Thinking Tools4.3 Crafting Solutions for the Future StateAlso known as Art of War Strategy, Sun Tzu Asymmetric Logic
From Sun Tzu (The Art of War, c. 5th century BCE), in the translation of Samuel B. Griffith (1963) and applied to business by Mark McNeilly (Sun Tzu and the Art of Business, 1996).
Favors position, surprise, and the indirect approach over head-on contest: know both sides, avoid strength, strike weakness, and win before the fight begins.
Eight fronts between a regional payroll firm and a national rival, sorted by who is strong where
Each tag is a front the two firms could compete on, with what each side brings to it. Select one, then the box for both sides' strength there: the box says whether to strike, build position first, avoid the contest, or leave it. The first is placed as an example. Illustrative.
Items (select one, then a box)
Not placedPlacedStrike hereBuild position firstAvoid the contestLeave it for now
Not placedPlacedStrike hereBuild position firstAvoid the contestLeave it for now
Not placedPlacedStrike hereBuild position firstAvoid the contestLeave it for now
Not placedPlacedStrike hereBuild position firstAvoid the contestLeave it for now
Not placedPlacedStrike hereBuild position firstAvoid the contestLeave it for now
Not placedPlacedStrike hereBuild position firstAvoid the contestLeave it for now
Not placedPlacedStrike hereBuild position firstAvoid the contestLeave it for now
Not placedPlacedStrike hereBuild position firstAvoid the contestLeave it for now
The regional firm on this front
StrongThin
Strike here
Build position first
Leave it for now
Avoid the contest
ThinStrong
The national rival on this front
Restaurants with tips. The regional firm built tip-pooling and serves 300 restaurants; the rival's product cannot split tips.Not placed yet.Restaurants with tips. The regional firm built tip-pooling and serves 300 restaurants; the rival's product cannot split tips.Strike here: The firm is strong where the rival is thin: sales effort, product work, and money go here first.Strong against thin: the firm's best front. It goes after restaurants first.Restaurants with tips. The regional firm built tip-pooling and serves 300 restaurants; the rival's product cannot split tips.Build position first: Both sides are strong, so a head-on fight is costly: win an ally, a channel, or better information before contesting it.Restaurants with tips. The regional firm built tip-pooling and serves 300 restaurants; the rival's product cannot split tips.Avoid the contest: The rival is strong where the firm is thin: concede it on purpose and keep resources out of it.Restaurants with tips. The regional firm built tip-pooling and serves 300 restaurants; the rival's product cannot split tips.Leave it for now: Neither side is strong: not worth resources unless it opens a route to a front the firm can win.Accountant referrals. Sixty local accountants send the regional firm clients; the rival sells direct and has no accountant program.Not placed yet.Accountant referrals. Sixty local accountants send the regional firm clients; the rival sells direct and has no accountant program.Strike here: The firm is strong where the rival is thin: sales effort, product work, and money go here first.Strong against thin: a channel the rival cannot buy quickly. Sales time goes to the accountants.Accountant referrals. Sixty local accountants send the regional firm clients; the rival sells direct and has no accountant program.Build position first: Both sides are strong, so a head-on fight is costly: win an ally, a channel, or better information before contesting it.Accountant referrals. Sixty local accountants send the regional firm clients; the rival sells direct and has no accountant program.Avoid the contest: The rival is strong where the firm is thin: concede it on purpose and keep resources out of it.Accountant referrals. Sixty local accountants send the regional firm clients; the rival sells direct and has no accountant program.Leave it for now: Neither side is strong: not worth resources unless it opens a route to a front the firm can win.Same-day phone support. A local team answers within minutes; the rival's queue takes two days.Not placed yet.Same-day phone support. A local team answers within minutes; the rival's queue takes two days.Strike here: The firm is strong where the rival is thin: sales effort, product work, and money go here first.Strong against thin: support becomes the reason to stay, and the firm says so in every renewal.Same-day phone support. A local team answers within minutes; the rival's queue takes two days.Build position first: Both sides are strong, so a head-on fight is costly: win an ally, a channel, or better information before contesting it.Same-day phone support. A local team answers within minutes; the rival's queue takes two days.Avoid the contest: The rival is strong where the firm is thin: concede it on purpose and keep resources out of it.Same-day phone support. A local team answers within minutes; the rival's queue takes two days.Leave it for now: Neither side is strong: not worth resources unless it opens a route to a front the firm can win.Price for small offices. The rival cut prices thirty percent and has the scale to hold them; the regional firm cannot match without losses.Not placed yet.Price for small offices. The rival cut prices thirty percent and has the scale to hold them; the regional firm cannot match without losses.Strike here: The firm is strong where the rival is thin: sales effort, product work, and money go here first.Price for small offices. The rival cut prices thirty percent and has the scale to hold them; the regional firm cannot match without losses.Build