking alerts. The app flags hard braking and speeding to the driver and the depot.Fairness: Fairness to customers: whether every customer gets the same service for the same price.Harsh-braking alerts. The app flags hard braking and speeding to the driver and the depot.Wellbeing: Neighbors' wellbeing: safety and quiet on the streets the vans use.Harsh-braking alerts. The app flags hard braking and speeding to the driver and the depot.Autonomy: Neighbors' autonomy: their choice about being recorded by a company they never dealt with.Harsh-braking alerts. The app flags hard braking and speeding to the driver and the depot.Fairness: Fairness to neighbors: whether the costs of the routes fall evenly across the city.Scores ignore traffic. Drivers are ranked by stops per hour, city routes against suburban ones.Not placed yet.Scores ignore traffic. Drivers are ranked by stops per hour, city routes against suburban ones.Wellbeing: Drivers' wellbeing: their safety, health, stress, and pay.Scores ignore traffic. Drivers are ranked by stops per hour, city routes against suburban ones.Autonomy: Drivers' autonomy: their control over their own time, data, and judgment on the road.Scores ignore traffic. Drivers are ranked by stops per hour, city routes against suburban ones.Fairness: Fairness to drivers: whether each is judged and paid on equal terms.A real concern: city drivers rank last for traffic they cannot control. Remedy: compare drivers only within the same route type.Scores ignore traffic. Drivers are ranked by stops per hour, city routes against suburban ones.Wellbeing: Customers' wellbeing: whether they get what they ordered, safely and on time.Scores ignore traffic. Drivers are ranked by stops per hour, city routes against suburban ones.Autonomy: Customers' autonomy: their control over what is known about them and their homes.Scores ignore traffic. Drivers are ranked by stops per hour, city routes against suburban ones.Fairness: Fairness to customers: whether every customer gets the same service for the same price.Scores ignore traffic. Drivers are ranked by stops per hour, city routes against suburban ones.Wellbeing: Neighbors' wellbeing: safety and quiet on the streets the vans use.Scores ignore traffic. Drivers are ranked by stops per hour, city routes against suburban ones.Autonomy: Neighbors' autonomy: their choice about being recorded by a company they never dealt with.Scores ignore traffic. Drivers are ranked by stops per hour, city routes against suburban ones.Fairness: Fairness to neighbors: whether the costs of the routes fall evenly across the city.Accurate arrival windows. Live location lets customers see a 30-minute window.Not placed yet.Accurate arrival windows. Live location lets customers see a 30-minute window.Wellbeing: Drivers' wellbeing: their safety, health, stress, and pay.Accurate arrival windows. Live location lets customers see a 30-minute window.Autonomy: Drivers' autonomy: their control over their own time, data, and judgment on the road.Accurate arrival windows. Live location lets customers see a 30-minute window.Fairness: Fairness to drivers: whether each is judged and paid on equal terms.Accurate arrival windows. Live location lets customers see a 30-minute window.Wellbeing: Customers' wellbeing: whether they get what they ordered, safely and on time.A benefit to customers. Keep it.Accurate arrival windows. Live location lets customers see a 30-minute window.Autonomy: Customers' autonomy: their control over what is known about them and their homes.Accurate arrival windows. Live location lets customers see a 30-minute window.Fairness: Fairness to customers: whether every customer gets the same service for the same price.Accurate arrival windows. Live location lets customers see a 30-minute window.Wellbeing: Neighbors' wellbeing: safety and quiet on the streets the vans use.Accurate arrival windows. Live location lets customers see a 30-minute window.Autonomy: Neighbors' autonomy: their choice about being recorded by a company they never dealt with.Accurate arrival windows. Live location lets customers see a 30-minute window.Fairness: Fairness to neighbors: whether the costs of the routes fall evenly across the city.Delivery history kept. Every drop is stored with a time and a photo of the door, kept indefinitely.Not placed yet.Delivery history kept. Every drop is stored with a time and a photo of the door, kept indefinitely.Wellbeing: Drivers' wellbeing: their safety, health, stress, and pay.Delivery history kept. Every drop is stored with a time and a photo of the door, kept indefinitely.Autonomy: Drivers' autonomy: their control over their own time, data, and judgment on the road.Delivery history kept. Every drop is stored with a time and a photo of the door, kept indefinitely.Fairness: Fairness to drivers: whether each is judged and paid on equal terms.Delivery history kept. Every drop is stored with a time and a photo of the door, kept indefinitely.Wellbeing: Customers' wellbeing: whether they get what they ordered, safely and on time.Delivery history kept. Every drop is stored with a time and a photo of the door, kept indefinitely.Autonomy: Customers' autonomy: their control over what is known about them and their homes.A real concern: the records show when each home is empty. Remedy: delete photos after 30 days and say so at checkout.Delivery history kept. Every drop is stored with a time and a photo of the door, kept indefinitely.Fairness: Fairness to customers: whether every customer gets the same service for the same price.Delivery history kept. Every drop is stored with a time and a photo of the door, kept indefinitely.Wellbeing: Neighbors' wellbeing: safety and quiet on the streets the vans use.Delivery history kept. Every drop is stored with a time and a photo of the door, kept indefinitely.Autonomy: Neighbors' autonomy: their choice about being recorded by a company they never dealt with.Delivery history kept. Every drop is stored with a time and a photo of the door, kept indefinitely.Fairness: Fairness to neighbors: whether the costs of the routes fall evenly across the city.Rural evening slots cut. The tracking data shows rural evening routes are slow, and planning wants to drop them.Not placed yet.Rural evening slots cut. The tracking data shows rural evening routes are slow, and planning wants to drop them.Wellbeing: Drivers' wellbeing: their safety, health, stress, and pay.Rural evening slots cut. The tracking data shows rural evening routes are slow, and planning wants to drop them.Autonomy: Drivers' autonomy: their control over their own time, data, and judgment on the road.Rural evening slots cut. The tracking data shows rural evening routes are slow, and planning wants to drop them.Fairness: Fairness to drivers: whether each is judged and paid on equal terms.Rural evening slots cut. The tracking data shows rural evening routes are slow, and planning wants to drop them.Wellbeing: Customers' wellbeing: whether they get what they ordered, safely and on time.Rural evening slots cut. The tracking data shows rural evening routes are slow, and planning wants to drop them.Autonomy: Customers' autonomy: their control over what is known about them and their homes.Rural evening slots cut. The tracking data shows rural evening routes are slow, and planning wants to drop them.Fairness: Fairness to customers: whether every customer gets the same service for the same price.A real concern: rural customers pay the same and lose a service. Remedy: keep the slots and price them openly, or cut them only with notice.Rural evening slots cut. The tracking data shows rural evening routes are slow, and planning wants to drop them.Wellbeing: Neighbors' wellbeing: safety and quiet on the streets the vans use.Rural evening slots cut. The tracking data shows rural evening routes are slow, and planning wants to drop them.Autonomy: Neighbors' autonomy: their choice about being recorded by a company they never dealt with.Rural evening slots cut. The tracking data shows rural evening routes are slow, and planning wants to drop them.Fairness: Fairness to neighbors: whether the costs of the routes fall evenly across the city.Fewer speeding vans. Speed alerts cut speeding on residential streets.Not placed yet.Fewer speeding vans. Speed alerts cut speeding on residential streets.Wellbeing: Drivers' wellbeing: their safety, health, stress, and pay.Fewer speeding vans. Speed alerts cut speeding on residential streets.Autonomy: Drivers' autonomy: their control over their own time, data, and judgment on the road.Fewer speeding vans. Speed alerts cut speeding on residential streets.Fairness: Fairness to drivers: whether each is judged and paid on equal terms.Fewer speeding vans. Speed alerts cut speeding on residential streets.Wellbeing: Customers' wellbeing: whether they get what they ordered, safely and on time.Fewer speeding vans. Speed alerts cut speeding on residential streets.Autonomy: Customers' autonomy: their control over what is known about them and their homes.Fewer speeding vans. Speed alerts cut speeding on residential streets.Fairness: Fairness to customers: whether every customer gets the same service for the same price.Fewer speeding vans. Speed alerts cut speeding on residential streets.Wellbeing: Neighbors' wellbeing: safety and quiet on the streets the vans use.A benefit to neighbors. Report it.Fewer speeding vans. Speed alerts cut speeding on residential streets.Autonomy: Neighbors' autonomy: their choice about being recorded by a company they never dealt with.Fewer speeding vans. Speed alerts cut speeding on residential streets.Fairness: Fairness to neighbors: whether the costs of the routes fall evenly across the city.Passersby on dashcam. Road-facing cameras record pedestrians and other cars on every route.Not placed yet.Passersby on dashcam. Road-facing cameras record pedestrians and other cars on every route.Wellbeing: Drivers' wellbeing: their safety, health, stress, and