Developed at McKinsey by Robert H. Waterman Jr., Thomas J. Peters, and Julien R. Phillips (Structure Is Not Organization, 1980), with Richard T. Pascale and Anthony G. Athos.
Checks an organization's alignment across strategy, structure, systems, shared values, style, staff, and skills, and produces a list of gaps between its current and required state.
Seven elements of a software firm moving to subscriptions, and the gaps between them
The strategy has already moved to subscriptions; the other six elements still fit the old license business. Each line names a gap and how long that element takes to move. Switch the other six to their required state, one at a time, and watch the gaps close; the four soft elements take years. Illustrative.
Strategy (hard)
Structure (hard)
Systems (hard)
Shared values (soft)
Style (soft)
Staff (soft)
Skills (soft)
- No gap between the strategy and the other six elements.Structure lags: product teams own the first sale and nobody owns the renewal. Hard: a reorganization, one or two quarters.Systems lag: billing invoices once per deal and cannot report churn. Hard: about two quarters to replace.Shared values lag: closing is what the firm admires, so renewals feel like admin. Soft: the slowest to move, two years or more.Style lags: leaders ring the bell for big signings and never for a renewal. Soft: a year of changed habits at the top.Staff lags: every seller is a hunter paid on the first year. Soft: new roles and pay plans, a year or more.Skills lag: sellers pitch features, and nobody can show value in use. Soft: a year of training and hiring.All seven point the same way. Budget the three hard elements in quarters and the four soft ones in years.
- No gap between the strategy and the other six elements.Structure lags: product teams own the first sale and nobody owns the renewal. Hard: a reorganization, one or two quarters.Systems lag: billing invoices once per deal and cannot report churn. Hard: about two quarters to replace.Shared values lag: closing is what the firm admires, so renewals feel like admin. Soft: the slowest to move, two years or more.Style lags: leaders ring the bell for big signings and never for a renewal. Soft: a year of changed habits at the top.Staff lags: every seller is a hunter paid on the first year. Soft: new roles and pay plans, a year or more.Skills lag: sellers pitch features, and nobody can show value in use. Soft: a year of training and hiring.All seven point the same way. Budget the three hard elements in quarters and the four soft ones in years.
- No gap between the strategy and the other six elements.Structure lags: product teams own the first sale and nobody owns the renewal. Hard: a reorganization, one or two quarters.Systems lag: billing invoices once per deal and cannot report churn. Hard: about two quarters to replace.Shared values lag: closing is what the firm admires, so renewals feel like admin. Soft: the slowest to move, two years or more.Style lags: leaders ring the bell for big signings and never for a renewal. Soft: a year of changed habits at the top.Staff lags: every seller is a hunter paid on the first year. Soft: new roles and pay plans, a year or more.Skills lag: sellers pitch features, and nobody can show value in use. Soft: a year of training and hiring.All seven point the same way. Budget the three hard elements in quarters and the four soft ones in years.
- No gap between the strategy and the other six elements.Structure lags: product teams own the first sale and nobody owns the renewal. Hard: a reorganization, one or two quarters.Systems lag: billing invoices once per deal and cannot report churn. Hard: about two quarters to replace.Shared values lag: closing is what the firm admires, so renewals feel like admin. Soft: the slowest to move, two years or more.Style lags: leaders ring the bell for big signings and never for a renewal. Soft: a year of changed habits at the top.Staff lags: every seller is a hunter paid on the first year. Soft: new roles and pay plans, a year or more.Skills lag: sellers pitch features, and nobody can show value in use. Soft: a year of training and hiring.All seven point the same way. Budget the three hard elements in quarters and the four soft ones in years.
- No gap between the strategy and the other six elements.Structure lags: product teams own the first sale and nobody owns the renewal. Hard: a reorganization, one or two quarters.Systems lag: billing invoices once per deal and cannot report churn. Hard: about two quarters to replace.Shared values lag: closing is what the firm admires, so renewals feel like admin. Soft: the slowest to move, two years or more.Style lags: leaders ring the bell for big signings and never for a renewal. Soft: a year of changed habits at the top.Staff lags: every seller is a hunter paid on the first year. Soft: new roles and pay plans, a year or more.Skills lag: sellers pitch features, and nobody can show value in use. Soft: a year of training and hiring.All seven point the same way. Budget the three hard elements in quarters and the four soft ones in years.
- No gap between the strategy and the other six elements.Structure lags: product teams own the first sale and nobody owns the renewal. Hard: a reorganization, one or two quarters.Systems lag: billing invoices once per deal and cannot report churn. Hard: about two quarters to replace.Shared values lag: closing is what the firm admires, so renewals feel like admin. Soft: the slowest to move, two years or more.Style lags: leaders ring the bell for big signings and never for a renewal. Soft: a year of changed habits at the top.Staff lags: every seller is a hunter paid on the first year. Soft: new roles and pay plans, a year or more.Skills lag: sellers pitch features, and nobody can show value in use. Soft: a year of training and hiring.All seven point the same way. Budget the three hard elements in quarters and the four soft ones in years.