position first: Both sides are strong, so a head-on fight is costly: win an ally, a channel, or better information before contesting it.Price for small offices. The rival cut prices thirty percent and has the scale to hold them; the regional firm cannot match without losses.Avoid the contest: The rival is strong where the firm is thin: concede it on purpose and keep resources out of it.Thin against strong: matching the cut spends cash where the rival is strongest. The firm lets the cheapest offices go.Price for small offices. The rival cut prices thirty percent and has the scale to hold them; the regional firm cannot match without losses.Leave it for now: Neither side is strong: not worth resources unless it opens a route to a front the firm can win.National advertising. The rival runs ads in every market; the regional firm has no ad budget to speak of.Not placed yet.National advertising. The rival runs ads in every market; the regional firm has no ad budget to speak of.Strike here: The firm is strong where the rival is thin: sales effort, product work, and money go here first.National advertising. The rival runs ads in every market; the regional firm has no ad budget to speak of.Build position first: Both sides are strong, so a head-on fight is costly: win an ally, a channel, or better information before contesting it.National advertising. The rival runs ads in every market; the regional firm has no ad budget to speak of.Avoid the contest: The rival is strong where the firm is thin: concede it on purpose and keep resources out of it.Thin against strong: no contest worth entering. Referrals do the regional firm's marketing.National advertising. The rival runs ads in every market; the regional firm has no ad budget to speak of.Leave it for now: Neither side is strong: not worth resources unless it opens a route to a front the firm can win.Multi-state payroll. The rival handles all fifty states; the regional firm handles three.Not placed yet.Multi-state payroll. The rival handles all fifty states; the regional firm handles three.Strike here: The firm is strong where the rival is thin: sales effort, product work, and money go here first.Multi-state payroll. The rival handles all fifty states; the regional firm handles three.Build position first: Both sides are strong, so a head-on fight is costly: win an ally, a channel, or better information before contesting it.Multi-state payroll. The rival handles all fifty states; the regional firm handles three.Avoid the contest: The rival is strong where the firm is thin: concede it on purpose and keep resources out of it.Thin against strong: the firm refers multi-state employers elsewhere and keeps its focus.Multi-state payroll. The rival handles all fifty states; the regional firm handles three.Leave it for now: Neither side is strong: not worth resources unless it opens a route to a front the firm can win.Mid-size employers. The regional firm has forty clients over 200 staff; the rival bundles a strong HR suite.Not placed yet.Mid-size employers. The regional firm has forty clients over 200 staff; the rival bundles a strong HR suite.Strike here: The firm is strong where the rival is thin: sales effort, product work, and money go here first.Mid-size employers. The regional firm has forty clients over 200 staff; the rival bundles a strong HR suite.Build position first: Both sides are strong, so a head-on fight is costly: win an ally, a channel, or better information before contesting it.Strong against strong: the firm signs a local HR software partner before contesting these accounts.Mid-size employers. The regional firm has forty clients over 200 staff; the rival bundles a strong HR suite.Avoid the contest: The rival is strong where the firm is thin: concede it on purpose and keep resources out of it.Mid-size employers. The regional firm has forty clients over 200 staff; the rival bundles a strong HR suite.Leave it for now: Neither side is strong: not worth resources unless it opens a route to a front the firm can win.Seasonal farm crews. Neither firm handles day-rate seasonal crews well, and the margins are thin.Not placed yet.Seasonal farm crews. Neither firm handles day-rate seasonal crews well, and the margins are thin.Strike here: The firm is strong where the rival is thin: sales effort, product work, and money go here first.Seasonal farm crews. Neither firm handles day-rate seasonal crews well, and the margins are thin.Build position first: Both sides are strong, so a head-on fight is costly: win an ally, a channel, or better information before contesting it.Seasonal farm crews. Neither firm handles day-rate seasonal crews well, and the margins are thin.Avoid the contest: The rival is strong where the firm is thin: concede it on purpose and keep resources out of it.Seasonal farm crews. Neither firm handles day-rate seasonal crews well, and the margins are thin.Leave it for now: Neither side is strong: not worth resources unless it opens a route to a front the firm can win.Thin against thin: left alone until a front beside it, restaurants or accountants, makes it worth entering.
Your sort matched 0 of 8.Your sort matched 1 of 8.Your sort matched 2 of 8.Your sort matched 3 of 8.Your sort matched 4 of 8.Your sort matched 5 of 8.Your sort matched 6 of 8.Your sort matched 7 of 8.Your sort matched 8 of 8.
Strike here
The firm is strong where the rival is thin: sales effort, product work, and money go here first.
Build position first
Both sides are strong, so a head-on fight is costly: win an ally, a channel, or better information before contesting it.
Avoid the contest
The rival is strong where the firm is thin: concede it on purpose and keep resources out of it.
