Function Analysis

Thinking Tools3.3 Mapping the System Around the ProblemAlso known as Function Modeling, Function-Cost Analysis

Grew from Lawrence D. Miles's value analysis at General Electric (Techniques of Value Analysis and Engineering, 1961), rebuilt as function analysis by the TRIZ school of the 1980s, and set out by Darrell Mann (Hands-On Systematic Innovation, 2002).

Maps a product, service, or process as components joined by the functions they perform, tagging each function useful, harmful, too weak, or excessive to show where value leaks.

Eight functions of an office coffee machine, tagged by whether they are wanted and how strong they are

Each tag is one thing a part does to another, written as a verb and an object. Select one, then the box that fits: wanted or not, and too weak, right, or too much. Harmful and excessive functions are the first redesign targets. Show the sort to compare yours. Illustrative.

Items (select one, then a box)
  • Not placedPlacedToo weakUsefulExcessiveHarmful
  • Not placedPlacedToo weakUsefulExcessiveHarmful
  • Not placedPlacedToo weakUsefulExcessiveHarmful
  • Not placedPlacedToo weakUsefulExcessiveHarmful
  • Not placedPlacedToo weakUsefulExcessiveHarmful
  • Not placedPlacedToo weakUsefulExcessiveHarmful
  • Not placedPlacedToo weakUsefulExcessiveHarmful
  • Not placedPlacedToo weakUsefulExcessiveHarmful

Is it wanted?

