Developed by Stephen Toulmin (The Uses of Argument, 1958).
Breaks an argument into claim, data, warrant, backing, qualifier, and rebuttal, showing exactly which link is weak or missing.
A price-rise proposal taken apart into its six parts
The claim at the root, and the five parts that hold it up. Select each part to read the check a skeptic would run on it, then mark the one link the whole argument cannot survive losing. Illustrative.
0 of 1 marked1 of 1 marked
An example
An industrial components maker's pricing committee had a one-page proposal to raise list prices 5 percent in January. Its case looked strong: two earlier rises of 3 percent had lost no large account, and the two biggest rivals had raised prices 6 percent that year.
The CFO asked the author to lay the argument out in its parts before the vote. The claim and the data were on the page. The warrant, the rule that turned the data into the claim, was not: customers will not switch over a 5 percent rise. Written down, it was plainly a stretch from evidence about 3 percent. Its backing, the six months it takes a customer to requalify parts from a new supplier, held for engineered parts and not for catalog items. The rebuttal was dated: three of the largest contracts renewed in March. The committee approved 5 percent on engineered parts, 3 percent on the catalog, and a call to each of the ten largest accounts before the letters went out.
Why it works
Most arguments that fail in the boardroom fail at a link nobody stated. People present data and a conclusion, and the step between them, the general rule that makes this kind of evidence support this kind of claim, stays in the author's head. Laying the argument out in its parts forces that rule onto the page, where it can be checked against what the data actually shows.
The other parts do similar work. Backing asks why the rule should be believed. The qualifier makes the author say how strongly the claim holds, which often narrows it in useful ways. The rebuttal names the conditions under which it fails, which turns a debate into a short list of things to check, and shows a skeptic that the author has already looked.
The thinking behind it
Stephen Toulmin Stephen Toulmin, a British philosopher, set out his model of practical argument in The Uses of Argument (Cambridge University Press, 1958). He laid an argument out in six parts: the claim; the grounds offered for it; the warrant, which links the grounds to the claim; the backing for the warrant; the qualifier, which states how certain the claim is; and the rebuttal, which names the conditions under which it fails. The qualifier and the rebuttal are what set the layout apart from a bare chain of premises and conclusion: they build doubt into the argument itself.
How to run it
- State the claim precisely. Write what you want accepted in one sentence, with its numbers and dates.
- List the data. Put down the facts offered in support, each one checkable.
- Write the warrant out. State the general rule that makes this data support this claim, in a sentence that begins with "because" or "whenever".
- Give the warrant its backing. Say why the rule should be believed: a study, a precedent, a record.
- Qualify the claim. Say how strongly it holds and for whom, such as presumably, for contract customers.
- Name the rebuttals. List the conditions under which the claim would fail, with dates where you can.
- Test the weakest link first. Ask which part a skeptic would attack, and gather evidence for it before the meeting.
Where it goes wrong
The warrant stays unstated. Authors list data and claim and assume the link is obvious. If you cannot write the warrant as a sentence, you do not yet know why your data supports your claim.
The parts are labeled and never checked. Filling in six boxes feels rigorous and changes nothing. For each part, write the question a skeptic would ask and the answer you have.
The rebuttal is a straw man. Listing only exceptions that will never happen protects the claim and teaches nothing. Ask the person most likely to oppose the proposal what would make it fail.
When to use something else
- Dialectical Mapping. When two camps hold opposing claims and the arguments on both sides need weighing together.
- Steelmanning. When the job is to state the opposing argument at its strongest before answering it.
- Murder Board. When the argument is ready and needs live attack from a panel before the real audience sees it.
Where it sits in SOLVE eX
Go to the source
- The Uses of Argument, 1958