Capital Allocation

Thinking Tools5.2 Selecting the Right Decision Tools

From corporate finance (Richard A. Brealey and Stewart C. Myers, Principles of Corporate Finance, 1981), set out as the chief executive's central job by Warren Buffett (Berkshire Hathaway letters, from 1977) and William N. Thorndike Jr. (The Outsiders, 2012).

Compares the expected returns and risks of every use of available capital (reinvestment, acquisitions, debt repayment, dividends, buybacks, or cash) and funds the best first.

Rank every use of the $50 million by risk-adjusted return, and fund down the list

Five claims on a manufacturer's $50 million, each bar its expected return less a premium for its risk, against the black line of the cost of capital. Funding goes down the list from the highest bar until the money runs out or the bars fall below the line; the rest is held as cash. Change the acquisition's promised return, the premium its risk deserves, or the cost of capital, and watch the funding move. Illustrative.

18%
8 points
9.0%
New product line ($10M, 14% after risk)
$10M
Plant expansion ($15M, 12% after risk)
$15M
Acquisition ($25M)
$25M
Share buyback ($20M, 9.5% after risk)
$0M
Paying down 7% debt ($15M)
$0M
Held as cash
$0M

Return after the risk premium, %Cost of capital, %

0.05.010.015.020.014.012.010.09.57.0Product linePlantDealBuybackPay debt0.05.010.015.020.014.012.010.09.57.0ProductlinePlantDealBuybackPay debt

An example

A maker of industrial pumps ended the year with $50 million it did not need for operations, and five sponsors wanted it. Product development had a new line for $10 million. Operations wanted $15 million to expand a plant. Corporate development had a $25 million acquisition with a promised 18 percent return. The treasurer proposed a $20 million buyback, and the CFO's own staff suggested paying down $15 million of 7 percent debt.

The CEO asked for every claim on one page, each return reduced by a premium for its risk, set against a cost of capital of 9 percent. The acquisition dropped from 18 to about 10 percent once its integration risk was priced. Funding went down the list: the product line, the plant, then the acquisition, which used the last of the money. The buyback cleared the bar but missed out, and the debt paydown fell below it. A year later, when the acquisition's integration costs rose, the board could see that the buyback had been the next use in line.

Why it works

Every dollar a company holds has several possible uses, and each sponsor sees only one of them. Left alone, capital goes to whoever argues best or whoever asked first. Capital allocation replaces that with a single ranking on a common basis: the return each use is expected to earn, cut by a premium for its risk, and compared with what the owners could earn elsewhere, the cost of capital.

Two rules do most of the work. Fund from the top, so the best uses are never crowded out by earlier or louder ones. Stop at the bar, so money that cannot beat the cost of capital is held or returned instead of spent. Buybacks, dividends, and debt repayment sit on the same list as projects, which forces the question every sponsor would rather skip: is this better than giving the money back?

The thinking behind it

William N. Thorndike Jr. William N. Thorndike Jr., founder of the Boston firm Housatonic Partners, wrote The Outsiders: Eight Unconventional CEOs and Their Radically Rational Blueprint for Success (2012). He profiled eight chief executives whose companies outperformed their peers and the market, and argued that what they shared was disciplined capital allocation: judging each use of cash by its long-run return to shareholders. It is an investor's book of case studies, not a research study.

Warren E. Buffett Warren E. Buffett, the longtime chairman and chief executive of Berkshire Hathaway, has written an annual letter to shareholders since 1977. The letters are a practitioner's classic on investing and on allocating capital, and they treat allocation as the chief executive's central job. The 1996 letter adds a limit that applies to every ranking on this page: an investor needs to be able to judge only the companies inside a circle of competence.

Richard A. Brealey Richard A. Brealey, an emeritus professor of finance at London Business School, wrote Principles of Corporate Finance (1981) with Stewart C. Myers, later joined by Franklin Allen. The standard graduate textbook on valuation, capital budgeting, and financing decisions, it supplies the machinery behind the ranking: returns estimated on a common basis, adjusted for risk, and compared with the cost of capital.

How to run it

  1. Total the capital available. Count what is free now and what operations will release over the year, after a safety reserve.
  2. List every possible use. Include buybacks, dividends, debt repayment, and holding cash beside the projects and deals.
  3. Estimate each return on a common basis. Use the same horizon and the same treatment of taxes and overhead for every use.
  4. Cut each return by a premium for its risk. An acquisition or a new market carries more than a plant upgrade, and the premium should say so.
  5. Rank and fund from the top. Go down the list until the money runs out or the next use falls below the cost of capital.
  6. Hold or return what is left. Cash that clears no bar goes back to the owners or waits for a better use.
  7. Review the ranking each quarter. Returns, risks, and the cost of capital all move, and so does the line.

Where it goes wrong

The common failure is letting each sponsor estimate their own return unchallenged. Promised returns inflate, and the ranking rewards optimism. Have one team build every estimate on the same assumptions, and price risk the sponsor would rather not mention.

A second failure is leaving buybacks, dividends, and debt off the list. Projects are then compared only with each other, and a mediocre one wins because it is the best of a weak set. The third is a cost of capital set by habit. A bar left at a number from five years ago lets too much through, or too little; revisit it when rates and the business's risk change, and watch how the funding line moves.

When to use something else

Where it sits in SOLVE eX

Go to the source

Back to the catalog