WantedUnwanted
Too weak
Useful
Excessive
Harmful
Too weakAbout rightToo much

How strong the effect is

Hard water coats heater. Minerals in the water settle on the heating element as scale.Not placed yet.Hard water coats heater. Minerals in the water settle on the heating element as scale.Too weak: A function the machine needs, delivered short. Find what is holding it back before adding power.Hard water coats heater. Minerals in the water settle on the heating element as scale.Useful: Wanted and the right size. Leave it alone, and protect it during the redesign.Hard water coats heater. Minerals in the water settle on the heating element as scale.Excessive: Wanted, but more than anyone needs. Money and energy spent past the point of use: shrink it.Hard water coats heater. Minerals in the water settle on the heating element as scale.Harmful: Nobody wants it, at any strength. Remove it, block it, or turn it into something useful. A top redesign target.No one designed it, and it insulates the heater, which is why the coffee comes out lukewarm. Tagged harmful, it leads straight to the weak function it causes.Heater heats the water. Water leaves the heater at 82 degrees; good coffee needs about 92.Not placed yet.Heater heats the water. Water leaves the heater at 82 degrees; good coffee needs about 92.Too weak: A function the machine needs, delivered short. Find what is holding it back before adding power.Needed, and short by ten degrees. A bigger heater would only feed the scale; clearing the scale restores it.Heater heats the water. Water leaves the heater at 82 degrees; good coffee needs about 92.Useful: Wanted and the right size. Leave it alone, and protect it during the redesign.Heater heats the water. Water leaves the heater at 82 degrees; good coffee needs about 92.Excessive: Wanted, but more than anyone needs. Money and energy spent past the point of use: shrink it.Heater heats the water. Water leaves the heater at 82 degrees; good coffee needs about 92.Harmful: Nobody wants it, at any strength. Remove it, block it, or turn it into something useful. A top redesign target.Pump pushes water. Steady pressure through the coffee, within the maker's range.Not placed yet.Pump pushes water. Steady pressure through the coffee, within the maker's range.Too weak: A function the machine needs, delivered short. Find what is holding it back before adding power.Pump pushes water. Steady pressure through the coffee, within the maker's range.Useful: Wanted and the right size. Leave it alone, and protect it during the redesign.Wanted and the right size. Keep it as it is.Pump pushes water. Steady pressure through the coffee, within the maker's range.Excessive: Wanted, but more than anyone needs. Money and energy spent past the point of use: shrink it.Pump pushes water. Steady pressure through the coffee, within the maker's range.Harmful: Nobody wants it, at any strength. Remove it, block it, or turn it into something useful. A top redesign target.Grinder grinds beans. Fresh grounds for every cup, at the setting the beans need.Not placed yet.Grinder grinds beans. Fresh grounds for every cup, at the setting the beans need.Too weak: A function the machine needs, delivered short. Find what is holding it back before adding power.Grinder grinds beans. Fresh grounds for every cup, at the setting the beans need.Useful: Wanted and the right size. Leave it alone, and protect it during the redesign.Wanted and right. No complaints trace to it.Grinder grinds beans. Fresh grounds for every cup, at the setting the beans need.Excessive: Wanted, but more than anyone needs. Money and energy spent past the point of use: shrink it.Grinder grinds beans. Fresh grounds for every cup, at the setting the beans need.Harmful: Nobody wants it, at any strength. Remove it, block it, or turn it into something useful. A top redesign target.Filter softens water. The cartridge lasts three weeks; offices change it every three months.Not placed yet.Filter softens water. The cartridge lasts three weeks; offices change it every three months.Too weak: A function the machine needs, delivered short. Find what is holding it back before adding power.Wanted, and spent most of the time, which is how the scale builds. A larger cartridge with a reminder fixes it.Filter softens water. The cartridge lasts three weeks; offices change it every three months.Useful: Wanted and the right size. Leave it alone, and protect it during the redesign.Filter softens water. The cartridge lasts three weeks; offices change it every three months.Excessive: Wanted, but more than anyone needs. Money and energy spent past the point of use: shrink it.Filter softens water. The cartridge lasts three weeks; offices change it every three months.Harmful: Nobody wants it, at any strength. Remove it, block it, or turn it into something useful. A top redesign target.Hot plate heats the jug. Keeps brewed coffee at 85 degrees for up to four hours.Not placed yet.Hot plate heats the jug. Keeps brewed coffee at 85 degrees for up to four hours.Too weak: A function the machine needs, delivered short. Find what is holding it back before adding power.Hot plate heats the jug. Keeps brewed coffee at 85 degrees for up to four hours.Useful: Wanted and the right size. Leave it alone, and protect it during the redesign.Hot plate heats the jug. Keeps brewed coffee at 85 degrees for up to four hours.Excessive: Wanted, but more than anyone needs. Money and energy spent past the point of use: shrink it.Wanted warmth, far past what anyone needs: it burns the coffee and runs all day. A thermal jug does the job without power.Hot plate heats the jug. Keeps brewed coffee at 85 degrees for up to four hours.Harmful: Nobody wants it, at any strength. Remove it, block it, or turn it into something useful. A top redesign target.Screen offers 14 drinks. Most offices use three of the fourteen.Not placed yet.Screen offers 14 drinks. Most offices use three of the fourteen.Too weak: A function the machine needs, delivered short. Find what is holding it back before adding power.Screen offers 14 drinks. Most offices use three of the fourteen.Useful: Wanted and the right size. Leave it alone, and protect it during the redesign.Screen offers 14 drinks. Most offices use three of the fourteen.Excessive: Wanted, but more than anyone needs. Money and energy spent past the point of use: shrink it.More than people use, and the large screen is the machine's most expensive part to replace.Screen offers 14 drinks. Most offices use three of the fourteen.Harmful: Nobody wants it, at any strength. Remove it, block it, or turn it into something useful. A top redesign target.Spills rust the frame. The drip tray overflows and water runs into the base.Not placed yet.Spills rust the frame. The drip tray overflows and water runs into the base.Too weak: A function the machine needs, delivered short. Find what is holding it back before adding power.Spills rust the frame. The drip tray overflows and water runs into the base.Useful: Wanted and the right size. Leave it alone, and protect it during the redesign.Spills rust the frame. The drip tray overflows and water runs into the base.Excessive: Wanted, but more than anyone needs. Money and energy spent past the point of use: shrink it.Spills rust the frame. The drip tray overflows and water runs into the base.Harmful: Nobody wants it, at any strength. Remove it, block it, or turn it into something useful. A top redesign target.Unwanted at any strength, and the second most common reason for a service call.

Your sort matched 0 of 8.Your sort matched 1 of 8.Your sort matched 2 of 8.Your sort matched 3 of 8.Your sort matched 4 of 8.Your sort matched 5 of 8.Your sort matched 6 of 8.Your sort matched 7 of 8.Your sort matched 8 of 8.

Too weak
A function the machine needs, delivered short. Find what is holding it back before adding power.
Useful
Wanted and the right size. Leave it alone, and protect it during the redesign.
Excessive
Wanted, but more than anyone needs. Money and energy spent past the point of use: shrink it.
Harmful
Nobody wants it, at any strength. Remove it, block it, or turn it into something useful. A top redesign target.

