Draws on change-management practice: the commitment chart of Richard Beckhard and Reuben T. Harris (Organizational Transitions, 1977) and the guiding coalition of John P. Kotter (1995).
Lists everyone whose backing a decision needs, rates each from champion to opponent, notes what would move each one, and orders the conversations accordingly.
Nine people a new pricing model needs, mapped by where they stand and how much they decide
Each person's note says what they told the project lead. Place each by how committed they are today and whether they vote; the box says which conversation to have and in what order, and each person's line names what would move them one column right. The first is placed as an example. Illustrative.
Items (select one, then a box)
Not placedPlaced1. Meet first3. One step2. Early yesesAnswer itKeep informedVouch
Not placedPlaced1. Meet first3. One step2. Early yesesAnswer itKeep informedVouch
Not placedPlaced1. Meet first3. One step2. Early yesesAnswer itKeep informedVouch
Not placedPlaced1. Meet first3. One step2. Early yesesAnswer itKeep informedVouch
Not placedPlaced1. Meet first3. One step2. Early yesesAnswer itKeep informedVouch
Not placedPlaced1. Meet first3. One step2. Early yesesAnswer itKeep informedVouch
Not placedPlaced1. Meet first3. One step2. Early yesesAnswer itKeep informedVouch
Not placedPlaced1. Meet first3. One step2. Early yesesAnswer itKeep informedVouch
Not placedPlaced1. Meet first3. One step2. Early yesesAnswer itKeep informedVouch
Weight in the decision
VotesAdvises
1. Meet first
3. One step
2. Early yeses
Answer it
Keep informed
Vouch
OpposesWill let it happenWill helpWill make it happen
Commitment today
Head of sales. Says the new model will cut his team's commissions.Not placed yet.Head of sales. Says the new model will cut his team's commissions.1. Meet first: A vote against. Meet one to one before anyone else, about the concern they named; never let them hear the plan first in the room.What would move him: a commission plan that pays on renewals under the new model. First meeting on the list.Head of sales. Says the new model will cut his team's commissions.3. One step: A vote with no view yet. Find what would move them one column right, and ask for exactly that.Head of sales. Says the new model will cut his team's commissions.2. Early yeses: Supporters with a vote. Get their yes on record early, and ask each to bring one colleague along.Head of sales. Says the new model will cut his team's commissions.Answer it: Opposed, without a vote. Answer the concern in writing so it does not travel to the voters unanswered.Head of sales. Says the new model will cut his team's commissions.Keep informed: No vote, no objection. A short update at each stage is enough.Head of sales. Says the new model will cut his team's commissions.Vouch: Champions without a vote. Their word with the voters can carry more than the project lead's.CFO. Asked for the pricing review herself.Not placed yet.CFO. Asked for the pricing review herself.1. Meet first: A vote against. Meet one to one before anyone else, about the concern they named; never let them hear the plan first in the room.CFO. Asked for the pricing review herself.3. One step: A vote with no view yet. Find what would move them one column right, and ask for exactly that.CFO. Asked for the pricing review herself.2. Early yeses: Supporters with a vote. Get their yes on record early, and ask each to bring one colleague along.Already a champion. Ask her to speak first when the committee meets.CFO. Asked for the pricing review herself.Answer it: Opposed, without a vote. Answer the concern in writing so it does not travel to the voters unanswered.CFO. Asked for the pricing review herself.Keep informed: No vote, no objection. A short update at each stage is enough.CFO. Asked for the pricing review herself.Vouch: Champions without a vote. Their word with the voters can carry more than the project lead's.Product chief. Likes the model; worried about the launch date.Not placed yet.Product chief. Likes the model; worried about the launch date.1. Meet first: A vote against. Meet one to one before anyone else, about the concern they named; never let them hear the plan first in the room.Product chief. Likes the model; worried about the launch date.3. One step: A vote with no view yet. Find what would move them one column right, and ask for exactly that.Product chief. Likes the model; worried about the launch date.2. Early yeses: Supporters with a vote. Get their yes on record early, and ask each to bring one colleague along.What would move him: a date after the spring release. Then he speaks for it.Product chief. Likes the model; worried about the launch date.Answer it: Opposed, without a vote. Answer the concern in writing so it does not travel to the voters unanswered.Product chief. Likes the model; worried about the launch date.Keep informed: No vote, no objection. A short update at each stage is enough.Product chief. Likes the model; worried about the launch date.Vouch: Champions without a vote. Their word with the voters can carry more than the project lead's.COO. Says she has no view yet.Not placed yet.COO. Says she has no view yet.1. Meet first: A vote against. Meet one to one before anyone else, about the concern they named; never let them hear the plan first in the room.COO. Says she has no view yet.3. One step: A vote with no view yet. Find what would move them one column right, and ask for exactly that.What would move her: the support forecast, showing no rise in tickets.COO. Says she has no view yet.2. Early yeses: Supporters with a vote. Get their yes on record early, and ask each to bring one colleague along.COO. Says she has no view yet.Answer it: Opposed, without a vote. Answer the concern in writing so it does not travel to the voters unanswered.COO. Says she has no view yet.Keep informed: No vote, no objection. A short update at