Center of Gravity Analysis

Thinking Tools3.3 Mapping the System Around the ProblemAlso known as Clausewitz's Center of Gravity, Schwerpunkt

From Carl von Clausewitz (On War, 1832), made into a working method by Joe Strange (Centers of Gravity and Critical Vulnerabilities, 1996).

Finds the element a competitor, organization, or plan depends on for its strength, then its weak supports, so effort goes where it will be decisive.

What a rival's dealer network needs, sorted to find the one place to aim

The rival's dealer network passed the test the others failed: without it, the rival could neither sell nor service a machine. Each tag is something the network needs. Place it by whether the network fails without it and whether it can be reached; the top-right box is the critical vulnerability. The first is placed as an example. Illustrative.

Items (select one, then a box)
  • Not placedPlacedAim hereCritical, out of reachEasy, but no effectLeave it
  • Not placedPlacedAim hereCritical, out of reachEasy, but no effectLeave it
  • Not placedPlacedAim hereCritical, out of reachEasy, but no effectLeave it
  • Not placedPlacedAim hereCritical, out of reachEasy, but no effectLeave it
  • Not placedPlacedAim hereCritical, out of reachEasy, but no effectLeave it
  • Not placedPlacedAim hereCritical, out of reachEasy, but no effectLeave it
  • Not placedPlacedAim hereCritical, out of reachEasy, but no effectLeave it
  • Not placedPlacedAim hereCritical, out of reachEasy, but no effectLeave it

Can a competitor reach it?

ExposedWell protected
Easy, but no effect
Aim here
Leave it
Critical, out of reach
Helpful onlyFails without it

Does the network fail without it?

