SECI Model

Thinking Tools3.3 Mapping the System Around the ProblemAlso known as Knowledge spiral

Developed by Ikujiro Nonaka (1994) and by Nonaka and Hirotaka Takeuchi (The Knowledge-Creating Company, 1995), on the tacit dimension of Michael Polanyi (1966).

Sorts how knowledge moves in an organization into four conversions between tacit and explicit forms, showing which conversion a knowledge system is missing.

Eight ways an elevator service firm passes on know-how, sorted into the four conversions

Each activity moves knowledge from one form to another: tacit (in people's heads and hands) or explicit (written down). The first is placed as an example. Select each other activity, then the box for the conversion it performs. Show the sort: the box with almost nothing in it is the conversion the firm is missing. Illustrative.

Items (select one, then a box)
  • Not placedPlacedSocializationExternalizationCombinationInternalization
  • Not placedPlacedSocializationExternalizationCombinationInternalization
  • Not placedPlacedSocializationExternalizationCombinationInternalization
  • Not placedPlacedSocializationExternalizationCombinationInternalization
  • Not placedPlacedSocializationExternalizationCombinationInternalization
  • Not placedPlacedSocializationExternalizationCombinationInternalization
  • Not placedPlacedSocializationExternalizationCombinationInternalization
  • Not placedPlacedSocializationExternalizationCombinationInternalization

From

TacitExplicit
Socialization
Externalization
Internalization
Combination
TacitExplicit

Into

Shadowing a senior tech.Not placed yet.Shadowing a senior tech.Socialization: Tacit to tacit: know-how passed by working side by side. Strong for one apprentice at a time, and none of it is written down.Watching and copying passes skill directly from one head to another, with nothing written down.Shadowing a senior tech.Externalization: Tacit to explicit: putting what experts sense into words, through metaphor, analogy, and models. The hardest conversion, and the one that builds new shared knowledge.Shadowing a senior tech.Combination: Explicit to explicit: sorting, merging, and spreading what is already written. Fast and scalable, but it only recombines what someone has already put into words.Shadowing a senior tech.Internalization: Explicit to tacit: practicing what is written until it becomes skill. Without it, documents sit unread.Night call ride-alongs.Not placed yet.Night call ride-alongs.Socialization: Tacit to tacit: know-how passed by working side by side. Strong for one apprentice at a time, and none of it is written down.Shared experience under real conditions, the purest tacit-to-tacit transfer.Night call ride-alongs.Externalization: Tacit to explicit: putting what experts sense into words, through metaphor, analogy, and models. The hardest conversion, and the one that builds new shared knowledge.Night call ride-alongs.Combination: Explicit to explicit: sorting, merging, and spreading what is already written. Fast and scalable, but it only recombines what someone has already put into words.Night call ride-alongs.Internalization: Explicit to tacit: practicing what is written until it becomes skill. Without it, documents sit unread.War stories over lunch.Not placed yet.War stories over lunch.Socialization: Tacit to tacit: know-how passed by working side by side. Strong for one apprentice at a time, and none of it is written down.Stories pass judgment from person to person, but only to whoever is at the table.War stories over lunch.Externalization: Tacit to explicit: putting what experts sense into words, through metaphor, analogy, and models. The hardest conversion, and the one that builds new shared knowledge.War stories over lunch.Combination: Explicit to explicit: sorting, merging, and spreading what is already written. Fast and scalable, but it only recombines what someone has already put into words.War stories over lunch.Internalization: Explicit to tacit: practicing what is written until it becomes skill. Without it, documents sit unread.Repair logs merged.Not placed yet.Repair logs merged.Socialization: Tacit to tacit: know-how passed by working side by side. Strong for one apprentice at a time, and none of it is written down.Repair logs merged.Externalization: Tacit to explicit: putting what experts sense into words, through metaphor, analogy, and models. The hardest conversion, and the one that builds new shared knowledge.Repair logs merged.Combination: Explicit to explicit: sorting, merging, and spreading what is already written. Fast and scalable, but it only recombines what someone has already put into words.Written records combined into a new written whole: explicit to explicit.Repair logs merged.Internalization: Explicit to tacit: practicing what is written until it becomes skill. Without it, documents sit unread.Manuals made into a wiki.Not placed yet.Manuals made into a wiki.Socialization: Tacit to tacit: know-how passed by working side by side. Strong for one apprentice at a time, and none of it is written down.Manuals made into a wiki.Externalization: Tacit to explicit: putting what experts sense into words, through metaphor, analogy, and models. The hardest conversion, and the one that builds new shared knowledge.Manuals made into a wiki.Combination: Explicit to explicit: sorting, merging, and spreading what is already written. Fast and scalable, but it only recombines what someone has already put into words.Existing documents reorganized and spread: useful, and nothing new enters.Manuals made into a wiki.Internalization: Explicit to tacit: practicing what is written until it becomes skill. Without it, documents sit unread.Monthly fault dashboard.Not placed yet.Monthly fault dashboard.Socialization: Tacit to tacit: know-how passed by working side by side. Strong for one apprentice at a time, and none of it is written down.Monthly fault dashboard.Externalization: Tacit to explicit: putting what experts sense into words, through metaphor, analogy, and models. The hardest conversion, and the one that builds new shared knowledge.Monthly fault dashboard.Combination: Explicit to explicit: sorting, merging, and spreading what is already written. Fast and scalable, but it only recombines what someone has already put into words.Numbers already recorded, summarized for managers.Monthly fault dashboard.Internalization: Explicit to tacit: practicing what is written until it becomes skill. Without it, documents sit unread.Drills on a test rig.Not placed yet.Drills on a test rig.Socialization: Tacit to tacit: know-how passed by working side by side. Strong for one apprentice at a time, and none of it is written down.Drills on a test rig.Externalization: Tacit to explicit: putting what experts sense into words, through metaphor, analogy, and models. The hardest conversion, and the one that builds new shared knowledge.Drills on a test rig.Combination: Explicit to explicit: sorting, merging, and spreading what is already written. Fast and scalable, but it only recombines what someone has already put into words.Drills on a test rig.Internalization: Explicit to tacit: practicing what is written until it becomes skill. Without it, documents sit unread.Written procedures practiced until they become feel and reflex.Sounds told by analogy.Not placed yet.Sounds told by analogy.Socialization: Tacit to tacit: know-how passed by working side by side. Strong for one apprentice at a time, and none of it is written down.Sounds told by analogy.Externalization: Tacit to explicit: putting what experts sense into words, through metaphor, analogy, and models. The hardest conversion, and the one that builds new shared knowledge.A senior tech's ear for a failing motor, put into words a novice can use: the only externalization the firm does, and it happens by chance.Sounds told by analogy.Combination: Explicit to explicit: sorting, merging, and spreading what is already written. Fast and scalable, but it only recombines what someone has already put into words.Sounds told by analogy.Internalization: Explicit to tacit: practicing what is written until it becomes skill. Without it, documents sit unread.