The sort

  • Hard water coats heater: Harmful. No one designed it, and it insulates the heater, which is why the coffee comes out lukewarm. Tagged harmful, it leads straight to the weak function it causes.
  • Heater heats the water: Too weak. Needed, and short by ten degrees. A bigger heater would only feed the scale; clearing the scale restores it.
  • Pump pushes water: Useful. Wanted and the right size. Keep it as it is.
  • Grinder grinds beans: Useful. Wanted and right. No complaints trace to it.
  • Filter softens water: Too weak. Wanted, and spent most of the time, which is how the scale builds. A larger cartridge with a reminder fixes it.
  • Hot plate heats the jug: Excessive. Wanted warmth, far past what anyone needs: it burns the coffee and runs all day. A thermal jug does the job without power.
  • Screen offers 14 drinks: Excessive. More than people use, and the large screen is the machine's most expensive part to replace.
  • Spills rust the frame: Harmful. Unwanted at any strength, and the second most common reason for a service call.

An example

A company that leases coffee machines to offices was losing money on its largest model: service calls cost more than the lease brought in. The usual cost review had looked at the parts list and found nothing to cut, since every part seemed necessary.

The product team ran a function analysis instead. They listed each component and what it does to another, as a verb and an object, then tagged each function. Two functions nobody had designed turned out to drive most of the calls: hard water coating the heater with scale, and an overflowing drip tray rusting the frame. The scale explained the most common complaint, lukewarm coffee, because it weakened the heater, and the filter meant to prevent it was spent most of the time. Two functions were overdone: a hot plate that burned coffee all day, and a screen offering fourteen drinks to offices that used three. The redesign added a larger filter with a change reminder, a deeper drip tray, a thermal jug in place of the hot plate, and a smaller screen.

Why it works

A parts list hides the problem, because every part looks necessary. A list of functions shows what each part does to another, and once each function is written as a verb and an object it can be judged: is this wanted, and is it the right size? Most cost and most complaints trace to a few functions that are harmful, too weak, or overdone, and they stay invisible until someone writes them down.

The four tags also order the redesign. A harmful function is a target in itself, and it often explains a weak one nearby, as scale on a heater explains lukewarm coffee. An excessive function is money spent past the point of use. A function that is wanted and the right size is left alone, which keeps a cost exercise from cutting what works.

The thinking behind it

Lawrence D. Miles Lawrence D. Miles, an engineer at General Electric, devised value analysis in 1947, the origin of value engineering, and set it out in Techniques of Value Analysis and Engineering (McGraw-Hill, 1961). Its core move is to describe each part of a product by the function it performs, in a verb and a noun, and then to look for the lowest-cost way to perform that function reliably. Writing the job a part does in place of the part's name turns a parts list into a list of jobs, each of which can be priced and questioned.

Darrell Mann Darrell Mann, an engineer and TRIZ practitioner, set out function analysis in Hands-On Systematic Innovation (CREAX Press, 2002), the handbook that updates Genrich Altshuller's theory of inventive problem solving with function analysis, trimming, the ideal final result, and the separation principles. The TRIZ form of the method, rebuilt from value analysis in the 1980s, tags each function useful, harmful, too weak, or excessive, and draws them all on one diagram so the problems show where they sit.

How to run it

  1. List every component. Include the parts, what they handle, and outside things that act on them, such as hard water or the user.
  2. Write each function as verb and object. Component, verb, target: the pump pushes water, scale coats the heater.
  3. Tag each function. Useful and the right size, too weak, excessive, or harmful.
  4. Draw them on one diagram. Components as boxes and functions as arrows, each tag in its own line style.
  5. Find the chains. Look for a harmful function behind a weak one; fixing the first often fixes the second.
  6. Target harmful and excessive functions first. Remove, block, or shrink them before adding anything new.
  7. Redesign and redraw. Draw the diagram again after the change to confirm no new harmful function appeared.

Where it goes wrong

The first failure is listing parts and calling it function analysis. A component list with costs is a bill of materials, and without verbs and targets nothing on it can be judged. Spot it when the diagram has boxes but no labeled arrows.

The second is leaving out the harmful functions nobody designed, such as scale, heat, vibration, or a confused user, because they appear on no drawing. Ask what acts on each component that no one intended. The third is cutting by tag alone. A function marked excessive for one customer may be exactly right for another, so check each tag with the people who use the machine before removing anything.

When to use something else

  • TRIZ Trimming. When the diagram is done and the aim is to remove whole components by handing their functions to parts that stay.
  • TRIZ Inventive Principles. When a harmful function cannot be removed without losing a useful one, and the conflict needs an inventive way out.
  • Value Stream Mapping. When the system is a process of steps and waits, and the waste lies in how the work flows.

Where it sits in SOLVE eX

Go to the source

  • Techniques of Value Analysis and Engineering, McGraw-Hill, 1961
  • Hands-On Systematic Innovation, CREAX Press, 2002

Back to the catalog