Draws on the facilitative and evaluative grid of Leonard L. Riskin (1996), the transformative mediation of Robert A. Baruch Bush and Joseph P. Folger (1994), and Christopher W. Moore (The Mediation Process, 1986).
Matches the mediator's style to the dispute: transformative when the relationship needs repair, facilitative when parties can solve it with help, and evaluative when they need a neutral read.
Seven disputes matched to a mediation style
Each dispute is placed by whether the parties must keep working together afterward and how much a neutral read on who is right is worth. The first is placed as an example; place the rest, and the box names the style of mediator to hire. Illustrative.
Items (select one, then a box)
Not placedPlacedTransformativeFacilitativeFacilitative, briefEvaluative
Not placedPlacedTransformativeFacilitativeFacilitative, briefEvaluative
Not placedPlacedTransformativeFacilitativeFacilitative, briefEvaluative
Not placedPlacedTransformativeFacilitativeFacilitative, briefEvaluative
Not placedPlacedTransformativeFacilitativeFacilitative, briefEvaluative
Not placedPlacedTransformativeFacilitativeFacilitative, briefEvaluative
Not placedPlacedTransformativeFacilitativeFacilitative, briefEvaluative
The relationship afterward
ContinuesEnds
Transformative
Facilitative
Facilitative, brief
Evaluative
LittleA lot
Worth of a neutral read on the merits
Co-founders not speaking. Two founders of a growing firm have stopped attending each other's meetings. Neither disputes the facts.Not placed yet.Co-founders not speaking. Two founders of a growing firm have stopped attending each other's meetings. Neither disputes the facts.Transformative: The parties must keep working together, and what is broken is how they deal with each other. The mediator helps each side speak for itself and hear the other; a changed relationship counts as success.They will run the company together for years, and the problem is how they treat each other. A verdict would fix nothing.Co-founders not speaking. Two founders of a growing firm have stopped attending each other's meetings. Neither disputes the facts.Facilitative: They must keep working together, and the terms are in dispute. The mediator helps them find their interests and build the terms themselves; a verdict would leave a winner and a loser who still share a desk.Co-founders not speaking. Two founders of a growing firm have stopped attending each other's meetings. Neither disputes the facts.Facilitative, brief: No relationship to protect and no merits to judge, only something to divide. A short facilitated session that moves quickly to options and numbers.Co-founders not speaking. Two founders of a growing firm have stopped attending each other's meetings. Neither disputes the facts.Evaluative: The relationship ends with the deal, and the parties are stuck on who is right. The mediator assesses the case and says how it would likely come out, which moves both toward a settlement.Ex-supplier's invoice. A supplier the company dropped bills for work it says the contract covered. The contract is ambiguous.Not placed yet.Ex-supplier's invoice. A supplier the company dropped bills for work it says the contract covered. The contract is ambiguous.Transformative: The parties must keep working together, and what is broken is how they deal with each other. The mediator helps each side speak for itself and hear the other; a changed relationship counts as success.Ex-supplier's invoice. A supplier the company dropped bills for work it says the contract covered. The contract is ambiguous.Facilitative: They must keep working together, and the terms are in dispute. The mediator helps them find their interests and build the terms themselves; a verdict would leave a winner and a loser who still share a desk.Ex-supplier's invoice. A supplier the company dropped bills for work it says the contract covered. The contract is ambiguous.Facilitative, brief: No relationship to protect and no merits to judge, only something to divide. A short facilitated session that moves quickly to options and numbers.Ex-supplier's invoice. A supplier the company dropped bills for work it says the contract covered. The contract is ambiguous.Evaluative: The relationship ends with the deal, and the parties are stuck on who is right. The mediator assesses the case and says how it would likely come out, which moves both toward a settlement.The relationship is over, and the question is what the contract means. A neutral read of the likely outcome settles it fastest.Top distributor's rebate. The distributor that sells half the volume disputes how this year's rebate was calculated.Not placed yet.Top distributor's rebate. The distributor that sells half the volume disputes how this year's rebate was calculated.Transformative: The parties must keep working together, and what is broken is how they deal with each other. The mediator helps each side speak for itself and hear the other; a changed relationship counts as success.Top distributor's rebate. The distributor that sells half the volume disputes how this year's rebate was calculated.Facilitative: They must keep working together, and the terms are in dispute. The mediator helps them find their interests and build the terms themselves; a verdict would leave a winner and a loser who still share a desk.Both sides need each other next year. Let them build the formula together; a ruling would sour the account.Top distributor's rebate. The distributor that sells half the volume disputes how this year's rebate was calculated.Facilitative, brief: No relationship to protect and no merits to judge, only something to divide. A short facilitated session that moves quickly to options and numbers.Top distributor's rebate. The distributor that sells half the volume disputes how this year's rebate was calculated.Evaluative: The relationship ends with the deal, and the parties are stuck on who is right. The mediator assesses the case and says how it would likely come out, which moves both toward a settlement.Departing partner's book. A partner is leaving and the firm and she must divide eleven client accounts. No contract governs it.Not placed yet.Departing partner's book. A partner is leaving and the firm and she must divide eleven