Your sort matched 0 of 8.Your sort matched 1 of 8.Your sort matched 2 of 8.Your sort matched 3 of 8.Your sort matched 4 of 8.Your sort matched 5 of 8.Your sort matched 6 of 8.Your sort matched 7 of 8.Your sort matched 8 of 8.

Socialization
Tacit to tacit: know-how passed by working side by side. Strong for one apprentice at a time, and none of it is written down.
Externalization
Tacit to explicit: putting what experts sense into words, through metaphor, analogy, and models. The hardest conversion, and the one that builds new shared knowledge.
Combination
Explicit to explicit: sorting, merging, and spreading what is already written. Fast and scalable, but it only recombines what someone has already put into words.
Internalization
Explicit to tacit: practicing what is written until it becomes skill. Without it, documents sit unread.

The sort

  • Shadowing a senior tech: Socialization. Watching and copying passes skill directly from one head to another, with nothing written down.
  • Night call ride-alongs: Socialization. Shared experience under real conditions, the purest tacit-to-tacit transfer.
  • War stories over lunch: Socialization. Stories pass judgment from person to person, but only to whoever is at the table.
  • Repair logs merged: Combination. Written records combined into a new written whole: explicit to explicit.
  • Manuals made into a wiki: Combination. Existing documents reorganized and spread: useful, and nothing new enters.
  • Monthly fault dashboard: Combination. Numbers already recorded, summarized for managers.
  • Drills on a test rig: Internalization. Written procedures practiced until they become feel and reflex.
  • Sounds told by analogy: Externalization. A senior tech's ear for a failing motor, put into words a novice can use: the only externalization the firm does, and it happens by chance.