Contracts renewing. Forty of the rival's 120 dealers come off three-year exclusive contracts next year.Not placed yet.Contracts renewing. Forty of the rival's 120 dealers come off three-year exclusive contracts next year.Aim here: Critical and exposed: a critical vulnerability. Effort here can take the whole center down. Check the same point in your own business.Without dealers there is no network, and a third of them are free to choose next year.Contracts renewing. Forty of the rival's 120 dealers come off three-year exclusive contracts next year.Critical, out of reach: The network needs it, but it is well defended. Attacking it wastes the budget; watch it for a change.Contracts renewing. Forty of the rival's 120 dealers come off three-year exclusive contracts next year.Easy, but no effect: Reachable, and tempting, but the network survives without it. Winning here feels like progress and changes little.Contracts renewing. Forty of the rival's 120 dealers come off three-year exclusive contracts next year.Leave it: Neither critical nor reachable.Certified technicians. Every dealer needs a certified technician; there is a waiting list for certification.Not placed yet.Certified technicians. Every dealer needs a certified technician; there is a waiting list for certification.Aim here: Critical and exposed: a critical vulnerability. Effort here can take the whole center down. Check the same point in your own business.No technician, no service, no dealer. And technicians are scarce enough to be hired away with better training.Certified technicians. Every dealer needs a certified technician; there is a waiting list for certification.Critical, out of reach: The network needs it, but it is well defended. Attacking it wastes the budget; watch it for a change.Certified technicians. Every dealer needs a certified technician; there is a waiting list for certification.Easy, but no effect: Reachable, and tempting, but the network survives without it. Winning here feels like progress and changes little.Certified technicians. Every dealer needs a certified technician; there is a waiting list for certification.Leave it: Neither critical nor reachable.Parts depot in reach. The rival owns four depots, each within a day's drive of every dealer, with deep stock.Not placed yet.Parts depot in reach. The rival owns four depots, each within a day's drive of every dealer, with deep stock.Aim here: Critical and exposed: a critical vulnerability. Effort here can take the whole center down. Check the same point in your own business.Parts depot in reach. The rival owns four depots, each within a day's drive of every dealer, with deep stock.Critical, out of reach: The network needs it, but it is well defended. Attacking it wastes the budget; watch it for a change.Essential to next-day service, and owned outright: there is nothing to win here.Parts depot in reach. The rival owns four depots, each within a day's drive of every dealer, with deep stock.Easy, but no effect: Reachable, and tempting, but the network survives without it. Winning here feels like progress and changes little.Parts depot in reach. The rival owns four depots, each within a day's drive of every dealer, with deep stock.Leave it: Neither critical nor reachable.Its own finance arm. Dealers buy stock on credit from the rival's finance company.Not placed yet.Its own finance arm. Dealers buy stock on credit from the rival's finance company.Aim here: Critical and exposed: a critical vulnerability. Effort here can take the whole center down. Check the same point in your own business.Its own finance arm. Dealers buy stock on credit from the rival's finance company.Critical, out of reach: The network needs it, but it is well defended. Attacking it wastes the budget; watch it for a change.Dealers could not carry stock without it, but it is the rival's own balance sheet.Its own finance arm. Dealers buy stock on credit from the rival's finance company.Easy, but no effect: Reachable, and tempting, but the network survives without it. Winning here feels like progress and changes little.Its own finance arm. Dealers buy stock on credit from the rival's finance company.Leave it: Neither critical nor reachable.National TV campaign. The rival runs ads during farm reports every spring.Not placed yet.National TV campaign. The rival runs ads during farm reports every spring.Aim here: Critical and exposed: a critical vulnerability. Effort here can take the whole center down. Check the same point in your own business.National TV campaign. The rival runs ads during farm reports every spring.Critical, out of reach: The network needs it, but it is well defended. Attacking it wastes the budget; watch it for a change.National TV campaign. The rival runs ads during farm reports every spring.Easy, but no effect: Reachable, and tempting, but the network survives without it. Winning here feels like progress and changes little.Easy to outspend for a season, and the dealers keep selling without it.National TV campaign. The rival runs ads during farm reports every spring.Leave it: Neither critical nor reachable.Online price builder. Buyers can configure a machine on the rival's website.Not placed yet.Online price builder. Buyers can configure a machine on the rival's website.Aim here: Critical and exposed: a critical vulnerability. Effort here can take the whole center down. Check the same point in your own business.Online price builder. Buyers can configure a machine on the rival's website.Critical, out of reach: The network needs it, but it is well defended. Attacking it wastes the budget; watch it for a change.Online price builder. Buyers can configure a machine on the rival's website.Easy, but no effect: Reachable, and tempting, but the network survives without it. Winning here feels like progress and changes little.Easy to copy and beat, and buyers still sign at the dealer.Online price builder. Buyers can configure a machine on the rival's website.Leave it: Neither critical nor reachable.Dealer conference. A three-day event for dealers each winter.Not placed yet.Dealer conference. A three-day event for dealers each winter.Aim here: Critical and exposed: a critical vulnerability. Effort here can take the whole center down. Check the same point in your own business.Dealer conference. A three-day event for dealers each winter.Critical, out of reach: The network needs it, but it is well defended. Attacking it wastes the budget; watch it for a change.Dealer conference. A three-day event for dealers each winter.Easy, but no effect: Reachable, and tempting, but the network survives without it. Winning here feels like progress and changes little.Dealer conference. A three-day event for dealers each winter.Leave it: Neither critical nor reachable.Good for morale; the network runs fine without it, and it cannot be touched.Farmer loyalty points. Farmers earn points on parts purchases.Not placed yet.Farmer loyalty points. Farmers earn points on parts purchases.Aim here: Critical and exposed: a critical vulnerability. Effort here can take the whole center down. Check the same point in your own business.Farmer loyalty points. Farmers earn points on parts purchases.Critical, out of reach: The network needs it, but it is well defended. Attacking it wastes the budget; watch it for a change.Farmer loyalty points. Farmers earn points on parts purchases.Easy, but no effect: Reachable, and tempting, but the network survives without it. Winning here feels like progress and changes little.Farmer loyalty points. Farmers earn points on parts purchases.Leave it: Neither critical nor reachable.Few farmers choose a dealer for points, and the program is the rival's to run.

Your sort matched 0 of 8.Your sort matched 1 of 8.Your sort matched 2 of 8.Your sort matched 3 of 8.Your sort matched 4 of 8.Your sort matched 5 of 8.Your sort matched 6 of 8.Your sort matched 7 of 8.Your sort matched 8 of 8.

Aim here
Critical and exposed: a critical vulnerability. Effort here can take the whole center down. Check the same point in your own business.
Critical, out of reach
The network needs it, but it is well defended. Attacking it wastes the budget; watch it for a change.
Easy, but no effect
Reachable, and tempting, but the network survives without it. Winning here feels like progress and changes little.
Leave it
Neither critical nor reachable.