each stage is enough.COO. Says she has no view yet.Vouch: Champions without a vote. Their word with the voters can carry more than the project lead's.General counsel. Asked only whether every contract must be rewritten.Not placed yet.General counsel. Asked only whether every contract must be rewritten.1. Meet first: A vote against. Meet one to one before anyone else, about the concern they named; never let them hear the plan first in the room.General counsel. Asked only whether every contract must be rewritten.3. One step: A vote with no view yet. Find what would move them one column right, and ask for exactly that.What would move him: a contract amendment drafted before the vote.General counsel. Asked only whether every contract must be rewritten.2. Early yeses: Supporters with a vote. Get their yes on record early, and ask each to bring one colleague along.General counsel. Asked only whether every contract must be rewritten.Answer it: Opposed, without a vote. Answer the concern in writing so it does not travel to the voters unanswered.General counsel. Asked only whether every contract must be rewritten.Keep informed: No vote, no objection. A short update at each stage is enough.General counsel. Asked only whether every contract must be rewritten.Vouch: Champions without a vote. Their word with the voters can carry more than the project lead's.Head of success. Fears renewal calls will turn into price fights.Not placed yet.Head of success. Fears renewal calls will turn into price fights.1. Meet first: A vote against. Meet one to one before anyone else, about the concern they named; never let them hear the plan first in the room.Head of success. Fears renewal calls will turn into price fights.3. One step: A vote with no view yet. Find what would move them one column right, and ask for exactly that.Head of success. Fears renewal calls will turn into price fights.2. Early yeses: Supporters with a vote. Get their yes on record early, and ask each to bring one colleague along.Head of success. Fears renewal calls will turn into price fights.Answer it: Opposed, without a vote. Answer the concern in writing so it does not travel to the voters unanswered.No vote, but her team talks to every customer. A written script for renewal calls answers her and keeps it from spreading.Head of success. Fears renewal calls will turn into price fights.Keep informed: No vote, no objection. A short update at each stage is enough.Head of success. Fears renewal calls will turn into price fights.Vouch: Champions without a vote. Their word with the voters can carry more than the project lead's.Regional lead. Will follow whatever is decided.Not placed yet.Regional lead. Will follow whatever is decided.1. Meet first: A vote against. Meet one to one before anyone else, about the concern they named; never let them hear the plan first in the room.Regional lead. Will follow whatever is decided.3. One step: A vote with no view yet. Find what would move them one column right, and ask for exactly that.Regional lead. Will follow whatever is decided.2. Early yeses: Supporters with a vote. Get their yes on record early, and ask each to bring one colleague along.Regional lead. Will follow whatever is decided.Answer it: Opposed, without a vote. Answer the concern in writing so it does not travel to the voters unanswered.Regional lead. Will follow whatever is decided.Keep informed: No vote, no objection. A short update at each stage is enough.Monthly updates; nothing to change.Regional lead. Will follow whatever is decided.Vouch: Champions without a vote. Their word with the voters can carry more than the project lead's.Marketing head. Offered to write the customer announcement.Not placed yet.Marketing head. Offered to write the customer announcement.1. Meet first: A vote against. Meet one to one before anyone else, about the concern they named; never let them hear the plan first in the room.Marketing head. Offered to write the customer announcement.3. One step: A vote with no view yet. Find what would move them one column right, and ask for exactly that.Marketing head. Offered to write the customer announcement.2. Early yeses: Supporters with a vote. Get their yes on record early, and ask each to bring one colleague along.Marketing head. Offered to write the customer announcement.Answer it: Opposed, without a vote. Answer the concern in writing so it does not travel to the voters unanswered.Marketing head. Offered to write the customer announcement.Keep informed: No vote, no objection. A short update at each stage is enough.Keep informed, and take the offer.Marketing head. Offered to write the customer announcement.Vouch: Champions without a vote. Their word with the voters can carry more than the project lead's.Pricing analyst. Built the model and knows every number in it.Not placed yet.Pricing analyst. Built the model and knows every number in it.1. Meet first: A vote against. Meet one to one before anyone else, about the concern they named; never let them hear the plan first in the room.Pricing analyst. Built the model and knows every number in it.3. One step: A vote with no view yet. Find what would move them one column right, and ask for exactly that.Pricing analyst. Built the model and knows every number in it.2. Early yeses: Supporters with a vote. Get their yes on record early, and ask each to bring one colleague along.Pricing analyst. Built the model and knows every number in it.Answer it: Opposed, without a vote. Answer the concern in writing so it does not travel to the voters unanswered.Pricing analyst. Built the model and knows every number in it.Keep informed: No vote, no objection. A short update at each stage is enough.Pricing analyst. Built the model and knows every number in it.Vouch: Champions without a vote. Their word with the voters can carry more than the project lead's.Ask her to walk the COO and the counsel through the numbers herself.