client accounts. No contract governs it.Transformative: The parties must keep working together, and what is broken is how they deal with each other. The mediator helps each side speak for itself and hear the other; a changed relationship counts as success.Departing partner's book. A partner is leaving and the firm and she must divide eleven client accounts. No contract governs it.Facilitative: They must keep working together, and the terms are in dispute. The mediator helps them find their interests and build the terms themselves; a verdict would leave a winner and a loser who still share a desk.Departing partner's book. A partner is leaving and the firm and she must divide eleven client accounts. No contract governs it.Facilitative, brief: No relationship to protect and no merits to judge, only something to divide. A short facilitated session that moves quickly to options and numbers.There is no case to judge and no relationship after. A brief session to trade accounts until both accept the split.Departing partner's book. A partner is leaving and the firm and she must divide eleven client accounts. No contract governs it.Evaluative: The relationship ends with the deal, and the parties are stuck on who is right. The mediator assesses the case and says how it would likely come out, which moves both toward a settlement.Feuding plant managers. Their crews refuse to share the one forklift pool. Each manager blames the other for the last stoppage.Not placed yet.Feuding plant managers. Their crews refuse to share the one forklift pool. Each manager blames the other for the last stoppage.Transformative: The parties must keep working together, and what is broken is how they deal with each other. The mediator helps each side speak for itself and hear the other; a changed relationship counts as success.They share a site for years, and the fight is about respect, not equipment. Repair how they deal with each other first.Feuding plant managers. Their crews refuse to share the one forklift pool. Each manager blames the other for the last stoppage.Facilitative: They must keep working together, and the terms are in dispute. The mediator helps them find their interests and build the terms themselves; a verdict would leave a winner and a loser who still share a desk.Feuding plant managers. Their crews refuse to share the one forklift pool. Each manager blames the other for the last stoppage.Facilitative, brief: No relationship to protect and no merits to judge, only something to divide. A short facilitated session that moves quickly to options and numbers.Feuding plant managers. Their crews refuse to share the one forklift pool. Each manager blames the other for the last stoppage.Evaluative: The relationship ends with the deal, and the parties are stuck on who is right. The mediator assesses the case and says how it would likely come out, which moves both toward a settlement.Ex-employee overtime. A former shift lead claims two years of unpaid overtime. The records are partial.Not placed yet.Ex-employee overtime. A former shift lead claims two years of unpaid overtime. The records are partial.Transformative: The parties must keep working together, and what is broken is how they deal with each other. The mediator helps each side speak for itself and hear the other; a changed relationship counts as success.Ex-employee overtime. A former shift lead claims two years of unpaid overtime. The records are partial.Facilitative: They must keep working together, and the terms are in dispute. The mediator helps them find their interests and build the terms themselves; a verdict would leave a winner and a loser who still share a desk.Ex-employee overtime. A former shift lead claims two years of unpaid overtime. The records are partial.Facilitative, brief: No relationship to protect and no merits to judge, only something to divide. A short facilitated session that moves quickly to options and numbers.Ex-employee overtime. A former shift lead claims two years of unpaid overtime. The records are partial.Evaluative: The relationship ends with the deal, and the parties are stuck on who is right. The mediator assesses the case and says how it would likely come out, which moves both toward a settlement.No ongoing relationship, and the dispute turns on what the law and the records say. An evaluative mediator's read narrows the gap.Joint venture overrun. The venture runs ten more years. The partners disagree on who pays a $4 million overrun.Not placed yet.Joint venture overrun. The venture runs ten more years. The partners disagree on who pays a $4 million overrun.Transformative: The parties must keep working together, and what is broken is how they deal with each other. The mediator helps each side speak for itself and hear the other; a changed relationship counts as success.Joint venture overrun. The venture runs ten more years. The partners disagree on who pays a $4 million overrun.Facilitative: They must keep working together, and the terms are in dispute. The mediator helps them find their interests and build the terms themselves; a verdict would leave a winner and a loser who still share a desk.A long partnership and a real dispute over terms: help them find an allocation both can live with for a decade.Joint venture overrun. The venture runs ten more years. The partners disagree on who pays a $4 million overrun.Facilitative, brief: No relationship to protect and no merits to judge, only something to divide. A short facilitated session that moves quickly to options and numbers.Joint venture overrun. The venture runs ten more years. The partners disagree on who pays a $4 million overrun.Evaluative: The relationship ends with the deal, and the parties are stuck on who is right. The mediator assesses the case and says how it would likely come out, which moves both toward a settlement.
Your sort matched 0 of 7.Your sort matched 1 of 7.Your sort matched 2 of 7.Your sort matched 3 of 7.Your sort matched 4 of 7.Your sort matched 5 of 7.Your sort matched 6 of 7.Your sort matched 7 of 7.
Transformative
The parties must keep working together, and what is broken is how they deal with each other. The mediator helps each side speak for itself and hear the other; a changed relationship counts as success.