Leave it for now
Neither side is strong: not worth resources unless it opens a route to a front the firm can win.
The sort
Restaurants with tips: Strike here. Strong against thin: the firm's best front. It goes after restaurants first.
Accountant referrals: Strike here. Strong against thin: a channel the rival cannot buy quickly. Sales time goes to the accountants.
Same-day phone support: Strike here. Strong against thin: support becomes the reason to stay, and the firm says so in every renewal.
Price for small offices: Avoid the contest. Thin against strong: matching the cut spends cash where the rival is strongest. The firm lets the cheapest offices go.
National advertising: Avoid the contest. Thin against strong: no contest worth entering. Referrals do the regional firm's marketing.
Multi-state payroll: Avoid the contest. Thin against strong: the firm refers multi-state employers elsewhere and keeps its focus.
Mid-size employers: Build position first. Strong against strong: the firm signs a local HR software partner before contesting these accounts.
Seasonal farm crews: Leave it for now. Thin against thin: left alone until a front beside it, restaurants or accountants, makes it worth entering.
An example
A regional payroll company of forty people learned that a national payroll giant was entering its three states with prices thirty percent lower. The chief executive's first instinct was to match the cut. The chief operating officer asked for two days to compare the two firms front by front first.
The comparison was blunt. On price for small offices, national advertising, and payroll across many states, the rival was far stronger. On restaurants, where it had built tip-pooling that the rival's product lacked, on referrals from sixty local accountants, and on support answered by a person within minutes, the rival was thin. Mid-size employers were a draw: both were strong.
The plan followed the gaps. Prices stayed where they were. Sales effort went to restaurants and the accountants, the firm signed a partnership with a local HR software vendor before contesting mid-size accounts, and it let the cheapest small offices go. A year later it had lost six percent of its small-office clients and added forty restaurants, with margins intact.
Why it works
A head-on contest is decided mostly by resources, and the stronger side usually has more. Comparing the two sides front by front shows that strength is uneven: a larger rival is strong in some places and thin in others, and so is the smaller firm. Competing where the two sides' strengths are mismatched in the smaller firm's favor turns a contest of size into one of position, which a smaller player can win.
The assessment also says where not to fight. Matching a stronger rival's price cut spends the scarcest resource on the front where the rival is strongest. Conceding that front deliberately, and building alliances or information before contesting the even ones, keeps resources for the places where they buy the most. Most of the outcome is decided by these choices before any customer is contested.
The thinking behind it
Sun Tzu (Sunzi) Sun Tzu is the traditional author of The Art of War, a short Chinese treatise on strategy traditionally dated to the late sixth century BCE and probably compiled during the Warring States period. It holds that the best victory is won without fighting, and that a commander who knows the enemy and knows himself need not fear the outcome. It is a strategist's classic, read for its maxims, and its case for position over open contest is the core of this tool. Samuel B. Griffith's 1963 translation is one of the standard English versions.
Mark McNeilly Mark McNeilly, a business writer, adapted the treatise for managers in Sun Tzu and the Art of Business: Six Strategic Principles for Managers (1996). It is a popular synthesis written for people running companies, and it makes no claim to be research: it takes the treatise's maxims about strategy and restates them as six principles for competing in markets, where the rival is a company and the ground is a set of customers.
How to run it
Name the fronts. List the places the two sides could compete: segments, channels, prices, services, and partners.
Assess your own side honestly. Rate your strength on each front with evidence, such as client counts, win rates, and costs.
Assess the rival the same way. Use what can be observed: pricing, hiring, product gaps, and what lost customers say.
Mark the mismatches. Find the fronts where you are strong and they are thin, and those where the reverse holds.
Concentrate on the strong fronts. Put sales effort, product work, and money where the mismatch favors you.
Build position before the even fronts. Win an ally, a channel, or better information before contesting a front where both are strong.
Concede where they are strong. Decide in advance which business you will let go, and keep resources out of that contest.
Where it goes wrong
The assessment flatters one side. Teams rate themselves strong everywhere and the rival weak, and the plan attacks fronts that turn out to be well defended. Score the firm's own side from evidence and ask a lost customer or a recent hire from the rival to check the scores.
The firm cannot bring itself to concede. Giving up the cheapest customers feels like losing, so it matches the price cut anyway and starves the fronts it could win. Write the concession into the plan with a number attached.
The mismatch is treated as permanent. A rival that sees its weak front under attack can fix it within a year. Reassess every quarter and keep looking for the next gap.
When to use something else
Porter's Five Forces. When the question is how attractive the whole industry is, beyond one rivalry.
Center of Gravity Analysis. When the task is finding the one source of the rival's strength that everything else depends on.
Game Theory. When each side's best move depends on what the other is expected to do, and the payoffs can be written down.