Originated by Edward de Bono (CoRT Thinking Lessons, 1973).
Lists the pluses, minuses, and merely interesting points of an option, each in a short timed burst, before anyone passes judgment on it.
Nine points about a four-day week, sorted into plus, minus, and interesting
The leadership team's first reaction was no. Sort each point into its column; the first is placed as an example. The Interesting column holds the points that are neither good nor bad, and they turn out to be the questions the decision depends on. Illustrative.
- Not placedPlacedPlusMinusInteresting
- Not placedPlacedPlusMinusInteresting
- Not placedPlacedPlusMinusInteresting
- Not placedPlacedPlusMinusInteresting
- Not placedPlacedPlusMinusInteresting
- Not placedPlacedPlusMinusInteresting
- Not placedPlacedPlusMinusInteresting
- Not placedPlacedPlusMinusInteresting
- Not placedPlacedPlusMinusInteresting
The proposal
What kind of point it is
Your sort matched 0 of 9.Your sort matched 1 of 9.Your sort matched 2 of 9.Your sort matched 3 of 9.Your sort matched 4 of 9.Your sort matched 5 of 9.Your sort matched 6 of 9.Your sort matched 7 of 9.Your sort matched 8 of 9.Your sort matched 9 of 9.
- Plus
- A reason the idea is good. List them for two minutes before anyone argues.
- Minus
- A reason the idea is bad. List them for two minutes, without defending the idea.
- Interesting
- Neither good nor bad: a consequence, a question, or an angle worth following. These are what the first reaction skipped.
The sort
- Easier to hire engineers: Plus. The firm loses candidates to larger offers; a shorter week is a perk a small firm can afford.
- Fewer sick days: Plus. Staff with a rest day take fewer unplanned days off.
- Forces fewer meetings: Plus. Thirty-two hours leave no room for the standing meetings nobody defends.
- Support needs Fridays: Minus. Customers file tickets on Fridays, and someone has to answer them.
- Friday sales calls lost: Minus. Two large accounts schedule their reviews on Fridays.
- Crunch weeks get worse: Minus. A release with a fixed date has a day less to absorb a slip.
- Teams pick their own day: Interesting. Not good or bad yet: it might solve the support cover, or it might wreck coordination. Worth testing.
- What do Fridays need?: Interesting. Nobody knows how many Friday requests are urgent. Counting them would settle half the minuses.
- Output per hour?: Interesting. A trial would show whether output per hour rises, which is the real question behind the cost worry.
An example
A sixty-person software firm's head of people proposed a four-day week, and the leadership team's reaction came within a minute: no, it costs a fifth of capacity. The founder asked for six minutes before the vote. Two minutes of pluses (easier hiring against larger firms, fewer sick days, fewer standing meetings), two minutes of minuses (support needs Friday cover, two large accounts hold their reviews on Fridays, crunch weeks would get worse), and two minutes of points that were neither.
The third list changed the meeting. Could teams pick their own day off? How many Friday requests were actually urgent? Would output per hour rise enough to cover the lost day? Nobody knew, and each answer would settle a minus. The team voted for a three-month trial with support and sales on rotating days, Friday requests counted from week one, and output per engineer tracked against the previous quarter.
Why it works
A first reaction arrives with its reasons attached, and the reasons that fit it are the only ones anyone looks for. PMI breaks that by making the scan come before the verdict, one direction at a time: everyone lists pluses together, then minuses together, so a person against the idea still has to produce its pluses.
The third column does the most work. Interesting points are consequences, questions, and angles that are neither for nor against, and a judgment made in a hurry skips them because they do not help win the argument. They are usually where the decision actually turns: an unknown fact, a variation of the idea, a test that would settle a dispute. Short, timed bursts keep the whole thing to minutes, so it gets used.
The thinking behind it
Edward de Bono Edward de Bono, a Maltese physician and writer who coined the term lateral thinking, made PMI one of the lessons of his CoRT Thinking program (1973), a set of short attention-directing tools for schools and business that also included OPV, other people's views. The tools ask a thinker to point attention in one direction at a time, so that a scan comes before a judgment. A review of 42 thinking frameworks (Moseley and colleagues, Frameworks for Thinking) found sparse research evidence that CoRT training improves thinking in general; the tools are valued for their use, not for tested effects.
How to run it
- State the idea in one sentence. A four-day week at full pay for everyone, starting next quarter; vagueness lets each person judge a different idea.
- Note the first reaction. Write the room's snap verdict down so it can be compared at the end.
- List pluses for two minutes. Everyone, including the people against it; no arguing, no minuses.
- List minuses for two minutes. Everyone, including the person who proposed it; no defending.
- List interesting points for two minutes. Consequences, questions, variations, and unknowns that are neither good nor bad.
- Turn the interesting points into next steps. Each one is a fact to find, a variation to consider, or a test to run.
- Revisit the first reaction. Say whether it stands, changes, or becomes a trial, and why.
Where it goes wrong
The lists are not equal effort. The pluses get forty seconds of half-hearted thought from people who already decided, and the result confirms the first reaction. Keep the clock honest and ask each opponent for one plus by name.
The Interesting column fills with minuses in disguise. A point like what if clients leave is a minus phrased as a question. Ask whether the point could turn out either way; if not, move it.
The lists are counted. Seven minuses beat four pluses, and the idea dies. The lists are a scan, not a scoreboard: one large plus can outweigh five small minuses, and the interesting points may change the idea itself.
When to use something else
- Six Thinking Hats. When a group needs more directions than three, such as feelings, facts, and new ideas, each in its own pass.
- Weighted Decision Matrix. When several options are on the table and the points need weights so they can be compared.
- Premortem. When the idea is already chosen and the job is finding how it will fail.
Where it sits in SOLVE eX
Go to the source
- CoRT Thinking Lessons, CoRT 1: Breadth, Direct Education Services, 1973