Facilitative
They must keep working together, and the terms are in dispute. The mediator helps them find their interests and build the terms themselves; a verdict would leave a winner and a loser who still share a desk.
Facilitative, brief
No relationship to protect and no merits to judge, only something to divide. A short facilitated session that moves quickly to options and numbers.
Evaluative
The relationship ends with the deal, and the parties are stuck on who is right. The mediator assesses the case and says how it would likely come out, which moves both toward a settlement.
The sort
Co-founders not speaking: Transformative. They will run the company together for years, and the problem is how they treat each other. A verdict would fix nothing.
Ex-supplier's invoice: Evaluative. The relationship is over, and the question is what the contract means. A neutral read of the likely outcome settles it fastest.
Top distributor's rebate: Facilitative. Both sides need each other next year. Let them build the formula together; a ruling would sour the account.
Departing partner's book: Facilitative, brief. There is no case to judge and no relationship after. A brief session to trade accounts until both accept the split.
Feuding plant managers: Transformative. They share a site for years, and the fight is about respect, not equipment. Repair how they deal with each other first.
Ex-employee overtime: Evaluative. No ongoing relationship, and the dispute turns on what the law and the records say. An evaluative mediator's read narrows the gap.
Joint venture overrun: Facilitative. A long partnership and a real dispute over terms: help them find an allocation both can live with for a decade.
An example
A general counsel had two disputes headed for mediation in the same month and one roster of mediators. The first was a former supplier billing for work the company said the contract already covered; the contract was vague and the relationship was over. The second was between the company's two founders, who had stopped attending each other's meetings after a fight over a hire. Neither disputed the facts.
Her first instinct was to send both to the retired judge who had settled the last three cases. She asked two questions of each dispute instead: would the parties have to work together afterward, and would a neutral read of who was right help? The supplier case scored no and yes, so the judge, an evaluative mediator, took it and settled it in a day. The founders scored yes and no. She hired a transformative mediator, who spent three sessions on how the two of them made decisions together, and the hire never came up.
Why it works
Mediators do different jobs. An evaluative mediator tells the parties how their case would likely come out. A facilitative one helps them find what each needs and build the terms themselves. A transformative one works on how the parties deal with each other and counts a changed relationship as success, settlement or not.
Each style fits some disputes and damages others. A verdict ends a dispute between strangers quickly, but between people who must keep working together it produces a winner and a loser who still share a building. Months of relationship work frustrate two parties who only want a number. Asking up front what must survive the dispute, and what is actually stuck, picks the style before the mediator's habit picks it.
The thinking behind it
Leonard L. Riskin Leonard L. Riskin, a law professor, published his grid in the Harvard Negotiation Law Review in 1996. He sorted mediators on two axes: whether they evaluate the parties' positions or facilitate the parties' own negotiation, and whether they define the problem narrowly or broadly. The four quadrants that result shaped a decade of debate in the field about what mediators do and should do, much of it critical of the grid itself.
Robert A. Baruch Bush Robert A. Baruch Bush and Joseph P. Folger set out transformative mediation in The Promise of Mediation (1994). In their model the mediator's aim is a change in how the parties interact, through empowerment, each party's growing capacity to decide for itself, and recognition, each party's growing ability to see the other's view. A settlement may follow, but it is not the measure of success.
Christopher W. Moore Christopher W. Moore, a mediator and dispute systems designer who has worked in more than 50 countries, wrote The Mediation Process (1986, fourth edition 2014), a standard practitioner's account of how mediators move a dispute from first contact to settlement. The stages it lays out are where a chosen style has to be carried through, session by session and party by party.
How to run it
Ask whether the parties must keep working together. Colleagues, partners, and key accounts must; a former supplier or employee usually need not.
Ask what is actually stuck. It may be how they deal with each other, what a fair split is, or who is right on the facts or the law.
Ask what a neutral read would be worth. If the dispute turns on a contract or a statute, a credible prediction of the outcome moves both sides.
Place the dispute and name the style. Repair calls for transformative, building terms together for facilitative, and a verdict on the merits for evaluative.
Interview mediators on their practice. Ask how they ran their last three cases; most have one style whatever their brochure says.
Agree the style with both parties. Both should know whether they are coming for a read on the case or for help working it out.
Where it goes wrong
The mediator's habit sets the style. A mediator who evaluates by reflex will tell the founders who was right about the hire, and one will leave feeling judged. Ask before hiring how the mediator handles a case with an ongoing relationship.
The relationship question gets a polite answer. Parties say they want to keep working together when they have already decided to part, or the reverse. Look at what they are doing (planning an exit, hiring around each other) more than at what they say.
The style never changes. A facilitative session that stalls on a legal question can switch to an evaluative read on that one point, if both parties agree. Name the switch out loud and return afterward.
When to use something else
Interest-Based Bargaining. When the parties can negotiate directly and need a method for working from interests, not a third party.
BATNA and ZOPA. When the dispute is one number and each side needs to know its walk-away before mediating.
Difficult Conversations. When the trouble is one conversation between two people and no third party is needed yet.