The sort

  • Contracts renewing: Aim here. Without dealers there is no network, and a third of them are free to choose next year.
  • Certified technicians: Aim here. No technician, no service, no dealer. And technicians are scarce enough to be hired away with better training.
  • Parts depot in reach: Critical, out of reach. Essential to next-day service, and owned outright: there is nothing to win here.
  • Its own finance arm: Critical, out of reach. Dealers could not carry stock without it, but it is the rival's own balance sheet.
  • National TV campaign: Easy, but no effect. Easy to outspend for a season, and the dealers keep selling without it.
  • Online price builder: Easy, but no effect. Easy to copy and beat, and buyers still sign at the dealer.
  • Dealer conference: Leave it. Good for morale; the network runs fine without it, and it cannot be touched.
  • Farmer loyalty points: Leave it. Few farmers choose a dealer for points, and the program is the rival's to run.

An example

A maker of small farm machinery had a third of its larger rival's sales and a marketing budget to match. Its leadership team had a list of eleven ways to compete, from television to a new website, and money for perhaps two.

The strategy lead asked a different question first: what does the rival's strength actually rest on? Three candidates came up: its brand, its low prices, and its 120 dealers. The test was blunt. If the rival lost this, would it still win? Without the brand, the dealers would still sell. Without the low prices, the dealers would still service. Without the dealers, it could neither sell nor fix a machine. The network was the center.

The team then listed what the network needed to work and found two weak supports: forty dealer contracts came up for renewal next year, and every dealer depended on one certified technician who was hard to replace. The plan became a better contract offer for those forty dealers and a free technician academy. The team also checked its own dealers' renewal dates.

Why it works

Effort spread evenly across every front produces even, small results. Most organizations, plans, and rivals depend on one element more than the rest, and harm to everything else is survivable while harm to that element is not. The collapse test separates the real source of strength from things that are merely large or visible.

The second half of the method matters as much. The center itself is usually the best-defended thing in the system, so a frontal attack on it fails. Working down from what the center does, to what it needs, to which of those needs is weak, finds a point that is both decisive and reachable. The same walk, done on your own side, shows what to protect.

The thinking behind it

Carl von Clausewitz Carl von Clausewitz, a Prussian general and military theorist, wrote in On War (1832), published after his death by his widow Marie von Clausewitz, of the center of gravity: the hub of power and movement on which everything depends, and the point against which all energy should be directed. He treated war as the continuation of policy by other means, which is part of why the idea carries over to competition between firms and to campaigns of change inside one.

Joseph L. Strange Joseph L. Strange, in Centers of Gravity and Critical Vulnerabilities (1996, Marine Corps University), turned the idea into an analytic sequence: identify the center of gravity, then the critical capabilities through which it acts, then the critical requirements those capabilities depend on, then the critical vulnerabilities among those requirements. His framework underpins most modern center-of-gravity analysis in military planning, and it is the descent the figure walks.

How to run it

  1. Choose the system. Name whose strength is being analyzed: a rival, a coalition opposing a change, or your own organization.
  2. List the candidate centers. Write down every element someone in the room believes the system's strength rests on.
  3. Apply the collapse test. For each candidate ask: if it were gone, would the system still win? Keep the one whose loss ends the contest.
  4. Name what the center does. List its critical capabilities, the few actions through which it exerts strength.
  5. List what those actions need. Write every resource, relationship, and condition each capability depends on, with its current state.
  6. Find the weak requirements. Mark those that are both essential and exposed; these are the critical vulnerabilities to aim at.
  7. Turn the analysis on yourself. Run the same walk on your own center of gravity and protect the weak supports you find there.

Where it goes wrong

The center is picked by size. The biggest budget line or the loudest brand gets named because it is visible, and the collapse test is skipped. Run the test aloud for every candidate, including the obvious one.

The team attacks the center head on. Having found it, people aim straight at it, at its best-defended point, and lose. Keep going down to the requirements before choosing where to act.

The rival is treated as static. Once one weak support is exploited, the rival shores it up, and the analysis goes stale. Revisit the requirements after each move, and assume the rival is running the same analysis on you.

When to use something else

  • Porter's Five Forces. When the question is how attractive the industry is for everyone in it, not where one rival can be beaten.
  • Sun Tzu's Principles of Strategy. When the contest is uneven and the smaller side needs ways to avoid fighting on the larger side's terms.
  • Theory of Constraints. When the system to analyze is your own process, and the weak point is the step that limits its output.

Where it sits in SOLVE eX

Go to the source

  • On War (Vom Kriege), 1832
  • Centers of Gravity and Critical Vulnerabilities, 1996

Back to the catalog