Mutual Gains Approach

Thinking Tools5.2 Selecting the Right Decision ToolsAlso known as Mutual Gains Framework

Developed by Lawrence Susskind and colleagues at the Consensus Building Institute (Breaking the Impasse, with Jeffrey Cruikshank, 1987; Dealing with an Angry Public, with Patrick Field, 1996), extending Roger Fisher and William Ury (1981).

A five-step negotiation process (prepare, create value, distribute value, follow through, and learn) in which parties invent joint options before anyone claims a share.

A three-party supply contract built in five steps, with the options before the split

Play the negotiation, or select a step to read what the grocery chain, the dairy co-op, and the carrier did there. The options that enlarge the deal come before anyone claims a share. Illustrative.

  • Into the next negotiation (Learn to Prepare)

Select a stage to read it, or play the sequence.Prepare. Each side writes down what it needs and what it does if there is no deal. The chain wants fewer empty shelves; the co-op wants steady volume to plan its herds; the carrier wants full trucks both ways. Each names who can sign.Create value. Before anyone names a price, the three list options together: a twelve-month standing order, milk riding in the carrier's half-empty return trucks, a second delivery window. Together the options are worth about $1.4 million a year more than the old deal.Distribute value. They divide the gain using the regional milk price index and each party's share of the freight saved. The chain gets a 3 percent price cut, the co-op a volume floor, and the carrier the return loads.Follow through. The contract carries a monthly fill-rate report, a clause that reopens price if the index moves more than 8 percent, and a named contact at each firm for problems.Learn. Each side debriefs. The shared-truck idea came from the carrier, which had not been at the table for the last renewal: next time, bring the carrier in from the start.
  1. Prepare. Each side writes down what it needs and what it does if there is no deal. The chain wants fewer empty shelves; the co-op wants steady volume to plan its herds; the carrier wants full trucks both ways. Each names who can sign.
  2. Create value. Before anyone names a price, the three list options together: a twelve-month standing order, milk riding in the carrier's half-empty return trucks, a second delivery window. Together the options are worth about $1.4 million a year more than the old deal.
  3. Distribute value. They divide the gain using the regional milk price index and each party's share of the freight saved. The chain gets a 3 percent price cut, the co-op a volume floor, and the carrier the return loads.
  4. Follow through. The contract carries a monthly fill-rate report, a clause that reopens price if the index moves more than 8 percent, and a named contact at each firm for problems.
  5. Learn. Each side debriefs. The shared-truck idea came from the carrier, which had not been at the table for the last renewal: next time, bring the carrier in from the start.

An example

A regional grocery chain's milk contract with a dairy co-op was up for renewal, and the last two renewals had been a fight over price that left empty shelves every summer. This time the chain's buyer invited the co-op and the freight carrier that hauled for both of them.

Each party prepared its interests, its walkaway, and who could sign. The first joint session had one rule: options only, no prices. The list ran to eleven items, and three of them carried the deal: a twelve-month standing order that let the co-op plan its herds, the co-op's milk riding in the carrier's half-empty return trucks, and a second delivery window on weekends. Together they were worth about $1.4 million a year. The split came after, by the regional milk price index and each side's share of the freight saved. The contract carried a monthly fill-rate report and a price reopener. Summer stockouts fell by two-thirds in the first year.

Why it works

When parties bargain over price first, every dollar one gains the other loses, so each hides what it values and the deal shrinks to the one issue on the table. Inventing options before anyone claims a share changes what is being divided. Parties value things differently (certainty for the co-op, full trucks for the carrier, full shelves for the chain), and trades across those differences make the total larger before it is split.

The other steps protect that gain. Preparing walkaways keeps anyone from accepting a deal worse than no deal. Splitting by criteria all sides accept, such as a published index, makes the division a question of fact, so it does not sour the relationship the deal depends on. And because the parties will keep working together, writing monitoring and reopeners into the contract keeps the agreement alive when conditions change.

The thinking behind it

Lawrence Susskind Lawrence Susskind, a professor of urban and environmental planning at MIT, developed the mutual gains approach to negotiation and consensus building in public disputes and founded the Consensus Building Institute in 1993. Breaking the Impasse (1987), written with Jeffrey Cruikshank, set out consensual approaches in which all sides can gain, the basis of what he and his colleagues later called the Mutual Gains Approach.

Patrick Field Patrick Field wrote Dealing with an Angry Public (1996) with Susskind, the book that gave the approach its name in its subtitle. It argues that companies and public agencies facing an angry public should negotiate with it for mutual gains: acknowledge its concerns, share information, and build trust, instead of trying to manage it. The same steps carry over to commercial deals with many parties.

Roger Fisher Roger Fisher, a Harvard Law School professor and director of the Harvard Negotiation Project, set out principled negotiation with William Ury in Getting to Yes (1981): separate the people from the problem, focus on interests, invent options for mutual gain, and use objective criteria. The book also defined the BATNA, the best alternative to a negotiated agreement. The mutual gains approach extends that work to disputes with many parties.

How to run it

  1. Prepare each party's position. Write down interests, the walkaway if there is no deal, priorities among issues, and who has authority to sign.
  2. Bring every party that matters. Invite the parties whose cooperation the deal needs, even those outside the usual two-way talk.
  3. Invent options before prices. Hold a session where only options are allowed, and list everything that could make the deal larger.
  4. Value the options together. Estimate what each option is worth to each party, and look for trades where one side gives what it values least.
  5. Split by agreed criteria. Divide the gain by standards all parties accept, such as an index or a share of savings.
  6. Write the follow-through into the deal. Add monitoring, contingencies, named contacts, and triggers for reopening terms.
  7. Debrief and carry it forward. Record what created value and what stalled, and use it to set up the next negotiation.

Where it goes wrong

The value-creating session collapses into bargaining when someone names a number too early. Once a price is on the table, every option gets judged by its effect on that number, and the parties start hiding what they value. Hold to the rule that options come first, and park any price that slips out.

A second failure is leaving out a party whose cooperation the deal needs. The two-party version of this contract could never have found the shared-truck option. List who can help or block before choosing who sits at the table.

The third is a strong agreement with no follow-through. Conditions change, and a deal with no monitoring or reopener breaks at the first surprise, usually blamed on bad faith. Write the triggers in while relations are good.

When to use something else

  • BATNA and ZOPA. When the question is whether a deal beats walking away and where an agreement between two sides could land.
  • Interest-Based Bargaining. When two parties with a long relationship, such as a company and a union, need to bargain over interests together.
  • Coalition Mapping. When the first job is working out who supports, opposes, or could block the deal before any talks begin.

Where it sits in SOLVE eX

Go to the source

  • Breaking the Impasse: Consensual Approaches to Resolving Public Disputes, Basic Books, 1987
  • Dealing with an Angry Public: The Mutual Gains Approach to Resolving Disputes, Free Press, 1996
  • Getting to Yes, 1981

Back to the catalog