Your sort matched 0 of 9.Your sort matched 1 of 9.Your sort matched 2 of 9.Your sort matched 3 of 9.Your sort matched 4 of 9.Your sort matched 5 of 9.Your sort matched 6 of 9.Your sort matched 7 of 9.Your sort matched 8 of 9.Your sort matched 9 of 9.
1. Meet first
A vote against. Meet one to one before anyone else, about the concern they named; never let them hear the plan first in the room.
3. One step
A vote with no view yet. Find what would move them one column right, and ask for exactly that.
2. Early yeses
Supporters with a vote. Get their yes on record early, and ask each to bring one colleague along.
Answer it
Opposed, without a vote. Answer the concern in writing so it does not travel to the voters unanswered.
Keep informed
No vote, no objection. A short update at each stage is enough.
Vouch
Champions without a vote. Their word with the voters can carry more than the project lead's.
The sort
Head of sales: 1. Meet first. What would move him: a commission plan that pays on renewals under the new model. First meeting on the list.
CFO: 2. Early yeses. Already a champion. Ask her to speak first when the committee meets.
Product chief: 2. Early yeses. What would move him: a date after the spring release. Then he speaks for it.
COO: 3. One step. What would move her: the support forecast, showing no rise in tickets.
General counsel: 3. One step. What would move him: a contract amendment drafted before the vote.
Head of success: Answer it. No vote, but her team talks to every customer. A written script for renewal calls answers her and keeps it from spreading.
Regional lead: Keep informed. Monthly updates; nothing to change.
Marketing head: Keep informed. Keep informed, and take the offer.
Pricing analyst: Vouch. Ask her to walk the COO and the counsel through the numbers herself.
An example
A software company's project lead had eight weeks to get a usage-based pricing model through the executive committee. Five executives would vote, and four other people would shape how they voted.
She listed all nine and marked each one's commitment as it stood. The CFO had asked for the review herself. The product chief liked the model but feared it would collide with the spring release. The COO and the general counsel had no view yet. The head of sales was against it, because he thought it would cut his team's commissions. Beside each name she wrote what would move that person one step: a commission plan that paid on renewals, a launch date after the release, a support forecast, a drafted contract amendment.
The order followed. She met the head of sales first and alone, then got the CFO's and the product chief's support on record, then went to the COO with the forecast and to counsel with the amendment. The vote passed four to one, and sales signed off on the commission plan a week later.
Why it works
A decision that needs several people is won or lost one conversation at a time, and in a particular order. Without a map, a project lead talks most to the people who already agree, meets opposition for the first time in the room, and treats a vote as a single event.
The map changes three things. Writing every name down shows the people who matter but were never on the invitation list. Rating each one's commitment, and naming what would move them a single step, turns a vague effort to win support into a short list of specific offers. Ordering the conversations lets each early yes make the next one easier, and makes sure no opponent first hears the proposal in public, where changing position is hardest.
The thinking behind it
Richard Beckhard Richard Beckhard, a founder of organization development who taught at MIT Sloan, and Reuben T. Harris set out in Organizational Transitions: Managing Complex Change (1977) how to plan an organization's move from its present state to a desired one. Their commitment chart maps who must support a change, how committed each person is now, and how committed they need to be, so that effort goes to closing the gaps that matter. The map in the figure is a version of it.
John P. Kotter John P. Kotter, in Leading Change: Why Transformation Efforts Fail (1995, Harvard Business Review) and the book Leading Change (1996), listed the errors that sink major change, drawn from watching more than a hundred companies attempt it. Among his steps is forming a powerful guiding coalition of people with enough position, expertise, and credibility to lead the change. Coalition mapping is how the coalition gets assembled, one person at a time.
How to run it
Define what is being approved. Write the decision, who formally decides it, and the date, in one sentence.
List everyone who matters. Include the voters and the people the voters listen to, such as analysts, deputies, and peers.
Rate each person's commitment today. Use what they have said and done, from opposes to will make it happen, and mark who votes.
Write what would move each one a step. Name the specific concern or interest and the offer that answers it, not a general hope for support.
Order the conversations. Meet strong opponents first and alone, then secure the early yeses, then work the undecided with what they need.
Enlist the champions. Ask supporters to speak to specific colleagues, since their word often carries more than yours.
Update the map every week. Move people as they move, and redo the order when someone shifts or a new name appears.
Where it goes wrong
The ratings are hopes. A neutral is recorded as a supporter because the meeting felt friendly. Rate by what each person has said or done, and treat silence as undecided.
The map leaves out the influencers. The voters are listed, but the deputy who briefs one of them, or the analyst whose numbers they trust, is not. Ask each voter who they will consult before deciding.
The map becomes a secret dossier. If people learn they were rated and worked, trust goes quickly. Keep the notes to concerns and offers you would be comfortable saying aloud to the person, and make every offer one you would make openly.
When to use something else
Power-Interest Grid. When the job is deciding how much attention each group gets over a long project, not winning one vote.
Influence Sociogram. When the question is who influences whom, and the map needs the ties between people.
Interest-Based Bargaining. When the decision comes down to one opponent, and the work is finding what both sides need.