Reasoning from Precedent

Thinking Tools3.2 Finding the Past FactsAlso known as Legal Precedent Reasoning, Reasoning by Example

From the common-law tradition of precedent, as set out by Edward H. Levi (An Introduction to Legal Reasoning, 1949) and Karl N. Llewellyn (The Common Law Tradition, 1960).

Decides a new case by finding earlier cases with similar facts, taking the rule each settled, and either applying it or showing why the facts differ.

An example

A design agency's managing partner had to decide what to do about a freelance art director who had posted a mocking thread about a client's new logo. The thread did not name the client, but people inside the industry could tell who it was, and the agency was midway through the client's packaging work. Two partners wanted him gone that day; one thought the agency was overreacting.

The operations director pulled the two earlier cases the agency had decided. In 2022 it had ended a contractor who complained publicly, by name, about a live client's slow payments. In 2023 it had kept a staff designer who wrote a sharp essay on the industry's free-pitch habits, no client named. They compared the new case with each, fact by fact, and asked which differences mattered to the rule each case had settled. Most facts were mixed. The one that decided it was that the project was live, exactly as in 2022. The agency ended the engagement at the next milestone, paid him in full, and wrote the rule into its contractor guide.

Why it works

Decisions on exceptions drift when each one is argued fresh. The answer comes to depend on who is in the room, and people learn that outcomes are negotiable. Reasoning from earlier cases ties today's decision to what the organization already did, so similar cases get similar answers and anyone can see why.

The method's real work is in the comparison. Two cases are never identical, so the question becomes which differences are material: would the earlier decision have come out differently if that fact had been different? Answering it forces the rule into words. Each new case then either follows that rule or, if a material fact differs, refines it, and the body of decisions gets sharper with every case.

The thinking behind it

Edward H. Levi Edward Levi, a law professor who later led the University of Chicago and served as United States Attorney General, described the method in An Introduction to Legal Reasoning (1949). He called it reasoning by example: a court sees a similarity between the present case and earlier ones, announces the rule those cases imply, and applies it. Because each new comparison restates the rule, the rule shifts as cases accumulate, which is how the law can stay consistent and still change.

Karl N. Llewellyn Karl Llewellyn, a leading figure of American legal realism at Columbia and later Chicago, and the chief drafter of the Uniform Commercial Code, wrote The Common Law Tradition: Deciding Appeals (1960), his last major book. It studies how appellate courts actually reason from precedent, case by case, and argues that their results are more predictable than the realists' critics feared. For an organization deciding its own exceptions, that is the point: decisions grounded in earlier cases can be anticipated by the people they affect.

How to run it

  1. State the new case's facts. Write them plainly, without the conclusion built into the wording.
  2. Find earlier cases with similar facts. Search the organization's own decisions first: past exceptions, disciplinary files, rulings on the same policy.
  3. Extract the rule each one decided. Write the rule as the decision actually applied it, which may be narrower than what anyone said at the time.
  4. Compare the facts one by one. Mark each fact as alike or different, case by case.
  5. Decide which differences are material. Ask whether the earlier decision would have changed if that fact had been different.
  6. Apply the rule or distinguish the case. Follow the closer precedent, or name the material fact that sets the new case apart.
  7. Record the reasoning. Write the rule as it now stands so the next case starts from it.

Where it goes wrong

The first failure is matching on surface facts. Two posts on social media look alike, and the platform may have nothing to do with either decision. Test every similarity by asking whether the earlier outcome depended on it.

The second is stating the rule too broadly. A rule written as any public criticism ends the contract claims far more than the earlier case decided, and the next case will expose it. Write the narrowest rule that explains the outcome.

The third is following a precedent that was wrong. Consistency with a bad decision spreads it. When a precedent's rule produces an outcome nobody would choose today, say so openly and change the rule, so the record shows why.

When to use something else

  • Casuistry. When no earlier decision exists and the case has to be judged against clear examples of right and wrong.
  • Toulmin Model. When the task is laying out one argument's claim, grounds, and warrant for others to test.
  • Burden of Proof Analysis. When the parties agree on the rule and disagree about who has to show the facts meet it.

Where it sits in SOLVE eX

Go to the source

  • An Introduction to Legal Reasoning, 1949
  • The Common Law Tradition: Deciding Appeals, 1960

Back to the catalog