- Structure lags: product teams own the first sale and nobody owns the renewal. Hard: a reorganization, one or two quarters. (strategy: Sell subscriptions, structure: Sales by product line)
- Systems lag: billing invoices once per deal and cannot report churn. Hard: about two quarters to replace. (strategy: Sell subscriptions, systems: Bill once per deal)
- Shared values lag: closing is what the firm admires, so renewals feel like admin. Soft: the slowest to move, two years or more. (strategy: Sell subscriptions, values: Close the deal)
- Style lags: leaders ring the bell for big signings and never for a renewal. Soft: a year of changed habits at the top. (strategy: Sell subscriptions, style: Cheer big signings)
- Staff lags: every seller is a hunter paid on the first year. Soft: new roles and pay plans, a year or more. (strategy: Sell subscriptions, staff: All hunters)
- Skills lag: sellers pitch features, and nobody can show value in use. Soft: a year of training and hiring. (strategy: Sell subscriptions, skills: Pitch features)
- All seven point the same way. Budget the three hard elements in quarters and the four soft ones in years. (strategy: Sell subscriptions, structure: Teams by customer, systems: Bill monthly, see churn, values: Keep the customer, style: Cheer renewals too, staff: Hunters and farmers, skills: Prove value in use)
An example
An industrial software firm moved from selling perpetual licenses to selling subscriptions. It changed the price list in January and the contracts in March. A year later, renewals were running at 71 percent, well below the plan's 90, and the board wanted to know why.
The chief strategy officer ran a review of seven elements, each judged on where it stood today against where the subscription business needed it. Only the strategy had moved. Sales was still organized by product line, so nobody owned a customer after the first sale. Billing invoiced once per deal and could not show churn. Leaders rang a bell for big signings and had never celebrated a renewal. Every seller was a hunter paid on first-year value, and the firm's pride was in closing. She presented the gaps with a time for each: billing and structure in two quarters, the four people-side elements over two years. The board approved a customer success team, a new pay plan, and a renewal target on every leader's scorecard.
Why it works
Strategies fail in the gaps between the parts of an organization. A firm can announce a new strategy in a day, but its structure, systems, people, skills, leadership habits, and shared beliefs were all built for the old one, and each keeps pulling the work back toward it. The new strategy loses to six forces nobody listed.
The framework works by forcing the list. Each of the seven elements is judged on two states, current and required, and every element that has not moved is a gap. Because the elements depend on each other, closing one gap often exposes another. The split between hard elements (strategy, structure, systems) and soft ones (shared values, style, staff, skills) adds the second lesson: the soft four move slowest, so a plan that budgets them in quarters will be late.
The thinking behind it
Robert H. Waterman Jr. Robert H. Waterman Jr., a McKinsey director, published the 7S framework with Thomas J. Peters and Julien R. Phillips in Structure Is Not Organization (1980), in Business Horizons. The article holds that strategy, structure, systems, style, staff, skills, and shared values must fit together, so that a change in one has to be matched in the others. Waterman went on to co-write In Search of Excellence (1982) with Peters.
Thomas J. Peters Thomas J. Peters, a McKinsey consultant who became a management writer, co-wrote the 1980 article that first set out the seven elements. Its title carries the argument: the boxes and lines of an organization chart are one element of seven, and redrawing them alone leaves the other six as they were. In Search of Excellence (1982), which he wrote with Waterman, was organized around the framework.
Richard T. Pascale Richard T. Pascale, a scholar at the Stanford Graduate School of Business, helped Peters and Waterman develop the framework at a 1980 retreat, together with Anthony G. Athos. Pascale and Athos then used the seven elements in The Art of Japanese Management (1981) to compare how a large Japanese firm and a large American one were managed, element by element.
How to run it
- Name the change. State the shift the organization must make in one line, such as licenses to subscriptions.
- Describe each element today. For all seven, write what is true now in plain terms, from the org chart to what people admire.
- Describe each element as required. Write what each must look like for the new strategy to work.
- Mark the gaps. Flag every element whose current state does not match its required state.
- Check the fit between elements. Look for pairs that pull against each other, such as a customer strategy with deal-based pay.
- Put a time on each gap. Budget the hard elements in quarters and the soft ones, values, style, staff, and skills, in years.
- Sequence the work. Start the slow soft changes first, and review all seven again every six months.
Where it goes wrong
The first failure is closing only the hard gaps. A new org chart and a billing system are visible and finishable, so they get done, and the firm declares the change complete while the values and pay still reward the old business. If the soft four have no owner and no date, the plan is unfinished.
The second is describing elements in slogans. "Customer-centric values" tells no one what changes. Write each state as something an observer could check.
The third is treating the seven as a checklist to tick once. They move together, so a fix to one can open a gap in another. Review the whole set again after each major change.
When to use something else
- Hoshin Kanri. When the strategy is settled and the job is cascading it into each unit's goals and measures.
- Iceberg Model. When the gap looks like a symptom of deeper structures and beliefs that need tracing first.
- Force Field Analysis. When the question is which forces push the change and which resist it, and how hard.
Where it sits in SOLVE eX
Go to the source
- Structure Is Not Organization, Business Horizons 23(3), 1980
- The Art of Japanese Management, Simon and Schuster, 1981
- In Search of Excellence, Harper and Row, 1982