pay.Passersby on dashcam. Road-facing cameras record pedestrians and other cars on every route.Autonomy: Drivers' autonomy: their control over their own time, data, and judgment on the road.Passersby on dashcam. Road-facing cameras record pedestrians and other cars on every route.Fairness: Fairness to drivers: whether each is judged and paid on equal terms.Passersby on dashcam. Road-facing cameras record pedestrians and other cars on every route.Wellbeing: Customers' wellbeing: whether they get what they ordered, safely and on time.Passersby on dashcam. Road-facing cameras record pedestrians and other cars on every route.Autonomy: Customers' autonomy: their control over what is known about them and their homes.Passersby on dashcam. Road-facing cameras record pedestrians and other cars on every route.Fairness: Fairness to customers: whether every customer gets the same service for the same price.Passersby on dashcam. Road-facing cameras record pedestrians and other cars on every route.Wellbeing: Neighbors' wellbeing: safety and quiet on the streets the vans use.Passersby on dashcam. Road-facing cameras record pedestrians and other cars on every route.Autonomy: Neighbors' autonomy: their choice about being recorded by a company they never dealt with.A real concern for people who never agreed to it. Remedy: record only on a crash or a hard brake, and blur faces in stored clips.Passersby on dashcam. Road-facing cameras record pedestrians and other cars on every route.Fairness: Fairness to neighbors: whether the costs of the routes fall evenly across the city.Routes via side streets. The routing engine sends vans down three residential streets to skip a busy junction.Not placed yet.Routes via side streets. The routing engine sends vans down three residential streets to skip a busy junction.Wellbeing: Drivers' wellbeing: their safety, health, stress, and pay.Routes via side streets. The routing engine sends vans down three residential streets to skip a busy junction.Autonomy: Drivers' autonomy: their control over their own time, data, and judgment on the road.Routes via side streets. The routing engine sends vans down three residential streets to skip a busy junction.Fairness: Fairness to drivers: whether each is judged and paid on equal terms.Routes via side streets. The routing engine sends vans down three residential streets to skip a busy junction.Wellbeing: Customers' wellbeing: whether they get what they ordered, safely and on time.Routes via side streets. The routing engine sends vans down three residential streets to skip a busy junction.Autonomy: Customers' autonomy: their control over what is known about them and their homes.Routes via side streets. The routing engine sends vans down three residential streets to skip a busy junction.Fairness: Fairness to customers: whether every customer gets the same service for the same price.Routes via side streets. The routing engine sends vans down three residential streets to skip a busy junction.Wellbeing: Neighbors' wellbeing: safety and quiet on the streets the vans use.Routes via side streets. The routing engine sends vans down three residential streets to skip a busy junction.Autonomy: Neighbors' autonomy: their choice about being recorded by a company they never dealt with.Routes via side streets. The routing engine sends vans down three residential streets to skip a busy junction.Fairness: Fairness to neighbors: whether the costs of the routes fall evenly across the city.A real concern: a few streets carry the whole fleet. Remedy: cap van trips per residential street in the routing rules.
Your sort matched 0 of 9.Your sort matched 1 of 9.Your sort matched 2 of 9.Your sort matched 3 of 9.Your sort matched 4 of 9.Your sort matched 5 of 9.Your sort matched 6 of 9.Your sort matched 7 of 9.Your sort matched 8 of 9.Your sort matched 9 of 9.
Wellbeing
Drivers' wellbeing: their safety, health, stress, and pay.
Autonomy
Drivers' autonomy: their control over their own time, data, and judgment on the road.
Fairness
Fairness to drivers: whether each is judged and paid on equal terms.
Wellbeing
Customers' wellbeing: whether they get what they ordered, safely and on time.
Autonomy
Customers' autonomy: their control over what is known about them and their homes.
Fairness
Fairness to customers: whether every customer gets the same service for the same price.
Wellbeing
Neighbors' wellbeing: safety and quiet on the streets the vans use.
Autonomy
Neighbors' autonomy: their choice about being recorded by a company they never dealt with.
Fairness
Fairness to neighbors: whether the costs of the routes fall evenly across the city.
The sort
Tracked after shift ends: Autonomy. A real concern: the company learns where drivers go off the clock. Remedy: tracking stops at clock-out, and each driver can see their own data.
Harsh-braking alerts: Wellbeing. Mostly a benefit: fewer crashes. Watch the stress of constant scoring, and coach on the alerts instead of ranking by them.
