BATNA and ZOPA

Thinking Tools5.1 Defining the Evaluation CriteriaAlso known as Best alternative to a negotiated agreement, Zone of possible agreement

BATNA from Roger Fisher and William Ury (Getting to Yes, 1981); the zone of agreement from Howard Raiffa (The Art and Science of Negotiation, 1982).

Before a negotiation, pins down the best deal available without this counterparty, estimates theirs, and finds the range both sides prefer to walking away.

Each side's best alternative sets its walk-away price, and the overlap is the zone of agreement

A buyer renewing a software contract against a rival vendor's quote. Each bar is the prices one side would accept; the buyer's ends at its walk-away (the rival's price plus the cost of switching), the seller's starts at its floor. Where the bars overlap is the zone of possible agreement. Move a slider until the zone vanishes. Illustrative.

$420K
$60K
$400K
Buyer's walk-away: the most it should pay
$480K
Width of the zone of possible agreement
$80K
Zone of possible agreementBuyer would paySeller would take$300K$400K$500K$600K$700KRival's priceBuyer walks awaySeller walks awayZone of possible agreementBuyer would paySeller would take$300K$400K$500K$600K$700KRival's priceBuyer walks awaySeller walks away

Zone of possible agreementFrom $400K to $480KNo zone: restructure the deal or walk away.

An example

The head of procurement at a regional insurer had six weeks before the claims software contract renewed, and the vendor had asked for $495,000 a year, up 12 percent. Before replying she priced her alternative in full. A rival vendor quoted $420,000, and moving would cost about $60,000 a year in migration and retraining spread over the term, so her walk-away was $480,000. Anything above that was worse than leaving.

Then she estimated the vendor's side. Its cost to serve the account was well below the old price, and losing a reference customer in the region would hurt its next three sales, so she put its floor near $400,000. The zone ran from about $400,000 to $480,000. She told the account executive the rival's number, opened at $410,000, and asked for a three-year term. They settled at $445,000 a year, fixed for three years, and she spent two of the six weeks firming up the rival's quote so the alternative stayed real.

Why it works

A negotiator who has not priced the alternative judges every offer against the last offer, and the last offer is set by the other side. Naming the best alternative replaces that drifting anchor with a fixed one: an offer is good if it beats what happens without a deal, and bad if it does not. That one number tells the negotiator when to walk away and when to stop haggling.

The zone follows from doing the same for the other side. If the most one party will pay is above the least the other will take, every price in between beats both alternatives, and the bargaining is only over where in the zone the deal lands. If the walk-aways do not overlap, no amount of haggling helps, and the only moves are to change the deal or leave.

The thinking behind it

Roger Fisher Roger Fisher, a Harvard Law School professor who directed the Harvard Negotiation Project, set out principled negotiation with William Ury in Getting to Yes (1981): separate the people from the problem, focus on interests, invent options for mutual gain, and use objective criteria. The book defined the BATNA, the best alternative to a negotiated agreement, as the standard every proposal is measured against. Bruce Patton is credited as coauthor from the second edition (1991).

William Ury William Ury, a negotiation adviser with a doctorate in social anthropology from Harvard, wrote Getting to Yes with Roger Fisher and gave negotiation the term BATNA. The book teaches bargaining over interests instead of positions. In Getting Past No: Negotiating with Difficult People (1991) he added going to the balcony, stepping back from the exchange before reacting, which is easier to do with a priced alternative in hand.

Howard Raiffa Howard Raiffa, a Harvard decision theorist who helped found decision analysis and negotiation analysis, analyzed bargaining in The Art and Science of Negotiation (1982) through each side's reservation price and the zone of agreement between them. That zone is what is now usually called the ZOPA, the zone of possible agreement, and the figure on this page draws it as the gap between the two walk-aways.

How to run it

  1. Write down your best alternative. Name the who, what, and price of the deal you would take if this one failed, with every cost of switching included.
  2. Make the alternative real. Get the rival quote in writing or the internal plan approved before talks begin, since an alternative you cannot use is worth nothing at the table.
  3. Turn it into a walk-away number. The alternative's full cost is the most you should pay, or the least you should accept.
  4. Estimate the other side's alternative. Ask what they lose if you leave, what their next-best customer or supplier would give them, and what serving you costs them.
  5. Find the overlap. If your walk-away and theirs overlap, plan where in the zone to open and what you will trade to move within it.
  6. If there is no overlap, change the deal. Add term, volume, scope, or timing until a zone appears, or leave.
  7. Recheck both alternatives as talks move. A rival's quote can expire and theirs can improve, and either one moves the zone.

Where it goes wrong

The first failure is a BATNA that exists only in the negotiator's head: a rival never actually asked to bid, or an internal build nobody has costed. It shows when the other side calls the bluff and the alternative falls apart. Firm it up before talks begin.

The second is leaving out the cost of switching, which makes the alternative look cheaper than it is and the walk-away too low, so a good deal gets refused. The third is assuming the other side's floor equals its asking price. Ask what they lose without the deal; a vendor's floor is usually closer to its cost of serving the account than to its list price.

When to use something else

  • Interest-Based Bargaining. When the parties care about different things and trading across them can create more value than splitting one price.
  • Mutual Gains Approach. When many parties and issues are on the table and the work is building a package all of them prefer to walking away.
  • Auction Design. When several bidders compete and the rules of the bidding decide the price more than any one negotiation does.

Where it sits in SOLVE eX

Go to the source

  • Getting to Yes: Negotiating Agreement Without Giving In, 1981
  • The Art and Science of Negotiation, 1982

Back to the catalog