An example

A 300-technician elevator service firm expected a fifth of its seniors to retire within four years. The training director had a wiki, a database of ten years of repair logs, and a dashboard of faults by model. New technicians still took three years to handle a callout alone, and the seniors kept saying the hard part could not be written down.

She listed every way know-how moved and sorted each by its conversion. Shadowing, night ride-alongs, and lunch stories all passed skill from head to head. The wiki, the database, and the dashboard moved written knowledge into other written forms. A test rig let trainees practice the procedures. Only one thing turned what the seniors sensed into words, and it happened by chance: a veteran describing a failing motor as sounding like a coffee grinder with a stone in it. She set up monthly sessions where seniors were interviewed about hard calls and pushed for comparisons like that one. The results went into the wiki and onto the rig, and time to a first solo callout began to fall.

Why it works

Most knowledge programs invest in the conversion that is easiest to buy: software that stores, sorts, and spreads documents. That only recombines what someone already wrote. The skill that matters, such as hearing a failing motor, lives in people and moves in other ways, and a firm can be rich in documents and poor in the know-how that counts.

Sorting activities by conversion shows the gap. Each of the four moves something different. Working side by side passes skill to one person at a time; putting experience into words, usually through metaphor and analogy, makes it shareable; combining documents spreads it; practice turns it back into skill in new people. Knowledge grows when it passes through all four in turn, so the missing conversion is where to spend next.

The thinking behind it

Ikujiro Nonaka Ikujiro Nonaka, a theorist of knowledge management at Hitotsubashi University, set out the model in A Dynamic Theory of Organizational Knowledge Creation (1994), in Organization Science. Organizational knowledge, in his account, grows in a spiral between tacit and explicit forms through four conversions: socialization, externalization, combination, and internalization. Critics question whether a model drawn from Japanese firms applies elsewhere, and whether knowledge must pass through the four modes in that order.

Hirotaka Takeuchi Hirotaka Takeuchi, a Japanese management scholar later at Harvard Business School, wrote The Knowledge-Creating Company (1995) with Nonaka. The book carried the SECI model to a wide management readership. Its central picture is a spiral: knowledge moves between tacit and explicit forms through the four conversions, and the spiral widens as the knowledge passes from individuals to groups and then to the organization as a whole.

Michael Polanyi Michael Polanyi, a Hungarian-British chemist turned philosopher, argued in The Tacit Dimension (1966) that we know more than we can tell. His distinction between tacit knowledge, held in skill and practice, and explicit knowledge, which can be stated, is the base on which Nonaka and Takeuchi built the model. An expert can recognize a failing machine without being able to say how, and that gap between knowing and telling is what the second conversion works on.

How to run it

  1. Name the knowledge problem. State it as a cost, such as three years to a technician's first solo callout.
  2. List how know-how moves today. Include the informal ways: shadowing, stories, side conversations, as well as documents and systems.
  3. Sort each into a conversion. Tacit to tacit, tacit to explicit, explicit to explicit, or explicit to tacit.
  4. Find the empty or thin box. The conversion with least activity, or only accidental activity, is the gap.
  5. Design for the gap. Shadowing builds socialization, metaphor sessions with experts build externalization, synthesis builds combination, and drills build internalization.
  6. Run the knowledge through all four. Link the activities so each one feeds the next: interview an expert, write it up, combine it with what exists, practice it, and start again.

Where it goes wrong

The common failure is buying combination and calling it knowledge management. A new platform reorganizes the documents and leaves the know-how where it was. If the system is full and new hires are no faster, look at the conversions that involve people.

The second is forcing experts to write procedures. Asked for steps, they write down the easy parts and leave out the judgment. Interview them about hard cases and press for comparisons; the analogy often carries what the procedure cannot.

The third is treating the four as a strict sequence. Knowledge does not always move in that order, and the model drew on a particular set of firms. Use it to find the missing conversion, and expect the cycle to look different in each organization.

When to use something else

  • Cognitive Apprenticeship. When the task is teaching an expert's hidden reasoning to a novice through modeling, coaching, and gradually removed support.
  • After-Action Review. When the knowledge to capture comes from a specific event that just ended, while memories are fresh.
  • Double-Loop Learning. When the problem is that the organization keeps learning the same lesson and never changes the assumptions behind it.

Where it sits in SOLVE eX

Go to the source

  • A Dynamic Theory of Organizational Knowledge Creation, Organization Science, 1994
  • The Knowledge-Creating Company, 1995
  • The Tacit Dimension, 1966

Back to the catalog