Scores ignore traffic: Fairness. A real concern: city drivers rank last for traffic they cannot control. Remedy: compare drivers only within the same route type.
Accurate arrival windows: Wellbeing. A benefit to customers. Keep it.
Delivery history kept: Autonomy. A real concern: the records show when each home is empty. Remedy: delete photos after 30 days and say so at checkout.
Rural evening slots cut: Fairness. A real concern: rural customers pay the same and lose a service. Remedy: keep the slots and price them openly, or cut them only with notice.
Fewer speeding vans: Wellbeing. A benefit to neighbors. Report it.
Passersby on dashcam: Autonomy. A real concern for people who never agreed to it. Remedy: record only on a crash or a hard brake, and blur faces in stored clips.
Routes via side streets: Fairness. A real concern: a few streets carry the whole fleet. Remedy: cap van trips per residential street in the routing rules.
An example
A regional delivery company planned to put a tracking app and dashcams in all two hundred of its vans. The business case was a page of savings: lower insurance, fewer crashes, tighter routes. The operations director was asked to show the board who else the plan touched.
She drew three rows (drivers, customers, and the neighbors on the routes) and three columns (wellbeing, autonomy, and fairness) and wrote one specific effect in each of the nine cells. Three were plain benefits: fewer crashes, accurate arrival windows, slower vans on residential streets. Six were real concerns, and two of them nobody had raised: the app kept reporting location while vans sat parked at drivers' homes overnight, and stored door photos showed when each customer's house was usually empty. The board approved the plan with six remedies written into it, among them tracking that stops at clock-out, photos deleted after thirty days, and a cap on van trips per residential street.
Why it works
A business case counts what the decision maker cares about, so effects on everyone else go unwritten, and what is unwritten does not get weighed. The matrix makes the omission visible: every group gets a row, every principle a column, and a blank cell is a question someone has to answer.
The columns do the second half of the work. Asking about wellbeing alone finds harms and benefits; asking about autonomy finds the effects that cost nobody money and still take away someone's control; asking about fairness finds the costs that fall on some members of a group and not others. One decision usually touches all three, in different ways for each group. Writing a specific effect in each cell, and a remedy beside each real concern, turns a general worry about ethics into a list of design changes.
The thinking behind it
Ben Mepham Ben Mepham, a bioethicist at the University of Nottingham, devised the ethical matrix in Ethical Analysis of Food Biotechnologies: An Evaluative Framework, in Food Ethics (1996), which he edited. The table crosses the parties a decision affects with three principles, wellbeing, autonomy, and fairness, so that each party's stake is weighed in turn and none is left out of the argument. He built it for the ethics of food biotechnology, a field where many parties have a stake in one decision.
R. Edward Freeman R. Edward Freeman, a professor at the University of Virginia's Darden School, set out stakeholder theory in Strategic Management: A Stakeholder Approach (1984). A firm, he argued, should identify the groups that affect it or are affected by it and manage with their interests in view, not only the shareholders'. The rows of the matrix are his stakeholders, made explicit for a single decision.
How to run it
State the decision and its scope. Tracking app and dashcams in all two hundred vans, from the next quarter.
List every group it touches. Include indirect and future ones, such as neighbors on the routes or customers not yet signed.
Choose the columns. Wellbeing, autonomy, and fairness cover most cases; add one where the case needs it, such as the environment.
Write a specific effect in each cell. A sentence someone in that group would recognize, not a category; leave nothing blank.
Mark the real concerns. Ask whether a reasonable member of the group would object if they knew.
Design a remedy for each concern. A change to the plan, a limit, a notice, or a payment, with an owner.
File the matrix with the decision. So the next review can check which remedies were built and what was missed.
Where it goes wrong
The rows stop at the people in the room. The matrix lists employees, customers, and shareholders and misses the neighbors, the suppliers, or next year's customers. Ask who would be surprised to learn about the decision, and add them.
Cells get filled with categories. Privacy concerns in the autonomy cell says nothing anyone can fix. Write the effect a member of the group would describe (the app reports my location at home at night) and the remedy follows from it.
The matrix becomes a permission slip. It is drawn after the decision, every cell is marked acceptable, and it goes in the file. Draw it while the plan can still change, and judge it by the number of remedies it adds.
When to use something else
Power-Interest Grid. When the question is whose support the decision needs, sorted by power and interest, not what it does to each group.
Veil of Ignorance. When the issue is one rule's fairness, judged as if you did not know which group you would be in.
Consequentialism. When the effects can be counted and the decision turns on which option does the most good overall.