Named by Stewart C. Myers (Determinants of Corporate Borrowing, 1977), on the option pricing of Fischer Black and Myron Scholes (1973), and developed by Lenos Trigeorgis (Real Options, 1996) and Tom Copeland and Vladimir Antikarov (2001).
Values the right to expand, delay, shrink, switch, or abandon an investment later as uncertainty clears, which a standard discounted cash flow tends to miss.
Build the second plant now, or buy a year of learning first?
Two plans for the same market: build now and live with whatever demand turns out to be, or test it for a year with a co-packer and then build or walk away. Move the odds of strong demand and the loss if demand disappoints: above the line, the right to wait is worth more than it costs. Illustrative.
The better planAbove the line: the downside is big enough, and the odds open enough, that a year of learning beats committing today.Below the line: the case is strong or the downside is small, so the year's delay costs more than the option saves.
An example
A maker of plant-based cheeses had outgrown its one plant and was weighing a second, $40 million, to serve a new region. Finance put the chance of strong demand there at 40 percent. Strong demand made the plant worth $30 million in today's money; weak demand left a plant running at half speed and a $15 million loss. The plain net present value came out at $3 million: a yes, but a thin one.
The operations director proposed a different plan. Pay a co-packer to make the line for one year in two states, at a cost of $3 million, and build only if the product sold. In the good case, the year of waiting would cost about $5 million, the co-packer's fee included. Valued that way, the staged plan was worth $8.2 million, so the right to wait was worth $5.2 million more than committing. The board bought the year and wrote down the trigger in advance: build if the co-packed line reaches 60 percent of the plant's planned volume by month nine.
Why it works
A standard discounted cash flow assumes the company commits today and rides whatever happens. Most real investments are not like that. Managers learn as they go, and they can expand, slow down, switch, or stop once they see results. That right to act later, without the duty to, has value, and the value grows with uncertainty, because the option lets the company keep the upside and walk away from much of the downside.
The tool counts that value. It also explains a common puzzle: a small first step with a poor return on its own can be the best move available, because what it buys is information and a choice, and a project that fails the NPV test can still be worth starting small.
The thinking behind it
Stewart C. Myers Stewart C. Myers, a finance professor at MIT Sloan, coined the term real options in Determinants of Corporate Borrowing (1977). His point was that part of a firm's value lies in growth opportunities it has not yet taken up, and that those opportunities behave like options on future investment. They can be valued the way financial options are, which a plain forecast of cash flows leaves out.
Fischer Black Fischer Black and Myron Scholes derived a formula for the price of an option in The Pricing of Options and Corporate Liabilities (1973), and Robert C. Merton extended it. Real options analysis borrows the same logic for choices inside a business: the worth of a right to act later depends on how uncertain the outcome is and how long the right lasts. Scholes and Merton received the 1997 Nobel Memorial Prize for the method; Black had died in 1995.
Lenos Trigeorgis Lenos Trigeorgis, in Real Options: Managerial Flexibility and Strategy in Resource Allocation (1996), set out the kinds of flexibility a project can hold, the options to defer, expand, contract, switch, or abandon, and valued them on top of the project's static net present value. Tom Copeland and Vladimir Antikarov's Real Options: A Practitioner's Guide (2001) carried the method into company planning.
How to run it
- Name the decision and what will become known. Say which uncertainty will clear with time, such as demand, a regulator's ruling, or whether the technology works.
- Value committing now. Run the ordinary net present value over the outcomes and their odds, so the baseline is on the table.
- List the choices the plan leaves open. Look for a smaller first step, a delay, a later expansion, a switch to another use, or a way out with something recovered.
- Value the staged plan. Work out what happens in each outcome when the company acts on what it learns, counting the cost of the first step and of the delay.
- Take the difference. The gap between the staged plan and committing now is what the flexibility is worth; compare it with what the first step costs.
- Write the triggers before starting. Name the number, date, and owner that will decide expand or stop, so the option is exercised on evidence instead of momentum.
Where it goes wrong
The flexibility is imagined. A plan counts an option to abandon that the contracts, the workforce, or the politics will never allow. Before valuing a choice, ask who would have to agree to use it, and drop the ones nobody would.
The option is never exercised. The pilot keeps running on goodwill long after the trigger date, and the cost of waiting piles up unseen. A trigger written in advance, with an owner, is the cure.
The numbers outrun the knowledge. A full option-pricing model built on guessed volatility gives a precise answer to a question nobody can measure. For most business choices, the simple comparison of committing now against staging, on stated odds, carries most of the value.
When to use something else
- Decision Tree Analysis. When the choices and chance events are many and need drawing out branch by branch before any option is valued.
- One-Way and Two-Way Doors. When the first question is simply whether the decision can be undone cheaply, before putting a price on that.
- Sensitivity Analysis. When the choice is already made and the job is finding which assumption would change it.
Where it sits in SOLVE eX
Go to the source
- Determinants of Corporate Borrowing, Journal of Financial Economics, 1977
- The Pricing of Options and Corporate Liabilities, Journal of Political Economy, 1973
- Real Options: Managerial Flexibility and Strategy in Resource Allocation, 1996
- Real Options: A Practitioner's Guide, 2001