From the case-based moral reasoning of medieval and early modern Catholic moral theology, with roots in Cicero and the Stoics, revived by Albert R. Jonsen and Stephen Toulmin (The Abuse of Casuistry, 1988).
Reasons about a hard moral case by comparing it with clear cases whose verdicts nobody disputes, building judgment from cases upward.
A supplier's conference pass, set feature by feature between a clear gift and a clear bribe
Each feature of the hard case is scored by which clear case it resembles: 1 is the $30 holiday mug nobody questions, 5 is cash slipped to a buyer during a tender. Features that decide more count double. Move the renewal a year away (timing to 2) or take the decision out of her hands and watch the verdict cross over. Illustrative.
Value. Mug: $30. Bribe: $5,000. This pass, with the hotel: $1,800.
ResemblesTiming. Mug: at year end, no deal open. Bribe: during the tender. This pass: two weeks before the supplier's renewal. Weight 2
ResemblesHer role. Mug: no say in purchasing. Bribe: picks the winner. This manager signs the renewal. Weight 2
ResemblesOpenness. Mug: handed out in front of everyone. Bribe: hidden. This pass: offered by email, and she would log it.
ResemblesWho gets it. Mug: every customer. Bribe: one buyer. This pass: buyers at twelve customer firms.
ResemblesCloser to4.0
VerdictScore every row to see the verdict.The giftAccept it and record it in the gift log.Too close to callTake it to the ethics officer with this comparison, and decide before the renewal opens.The bribeDecline it, or have the company pay for the pass itself so the training stays and the debt goes.
What tips it, most like the bribe first
- 5.0Timing. Mug: at year end, no deal open. Bribe: during the tender. This pass: two weeks before the supplier's renewal.
- 5.0Her role. Mug: no say in purchasing. Bribe: picks the winner. This manager signs the renewal.
- 4.0Value. Mug: $30. Bribe: $5,000. This pass, with the hotel: $1,800.
- 2.0Openness. Mug: handed out in front of everyone. Bribe: hidden. This pass: offered by email, and she would log it.
- 2.0Who gets it. Mug: every customer. Bribe: one buyer. This pass: buyers at twelve customer firms.
An example
A purchasing manager at a regional hospital group was offered a free pass to a three-day supply-chain conference by one of her largest suppliers: registration and two hotel nights, about $1,800. The gift policy said gifts must be modest and must not influence decisions, which settled nothing; she asked the ethics officer.
He skipped the policy and laid out two cases no one in the building would argue about. A branded mug at the holidays, sent to every customer, was fine. Cash handed to a buyer during an open tender was a bribe. Then they went through the conference pass one feature at a time. On value it sat nearer the bribe. On openness it sat near the mug, since the offer came by email and she meant to log it, and the pass had gone to buyers at twelve firms. On timing and role it sat squarely with the bribe: the supplier's contract came up for renewal in two weeks, and she would sign it. The hospital paid for her pass itself, and she went.
Why it works
Principles are easy to agree with and hard to apply. Modest and must not influence are both true and both silent on an $1,800 pass. Clear cases carry judgments that people already share, so starting there replaces an argument about definitions with a comparison anyone can check: is this more like the mug or more like the cash, and on which features?
The comparison also shows what tips the case. Once each feature is placed, the debate narrows to the features that actually push toward the bribe, here timing and her role, and the fix often follows from them. Change the feature that makes the case look like the bad paradigm, and the case moves. A ruling built this way can be explained to the next person who faces a similar offer.
The thinking behind it
Albert R. Jonsen Albert Jonsen, one of the founders of bioethics, wrote The Abuse of Casuistry (1988) with Stephen Toulmin. They traced case-based moral reasoning from Cicero and the Stoics through the moral theology of the medieval and early modern Church, and argued that reasoning from paradigm cases to new ones by analogy is a sound method of moral reasoning. In their account, the method earned its bad name through its abuse, and the remedy is to use it with care.
Stephen Toulmin Stephen Toulmin, a British philosopher, is best known for The Uses of Argument (1958), which lays out a practical argument as a claim, its grounds, the warrant that links them, the backing for the warrant, a qualifier, and a rebuttal. That interest in how everyday arguments actually work, outside formal logic, carried into The Abuse of Casuistry (1988), written with Albert Jonsen, which made the case for judging hard moral questions case by case.
How to run it
- State the case plainly. Write the facts, who is involved, and what decision is pending, without any verdict in the wording.
- Find two clear cases nearby. Pick one plainly acceptable and one plainly wrong, close enough to share most of the hard case's features.
- Name what makes each one clear. List the features that settle each paradigm, such as value, timing, role, and secrecy.
- Place the case feature by feature. For each feature, say which paradigm the case resembles more, and note where it resembles neither.
- Weigh the features that decide. Give more weight to the features that made the paradigms clear in the first place.
- Judge by the closer paradigm. State the verdict and the one or two features that tipped it.
- Look for the change that moves it. Ask which feature, altered, would move the case to the acceptable side, and whether that change is available.
Where it goes wrong
The first failure is picking paradigms that flatter the conclusion. A bad case set beside an even worse one looks fine. Each paradigm should be one that nearly everyone, including a skeptic, would rule on the same way.
The second is counting features without weighing them. Five small similarities to the gift do not outweigh the fact that the person receiving it signs the contract. Ask which features made the clear cases clear, and give those the most weight.
The third is losing the reasons. A verdict without the features that tipped it cannot guide the next case, and a run of such verdicts drifts. Write down what tipped each one, so later cases are compared with the same features.
When to use something else
- Reasoning from Precedent. When earlier decisions inside the organization already settled similar cases and the new one should follow their rule.
- Ethical Matrix. When the question is how one choice affects several groups, and each group's interests need laying out side by side.
- Veil of Ignorance. When the issue is whether a rule or policy is fair to everyone it covers, before any single case arises.
Where it sits in SOLVE eX
Go to the source
- The Abuse of Casuistry: A History of Moral Reasoning, 1988